Robinson v. Healthworks Intern., LLC

837 So. 2d 714, 2003 La. App. LEXIS 134, 90 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 1756, 2003 WL 184698
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJanuary 29, 2003
Docket36,802-CA
StatusPublished
Cited by21 cases

This text of 837 So. 2d 714 (Robinson v. Healthworks Intern., LLC) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Robinson v. Healthworks Intern., LLC, 837 So. 2d 714, 2003 La. App. LEXIS 134, 90 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 1756, 2003 WL 184698 (La. Ct. App. 2003).

Opinion

837 So.2d 714 (2003)

Regina ROBINSON, Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
HEALTHWORKS INTERNATIONAL, L.L.C., Defendant-Appellant.

No. 36,802-CA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

January 29, 2003.
Rehearing Denied February 27, 2003.

*716 Stephen G. Dean, Rayville, James A. Rountree, for Appellant.

Courtman Employment Law Firm by: Matthew Maxwell Courtman, Robert Allen Lee, Monroe, for Appellee.

Before CARAWAY, PEATROSS and DREW, JJ.

CARAWAY, J.

Plaintiff left her former business and accepted employment with the defendant. After eight months, plaintiff quit her employment, claiming that she had been discriminated against on the basis of religion. She brought this suit for discrimination claims and for detrimental reliance concerning her change in employment. A jury awarded her judgment on both claims. For the following reasons, we affirm the judgment pertaining to employment discrimination, but reverse the judgment on plaintiff's detrimental reliance claim.

Facts

Healthworks International, L.L.C. ("Healthworks") employed plaintiff, Regina Robinson, from July of 1999 to March of 2000. Prior to her employment at Healthworks, Robinson and her current husband, Mike Johnson, owned and operated a business which made plastic display cases and repaired plastic tanks for farmers. They repaired approximately four tanks per week and sold approximately 200 plastic displays per week to Healthworks.

In March of 1998, Sam Noble and Ivan Hawthorne, the owners of Healthworks, approached Robinson and Johnson and asked them to work for the company. Healthworks wanted to produce the plastic displays in-house. Robinson and Johnson agreed to begin working there. At that time, Robinson and Johnson lived in West Carroll Parish and Healthworks' plant was located in Winnsboro. Robinson was employed as a "bending and assembly supervisor," which included the task of bending plastic used in the manufacturing process. Robinson's starting wages were $7.50 per hour, and she claims that Healthworks *717 offered to pay her $10 per hour after she was employed for six months.

Robinson is a Baptist. The other employees of Healthworks, including management, are Apostolic. Robinson stated that Mark Batterton, the operations manager, told her that women had to wear skirts to work. Prayer meetings were conducted every morning and Robinson was expected to attend those meetings.

She was also expected to attend the same church that the other employees and management attended, the Apostolic Tabernacle. At her first visit to the Tabernacle, she wore a dress with short sleeves. She also wore make-up and lipstick. Robinson testified that at that service the preacher pointed at her and called her a "Jezebel." During her second visit to the church with Johnson, the preacher commented that people with facial hair were evil. Johnson was the only person there with a beard.

According to Robinson, other employees ridiculed her about her religion. Don Batterton, a company supervisor, informed her that, according to the Bible, men were superior to women and that God would forgive her for being Baptist. Robinson testified that Batterton also played loud "preaching" tapes at the work site. The tapes were so loud that Robinson could not concentrate. On one occasion when Robinson's daughter was sick, Batterton instructed her to not take her daughter to the doctor and to let God heal her.

Robinson also testified that management and other employees also chanted and screamed, "We shall fear no evil." Employees looked at her and told her that there was an evil spirit in the factory and that they were going to cast out the evil spirit. On her last day of employment, one employee, Gloria Jackson, said, "God told me that someone was going to quit."

Procedural History and Jury Verdict

Robinson's petition urged various claims against Healthworks. She asserted an action for detrimental reliance, claiming that she had relied on Healthworks' promise to raise her salary to $10 per hour after her first six months of employment. After six months, she did not receive the raise. She further alleged that Healthworks' employment promises had caused her to abandon her plastics business in West Carroll Parish, and such business could not be re-established. Robinson also alleged claims for unlawful discrimination based on religion and gender.

Robinson requested a jury trial. In the jury charge, the trial court instructed the jury on two claims, detrimental reliance and religious discrimination. For the religious discrimination claim, the court specifically outlined the law pertaining to a hostile work environment and constructive discharge of an employee.

The jury found that Healthworks unlawfully discriminated against Robinson on the basis of her religion and awarded her $40,000 on that count. The jury awarded Robinson $31,200 in damages on the detrimental reliance claim. Additionally, pursuant to the employment discrimination statute, the trial court awarded Robinson attorney fees in the amount of $16,000.

The first five jury interrogatories were included under the subheading "Detrimental Reliance." The next six interrogatories were included under the subheading "Religious Discrimination." The jury answered "yes" to all of the jury interrogatories, which provided as follows:

1. Did Healthworks promise plaintiff $10 an hour after six months and a share of the profits of Healthworks?
2. Was the promise made in such a manner that Healthworks knew or *718 should have known that Mrs. Johnson would rely on the promise?
3. Did Mrs. Johnson change her position because of Healthworks' promise?
4. Was Mrs. Johnson's reliance on the promise reasonable?
5. Did Mrs. Johnson's reasonable reliance on the promise cause her damages?
6. Was Mrs. Johnson subjected to harassment?
7. Was the harassment motivated by discrimination against plaintiff's religion?
8. Did the harassment affect a term, condition, or privilege of employment?
9. Did Healthworks know, or should it have known, of the harassment, and if so, did it fail to take proper remedial action?
10. Was Mrs. Johnson subjected to such intolerable working conditions that she was forced to resign?
11. Were the intolerable working conditions the result of religious discrimination?

Answering the last two interrogatories, the jury fixed damages as follows:

12. If the answer to question five is "yes," state the amount of damages. $31,200.00
13. If the answer to question 11 is "yes," state the amount of damages. $40,000.

Healthworks appeals, raising the following assignments of error:

1. The trial court erred in finding that Robinson was constructively discharged;
2. The trial court erred in allowing Patrick and Christy Acton to testify as rebuttal witnesses; and
3. The trial court erred in awarding damages for both detrimental reliance and constructive discharge.

Robinson answered the appeal seeking additional attorney fees.

Discussion

Louisiana's anti-discrimination statute provides, in pertinent part, as follows:

It shall be unlawful discrimination in employment for an employer to engage in any of the following practices:

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Tarver v. Walmart Inc
W.D. Louisiana, 2024
Clark v. City of Alexandria
W.D. Louisiana, 2023
Germain Dodson v. Master Lube Express Inc.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2022
Arnold Lowther v. Town of Bastrop
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2020
Julie Gordon Kitziger Versus Michael F. Mire
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2019
Bolton v. Willis-Knighton Medical Center
116 So. 3d 76 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2013)
Harris v. Dunn
48 So. 3d 367 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010)
Stockmon v. Van Alstyne
976 So. 2d 336 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2008)
Bickham v. RIVERWOOD INTERN. CORP.
966 So. 2d 820 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2007)
May v. Harris Management Corp.
928 So. 2d 140 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2005)
Stewart v. Courtyard Management Corp.
155 F. App'x 756 (Fifth Circuit, 2005)
Hawthorne v. Couch
911 So. 2d 907 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2005)
Martin v. Martin
903 So. 2d 619 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2005)
Hibernia Nat. Bank v. Antonini
862 So. 2d 331 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2003)
St. Romain v. STATE, THROUGH DWF
863 So. 2d 577 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2003)
Ray v. City of Bossier City
859 So. 2d 264 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2003)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
837 So. 2d 714, 2003 La. App. LEXIS 134, 90 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 1756, 2003 WL 184698, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/robinson-v-healthworks-intern-llc-lactapp-2003.