State v. Torkelsen

2008 ND 141, 752 N.W.2d 640, 2008 N.D. LEXIS 148, 2008 WL 2789076
North Dakota Supreme Court·Decided July 21, 2008·No. 20070140·Published·Cited by 24 cases

Opinions

CROTHERS, Justice.

[¶ 1] Steven Torkelsen appeals from a criminal judgment after a jury found him guilty of murdering Rebecca Flaa. We affirm, concluding the district court did not err in denying Torkelsen’s motion to suppress evidence seized, and Torkelsen was not denied the right to represent himself.

I

[¶ 2] At approximately 9:00 a.m., on June 27, 2004, Tom Belzer, a local farmer, discovered a human body burning in a ditch east of Cando. Belzer told one of his employees to call emergency personnel. Before law enforcement officers arrived, Torkelsen drove up to the scene in his pickup, stepped out onto the road, and asked Belzer if he needed any help. Tor-kelsen was smoking a cigarette at the time, and a cigarette butt containing Tor-kelsen’s DNA was later found on the gravel road above the body. Belzer told Tor-kelsen to leave the area, and Torkelsen complied with the request.

[645] [¶ 3] When law enforcement officers arrived, Belzer told them about .Torkelsen. A “be on the lookout” bulletin was issued for Torkelsen’s pickup. While en route to the crime scene, North Dakota Bureau of Criminal Investigations Agent Craig Za-chmeier saw a green Florida Marlins jacket in the middle of the road, but proceeded on to the crime scene. The jacket was located on a direct route from the crime scene to Cando. Zachmeier arrived at the crime scene around 10:30 a.m., but later went back to collect the jacket. He noticed blood on the jacket, which was later tested and confirmed as Flaa’s blood.

[¶ 4] At approximately 1:26 p.m., Tor-kelsen’s vehicle was stopped 28 miles west of Cando. Torkelsen was informed that he was wanted for questioning and would be handcuffed for his own safety. Torkelsen was transported to Cando, and his pickup was left at the scene of the stop.

[¶ 5] Torkelsen’s handcuffs were removed upon his arrival at the Towner County Sheriffs Office. Zachmeier began interviewing Torkelsen at approximately 2:15 p.m., and the interview was videotaped. Zachmeier read Torkelsen his Miranda rights, and Torkelsen acknowledged he understood them. Zachmeier informed Torkelsen he was not under arrest, but was being detained for questioning because he was at the crime scene; however, Zachmeier did not tell Torkelsen he was free to leave. Zachmeier asked Torkelsen if he could talk to him about what happened that morning, and Torkelsen consented. Zachmeier asked Torkelsen what he saw when he ran into Belzer. earlier that day, where he was staying, and what he had been doing. Torkelsen said he stayed at his parents’ house in Cando the previous night, but went to his camper in the morning, and then watched a movie and slept. Zachmeier requested Torkel-sen’s consent to search his pickup and camper, and Torkelsen consented to a search of his camper twice and to a search of his pickup three times. Zachmeier requested Torkelsen’s permission to photograph Torkelsen’s hands, arms, back and legs, and Torkelsen consented. Zachmeier noticed an odor of alcohol on Torkelsen’s breath, and tests showed he had a blood alcohol concentration of .003 percent. At approximately 3:00 p.m., Zachmeier read Torkelsen the written consent to search form, which included language about the right to refuse to consent to the search. Torkelsen signed consent forms for searches of the camper and pickup.

[¶ 6] At approximately 3:30 p.m., Tor-kelsen and law enforcement officers arrived at the camper, located on the Abra-hamson farm. Torkelsen consented to the search again and showed officers how to unlock and enter the camper. Law enforcement officers found incriminating evidence in the camper, including tissue containing what appeared to be human blood; marijuana cigarette packs; rolling papers; papers with Flaa’s name on them; a video cassette case with what appeared to be human blood on it; blood on a cupboard, cabinet doors, molding, and the ceiling; a bag containing makeup with the name Becky; a knife with a broken tip in the sink; cigarette and marijuana cigarette butts; and papers with Torkelsen’s name on them. At approximately 5:00 p.m., before leaving the site of the camper search, Torkelsen again consented to a search of his pickup. Before going to Torkelseris pickup, officers gave Torkelsen something to eat and drink, but denied his request to stop at his parents’ house.

[¶ 7] At 6:20 p.m., the officers and Tor-kelsen arrived at the pickup for the search. Torkelsen consented to a search of the pickup again. The officers searched the pickup and found human hair; burnt fabric; a bloody bed sheet, which was later tested and confirmed as Flaa’s blood; a [646] pillow case; a knife; a blanket with hairs on it; three .270 caliber rifle cartridges; nylon rope; and black plastic bags. The search was completed around 7:45 p.m., and Torkelsen was transported back to Cando for a second interview.

[¶ 8] At 6:30 p.m., Highway Patrol Trooper Robert Kennedy learned from another law enforcement officer that Torkel-sen and Flaa had been staying together at the Abrahamson farm, owned by J.R. Gib-bens. Kennedy visited with Gibbens and learned Gibbens had padlocked the farmhouse a week earlier to prevent Torkelsen and Flaa from using it. At 7:40 p.m., Gibbens signed a consent form allowing officers to search the farmhouse located on the Abrahamson farm. At 8:45 p.m., officers searched the farmhouse and outbuildings and found a document and a magazine with Torkelsen’s name in the farmhouse, a clump of auburn hair similar to Flaa’s in the bathroom garbage and a spot of blood in the living room.

[¶ 9] At 9:45 p.m., Torkelsen was interviewed a second time, and the interview was videotaped. Zachmeier read Torkel-sen the Miranda warning again, and Tor-kelsen acknowledged he understood his rights. Torkelsen reviewed the consent to search forms and stated he did not have a problem with the searches of his camper and pickup. Zachmeier asked Torkelsen about the evidence found during the searches. Torkelsen said he was in a sexual relationship with Flaa. He said that she stayed with him in his camper on June 23, that he left the camper the next morning to go to his parents’ house in Cando, but Flaa was not at the camper when he returned at 9:00 p.m. that night and that he thought she left to go back to her boyfriend. He said he stayed at his parents’ house on June 25 and 26, but he left his parents’ house at 6:00 a.m. on June 27 and returned to the camper where he slept until 8:30 a.m. He stated he was traveling back to Cando on a rural county road out of his way, when he saw Belzer and asked if he needed any help. He said that after he talked to Belzer, he returned to his parents’ house, showered, changed his clothes, then left, after which law enforcement stopped his vehicle and took him into custody. Torkelsen also said he left a pair of work boots and a pair of tennis shoes at his parents’ house. He gave a description of Flaa, which matched the body found in the ditch, and identified the green Florida Marlins jacket as Flaa’s. Torkelsen claimed Flaa cut her lip and had a bloody nose to explain the blood found in the camper. At 10:05 p.m., Torkelsen consented to give a saliva sample for DNA. Tor-kelsen was formally arrested and taken to the Lake Region Correctional Center at approximately 11:30 p.m.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Torkelsen, 2008 ND 141, 752 N.W.2d 640, 2008 N.D. LEXIS 148, 2008 WL 2789076 (N.D. 2008).

2008 ND 141 (State v. Torkelsen) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Golberg
2026 ND 11 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2026)
State v. Bell
2025 ND 201 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2025)
State v. Janachovsky
2025 ND 30 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2025)
State v. Fleckenstein
2018 ND 52 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2018)
State v. Montgomery
2018 ND 20 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2018)
State v. Hawkins
2017 ND 172 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2017)
State v. Hightower
393 P.3d 224 (Oregon Supreme Court, 2017)
State v. Schmidt
2016 ND 187 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2016)
State v. Nagel
2014 ND 224 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2014)
State v. Zeller
2014 ND 65 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2014)
State v. Holly
2013 ND 94 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2013)
Scott v. State
2012 WY 86 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2012)
State v. Jones
2011 ND 234 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2011)
Dailey v. State
2011 ND 223 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2011)
State v. Pederson
2011 ND 155 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2011)
Gaede v. State
2011 ND 162 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2011)
State v. Byzewski
2010 ND 30 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2010)
State v. Torkelsen
2008 ND 141 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2008)