Long v. MEMORIAL HOSP. AT GULFPORT

969 So. 2d 35, 2007 WL 2948975
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedOctober 11, 2007
Docket2006-CA-00875-SCT
StatusPublished
Cited by39 cases

This text of 969 So. 2d 35 (Long v. MEMORIAL HOSP. AT GULFPORT) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Long v. MEMORIAL HOSP. AT GULFPORT, 969 So. 2d 35, 2007 WL 2948975 (Mich. 2007).

Opinion

969 So.2d 35 (2007)

Douglas LONG, Richard Long, Earl Long, and the Heirs at Law of Edward Long, who are Joyce Long, individually, Crystal Long, a minor, Edward Long, Jr., a minor, and Christopher Long, a minor, who are all represented by their Mother and Natural Guardian, Joyce Long; The Heirs at Law of David Long, Who are John Colby Long, a minor, represented by his Mother and Natural Guardian, Teri Long Scarborough, and Corey Long
v.
MEMORIAL HOSPITAL AT GULFPORT and Thomas Vaughan, M.D.

No. 2006-CA-00875-SCT.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

October 11, 2007.
Rehearing Denied December 13, 2007.

*37 William B. Weatherly, Gulfport, attorney for appellants.

Patricia K. Simpson, Gulfport, Gaye Nell Currie, Lynda C. Carter, Nicole C. Huffman, Jackson, attorneys for appellees.

Before WALLER, P.J., EASLEY and CARLSON, JJ.

WALLER, Presiding Justice, for the Court.

¶ 1. Lori McKinney filed a medical malpractice lawsuit against Memorial Hospital at Gulfport on behalf of herself and all the wrongful death beneficiaries of Huey P. Long in the First Judicial District of the Circuit Court of Harrison County, Mississippi, on October 17, 2002. She caused no summons to issue from the circuit court in relation to this filing. See Miss. R. Civ. P. 4(a). The next day, Douglas Long, Edward P. Long and Richard Long, without knowledge of the McKinney suit, filed a malpractice lawsuit based on the same event in the same court. They caused no summons to issue from the court at that time. This complaint was amended shortly thereafter to add Earl Long as a plaintiff. Again, no summons issued from the circuit court. Upon discovering the McKinney lawsuit, the Longs moved the circuit court to consolidate the actions. Initially, the circuit court denied consolidation and dismissed the Long action. Upon reconsideration, the court reversed its decision, granting consolidation and allowing the Longs to participate in the McKinney suit. The circuit court, again on reconsideration, ultimately denied the motion to consolidate and dismissed the Long complaint.

¶ 2. The interlocutory appeal from this judgment took the form of Long v. McKinney, 897 So.2d 160 (Miss.2004). This Court held that subsequent filings in wrongful death actions shall be dismissed, effectively affirming the circuit court's denial of consolidation and dismissal of the Long lawsuit. The opinion reversed the portions of the circuit court's order allowing McKinney and her counsel sole control of the proceedings on behalf of the plaintiffs and prohibiting participation by counsel for the Longs. Id. at 173-74, 178. The mandate of this opinion from this court issued April 14, 2005, directing the matter be remanded to the circuit court for further proceedings.

¶ 3. On June 3, 2005, a summons for Memorial Hospital issued from the circuit court and was served three days later on Memorial Hospital's registered agent for process. The Longs then filed an Amended Complaint on July 26, substituting Thomas Vaughan, M.D., for a John Doe defendant.[1] Summons for Vaughan issued the same day. Memorial Hospital filed a motion to dismiss on August 4, and its Answer on August 8, 2005. On November 23, the circuit court granted the Longs an extension of time to serve process on Vaughan. Service was accomplished on Vaughan on January 5, 2006. The circuit court granted Memorial Hospital's motion to dismiss, without prejudice, on January *38 9. Vaughan filed a motion to dismiss on February 7, along with his Answer. The court denied reconsideration of its order dismissing Memorial Hospital, and granted Vaughan's motion to dismiss, with prejudice. It is from these orders that the Longs now appeal.[2]

FACTS

¶ 4. The pertinent facts are uncontested. Huey P. Long died on October 8, 2002. Lori McKinney filed this medical malpractice action against Memorial Hospital at Gulfport on October 17, 2002. On September 19, 2003, this Court entered an order granting interlocutory appeal, stating the statute of limitations would be tolled during the pendency of the appeal and imposing a stay on the proceedings. This matter was remanded on April 15, 2005. No summons issued for Memorial Hospital until June 3, 2005. Process was served on Memorial Hospital three days later. The plaintiffs then filed an Amended Complaint naming Thomas Vaughan, M.D., as a defendant. Summons for Vaughan issued July 26, 2005, and was served on January 5, 2006. The trial court granted Memorial Hospital's motion to dismiss for the plaintiffs' failure to serve process upon it within 120 days of filing the lawsuit. The court later granted Vaughan's motion to dismiss.

STANDARD OF REVIEW

¶ 5. This Court leaves to the discretion of the trial court the finding of fact on the existence of good cause or excusable neglect for delay in serving process under Rule 4(h). Where such discretion is abused or is not supported by substantial evidence, this court will reverse. However, where the trial court's judgment involves the interpretation of legal principles, this court will conduct a de novo, or plenary, review of its interpretation, and reverse where it finds the trial court in error. Bennett v. McCaffrey, 937 So.2d 11, 14 (Miss.2006). See also Montgomery v. SmithKline Beecham, 910 So.2d 541, 544-45 (Miss.2005); Holmes v. Coast Transit Auth., 815 So.2d 1183, 1185 (Miss. 2002).

DISCUSSION

¶ 6. The circuit court's judgment dismissing Memorial Hospital without prejudice relied upon the facts that (1) neither McKinney nor the Longs caused a summons to issue from the circuit court or process to be served upon Memorial Hospital until almost three years after the filing of the original complaint, (2) no extension of time was requested or granted, and (3) there was no evidence Memorial Hospital attempted to evade service of process. The circuit court's order dismissing Vaughan found the statute of limitations barred the claims against him. We find the circuit court's judgment dismissing Memorial Hospital is supported by substantial evidence and it is, therefore, affirmed. For the reasons discussed below, we reverse the summary judgment granted in favor of Vaughan and remand this matter for further proceedings.

*39 I. WHETHER THE CIRCUIT COURT ERRED IN DISMISSING THE CLAIMS AGAINST MEMORIAL HOSPITAL AT GULFPORT.

¶ 7. The Longs argue the circuit court erred in granting Memorial Hospital's motion to dismiss because (1) it applied a strict rule that the complete failure to attempt service before the expiration of 120 days warranted dismissal, (2) the circuit court's orders forming the basis of the first appeal prohibited the Longs from having the McKinney complaint properly and timely served until after this Court's April 14, 2005, mandate on the first appeal, and (3) the circuit court's order dismissed the entire action, not simply the claims against Memorial Hospital. Memorial Hospital and Vaughan respond that the circuit court correctly applied Rule 4(h) to dismiss Memorial Hospital because good cause cannot be shown where no summons issued and no attempt to serve process occurred before June 6, 2005. They further contest the Longs's arguments that the court's rulings prohibited the Longs from serving process and the circuit court erred in dismissing the entire matter.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State of Louisiana v. Tyrek Randall
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2025
Reese Lindsey, D.O. v. Beverly Butts
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2024
Debra Green v. Singing River Health System
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2020
Palmer Ex Rel. Wrongful Death Beneficiaries v. Clark Clinic, Inc.
271 So. 3d 680 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2018)
Ali Almasri v. Cindy Hyde-Smith
246 So. 3d 84 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2018)
Robert Hammons, Jr. v. C. Wade Navarre, II
252 So. 3d 9 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2018)
Robert Hammons, Jr. v. C. Wade Navarre, II
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2017
Myrtle Booth v. Steven C. William, M.D.
200 So. 3d 1053 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2016)
David Glen Nunnery v. Paul Edward Nunnery
195 So. 3d 747 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2016)
Perriece Collins v. Toikus Westbrook
188 So. 3d 1206 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2014)
Burch v. Illinois Central Railroad
136 So. 3d 1063 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2014)
Clark v. Knesal
113 So. 3d 531 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2013)
Kevin G. Clark v. William E. Knesal
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2011
Copiah County School District v. Buckner
61 So. 3d 162 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2011)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
969 So. 2d 35, 2007 WL 2948975, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/long-v-memorial-hosp-at-gulfport-miss-2007.