W. K. Co. v. Commissioner

56 T.C. 434, 1971 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 128
CourtUnited States Tax Court
DecidedMay 27, 1971
DocketDocket Nos. 4658-69, 4659-69, 4660-69, 4661-69, 4662-69, 4663-69, 4664-69
StatusPublished
Cited by6 cases

This text of 56 T.C. 434 (W. K. Co. v. Commissioner) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Tax Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
W. K. Co. v. Commissioner, 56 T.C. 434, 1971 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 128 (tax 1971).

Opinion

TietjeNS, Judge:

The Commissioner determined the following income tax deficiencies in these consolidated cases:

Taxable Docket year Deficiency Petitioners No. ended
W. K. Co. and its wholly owned Subsidiary — Public Taxi Service, Ine_ 4668-69 Courteous Cab Co.-.. 4669-69 Courteous Cab Co., successor by merger to Gemini Cab Co_.— 4660-69 Courteous Cab Co., successor by merger to Four Star Cab Co. 4661-69 Courteous Cab Co., successor by merger to Venus Cab Corp. 4662-69 Courteous Cab Co., successor by mergor to Jupiter Cab Corp. 4663-69 Courteous Cab Co., successor by merger to Leo Cab Co.. 4664-69 [9/30/64 19/30/66 (9/30/66 6/30/66 [7/31/64 17/31/65 (7/31/66 [6/30/64 16/30/65 (6/30/66 |9/30/64 l9/30/65 (9/30/66 7/31/64 (7/31/66 (7/31/66 [9/30/64 (9/30/65 (9/30/66 $3,726.31 10,683.22 24,494.52 1,983.84 142.19 893.73 1,501.92 18.41 103.33 100.96 457.77 592.23 586.00 166.98 659.79 152.00 95.50 471.94 1,174.08

The sole issue presented for our resolution is whether petitioners are entitled to amortize certain taxicab licenses or whether such licenses cannot be amortized because they have indeterminate useful, lives.

FINDINGS OF FACT

Some of the facts have been stipulated. The stipulation and exhibits attached thereto are incorporated herein by this reference.

Petitioners, W. K. Co. and its wholly owned subsidiary, Public Taxi Service, Inc., are corporations organized and doing business under the laws of the State of Illinois and at the time they filed their petition herein their principal office was located at Chicago, Ill. Both corporations filed consolidated corporate income tax returns (Form 1120) for the taxable years ended September 30, 1964, September 30, 1965, and September 30, 1966, with the district director of internal revenue at Chicago, Ill.

Petitioner, Courteous Cab Co., is a corporation organized and doing business under the laws of the State of Illinois and at the time it filed its petition herein its principal office was located at Chicago, Ill. Its corporate income tax return (Form 1120) for the taxable year ended June 30, 1966, was filed with the district director of internal revenue at Chicago, I'll.

Courteous Cab Co. is also the successor by merger dated January 13, 1969, to Gemini Cab Co., Four Star 'Cab Co., Venus Cab Corp., Jupiter Cab Corp., and Leo Cab Co. At the time petitioner filed its petitions herein with respect to Gemini Cab Co. (docket No. 4660-69), Four Star Cab Co. (docket No. 4661-69), Venus Cab Corp. (docket No. 4662-69), Jupiter Cab Corp. (docket No. 4663-69), and Leo Cab Co. (docket No. 4664-69), its principal office was located at Chicago, Ill.

Gemini Cab Co. filed corporate income tax returns (Form 1120) for its taxable years ended July 31,1964, July 31,1965, and July 31,1966, with the district director of internal revenue at Chicago, Ill.

Four Star Cab Co. filed corporate income tax returns (Form 1120) for its taxable years ended June 30,1964, June 30, 1965, and June 30, 1966, with the district director of internal revenue at Chicago, Ill.

Venus Cab Corp. filed corporate income tax returns (Form 1120) for its taxable years ended September 30, 1964, September 30, 1965, and September 30,1966, with the district director of internal revenue at Chicago, Ill.

Jupiter Cab Corp. filed corporate income tax returns (Form 1120) for its taxable years ended July 31, 1964, July 31, 1965, and July 31, 1966, with the district director of internal revenue at Chicago, Ill.

Leo Cab Co. filed corporate income tax returns (Form 1120) for its taxable years ended September 30,1964, September 30,1965, and September 30, 1966, with the district director of internal revenue at Chicago, Ill.

Throughout the years here in question the petitioners’ outstanding stock was owned solely by Arthur Dickholtz. The petitioners, during the years in question, operated a fleet of taxicabs in the city of Chicago. Petitioners are considered to be among the “independent” companies as distinguished from Yellow Cab Co. and Checker Taxi Co.

Petitioners purchased taxicab licenses on the dates and for the amounts indicated below; petitioners also claimed deductions for the amortization of such license costs, as follows:

ifgesiiifsis 1 ÉÜMM t-Trt ri r-T CÍ* COCÓ'CÍCCCOCO'CO-sssssssssssss S §$3$£8888 IMIlls'llSSlIS I fgllill ^‘^.H^rírÍTH efcíc^fcírt* «O* mcocommT^co SSSB£SSS8g¡gg£S g 833ÍB8&B lllliglllllis iIgiiill rt“rírH-rt'-rrt'rt-rH cfeíw'círt" TO CO SggSgSSSggSgSS! g ssss 1 fill HHHH r4*4 ^"r-TríC^N r-T t-Tr-T SSWgggggggg Mummt -T SSSSSSSS^g^SS 5S gg£g$S$ 8SSggggggggigg§°goggoog llggliillgiillllilligl .■W^rfW-rfrfcffrfrfrf^^cfef^efffjJ SffIff f f f § §§ S !!!!!!! ssss 9/30 9/30 9/30 7,376.36 24,911.94 1 60,971.38 60,812.92 42,342.82 317.29 J9.?JL 00 '688 ‘i 2,389.00 S' 903.85 2,389.00 604.17 1,035.00 184.37 316.00 $2,464.00 $347.00 211.00 16.41 430.29 1,963.15 $4,165.00 211.00 428.00 1,961.00 $4’111! 00 428.00 1,961.00 $105.36 $211.00 250.00 428.00 653.85 1,961.00 6/30 9/65 $11,800.00 6/30 1/64 965.77 7/31 1/64 1,964.29 4/64 8,500.00 7/31 1/64 4,747.02 65 1/64 1,448.66 55 Leo Cab Co. Venus Cab Corp.._. Public Taxi Service. Jupiter Cab Corp. Courteous Cab Co. Four Star Cab Co. Gemini Cab Co___ 1969 1968 1967 1966 1965 f96I Riscal year Total Cost Date purchased Company Amortization of Taxicab

On May 18, 1934, the Chicago City Council passed an ordinance regulating the operation of taxicabs in the city of Chicago. This ordinance was a franchise ordinance granting permission and authority for the operation of taxicabs within the city and for the appointment of a public vehicle license commissioner. The ordinance provided for the issuance of licenses to operate taxicabs in the city for a term ending December 31, 1940, unless sooner terminated or revoked as provided in the ordinance. Based upon this ordinance, 4,108 taxicab licenses were issued in the city of Chicago. The Yellow Cab Co. received 2,166 licenses and the Checker Taxi Co. received 1,500. The remaining 442 licenses were received by “independents” including petitioner, Public Taxi Service, Inc.

As a result of the following period of economic depression, the operation of taxicabs in the city of Chicago resulted in unprofitable operations from the standpoint of the drivers and licensees, resulting in strikes and other violence on the city streets. In 1937, it was determined that a reduction in the number of taxicabs operated in the city and an increase in the fares charged was a matter of public convenience and necessity. Accordingly, on December 22, 1937, the city council passed an ordinance providing for a method of voluntary surrender by licensees of enough of their licenses to reduce the total from 4,108 to 3,000. This ordinance provided that in the event the number of authorized licenses should later be increased above the 3,000 figure, such additional licenses, not to exceed the number surrendered, should first be issued to licensees ratably in proportion to the number voluntarily surrendered by each licensee. The ordinance also provided that authority of the licensees to operate taxicabs under the 1934 ordinance be extended to December 31, 1945, provided the licensees accepted the terms of the 1937 ordinance.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cutler v. Commissioner
1977 T.C. Memo. 320 (U.S. Tax Court, 1977)
Van De Steeg v. Commissioner
60 T.C. No. 3 (U.S. Tax Court, 1973)
Mills Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Commissioner
57 T.C. 308 (U.S. Tax Court, 1971)
W. K. Co. v. Commissioner
56 T.C. 434 (U.S. Tax Court, 1971)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
56 T.C. 434, 1971 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 128, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/w-k-co-v-commissioner-tax-1971.