Sutton v. Commissioner

84 T.C. No. 17, 84 T.C. 210, 1985 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 122
CourtUnited States Tax Court
DecidedFebruary 13, 1985
DocketDocket Nos. 22131-81, 22639-81 (Nitrol Issues), 28537-81, 13350-82, 18891-82, 3114-83
StatusPublished
Cited by45 cases

This text of 84 T.C. No. 17 (Sutton v. Commissioner) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Tax Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Sutton v. Commissioner, 84 T.C. No. 17, 84 T.C. 210, 1985 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 122 (tax 1985).

Opinion

Nims, Judge:

In these consolidated cases, respondent determined the following deficiencies in petitioners’ Federal income taxes:

Docket No. Petitioner Year Deficiency
22131-81 William F. Sutton 1977 $62,616.00
and Helen C. Sutton 1978 60,127.00
22639-81 John F. Knowlton 1977 61,924.00
and Betty W. Knowlton 1978 63,281.00
28537-81 Joseph W. Fleece, Jr., 1975 13,784.00
and Joanne M. Fleece 1976 9,200.00
1977 108,792.00
1978 69,457.00
1979 97,811.00
13350-82 John C. Pruitt 1976 44,301.10
and Frances M. Pruitt 1977 101,453.70
1978 74,268.70
1979 17,446.18
18891-82. Jules Dressier and Muriel Dressier 1978 2,084.00
3114-83 R. Huston Babcock 1977 52,247.00
and Suzanne Babcock 1978 39,366.00
1979 45,787.00

One of the issues in docket No. 22639-81 was severed from this consolidated case and is the subject of a separate opinion by Judge Tannenwald reported at 84 T.C. 160 (1985). Judge Nims did not participate in the trial or opinion with regard to the severed issue. Judge Tannenwald’s disposition of the severed issue will be incorporated into the Rule 155 computation required in docket No. 22639-81.

Due to concessions, the issues for decision are: (1) Whether petitioners’ Nitrol Program activities were engaged in for profit within the meaning of section 183; and (2) whether certain nonrecourse notes may be included in the basis of the specially equipped refrigerated highway freight trailers acquired by petitioners.

FINDINGS OF FACT

Some of the facts have been stipulated. The stipulation of facts and exhibits attached thereto are incorporated herein by this reference.

Petitioners Joseph W., Jr., and Joanne M. Fleece, husband and wife, John C. and Frances M. Pruitt, husband and wife, John F. and Betty W. Knowlton, husband and wife, and R. Huston and Suzanne Babcock, husband and wife, resided at St. Petersburg, Florida, at the time their respective petitions were filed. Petitioners William F. and Helen C. Sutton, husband and wife, resided at Tampa, Florida, at the time their petition was filed. Petitioners Jules and Muriel Dressier, husband and wife, resided at Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, at the time their petition was filed.

For convenience, William F. Sutton, Betty W. Knowlton, Joseph W. Fleece, Jr., John C. Pruitt, R. Huston Babcock, and Jules Dressier will sometimes hereinafter be referred to as petitioners.

During the years in issue, petitioners were employed as follows:

Petitioner Profession
Sutton.Executive
Knowlton.Hotel manager
Fleece.Attorney
Babcock.Physician
Pruitt.Physician
Dressier.Executive

In December 1977, petitioners invested in a program (the Nitrol Program) offered by two California corporations, Nitrol Corp. (Nitrol) and Transit Management Co. (TMC). Under the program, investors purchased refrigerated highway freight trailers equipped with "controlled atmosphere units” from Nitrol and entered into a trailer management agreement with TMC. For convenience, we will hereinafter refer to the controlled atmosphere units as the Nitrol units and the refrigerated highway freight trailers equipped with the Nitrol units as the Nitrol trailers.

Sutton, Knowlton, and Babcock each purchased one Nitrol trailer. Fleece and Pruitt each purchased two Nitrol trailers. Dressier owned a limited partnership interest in Overnite, Ltd., a limited partnership formed to purchase one Nitrol trailer. For purposes of this opinion, reference to the term "petitioners” for convenience also sometimes refers to Over-nite, Ltd., and/or the general partner of that partnership.

David Dixon, a mechanical engineer, designed the Nitrol unit to produce a low-oxygen environment within the interior compartment of a standard refrigerated highway freight trailer. He worked from 1966 to 1968 developing the Nitrol unit. In June 1976, he received a patent (the 477 Patent) for the Nitrol unit.

The Nitrol unit consisted of an insulated storage tank filled with liquid oxygen and nitrogen mounted on the chasis of a refrigerated highway freight trailer. As the liquid vaporized, gases entered the trailer compartment through metal tubes leading from the tank to the compartment, producing a low-oxygen environment within the interior of the trailer.

Studies conducted during the early 1960’s by Dixon concluded that perishable commodities shipped in a low-oxygen environment would generally remain fresher than if shipped in a standard refrigerated truck. From the mid-1960’s to the mid-1970’s, several companies attempted to market trailers designed to transport perishable commodities in a low-oxygen environment. The unprofitability of the venture, however, forced each company to abandon the project.

Sometime during early 1977, Dixon, Steven Lewis (Lewis), James Power (Power), and Dorman Dimmitt (Dimmitt) joined together to develop the Nitrol Program to economically exploit the 477 Patent. Power incorporated Nitrol on June 3, 1977, to construct approximately 100 Nitrol trailers. Dimmitt, who had managed several trucking companies prior to his association with the Nitrol Program, incorporated TMC on July 11, 1977, to manage the Nitrol trailers sold by Nitrol. Dimmitt also became the chief operating officer of TMC.

Subsequent to the incorporation of Nitrol, Dixon and Lewis transferred an exclusive license under the 477 Patent to Nitrol. Nitrol agreed to pay Dixon and Lewis 70 percent of the net profits realized from the sale of Nitrol trailers. Power, as Nitrol’s sole shareholder and chief operating officer, effectively retained 30 percent of Nitrol’s profits.

Following the receipt of the exclusive license, Nitrol purchased 100 refrigerated highway freight trailers from Sierra Truck & Trailer Sales, Inc. (Sierra), for $27,500 per trailer. Nitrol financed the purchase of the trailers with Hobbs Corp. (Hobbs), the manufacturer of the trailers. Hobbs retained a security interest in each trailer sold. Although Nitrol was primarily liable on the installment contracts, all Nitrol Program investors were given the right to cure any default on the installment contracts.

Nitrol also contracted with Gibson Cryogenics to construct approximately 100 Nitrol units pursuant to Dixon’s specifications.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Nathel v. Commissioner
615 F.3d 83 (Second Circuit, 2010)
Holmes v. Commissioner
1997 T.C. Memo. 401 (U.S. Tax Court, 1997)
Dastgir v. Commissioner
1996 T.C. Memo. 169 (U.S. Tax Court, 1996)
Riddle v. Commissioner
1994 T.C. Memo. 133 (U.S. Tax Court, 1994)
Pacific Sound Prod. Ltd. Partnership v. Commissioner
1993 T.C. Memo. 253 (U.S. Tax Court, 1993)
Boyer
1992 T.C. Memo. 724 (U.S. Tax Court, 1992)
Martuccio v. Commissioner
1992 T.C. Memo. 311 (U.S. Tax Court, 1992)
Rasmussen v. Commissioner
1992 T.C. Memo. 212 (U.S. Tax Court, 1992)
Beltzhoover v. Commissioner
1991 T.C. Memo. 493 (U.S. Tax Court, 1991)
Thomas v. United States
758 F. Supp. 529 (E.D. Missouri, 1991)
Charlton v. Commissioner
1990 T.C. Memo. 402 (U.S. Tax Court, 1990)
Adler v. Commissioner
1989 T.C. Memo. 597 (U.S. Tax Court, 1989)
Del Guercio v. Commissioner
1989 T.C. Memo. 354 (U.S. Tax Court, 1989)
Hulter v. Commissioner
91 T.C. No. 31 (U.S. Tax Court, 1988)
Brand v. Commissioner
1988 T.C. Memo. 194 (U.S. Tax Court, 1988)
Gjesteby v. Commissioner
1987 T.C. Memo. 617 (U.S. Tax Court, 1987)
Leger v. Commissioner
1987 T.C. Memo. 146 (U.S. Tax Court, 1987)
Rose v. Commissioner
88 T.C. No. 18 (U.S. Tax Court, 1987)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
84 T.C. No. 17, 84 T.C. 210, 1985 U.S. Tax Ct. LEXIS 122, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/sutton-v-commissioner-tax-1985.