Deshotels v. SHRM Catering Services, Inc.

538 So. 2d 988, 1989 WL 6027
CourtSupreme Court of Louisiana
DecidedJanuary 30, 1989
Docket88-CQ-1323
StatusPublished
Cited by20 cases

This text of 538 So. 2d 988 (Deshotels v. SHRM Catering Services, Inc.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Louisiana primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Deshotels v. SHRM Catering Services, Inc., 538 So. 2d 988, 1989 WL 6027 (La. 1989).

Opinion

538 So.2d 988 (1989)

Joseph Mike DESHOTELS
v.
SHRM CATERING SERVICES, INC., et al.
v.
The LOUISIANA INSURANCE GUARANTY ASSOCIATION.

No. 88-CQ-1323.

Supreme Court of Louisiana.

January 30, 1989.
Rehearing Denied March 2, 1989.

Robert B. Nolan, Thomas G. O'Brien, Edwin C. Laizer, Adams & Reese, New Orleans, for defendant-third party plaintiff-appellee.

Judith R. Atkinson, Carey J. Guglielmo, Thomas E. Balhoff, Mathews, Atkinson, Guglielmo, Marks & Day, Baton Rouge, for third-party defendant-appellant.

WATSON, Justice.

This case involves a dispute between the Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association (LIGA) and plaintiff's employer, S.H.R.M. Catering Services, Inc. (SHRM). LIGA contends that SHRM's standard workers' compensation and liability policy is not covered by its insurance fund because the policy's maritime endorsement makes it ocean marine insurance exempted from coverage under LSA-R.S. 22:1377.

FACTS

The parties stipulated the following facts:

Joseph Mike Deshotels was employed by SHRM Catering Services, Inc. as a night cook aboard the MR. DEMP, a jack-up rig operating in the Gulf of Mexico. On September 26, 1984, while working on the vessel, Deshotels became ill with cellulitis and had to be transported by crewboat to a hospital on land. While he was in a personnel *989 basket being transferred to a crewboat, the crane operator lowering the basket dropped or slammed it to the deck of the crewboat from a height of about 10 feet. Deshotels suffered injuries to his cervical and lumbar regions that necessitated two surgeries.

In May 1985, Deshotels sued SHRM and Magnum-Marine Drilling Corporation, which owned the jack-up rig and employed the crane operator, for negligence under both general maritime law and the Jones Act.[1] In addition to general negligence claims under the Jones Act, he asserted a claim for maintenance and cure against SHRM and a claim against Magnum-Marine for breach of its duty to maintain a seaworthy vessel.

At the time of the accident, SHRM was insured by a "Standard Workmen's Compensation and Employer's Liability Policy" issued by Transit Casualty Company, a Missouri insurer. The policy included a maritime endorsement, which applied to "masters or members of the crews of vessels," noted that SHRM was engaged in offshore catering operations in Louisiana, and insured SHRM for its liability to provide transportation, wages, maintenance and cure to an employee who suffered bodily injury by accident or disease.

In December 1985, Transit was declared insolvent, and all Transit policies were cancelled by order of the Missouri Courts. SHRM then filed a third-party demand against LIGA contending that the claims asserted against it were covered by the Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association Law.[2] That law created LIGA as a non-profit, unincorporated entity to pay covered claims, up to statutory limits, in the event an insurer who was a member of the Association became insolvent.[3] LIGA coverage applies "to all kinds of direct insurance, except life, health and accident, title, disability, mortgage guaranty, and ocean marine insurance."[4]

LIGA denied liability to SHRM contending that Deshotel's claim involved "ocean marine insurance" to the extent he sought recovery under maritime laws for maritime-related injuries, such claims being risks normally and traditionally covered by ocean marine insurance.

Magnum-Marine filed for bankruptcy in Texas, and all proceedings against it were stayed. Prior to trial, Deshotels settled his claim with SHRM for $75,000.00, leaving only SHRM's third-party demand against LIGA. The parties submitted the matter to the trial court for decision on the basis of briefs, depositions, affidavits, stipulated facts and expert testimony in two other cases.[5]

Since policies of this type had been included in calculating the assessments that Transit paid to LIGA,[6] Judge Duhe of the federal district court decided that it would be inconsistent to exclude them from LIGA's protection. Therefore, the court ruled that the policy was not one of "ocean marine insurance" and LIGA was obligated to pay the amount of Deshotels' claim, as well as the expenses SHRM had incurred in defending and prosecuting the action. SHRM was awarded $75,000.00, the amount it had paid Deshotels to settle his claim; $24,143.79 in maintenance and cure benefits paid between December 1985 and August 1987; and $26,606.84 in attorney's fees incurred through July 31, 1987. The court also ruled that SHRM would be entitled *990 to any attorney's fees, costs, and expenses incurred after July 31, 1987.

CERTIFIED QUESTION

The Louisiana Supreme Court has accepted the following certified question:

"Does this claim for maritime-related injuries, brought on the Standard Workmen's Compensation and Employers' Liability policy with a marine endorsement, involve `ocean marine insurance' so as to be excluded, by virtue of La.R.S. 22:1377, from the coverage of the Insurance Guaranty Association Fund?"[7]

LAW

The Louisiana Insurance Code does not define "ocean marine" insurance. However, LSA-R.S. 22:6(13)(b) and (e) classify and define "marine and transportation (inland marine)" insurance, in pertinent part, as follows:

"(13) Marine and transportation (inland marine).

* * * * * *

"(b) Insurance against loss or damage to persons or property in connection with or appertaining to marine, inland marine, transit or transportation insurance, including liability for loss of or damage to either arising out of or in connection with the construction, repair, operation, maintenance, or use of the subject matter of such insurance,....
* * * * * *
"(e) `Marine protection and indemnity insurance,' meaning insurance against, or against legal liability of the insured for, loss, damage, or expense incident to ownership, operation, chartering, maintenance, use, repair or construction of any vessel, craft or instrumentality in use in ocean or inland waterways, including liability of the insured for personal injury, illness or death or for loss of or damage to the property of another person."

By its terms, the Louisiana Insurance Guaranty Association Act is to be "liberally construed" to avoid financial loss to claimants and distribute the cost of protecting insurers against insolvencies.[8]

According to the affidavit of the independent insurance broker which placed the coverage, SHRM's policies were not policies of "ocean marine insurance" and were not intended to be. They were compensation and general liability policies with an "admitted carrier", Transit.

The Federal courts considering numerous Louisiana cases involving this question have reached disparate results.

Sifers v. General Marine Catering Company[9] held that the ocean marine exclusion precluded LIGA liability for injuries or damages occurring during offshore marine activities with an admiralty setting. Coe v. L & L Sandblasting, Inc.[10] also held that a standard workers' compensation and employer's liability policy with a maritime endorsement was an ocean marine policy as to all maritime claims.

In Blair v. Sealift, Inc.,[11] Judge Heebe declined to follow Sifers and concluded that ocean marine insurance is property insurance covering ships and their cargoes. Therefore, an insurance policy which includes coverage for seamen's injuries is not a policy of ocean marine insurance.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Blair v. Sealift, Inc
Fifth Circuit, 1996
Tidelands Ltd. I v. La. Ins. Guar. Ass'n
645 So. 2d 1240 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1994)
Blair v. Sealift, Inc.
848 F. Supp. 670 (E.D. Louisiana, 1994)
Black v. Rebstock Drilling Co.
837 F. Supp. 200 (W.D. Louisiana, 1993)
Grubbs v. Gulf Intern. Marine, Inc.
625 So. 2d 495 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1993)
Florida Insurance Guaranty Ass'n v. Pilings & Structures, Inc.
616 So. 2d 532 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1993)
Doxey v. Zapata Haynie Corp.
615 So. 2d 36 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1993)
Nicholas v. New England International Surety of America, Inc.
613 So. 2d 1137 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1993)
Hae Woo Youn v. Maritime Overseas Corp.
605 So. 2d 187 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1992)
H & B Const. v. Louisiana Ins. Guar.
580 So. 2d 931 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1991)
Delaune v. Saint Marine Transportation Co.
749 F. Supp. 1463 (E.D. Louisiana, 1990)
Sifers v. General Marine Catering Co.
892 F.2d 386 (Fifth Circuit, 1990)
Oldham v. Touchard, Inc.
550 So. 2d 209 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Backhus v. Transit Cas. Co.
549 So. 2d 283 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1989)
Dominick v. Houtech Inland Well Service, Inc.
718 F. Supp. 489 (E.D. Louisiana, 1989)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
538 So. 2d 988, 1989 WL 6027, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/deshotels-v-shrm-catering-services-inc-la-1989.