Western Pioneer, Inc. v. United States

32 Cont. Cas. Fed. 73,617, 8 Cl. Ct. 291, 1985 U.S. Claims LEXIS 975
CourtUnited States Court of Claims
DecidedMay 30, 1985
DocketNo. 240-85C
StatusPublished
Cited by7 cases

This text of 32 Cont. Cas. Fed. 73,617 (Western Pioneer, Inc. v. United States) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Court of Claims primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Western Pioneer, Inc. v. United States, 32 Cont. Cas. Fed. 73,617, 8 Cl. Ct. 291, 1985 U.S. Claims LEXIS 975 (cc 1985).

Opinion

OPINION

MEROW, Judge:

Introduction

In this litigation, plaintiff, Western Pioneer, Inc., d/b/a Delta Western (Delta), seeks to invoke this court’s equitable pre-award contract claim jurisdiction, 28 U.S.C. § 1491(a)(3) (1982). Delta requests equitable relief precluding the transportation of certain bulk petroleum products to Galena Air Force Station, Alaska, other than in response to its April 1, 1985 proposal submitted to the Army transportation officer at Fort Richardson, Alaska. Alternatively, Delta seeks recovery of its preparation expenses.

Defendant, United States, and the inter-venor, Yutana Barge Lines, Inc. (Yutana), contest the court’s jurisdiction in this matter and oppose the relief sought. In the absence of disputed material facts, the issues have been placed before the court on the basis of motions filed by the parties with supporting documentation and oral argument.

Facts

For a number of years the United States Air Force has maintained a station at Galena, Alaska. This station is the northernmost forward operations base for air defense fighter aircraft. Two aircraft are maintained at Galena on strip alert at all times and are launched frequently to intercept unknown aircraft entering the Alaskan District Early Warning Identification Zone. Galena Air Force Station is located on the north bank of the Yukon River approximately 260 nautical miles west of Fairbanks and 300 nautical miles northwest of Anchorage. No railroads or highways serve Galena. The majority of the supplies required by the station are transported by river barge during the relatively brief period from June-September when the Yukon River is free from ice and has sufficient water for navigation.

The fuel (primarily diesel and JP-4) required for operations at Galena is purchased by the Defense Fuel Supply Center (DFSC) located at Cameron Station, Alexandria, Virginia. In recent years contracts have been awarded to MAPCO for the fuel required by Galena. This fuel has been delivered to the government at a MAPCO refinery located at North Pole, Alaska.

Arranging transportation of the fuel from the MAPCO North Pole refinery to Galena has been the responsibility of the Army transportation officer (TO) at Fort Richardson, Alaska. Around the first of the year the Air Force sends Galena fuel information to the TO who would then contact the Alaska Railroad to obtain rate quotations and relevant scheduling and equipment details. The Alaska Railroad was contacted because it served the MAP-CO refinery and the usual arrangement was for the fuel first to be carried by rail tank cars from the refinery to the city dock at Nenana. At this point the fuel would be transferred to a barge. Prior to 1985 the only company providing river barge service from Nenana to Galena was Yutana. Yu-tana and the Alaska Railroad developed joint rates which the railroad would then present to the TO at Fort Richardson. A [293]*293“Memorandum of Understanding” would then be drafted to cover the details as to Yukon River Resupply for the year concerned and this memorandum would be signed by the transportation companies and the government officials concerned.

For example, the 1984 Memorandum of Understanding contained the following provisions (in part):

Present at the Meeting of Understanding held at Headquarters, 172d Infantry Brigade (AK) 12 April 1984 were representatives of the following shipper and carrier organizations:
HQ, 172d Inf Bde (AK)
HQ, Alaskan Air Command
Defense Fuel Region, (AK)
Alaska Railroad
Yutana Barge Lines
Participants listed on page three (3) by authenticating this Memorandum agree to the following:
1. Tariffs to be used for the 1984 POL resupply of Yukon River stations are:
a. ARR Freight Tariff 8-T, Items 440 & 630, effective 8 Oct 1983
b. ICC-MJF-300-A effective 1 May 1984
2. The Alaska Railroad-Yutana River Schedule has been revised and the concept found acceptable. Shipper reserves the right to change products and destinations of individual sailings, if required. A schedule has been prepared by shipper, which will act as guide to Alaska Railroad-Yutana Barge Lines operations.
3. The equipment named by Yutana Barge Lines is the equipment to be utilized during the 1984 Resupply Program and it is understood that the equipment is in good operating condition. Coast Guard certificates covering the 1984 season will be available on or about 15 May 1984.
4. All barges that are utilized for fuel deliveries will be equipped with certified settable meter and a ticket printing device calibrated to furnish direct reading and ticket printing reflecting the volume in US Gallons delivered or transferred.
5. Control of the rail tank cars will be vested in the Transportation Officer, Fort Richardson. Release of loaded and empty tank cars, as well as spotting of cars for loading at fill stands will be effected through coordination between TO, Fort Richardson, Alaska Railroad, and PDO Personnel.
6. Yutana Barge Lines will insure rapid turn-around of all tank cars at Nenana consistent with the availability of barges. Yutana will be responsible for the release of empty tank cars to the Alaska Railroad.
7. Transportation Officer, Fort Richardson or his representatives will prepare GBL’s for the rail and the river portion of the POL movement. Government Bills of Lading issued for tank cars at Fort Richardson will be consigned to Yu-tana Barge Lines. The River Transportation Service will be based on quantity readings of gallons loaded in barges. These readings at Nenana will be obtained from total gallonage in cars loaded to barge by using figures from GSL’s/shipping documents from Fort Richardson showing gallonage in each car. If car, through leakage or other reason, has obviously less gallonage than documents indicate, Transportation Officer will be notified and joint determination of volume in car will be made. All cars will be sealed by shipper at DD Form 1149 for each tank car will be annotated as to condition at time of receipt at Nenana. This copy will be forwarded to Defense Fuel Region Alaska, Elmendorf AFB, AK 99506.
8. Quantity received at destination will be determined from the certified metering/ticket printers. In case of dispute between carrier and receiver concerning quantity discharged, such discrepancies will be reported within 24 hours. The carrier will notify TO, Fort Richardson and receiver will notify Alaskan Air Command to obtain instructions for disposition of difference. Before-and-after tank gauging (dipstick) will be jointly determined by receiving site, and the carrier’s [294]*294representative (if available), correcting all volumes to 60 degrees F.
9. Government Bills of Lading issued for the river portion of POL movement may be prepared for each barge sailing or cumulative for several sailings. Yuta-na Barge Lines will prepare a Commercial Bill of Lading/Freight Bill to accompany each shipment.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Crewzers Fire Crew Transport, Inc. v. United States
111 Fed. Cl. 148 (Federal Claims, 2013)
MORI Associates, Inc. v. United States
102 Fed. Cl. 503 (Federal Claims, 2011)
Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin v. United States
39 Fed. Cl. 441 (Federal Claims, 1997)
Almar Industries, Inc. v. United States
35 Cont. Cas. Fed. 75,621 (Court of Claims, 1989)
Caddell Construction Co. v. United States
33 Cont. Cas. Fed. 74,405 (Court of Claims, 1986)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
32 Cont. Cas. Fed. 73,617, 8 Cl. Ct. 291, 1985 U.S. Claims LEXIS 975, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/western-pioneer-inc-v-united-states-cc-1985.