Tunstull v. Commonwealth

337 S.W.3d 576, 2011 Ky. LEXIS 51, 2011 WL 1620588
CourtKentucky Supreme Court
DecidedApril 21, 2011
Docket2009-SC-000170-MR
StatusPublished
Cited by11 cases

This text of 337 S.W.3d 576 (Tunstull v. Commonwealth) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Kentucky Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Tunstull v. Commonwealth, 337 S.W.3d 576, 2011 Ky. LEXIS 51, 2011 WL 1620588 (Ky. 2011).

Opinions

Opinion of the Court by

Justice SCHRODER.

Troy Anthony Tunstull appeals as a matter of right from his conviction of four counts of second-degree robbery and being a-first-degree persistent felony offender, for which he was sentenced to a total of twenty years’ imprisonment. Appellant raises as error the trial court’s 1) denying his motion for directed verdict as to second-degree robbery; 2) failing to give instructions on theft by unlawful taking and facilitation to robbery; 3) ruling that he failed to make a prima facie showing of purposeful discrimination in the Commonwealth’s use of a peremptory challenge; 4) failing to strike three jurors for cause; 5) denying his motion for funds to hire an expert; 6) permitting the Commonwealth to introduce evidence of out-of-court identifications where he was not provided the [580]*580opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses; and 7) refusing to grant a mistrial when a detective’s testimony revealed he had a prior criminal record. We affirm.

In a jury trial which commenced on September 29, 2008, Appellant was tried on five counts of first-degree robbery in connection with five bank robberies which occurred in the Louisville area between April 2006 and October 2006.1 The first incident occurred on April 17, 2006, at the PNC Bank at 3348 Newburg Road. Bank tellers Stephanie Lafon and Donna Magee testified that a man wearing a ski mask and “covered from head to toe” ran into the bank and jumped up on the counter with a blue pillow case in his hand. Lafon testified that the man said, ‘You all know what time it is.” Magee recalled the man saying, ‘You know what I’m here for. You know what I want.” The man grabbed Lafon’s hand and had her hold open the pillow case and put money in it. When the man turned, Magee placed bait money in the bag. The man then left out the front door. Lafon had seen the man arrive in a four-door silver car and get out of the passenger side.

The second incident took place on May 1, 2006, at the Fifth Third Bank at 5393 New Cut Road. Four witnesses (two bank tellers, the branch manager, and a customer) testified as to the event. According to these witnesses, two men rushed into the bank, disguised with wigs, baggy clothes, sunglasses, and gloves, and announced, “You know what time it is.” One of the men jumped over the counter, and took money out of the tellers’ drawers and put it in a bag. The other man stood near the door with his hand in his pocket and repeatedly yelled “Time!”, in an effort to encourage the other man to hurry. The men left the building quickly with the bag of money.

The third incident took place on June 29, 2006, at Central Bank, located at 4640 Taylorsville Road. Bank tellers Lauren Armstrong and Daniel Spencer testified as follows. Shortly after 10:00 a.m., a dark red or maroon, four-door, older model car without a license plate backed up to the bank. Armstrong testified that a man exited the car on the passenger side and pulled a mask over his face. The man ran into the bank yelling, “Give it up! Give it up!” Spencer testified the man was wearing a solid white t-shirt, black baggy pants, and a black hat, and had a black and white bandana tied around his face. Armstrong threw money on. the counter, and the man grabbed it. The man then ran out and got into the passenger side of the car. Spencer believed it was the same man he had seen running across the parking lot approximately twenty minutes ■ earlier. Spencer told police that the man resembled a bank customer named Robert Harp. Spencer later identified a Chevy Caprice in a nearby apartment complex parking lot as the car he had seen at the bank. The Louisville Metro Police Department determined that the car belonged to a Laverne Westin.2

The fourth incident occurred on August 11, 2006, at the National City Bank at 5610 South Third Street. The Commonwealth presented testimony from seven witnesses (four bank tellers, the bank manager, and two customers). According to these wit[581]*581nesses, an African-American man entered the bank, pointed a gun at the tellers behind the counter, and demanded money. The man was wearing sunglasses, a black baseball cap, a long-sleeve jacket, black shorts, and tennis shoes. As the tellers placed the money on the counter, the man put it in a bag and then ran out the side door.

The fifth incident took place at the same branch of National City Bank on October 23, 2006. The same four tellers and bank manager who had been present during the August 11, 2006 robbery were again present. These five witnesses, along with an additional bank teller and a customer, testified as to what occurred. According to these witnesses, an African-American man entered the bank through the side door and demanded money in a loud, aggressive voice. The bank employees/witnesses who had witnessed the August robbery believed he sounded like the same man that had committed that robbery. However, this time, no one saw a gun. The man wore dark clothing, a black baseball cap, and white gloves, and had an unshaven face. The tellers handed the man money, which he put in a bag. When the man left, one teller followed and saw a red Chevrolet Cobalt, with the man inside, driving off quickly. The bank manager was able to read the license plate number, which was given to the police.

Police learned that the Cobalt had been leased by Enterprise Rent-A-Car to Shar-onda Sloss. The car was located that night in the parking lot of the Fern Creek Wal-Mart, where Sloss was employed. Police followed Sloss when she left work that evening and pulled her over. Sloss was taken to the police station for questioning, and her car was processed for evidence. Fingerprints matching Demond Tunstull, Appellant’s cousin, were found on the car. None of the fingerprints matched Appellant’s. At the police station, Sloss allegedly told Detective Larry Duncan that Appellant and Demond had taken the car around 1:00 p.m. while she was at a healthcare clinic, and had used it to commit the robbery.3 Sloss was in a relationship with Appellant at the time, whom she knew by the name Naim Abdul Jalil. Sloss also allegedly identified Appellant in still photographs made from the National City Bank surveillance video.

A search warrant was executed at Sloss’s apartment on October 24, 2006. Police retrieved a Kentucky driver’s license for Naim Abdul Jalil, a Halloween mask, packaging from two Halloween masks, a black hooded jacket, and a black nylon insulated bag. No cash or guns were found in the apartment.

FBI agents arrested Appellant at Sloss’s apartment on February 12, 2007, and transported him to the United States Marshal’s Office for questioning. Appellant initially denied any knowledge of the robberies, but, after being shown the bank surveillance photos and told that Sloss’s car had been used in a robbery, subsequently admitted to them all. This initial interrogation, which lasted a little over two hours, was not recorded. Appellant was then transported to the Louisville Metro Police Department (LMPD) headquarters where a taped statement was taken. Therein, Appellant admitted that he had committed the crimes at issue. This taped confession was played for the jury at trial.

Appellant testified in his own defense and denied committing the robberies. He [582]*582testified that he falsely confessed to the crimes to satisfy the police, in order to protect his family.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Kenye L. Langley v. Commonwealth of Kentucky
Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 2025
Kibambe Mwendapeke v. Merrick B. Garland
87 F.4th 860 (Seventh Circuit, 2023)
Manuel Crespo v. Commonwealth of Kentucky
Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 2023
United States v. Tyler Williams
39 F.4th 342 (Sixth Circuit, 2022)
Darryl Keith Baker v. Commonwealth of Kentucky
Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 2021
Rusty Weddle v. Commonwealth of Kentucky
Kentucky Supreme Court, 2019
Shawn Tigue v. Commonwealth of Kentucky
Kentucky Supreme Court, 2018
Sasser v. Commonwealth
485 S.W.3d 290 (Kentucky Supreme Court, 2016)
Tunstull v. Commonwealth
337 S.W.3d 576 (Kentucky Supreme Court, 2011)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
337 S.W.3d 576, 2011 Ky. LEXIS 51, 2011 WL 1620588, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/tunstull-v-commonwealth-ky-2011.