Highland Lakes Country Club & Community Ass'n v. Franzino

892 A.2d 646, 186 N.J. 99, 2006 N.J. LEXIS 169
CourtSupreme Court of New Jersey
DecidedMarch 6, 2006
StatusPublished
Cited by58 cases

This text of 892 A.2d 646 (Highland Lakes Country Club & Community Ass'n v. Franzino) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of New Jersey primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Highland Lakes Country Club & Community Ass'n v. Franzino, 892 A.2d 646, 186 N.J. 99, 2006 N.J. LEXIS 169 (N.J. 2006).

Opinions

[103]*103Justice LáVECCHIA

delivered the opinion of the Court.

In this matter, a homeowners’ association in a common-interest community seeks to compel a current homeowner to pay his unpaid membership fees, dues, and common assessments as well as arrears attributable to prior owners of the property. The homeowners’ association contends that recorded covenants in the community’s deeds and bylaws provided homeowners with notice that they would be responsible for arrears from prior owners and that their property would be encumbered by an equitable servitude for those arrears.

The homeowner argues to the contrary. He claims the covenant language did not provide him with sufficient notice that he was responsible for arrears from predecessors in title or that his property was conveyed subject to an equitable servitude in respect of arrears accrued by prior owners. Moreover, because there had been a recent mortgage foreclosure to which the Association had been a party, he argues that the foreclosure cleared the title of any lien for arrears that the Association may have had up to that point in time.

The Appellate Division, in an unpublished opinion, acknowledged that execution of a deed containing covenants compelling compliance with bylaw requirements can create an agreement to pay common fees and assessments (including arrears from prior owners), and also can give rise to a valid claim on property enforceable against a subsequent property owner. Here, however, the panel found that the terms of the recorded covenants were ambiguous and did not provide fair notice that property purchased in this community would be conveyed subject to a contractual requirement that the arrears of prior owners were enforceable against subsequent owners or that there would be an enforceable servitude on the property for those arrears.

We granted the Association’s petition for certification, Highland Lakes Country Club v. Franzino, 183 N.J. 213, 871 A.2d 91 (2005), and now reverse the judgment of the Appellate Division.

[104]*104I.

A.

Highland Lakes Country Club and Community Association (the Association) is a private, single-family, residential community governed by a not-for-profit corporation. Restrictive membership covenants contained in the community’s master deed, in subsequent deeds used in the transfer of title to property, and in the Association’s Bylaws require all property owners in the community to join the Association.1 There appears to be no dispute that membership covenants are valid and enforceable and run with the land, binding all owners of property within a community. Paulinskill Lake Ass’n, v. Emmich, 165 N.J.Super. 43, 45, 397 A.2d 698 (App.Div.1978). At issue is the Association’s position that, based on deed language requiring adherence to Bylaw requirements, arrears on membership charges that were accrued by predecessors in title may be enforced both as a contractual obligation undertaken by an acquiring property owner and as an equitable servitude on the property. We thus turn to the relevant language in the Bylaws that, coupled with the deed covenants, is asserted to provide notice that a purchaser in this community acquires the property with a concomitant obligation to pay arrears accrued by prior owners and that the property may be subject to an equitable servitude for such arrears.

Article III of the Bylaws includes the following provisions:

SECTION VIII. Membership privileges in the Club will not be granted on resale or other transfer of ownership of property until all Club dues, assessments and initiation fees in arrears are paid in full. (Amended 8/15/93)
[105]*105SECTION IX. Membership in the Club shall be granted automatically to new owners upon proof of conveyance of title to property in Highland Lakes satisfactory to the Membership Committee. The effective date of the membership of such new owners shall coincide with the effective date of the acquisition of title by such new owners, and such membership shall continue for the entire duration of ownership. Such new owners shall complete a membership data form and file the same with the Club at the time proof of conveyance of title is presented but any failure or delay in presenting such proof of conveyance of title or filing such membership data form shall not be deemed to relieve such new owners from the obligation of paying Club dues, assessments and initiation fees from the time the same shall have become due. (Amended 8/18/85)
SECTION X. All members shall comply with the By-Laws and Rules and Regulations of Highland Lakes Country Club and Community Association. (Amended 8/16/81)
SECTION XI. (Adopted 8/18/85) The Club shall have a lien on the real property in Highland Lakes of a member for all of such member’s unpaid dues, assessments and initiation fees, together with the late payment charges thereon and reasonable attorney’s fees for the collection thereof, which lien shall be effective and may be foreclosed in the following manner:
A. Such lien shall be effective from and after the time of recording in the office of the Clerk of Sussex County of a claim of lien stating the description of the property, the name and address of the record owner, the amount due and the date when due. Such claim of lien shall include only sums which are due and payable when the claim of lien is recorded and shall be signed and verified by an Officer of the Club. Upon full payment of all sums secured by the lien, the party making payment shall be entitled to a recordable satisfaction of lien. (Amended 8/15/93)
B. Liens for unpaid dues, assessments and initiation fees may be foreclosed by suit brought in the name of the Club in the same manner as a foreclosure of mortgage on real property.
C. Any suit brought by the Club to recover a money judgment for unpaid dues, assessments and initiation fees shall not be construed as a waiver on its part of the lien securing the same.

B.

The history of this litigation, culminating in the present claim for arrears filed against homeowner, Robert Franzino, may be summarized as follows. On June 22, 1972, Gregory and Marilyn Donchevich purchased the Highland Lakes home that is the subject of this appeal. The Doncheviehes gave a purchase money mortgage to Forman Mortgage Company. Through a series of assignments, Oxford Financial Companies (Oxford) came to hold the mortgage on the property. On December 12, 1990, Oxford [106]*106filed a complaint in foreclosure against the Doneheviches. The Association was joined as a party because it had a docketed judgment for arrears owed by the Doneheviches (Docket No. J-93072-89, entered in Superior Court of New Jersey on November 14, 1989 in the amount of 6,374.83, plus fees and costs). In Oxford’s prayers for relief it sought a judgment barring and foreclosing all defendants of all equity or redemption in and to the property.2

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Gagnesh Gupta v. Summit at Neptune Condominium Association
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2026
Astranza, Inc. v. Mod Lifestyles, LLC
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2026
Paul Savas v. New Jersey American Water Company, Inc.
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2025
Evolution Construction, LLC v. Finomus Orange Re Holdings, LLC
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2025
1410 Grand Adams, LLC v. Trematore Construction, LLC
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2025
Pmg New Jersey II, LLC v. Amrit Inc.
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2025
Sb Pb Victory, L.P. v. Tonnelle North Bergen, LLC
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2025
John P. Gross v. Ocean Beach Surf Club Unit 1
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2024
Nmr & Associates v. Hope Chapel Associates
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2024
Scott Diamond v. Warren Diamond
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2024
Patrick Boyle v. Carol Huff
Supreme Court of New Jersey, 2024
R.T.E. v. J.K.S.
New Jersey Superior Court App Division, 2024
ALBEE v. ALBEE
E.D. Pennsylvania, 2024
ARSENIS v. M&T BANK
D. New Jersey, 2024

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
892 A.2d 646, 186 N.J. 99, 2006 N.J. LEXIS 169, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/highland-lakes-country-club-community-assn-v-franzino-nj-2006.