Denver Foundation v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.

163 P.3d 1116, 2007 WL 1881125
CourtSupreme Court of Colorado
DecidedJuly 2, 2007
Docket05SC849
StatusPublished
Cited by379 cases

This text of 163 P.3d 1116 (Denver Foundation v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Colorado primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Denver Foundation v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 163 P.3d 1116, 2007 WL 1881125 (Colo. 2007).

Opinions

Chief Justice MULLARKEY

delivered the Opinion of the Court.

Charles Sterne and Dorothy Elder Sterne created a charitable trust bequeathing, upon their deaths, a portion of their estate for the uses and purposes of The Denver Foundation, a philanthropic community trust, to be held in trust by the United Bank of Denver. After the Sternes passed away, The Denver Foundation requested Wells Fargo Bank, successor trustee to the United Bank of Denver, to transfer the Sternes' trust principal to The Denver Foundation's nonprofit corporation to hold for management and investment. Wells Fargo refused, claiming the Sternes' trust document prohibited such a transfer. The Denver probate court granted summary judgment in favor of The Denver Foundation, but in Denver Foundation v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., 140 P.3d 78 (Colo.App.2005), the court of appeals reversed that judgment. We now reverse the court of appeals' decision, holding that the Sternes' trust instrument does not forbid the transfer of the trust principal to The Denver Foundation's nonprofit corporation and, indeed, that the [1119]*1119Sternes' intent in establishing the trust would be best effectuated by such a transfer.

I. Facts and Procedural History

In 1925, Denver community leaders created The Denver Foundation (also "the Foundation"), which was designed to serve the charitable, educational, and benevolent needs of the greater Denver area in perpetuity. The Denver Foundation was envisioned as an organization that would "afford an opportunity alike to persons of wealth and persons of moderate means to make their several gifts to different trustees of their own selection" while meeting "the changing needs for such gifts with flexibility in the power of distribution." To govern the organization, the creators of The Denver Foundation ratified a Declaration of Trust ("1925 Declaration") establishing the Foundation and describing its charitable purposes.

As envisioned in 1925, trust settlors were to make their gifts to trustee banks, which would hold the principal in trust and then disburse the yearly income on the principal to The Denver Foundation. In turn, The Denver Foundation would distribute a portion of that income to various community "beneficiaries" identified and selected by an impartial and changing committee knowledgeable about the charitable needs of the time. The Foundation would then reinvest the remainder in the Foundation's endowment, which is comprised of several component funds subject to separate accounting and community recognition.

From its inception as a community trust,1 The Denver Foundation has enjoyed expansive powers not generally accorded to traditional beneficiaries. For instance, The Denver Foundation's 1925 Declaration ensured it was free to modify restrictions in trust gifts that had ceased to serve the best interests of the Foundation's charitable beneficiaries.2 That Declaration also granted the Foundation the power to direct transfers of income and principal 3 and to conclusively construe, if in good faith, any provision contained in the Declaration.4

Drawn to the Foundation's mission and unique structure for charitable giving, Charles Sterne, a long-time Denver philanthropist, created a trust in 1976 for the uses and purposes of The Denver Foundation, naming United Bank of Denver (predecessor to Wells Fargo Bank, NA.) as trustee. In 1978, Dorothy Elder Sterne, his wife, created a similar trust (the two trusts are henceforth referred to as "the Sterne-Elder Trust" or "the Trust"). The Sterne-Elder Trust provided that upon the Sternes' deaths, the principal of the Trust should be held by the United Bank of Denver, and The Denver Foundation would receive and then distribute the income from the principal to various charities. The Sternes intended their gift as a permanent endowment. Section 2(c)(8)(d) of the Sterne-Elder Trust agreement provided that "[nleither The Denver Foundation nor its Distribution Committee is authorized to direct disbursement of principal, or invade the principal, of such Trust." The Sterne, Elder Trust incorporated by reference the [1120]*1120Foundation's Declaration of Trust, along with any future amendments to the Declaration.5

The Denver Foundation made a significant change to its structure in 1983. Until 1983, the Foundation could not directly hold and manage endowment funds; settlors were required to make gifts to trustee banks, which would hold the funds for the uses and purposes of the Foundation. In 1988, however, the Foundation established a nonprofit corporation capable of carrying out the same functions that had theretofore been performed by trustee banks-holding and investing trust principal as the Foundation's permanent endowment. Once the Foundation's nonprofit corporation was organized, the corporation assumed the role of the common governing body of the Foundation, and each trust held by the corporation for the uses and purposes of the Foundation was to be treated by the Internal Revenue Service as a "component part" of the Foundation. Since 1983, most settlors have chosen to make their gifts directly to the corporation, streamlining the charitable giving process by eliminating the middleman trustee banks, although settlors are still free to give a gift to be held in trust by a participating trustee bank.

In 1997, The Denver Foundation adopted an Amended and Restated Declaration of Trust ("1997 Declaration"), the operative doe-ument governing the Foundation and its activities at present. The 1997 Declaration continues to allow for alternative plans, administered either by the corporation or by trustees of settlors' own selection.6 All gifts, however, are governed by the 1997 Declaration, which contains many of the same types of provisions as those in the 1925 Declaration. For instance, the 1997 Declaration provides, in Article 2-8, a broad power to modify designations and restrictions on the "use or distribution of funds." Article 38-1.1, titled "Transfer of Funds to Corporation," mandates that "[elach Trustee Bank shall, within ten days after the last day of each calendar quarter, pay and disburse to the Corporation such portion of the net income and principal of each trust held by it hereunder as the Board of Trustees shall direct." Article 7-8.3 reiterates The Denver Foundation's power to conclusively construe the Foundation's Declaration,7 and Article 7-8.5 allows the Foundation to "[almend any of the terms or provisions of this Declaration ... provided, however, that no change shall be made to this Declaration of Trust that modifies, enlarges, or restricts the powers, duties or liabilities of any Trustee Bank."

Around the same time The Denver Foundation adopted the 1997 Declaration, it also reviewed the management of its endowment funds, including those component parts of its endowment held and managed by trustee banks. Based on that review, the Foundation determined that it could better serve the charitable needs of its community beneficiaries if it centralized management of its endowment in its nonprofit corporation.8 Accordingly, the Foundation requested its trustee banks transfer the principal of component trusts to the Foundation to be held by the corporation as part of its endowment.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Matter of Pedot Trust
Colorado Court of Appeals, 2026
Peo v. Teague
Colorado Court of Appeals, 2025
Matter of Sewell Properties Trust
Colorado Court of Appeals, 2025
Marriage of Terry
Colorado Court of Appeals, 2024
In re Marriage of Smith
2024 COA 95 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2024)
Sandstead-Corona v. Sandstead—Implied Trusts—
2018 CO 26 (Supreme Court of Colorado, 2018)
Cohen v. Minneapolis Jewish Fed'n
286 F. Supp. 3d 949 (W.D. Wisconsin, 2017)
Rice's Lucky Clover Honey, LLC. v. Hawley
700 F. App'x 852 (Tenth Circuit, 2017)
In re the Estate of Sandstead
2016 COA 49 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2016)
Sandstead v. Corona (In re Estate of Sandstead)
412 P.3d 799 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2016)
Van Gundy v. Van Gundy
2012 COA 194 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2012)
Casey v. Colorado Higher Education Insurance Benefits Alliance Trust
2012 COA 134 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2012)
United States v. Barnes
883 F. Supp. 2d 1156 (M.D. Florida, 2011)
Plains Metropolitan District v. Ken-Caryl Ranch Metropolitan District
250 P.3d 697 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2010)
Plains Metro. Dist. v. KEN-CARYL RANCH
250 P.3d 697 (Colorado Court of Appeals, 2010)
Hansen v. Bothe
10 So. 3d 213 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2009)
Denver Foundation v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.
163 P.3d 1116 (Supreme Court of Colorado, 2007)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
163 P.3d 1116, 2007 WL 1881125, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/denver-foundation-v-wells-fargo-bank-na-colo-2007.