State v. Phillips

111 N.E.3d 351, 2018 Ohio 1794
Court of Appeals of Ohio, Fourth District, Athens County·Decided May 1, 2018·No. No. 17CA38·Published·Cited by 6 cases

Opinion

McFarland, J.

{¶ 1} Gilbert Phillips appeals the judgment entry of conviction entered October 20, 2017 in the Athens Municipal Court. Appellant challenges his conviction of disorderly conduct, R.C. 2917.11, on two bases: (1) that the State failed to bring him to trial within the limitations for statutory speedy trial; and (2) that his conviction was not supported by the weight of the evidence. Having reviewed the record, we find Appellant's first assignment of error is with merit. Thus, his second assignment of error has been rendered moot. Accordingly, we reverse the judgment of the trial court and vacate Appellant's conviction.

FACTS

{¶ 2} On July 20, 2017, Appellant was charged with obstructing official business, a misdemeanor. The charge stemmed from a disagreement between Appellant and a representative of Columbia Gas who attempted to perform work at a job site on Big Baily Road in Athens County. The parties have provided differing versions of the events which transpired on that date.

{¶ 3} According to the State, Columbia Gas employees were planning to perform work at property owned by Ed Rence. Mr. Rence apparently shared a driveway with Appellant. Columbia Gas employee Ron Smith later testified at Appellant's bench trial that the Columbia Gas crew brought *353five vehicles and proceeded onto the shared driveway. Suddenly, Appellant drove his car at a high rate of speed toward the Columbia Gas vehicles. Appellant jumped out of his car, screaming obscenities, beating on his bare chest and kicking off his sandals. In a threatening manner, Appellant ordered the crew to leave and Rob Smith felt physically threatened. Mr. Smith called 911 and asked for assistance regarding "an irate landowner." After two Athens county deputies responded to the scene, Deputy John Morris made contact with Appellant who continued to "rant and rave." Appellant was ultimately cited for obstructing official business.

{¶ 4} According to Appellant, however, the Columbia Gas convoy of vehicles suddenly drove onto his private property without notifying him. The Columbia Gas vehicles not only blocked the driveway but also ended up on Appellant's private lawn. Appellant immediately drove down the driveway, confronted the crew, and ordered them off his property. Appellant claims he reached an agreement with the crew, who left in five to ten minutes. However, an Athens County Sheriff's deputy arrived approximately ten minutes after the crew left and Appellant was arrested on a charge of obstruction.

{¶ 5} Appellant spent one night in jail due to the obstruction charge. He entered a plea of not guilty at arraignment. The obstruction charge was eventually dismissed on September 26, 2017.

{¶ 6} On September 27, 2017, Deputy Morris cited Appellant for a violation of disorderly conduct, R.C. 2917.11(A)(1). On September 27, 2017, counsel for Appellant filed a written denial of the charge, along with a motion to dismiss. On October 5, 2017, the State filed a response to the motion to dismiss. On October 12, 2017, the matter came on for a bench trial.

{¶ 7} Prior to receiving testimony, the trial court heard the arguments of the parties with regard to the motion to dismiss. After doing so, the trial court ruled from the bench that "at this point in time, I'm going to rely on the fact that this was filed within the statute of limitations."1 On October 20, 2017, the court filed a judgment entry finding Appellant guilty. Appellant was fined in the amount of $50.00 and court costs.

{¶ 8} Appellant timely appealed. He also filed a motion for suspension of execution of sentence pending appeal.2

ASSIGNMENTS OF ERROR

"I. APPELLANT'S RIGHT TO A SPEEDY TRIAL HAD BEEN VIOLATED WHEN HE WAS NOT BROUGHT TO TRIAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER HIS ARREST ON A MINOR MISDEMEANOR."

STANDARD OF REVIEW

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Phillips, 111 N.E.3d 351, 2018 Ohio 1794 (Ohio Super. Ct. 2018).

111 N.E.3d 351 (State v. Phillips) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Stevens
2023 Ohio 3280 (Ohio Court of Appeals, 2023)
State v. Thacker
2021 Ohio 2726 (Ohio Court of Appeals, 2021)
State v. Boyce
2021 Ohio 712 (Ohio Court of Appeals, 2021)
State v. Long
2018 Ohio 5163 (Ohio Court of Appeals, 2018)