Waldschmidt v. Ranier (In Re Fulghum Construction Corp.)

78 B.R. 146
CourtDistrict Court, M.D. Tennessee
DecidedApril 7, 1987
Docket3-85-0713
StatusPublished
Cited by32 cases

This text of 78 B.R. 146 (Waldschmidt v. Ranier (In Re Fulghum Construction Corp.)) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court, M.D. Tennessee primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Waldschmidt v. Ranier (In Re Fulghum Construction Corp.), 78 B.R. 146 (M.D. Tenn. 1987).

Opinion

MEMORANDUM

HIGGINS, District Judge.

An involuntary petition was filed in the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Middle District of Tennessee against Fulg-hum Construction Corporation (Fulghum, debtor or Corporation) on January 25,1980. An order for relief was entered on March 17,1980. On February 6,1980, the Trustee for Fulghum, Robert H. Waldschmidt, filed this proceeding against Harry Ranier, Al-gin Nolan, and Ranier & Associates. Rani-er & Associates was the sole shareholder of Fulghum. The Trustee sought to set aside a sale of equipment from the debtor Fulghum to the defendant Ranier & Associates and also sought to avoid certain monetary transactions which occurred between the two parties in 1979, contending that such transactions constituted preferential transfers. This matter was tried before the bankruptcy court on May 22 and 23, 1980. On July 14, 1980, Judge Hippe entered a partial judgment and memorandum holding that the Trustee had no interest in the equipment. Judge Hippe applied the “net result rule” in connection with the analysis of 11 U.S.C. § 547(b)(5) and held on November 28, 1980, that the transactions were not preferences and that the creditor had not proven any damages. The determination that the transactions were not preferences eliminated the need to examine the 11 U.S.C. § 547(c)(1) and (c)(2) exceptions, although Judge Hippe stated that the exceptions “appeared” unavoidable. Waldschmidt v. Ranier (In re Fulghum Construction Company), 7 B.R. 629 (Bankr.M.D.Tenn.1980). An appeal was taken to the United States District Court *148 for the Middle District of Tennessee. On September 18, 1981, Judge Wiseman affirmed the decision of Judge Hippe. Judge Wiseman did not address the issue of the applicability of § 547(c)(1) and (c)(2). In re Fulghum Construction Corporation, 14 B.R. 293 (Bankr.M.D.Tenn.1981).

The case was then appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. The Sixth Circuit reversed and remanded the case on the issue of whether the transactions constituted preferential transfers. It also made a determination on the issue of the application of the net result rule, holding that the judicial interposition of the net result rule into § 547(c)(5) vitiates the congressional intent clearly reflected both on the face of § 547 and in the legislative history of the enactment. It affirmed the lower courts in all other respects on May 9, 1983. Waldschmidt v. Ranier (In re Fulghum Construction Corporation), 706 F.2d 171 (6th Cir.1983). By order of the district court, the case was remanded to the bankruptcy court consistent with the Sixth Circuit decision. The bankruptcy court determined that the majority of the transactions between the debt- or Fulghum and the defendant Ranier & Associates cannot be excepted from avoidance. The court determined that the defendant received preferential payments totaling $197,432.00. On December 7, 1984, the bankruptcy court ordered the defendant Ranier & Associates to turn over to the Trustee the $197,432.00 plus interest. Also, on December 7, 1984, the bankruptcy judge ruled that neither 11 U.S.C. § 547(c)(1) nor (c)(2) applied. On January 7,1985, Judge Paine entered an order denying the motion to alter or amend to the extent the motion sought either the deletion of prejudgment interest or a later date for the commencement of the interest. On June 10, 1985, the bankruptcy judge entered an order to supplement the record on appeal adding the March 26, 1980, press release but denying Ranier & Associates’ motion relative to the remaining press releases for 1980. 1

On January 17, 1985, the defendants filed a notice of appeal for the judgment and memorandum entered December 7, 1984, 45 B.R. 112, and the order entered January 7,1985, and they were transmitted to this Court. On June 20, 1985, the defendant Ranier & Associates appealed the order entered on June 10,1985. The Trustee filed a motion in bankruptcy court seeking to modify the December 7, 1984, judgment to include Harry Ranier and Algin Nolen, individually. After a hearing on October 1, 1985, the bankruptcy judge entered an order granting the Trustee’s motion. On October 9, 1985, this Court entered an order that the appeal presently pending before this Court shall be deemed to be an appeal filed by Harry Ranier, Algin Nolan and Ranier & Associates from the December 7, 1984, judgment and the January 7, 1985, order, as subsequently modified to include Harry Ranier and Algin Nolan, individually.

On appeal, there are three issues before this Court. The first issue is whether the bankruptcy court was correct in determining that the payment to Ranier & Associates on November 30, 1979, was not a substantially-contemporaneous exchange within the meaning of 11 U.S.C. § 547(c)(1) and was not in the regular course of business within the meaning of 11 U.S.C. § 547(c)(2). The second issue is whether the bankruptcy court should have permitted the record to be supplemented to include other press releases which were not related to the amount of interest being applied in this case. The third issue is whether the bankruptcy court was proper in awarding prejudgment interest.

Jurisdiction is based on 28 U.S.C. § 158. For the reasons set forth below, the judgment of the bankruptcy court is affirmed.

I.

Fulghum Construction Corporation was incorporated in Texas in 1966. It was in *149 volved in the construction of oil and natural gas pipe lines. Fulghum’s principal place of business was Lavergne, Tennessee. The Corporation was owned by James T. Fulg-hum and J.B. Miller. Mr. Miller also managed the operation of the business.

Fulghum had a long history in the construction business, during which time it accumulated a large amount of equipment. The losses it experienced through 1977, however, caused a need for additional operating capital. Consequently, in October 1977 all of the common stock of Fulghum was purchased by Mr. Ranier and Mr. Nea-le R. Hall. In July of 1978, Mr. Hall transferred his stock to Mr. Nolan and a partnership was formed between Mr. Ranier and Mr. Nolan under the name of Ranier & Associates. Ranier & Associates is a Kentucky general partnership formed in February 1978 and located in Mount Sterling, Kentucky. The partnership consists of Harry Ranier, who owns a 60 percent interest and Algin Nolan who owns a 40 percent interest. The partnership has owned real estate and stock in various companies, operated an equipment leasing business and served as a paid management, accounting and financial advisor primarily to companies in which it or the Ranier family had an interest. Ranier & Associates has continued as Fulghum’s sole shareholder since July, 1978.

Mr.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Dery v. Karafa (In re Dearborn Bancorp, Inc.)
583 B.R. 395 (E.D. Michigan, 2018)
In Re M & L Business Machine Company, Inc.
84 F.3d 1330 (Tenth Circuit, 1996)
Jobin v. McKay
84 F.3d 1330 (Tenth Circuit, 1996)
Mazer v. Broadway Southwest (In Re Roemig)
123 B.R. 405 (D. New Mexico, 1991)
Ellenberg v. Mercer (In Re Home Co.)
108 B.R. 357 (N.D. Georgia, 1989)
In Re Gardner Matthews Plantation Co.
118 B.R. 384 (D. South Carolina, 1989)
Levy v. Gatlin
118 B.R. 384 (E.D. South Carolina, 1989)
Darko v. Shotts (In re Justus)
104 B.R. 80 (S.D. Indiana, 1989)
Shaver Motors, Inc. v. Mills (In Re Mills)
111 B.R. 186 (N.D. Indiana, 1988)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
78 B.R. 146, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/waldschmidt-v-ranier-in-re-fulghum-construction-corp-tnmd-1987.