Hooks v. George County

748 So. 2d 678, 1999 WL 718795
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedSeptember 16, 1999
Docket98-SA-00571-SCT
StatusPublished
Cited by49 cases

This text of 748 So. 2d 678 (Hooks v. George County) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Hooks v. George County, 748 So. 2d 678, 1999 WL 718795 (Mich. 1999).

Opinion

748 So.2d 678 (1999)

Mary Jane HOOKS
v.
GEORGE COUNTY, Mississippi.

No. 98-SA-00571-SCT.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

September 16, 1999.

Mark H. Watts, Pascagoula, Attorney for Appellant.

Sidney Amon Barnett, Darryl A. Hurt, Jr., Gerald Alan Dickerson, Lucedale, Attorneys for Appellee.

BEFORE PITTMAN, P.J., McRAE AND SMITH, JJ.

SMITH, Justice, for the Court:

¶ 1. This appeal comes to this Court following the granting of a private right of way, by the George County Board of Supervisors (hereinafter "the Board"), across the property of Mary Jane Hooks for the sole benefit of Doug Welford and wife, Juanita Welford, (the "Welfords") and the partial affirmance of that decision by the Chancery Court of George County. We, therefore, find that the chancellor was correct regarding the Welfords' standing to bring a petition before the Board of Supervisors. *679 The Welford's should have offered proof that they had first sought to purchase the right of way from Hooks, prior to filing with the Board of Supervisors. To now require that the Welfords make a formal offer to purchase is rather impotent in view of the fact that our judicial system is now involved.

¶ 2. However, the Board failed to make a determination that the right of way was reasonably necessary in view of the fact that the Welfords had two other easements of access to their property. The chancellor erred regarding this issue and we reverse thereon.

FACTS

¶ 3. On August 8, 1978, Casper and Ruby Mergenschroer, Hooks's parents, purchased forty acres from Sarah Miller, north of Basin Refuge road, described as the Northwest ¼ of the Southeast ¼ Section 36, Township 2 South, Range 7 West, in George County, Mississippi. Included in this conveyance was a right of way across Patricia Horn's property which allowed ingress and egress from the property to the road. The Mergenschroers then conveyed approximately three acres to their daughter, Hooks. On May 22, 1979, the Mergenschroers conveyed a perpetual easement or road right of way to Hooks and her former husband to allow for ingress and egress from Basin Refuge Road.

¶ 4. On August 22, 1997, Doug and Juanita Welford purchased a tract of land adjacent to the north side of Hooks's parents' property from Ruth Deakle along with a right of way to the property across Deakle's property. On August 23, 1997, the Welfords purchased from the Deakles a strip of land thirty feet by one thousand three hundred twenty feet.

¶ 5. This narrow strip is the very same land to which Hooks claims she was granted the previously mentioned easement. On September 4, 1997, Hooks returned home from work to find a new locked gate preventing her egress and ingress to her house. On September 5, 1997, Hooks was granted a temporary injunction to have the gate removed.

¶ 6. On October 31, 1997, George County Chancellor William H. Myers dissolved the injunction and granted leave for the parties to seek such relief for a private right of way before the George County Board of Supervisors. The Welfords filed their request for a private way on November 17, 1997, with the Board. On December 1, 1997, the Board ordered to approve a private way for Welford across the property of Hooks and to appraise the property for damages payable to Hooks. On December 5, 1997, Hooks filed a Bill of Exceptions with the Circuit Court of George County to appeal the Board's order.

¶ 7. Meanwhile, the Mergenschroers filed a petition for an injunction with the George County Chancery Court involving the same strip of land and gate against the Welfords, the Deakles, and another adjoining landowner, Robert E. Eubanks. The chancellor granted that petition for temporary injunction on November 6, 1997. On December 11, 1997, the Welfords filed a motion to contest jurisdiction and dissolve the injunction. On December 12, 1997, Chancellor Myers recused himself by order from the Mergenschroers's case.

¶ 8. Being made aware of the Mergenschroers' action in chancery court, on January 26, 1998, and finding that judicial economy would be best served by a transfer the Circuit Court of George County, sua sponte, transferred the appeal of Hooks from the Board's order to the Chancery Court of George County. Chancellor Glenn Barlow considered the record and rendered an opinion on March 10, 1998, affirming in part and remanding one issue to the Board. Specifically, the chancellor reversed and remanded the case to the Board for a ruling consistent with the petition and request in that the private way should be equally shared between the Scotts and the Hooks.

*680 ¶ 9. Aggrieved, Hooks timely appealed on March 23, 1998, raising the following issues:

I. THE COURT ERRED IN AFFIRMING THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS' ORDER WHERE THE WELFORDS FAILED TO MAKE THE REQUIRED SHOWING THAT THEY WERE UNABLE TO OBTAIN A REASONABLE RIGHT OF WAY FROM ALL THE SURROUNDING PROPERTY OWNERS.

II. THE COURT ERRED IN AFFIRMING THE ORDER OF THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS WHERE THE WELFORDS FAILED TO ESTABLISH THAT THE PRIVATE WAY WAS REASONABLY NECESSARY FOR INGRESS AND EGRESS.

STANDARD OF REVIEW

¶ 10. The standard of review for this case is substantial evidence, the same standard which applies in appeals from decisions of administrative agencies and boards. Barnes v. Board of Supervisors, 553 So.2d 508, 511 (Miss.1989). "The decision of an administrative agency is not to be disturbed unless the agency order was unsupported by substantial evidence; was arbitrary or capricious; was beyond the agency's scope or powers; or violated the constitutional or statutory rights of the aggrieved party." Board of Law Enforcement Officers Standards & Training v. Butler, 672 So.2d 1196, 1199 (Miss.1996). Substantial evidence has been defined as "such relevant evidence as reasonable minds might accept as adequate to support a conclusion" or to put it simply, more than a "mere scintilla" of evidence. Johnson v. Ferguson, 435 So.2d 1191, 1195 (Miss.1983).

¶ 11. In an appeal from the decision of a municipal authority, Miss.Code Ann. § 11-51-75 (1972) states that the person aggrieved may "embody the facts, judgment and decision in a bill of exceptions" which will be transmitted to the circuit court acting as an appellate court. Miss.Code Ann. § 11-51-75 (1972). The bill of exceptions serves as the record on appeal, and we have held that "[t]he circuit court can only consider the case as made by the bill of exceptions. This is the only record before the circuit court, as an appellate court." Stewart v. City of Pascagoula, 206 So.2d 325, 328 (Miss.1968).

LEGAL ANALYSIS

I. THE COURT ERRED IN AFFIRMING THE BOARD OF SUPERVISORS' ORDER WHERE THE WELFORDS FAILED TO MAKE THE REQUIRED SHOWING THAT THEY WERE UNABLE TO OBTAIN A REASONABLE RIGHT OF WAY FROM ALL THE SURROUNDING PROPERTY OWNERS.

¶ 12. Article 3, Section 14 of the Mississippi Constitution of 1890 provides that "(n)o person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property except by due process of law."

¶ 13. Article 4, Section 110 of the Mississippi Constitution of 1890 provides as follows:

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

J&A Excavation, Inc. v. City of Ellisville, Mississippi
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2023
John T. Seyfarth, Jr. v. Adams County Board of Supervisors
267 So. 3d 767 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2019)
Curtis Ray McCarty, Jr. v. Arthur Wood, III
249 So. 3d 425 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2018)
Joseph E. Davidson v. William Dwight Collins
195 So. 3d 825 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2015)
Lowndes County Ex Rel. Board of Supervisors v. McClanahan
161 So. 3d 1052 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2015)
Johnson v. Mississippi Department of Employment Security
150 So. 3d 149 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2014)
May v. Adirondack Timber I, LLC
129 So. 3d 219 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2013)
McKee v. City of Starkville
97 So. 3d 97 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
Valley Road Action Committee v. Lauderdale County Board of Supervisors
97 So. 3d 1242 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
McDonald v. King
60 So. 3d 217 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2011)
Ward v. Trimac Investments, LLC
78 So. 3d 341 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2011)
Sun Vista, Inc. v. Mississippi Department of Employment Security
52 So. 3d 1262 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2011)
UNIV. OF MISSISSIPPI MEDICAL CTR. v. Gore
40 So. 3d 545 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2010)
University of Mississippi Medical Center v. Gore
40 So. 3d 545 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2010)
Hall v. City of Ridgeland
37 So. 3d 25 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2010)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
748 So. 2d 678, 1999 WL 718795, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/hooks-v-george-county-miss-1999.