Jenkins Subway, Inc. v. Jones

990 S.W.2d 713, 1998 Tenn. App. LEXIS 774
CourtCourt of Appeals of Tennessee
DecidedNovember 18, 1998
StatusPublished
Cited by40 cases

This text of 990 S.W.2d 713 (Jenkins Subway, Inc. v. Jones) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Tennessee primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Jenkins Subway, Inc. v. Jones, 990 S.W.2d 713, 1998 Tenn. App. LEXIS 774 (Tenn. Ct. App. 1998).

Opinion

FARMER, J.

Plaintiffs Jenkins Subway, Inc., and Rose Jenkins appeal the trial court’s final judgment dismissing their claims for breach of contract and breach of fiduciary duty against Defendant/Appellee Lynn Jones. The trial court’s judgment in favor of Jones was based primarily on the court’s ruling that, even if the subject contracts survived the December 1993 death of Rose Jenkins’ husband, Ed Jenkins, Rose Jenkins and Jenkins Subway effectively waived or were estopped from asserting their rights under the contracts. We conclude that this ruling was in error, and, thus, we reverse the trial court’s judgment and remand for further proceedings.

L Factual and Procedural History

In November 1991 Ed Jenkins and Lynn Jones entered into an agreement for the acquisition and management of a Subway sandwich shop franchise located in the Lynnwood shopping center in Jackson, Tennessee. In the event their franchise application was successful, the agreement required Ed Jenkins to finance the acquisition of the franchise’s assets and the operation of the franchise by guaranteeing and furnishing the collateral for a $160,000 note. The $160,000 note represented the $150,000 purchase price for the assets plus $10,000 in working capital for the franchise. In exchange, Jones agreed to attend any training sessions required by the Subway franchisor and to manage the franchise’s business. Following their acquisition of the franchise and assets, the agreement required the parties to transfer the assets to a newly-formed corporation. *716 The agreement gave Jones the right to serve as an officer and director in the corporation. Under the terms of the agreement, all of the corporate stock initially would be owned by Ed Jenkins. Once the $160,000 note was paid in full and Ed Jenkins was released from his guaranty, the agreement required him to transfer twenty-five percent (25%) of the corporation’s stock to Jones. In the event that Jones ceased to manage the Subway franchise prior to the note being paid, Jones would forfeit any interest in the corporation’s stock and assets.

In accordance with the 1991 agreement, Ed Jenkins formed a new corporation called Jenkins Subway, Inc. Thereafter, the Lynnwood Subway franchise’s assets were transferred to the corporation, and Lynn Jones became the corporation’s vice president. In 1992, Ed Jenkins and Jones acquired another Subway franchise in Camden, Tennessee. Because Ed Jenkins contemplated the acquisition of additional franchises, Ed Jenkins and Lynn Jones executed a second agreement in August 1993. The 1993 agreement recited that Subway had changed its requirements for franchisees by requiring that all named franchisees attend Subway’s training school. Inasmuch as Ed Jenkins did not wish to attend the training school, and inasmuch as Jones had attended and successfully completed the training school, the parties agreed that any franchises acquired by Ed Jenkins after the date of the agreement would be acquired in the name of Jones, although the funding for same would be provided by Ed Jenkins. To this end, the 1993 agreement provided that:

1.From and after the effective date of this Agreement and for so long as Subway requires its franchisees to attend its training school, any franchises acquired by Jenkins shall be in the name of Jones. Although the franchise will show Jones as the franchisee, it is the understanding and agreement of the parties that Jenkins shall be the real party in interest, and Jones shall if requested by Jenkins execute such documents as may be necessary to vest ownership of said franchise in Jenkins.
2. If at a future time the Corporation may be the franchisee of the franchises acquired in the name of Jones from and after the date of this Agreement, then Jones shall execute such documents as may be necessary to transfer said franchises to Corporation.
3. Jones agrees to continue to manage the various Subway franchises owned by Jenkins, including those acquired in Jones’ name subsequent to the execution of this Agreement, under and pursuant to that Agreement between the parties dated the [17th] day of November, 1991, under which, among other things, Jones will acquire twenty-five percent (25%) of the stpck of Corporation upon the repayment of those obligations made or guaranteed by Jenkins.
This Agreement shall be binding upon the parties, their heirs and assigns.

In accordance with their 1993 agreement, Ed Jenkins and Lynn Jones acquired two additional Subway franchises, one in McKenzie, Tennessee, and another in Huntingdon, Tennessee. In December 1993, however, Ed Jenkins died unexpectedly. Ed Jenkins’ widow, Plaintiff Rose Jenkins, inherited his assets, including his Subway franchises and all of the stock of Jenkins Subway, Inc.

In early 1994, Lynn Jones was offered the opportunity to participate in a partnership which would own and operate a new Subway franchise located in the Jackson-Madison County General Hospital. Jones already knew the other partners, who included Mark and Nancy Bradford and Cheri Childress, because they also owned Subway franchises in various cities. Initially, the other partners merely offered Jones two percent (2%) of the new franchise’s profits. 1 Jones responded by stat *717 ing that, out of respect for Ed Jenkins, he believed he should discuss the proposal with Rose Jenkins. When they subsequently discussed the proposal, Rose Jenkins asked Jones if they should get more than the two percent offered, and she indicated that they should “look into it” further.

After further negotiations, the Brad-fords and Cheri Childress proposed that they form a partnership with Lynn Jones to own and operate the hospital Subway franchise. The Bradfords and Childress proposed that Jones would own fifty percent (50%) of the new partnership, but they made clear that they did not want Rose Jenkins to be a partner because they did not know her. After Jones discussed this proposal with Rose Jenkins, she agreed that Jones should participate in the hospital Subway franchise as a 50% partner. Jones suggested that, if the hospital Subway franchise was profitable, at some future date he might be able to reduce his salary from Jenkins Subway and instead support himself with the income from the hospital Subway franchise. Jones and Rose Jenkins agreed that such an arrangement would be beneficial for Jenkins Subway.

In July 1994 Lynn Jones and the other partners signed an agreement whereby they formed a partnership called Health Ventures. The stated purpose of the partnership was to acquire, develop, and operate a Subway franchised facility in space to be leased from the Jackson-Madison County General Hospital. Paragraph 9.1 of the partnership agreement prohibited any of the partners from assigning, selling, transferring, hypothecating, conveying, mortgaging, or otherwise encumbering “his or her respective interest in the Partnership without the prior express consent of the other Partners.”

Lynn Jones’ participation in the partnership required an initial investment of almost $30,000, including $1250 for the franchise fee, $1700 for the first month’s rent, and $25,000 for operational expenses. As Ed Jenkins had done in acquiring past Subway franchises, Rose Jenkins provided the investment funds by obtaining a $30,-000 loan from Volunteer Bank.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

TIMGMT Acquisitions, LLC v. 5D Development, Inc.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2026
PHILIP J. BRYCE v. NATHAN PARTIN
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2025
Joe H. Edwards v. Angela L. Underwood
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2025
Harrington v. White
W.D. Tennessee, 2024
Old Hickory Coaches, LLC v. Star Coach Rentals, Inc.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2021
Phillip Mahnken v. Andrew Bettis Aviation, LLC
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2020
Solomon Menche v. White Eagle Property Group, LLC
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2019
Christine Song v. Jane C. Chung
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2018
Mike Cradic v. McCoy Motors, Inc.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2014
David Dell'Aquila v. Larry Head
545 F. App'x 439 (Sixth Circuit, 2013)
Productive MD, LLC v. Aetna Health, Inc.
969 F. Supp. 2d 901 (M.D. Tennessee, 2013)
Regions Bank v. Thomas D. Thomas
422 S.W.3d 550 (Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2013)
Delano v. Abbott Laboratories
908 F. Supp. 2d 888 (W.D. Tennessee, 2012)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
990 S.W.2d 713, 1998 Tenn. App. LEXIS 774, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/jenkins-subway-inc-v-jones-tennctapp-1998.