State v. Township of Pohatcong

9 N.J. Tax 528
CourtNew Jersey Tax Court
DecidedMarch 2, 1988
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 9 N.J. Tax 528 (State v. Township of Pohatcong) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering New Jersey Tax Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Township of Pohatcong, 9 N.J. Tax 528 (N.J. Super. Ct. 1988).

Opinion

ANDREW, J.T.C.

In this local property tax case plaintiff, State of New Jersey, by the Commissioner of Transportation (State) challenges, only [530]*530in part, the imposition of rollback taxes pursuant to the Farmland Assessment Act of 1964, (the act), N.J.S.A. 54:4-23.1 et seq., by the Warren County Board of Taxation.

On January 8, 1986 the State, in an exercise of its power of eminent domain, acquired 33.71 acres of agricultural land in the Township of Pohatcong known and designated as Block 78, Lot 5Q FARM on the township’s tax map. Inasmuch as the property had been preferentially valued, assessed and taxed under the provisions of the act and the State had no intention of continuing to use the parcel for agricultural purposes, the township applied to the Warren County Board of Taxation pursuant to N.J.S.A. 54:4-23.8, -23.9 and -63.12 et seq. for the assessment of additional or rollback taxes. The county board entered judgment imposing rollback taxes for the tax years of 1983, 1984 and 1985.

The parties to this action agree that since a change in use occurred in 1986 the judgment of the county board is in error with regard to the rollback tax assessment for 1983. See Eagle Plaza Assocs. v. Voorhees Tp., 6 N.J.Tax 582, 593 (Tax Ct.1984). The parties also agree that rollback taxes were properly imposed for 1984 and 1985. The present dispute arises with regard to tax year 1986, the year in which the State acquired the property and also in which, as the parties have stipulated, the change in use occurred. The State contends that it is not subject to rollback taxes for 1986 on the basis that N.J.S.A. 54:4-3.3b exempts it from the imposition of rollback taxes upon compliance with its terms.

N.J.S.A. 54:4-3.3b provides:

Where real property is acquired by the State or by a State agency, or by an authority created by the State, by purchase, condemnation or otherwise, such property shall become tax exempt on January 1 of the calendar year next following the date of acquisition, provided that the tax assessor of the municipality in which such property is located is given written notice of the acquisition by certified mail on or before January 10 of said calendar year next following; provided further that if real property is acquired between January 1 and January 10 inclusive and the prescribed notice is given on or before January 10, such real property shall become tax exempt as of the date of acquisition. [Emphasis supplied]

[531]*531The State maintains that since the property was acquired on January 8, 1986 and the requisite notice was given to the assessor on the same date, the property was tax exempt for 1986, and therefore the rollback statute, N.J.S.A. 54:4-23.8, directs only the imposition of rollback taxes for 1984 and 1985.1

On the other hand, Pohatcong asserts first, that the State did not meet the notice-to-the-assessor requirement in a timely manner and thus the property was not tax exempt for 1986; and second, assuming timely notice, “the Legislature intended the State to pay rollback taxes for the years in which the change in use occurred, [stipulated to be] 1986, and for the two years immediately preceding, 1985 and 1984.”

Pursuant to R. 8:8-1(b) the parties have agreed to have this matter decided on stipulated facts which are as follows:

1. On November 7, 1985, James V. Hyde, Jr., Director of Right of Way, New Jersey Department of Transportation, signed a Declaration of Taking as to 33.71 acres of farmland designated as Block 78, Lot 5Q FARM and owned by Russell E. Cole located in Pohatcong Township, Warren County, New Jersey, for the construction of State Highway Route 78.
2. That Declaration of Taking was filed in the Superior Court of New Jersey on January 7, 1986.
3. On January 8, 1986, the State of New Jersey, by the Commissioner of Transportation, deposited with the New Jersey Superior Court $442,700 as estimated compensation for the property being acquired and damages, if any, to the remaining property owned by Cole.
4. On January 7, 1986, the State of New Jersey, by the Commissioner of Transportation, served a copy of the Declaration of Taking as to the subject lands on the Tax Assessor for the Township of Pohatcong by forwarding same to him certified mail, return receipt requested, at the Pohatcong Township Municipal Building, Municipal Drive, Springstown, P.O. Box 35, R.D. 1, Phillips-burg, New Jersey 08865. The cover letter accompanying the copy of the Declaration of Taking informed the Township that the enclosed Declaration of Taking was the Township’s notice of the State’s acquisition pursuant to N.J.S. A. 54:4-3.3b. The certified mail containing the notice described above was delivered to Gloria Babirak, the Pohatcong Township Deputy Clerk, and she signed the return receipt on January 8, 1986. John Woolaver, Pohatcong Township Tax Assessor, who is employed part time, received the foregoing [532]*532notice on January 13,1986, which is evidenced by his stamp marked “Received”, which appears on the notice document and envelope.
5. In January 1986 Ms. Babirak was Deputy Township Clerk and she was authorized to accept certified mail for township officials.
6. The State of New Jersey acquired the subject property, pursuant to its powers of eminent domain, on January 8, 1986.
7. At the time of its acquisition the property acquired by the State was receiving a farmland assessment.
8. In August 1986 the Township of Pohatcong filed a complaint with the Warren County Board of Taxation naming the State as a defendant and seeking rollback taxes on 32.71 acres of the property acquired by the State. The Township had deducted one acre from the State’s total acquisition for the land affiliated with the former owner’s farm house.
9. The Township’s complaint sought rollback taxes for the tax years 1986, 1985 and 1984.
10. The complaint set forth the following amounts as assessments and taxes:
Tax Year Assessed As Farmland Regular Assessment Difference Applicable Tax Rate Am’t of Tax
1986 $7,098 $129,074 $121,976 3.68 $4,427.73
1985 7.098 129.074 121.976 3.91 3,891.03
1984 7.098 129.074 121.976 3.15 3,842.24
11. On September 8, 1986 the Warren County Board of Taxation, by unanimous decision, entered judgment for the Township assessing rollback taxes for the tax years 1985, 1984 and 1983.
12. The State does not challenge the rollback tax assessment for the tax year 1984 and stipulates to taxes due in that year in the amount of $3,842.24.
13. The State does not challenge the rollback tax assessment made for the tax year 1985 and stipulates to taxes due for that tax year in the amount of $3,891.03.
14. The property acquired by the State changed to a non-farmland use in 1986.
15. The township makes no claim for rollback taxes in the tax year 1983 or for prior tax years.
16.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

New Jersey Turnpike Authority v. Township of Monroe
28 N.J. Tax 158 (New Jersey Tax Court, 2014)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
9 N.J. Tax 528, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-township-of-pohatcong-njtaxct-1988.