State v. Green

613 So. 2d 263, 1992 WL 385520
Louisiana Court of Appeal·Decided December 29, 1992·No. 92-KA-0499·Published·Cited by 13 cases

Opinion

613 So.2d 263 (1992)

STATE of Louisiana
v.
Philip GREEN.

No. 92-KA-0499.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit.

December 29, 1992.

*265 Harry F. Connick, Dist. Atty., Jack Peebles, Asst. Dist. Atty., New Orleans, for appellee.

Patricia Regan Fox, Supervising Atty., Kelly E. Barbier, Matthew T. Jarreau, Student Practitioners, Loyola Law Clinic, New Orleans, for appellant.

Before KLEES, LOBRANO and JONES, JJ.

LOBRANO, Judge.

Defendant, Philip Green, was charged by bill of information with five (5) counts of armed robbery, one (1) count of attempted armed robbery and one (1) count of first degree robbery.

Defendant was arraigned on December 19, 1990 and pled not guilty to all counts. Defendant filed motions to suppress the evidence, identification and confession which were denied March 13, 1991. Defendant applied for supervisory writs to this Court. His application was denied on April 16, 1991. State v. Green, unpub. (91-K-0631) (La.App. 4th Cir. April 16, 1991).

On July 24, 1991, the State severed three (3) of the armed robbery counts and proceeded to trial on the remaining counts. A twelve member jury found defendant guilty as charged on the first degree robbery count; guilty of attempted first degree robbery on the attempted armed robbery count; guilty of first degree robbery as to one of the armed robbery counts and not guilty as to the other count.

On August 1, 1991, defendant filed a motion for a new trial.

On August 12, 1991, the state filed a multiple bill of information; defendant filed a post verdict judgment of acquittal.

On September 10, 1991, both defense motions were denied.

On October 2, 1991, the state dismissed two of the remaining armed robbery counts.

On October 17, 1991, the trial court sentenced defendant to serve twenty (20) years at hard labor without benefit of parole, probation or suspension of sentence on each count to run concurrently.

On January 23, 1991, the state withdrew the multiple bill.

FACTS:

On October 18, 1990, the EXXON service station at 1701 Canal Street was robbed. Theodoria Thomas, the cashier, testified that defendant stuck a gun inside the cash drawer of the cashier booth and demanded the contents of the cash register. Thomas gave defendant the money. Defendant then fled. Thomas described the perpetrator as 5'6" to 5'7" tall, 160-165 pounds wearing something "blue" or "dark".

On November 6, 1990, following defendant's arrest, Thomas positively identified defendant during the physical line up of six men, as the person who robbed her on October 18, 1990.

On October 22, 1990 at approximately 6:35 p.m., the Majak Market at 3622 General De Gaulle was robbed. Casandra Adams, the cashier, testified that defendant entered the store and lifted his shirt exposing the handle of a gun protruding from his waistband. He demanded the *266 money from the register and threatened to kill Adams if she did not comply. Adams gave the money to defendant and defendant left the store. Adams immediately called the police. She described the perpetrator as 5'8" tall, 160 pounds, medium build, 30 to 32 years old, dark skinned with a mustache and wearing a dark colored sweatshirt and dark pants.

Adams also identified defendant during the November 6, 1990 line up as the person who robbed her on October 22, 1990.

On October 22, 1990, the Time Saver Store on Broadway and Claiborne Avenue was also robbed. Bridgette Miles, the cashier, testified that defendant entered the store and asked for a pack of Kool Filter King cigarettes. As she turned to give defendant the pack, she observed the handle of a gun protruding from defendant's blue jeans. Defendant then demanded the money from the register, saying, "Bitch, big cash". Miles only had several one dollar bills and a five dollar bill. When defendant realized there were no large bills he left without taking the money. Miles called the police.

Officer Deborah Prosper responded to the call. She stated that Miles described the perpetrator as 5'5", 160 pounds, 30 to 35 years old with a mustache and wearing a blue shirt and blue pants.

Just as Thomas and Adams, Miles also positively identified defendant at the November 6, 1990 line up as the person who robbed her on October 22, 1990.

On October 31, 1990, the Time Saver Store at Robert E. Lee Boulevard was robbed. Virginia Johnson, the cashier, testified that around 2:00 p.m., defendant entered the store and asked for a pack of Kool Super Long cigarettes. When Johnson rang up the sale, defendant demanded the money in the register. Johnson noticed defendant in possession of a green colored object and assumed it was a weapon. She gave defendant the money.

Arlette Armoure, manager of the store, testified that she had gone to her car to retrieve some paperwork. She observed defendant drive up to the store. He exited his car leaving the motor running and entered the store. Within minutes she saw Johnson wave her hand and motion that the store had just been robbed. Defendant exited the store and drove away. Armoure wrote down the license plate number and a description of the car. Johnson and Armoure then telephoned the police giving them the descriptive information.

Vincent Di Giorgio, Director of Security for the New Orleans Museum of Art, heard the police broadcast of the robbery. Di Giorgio was at the corner of Marconi and Harrison Avenues. Di Giorgio observed the vehicle and notified the dispatcher that he was in pursuit. Di Giorgio put his blue flashing light on and pulled defendant over to the side of the street. Defendant threw various denominations of paper money from the car window into the street. Di Giorgio pulled his gun and ordered defendant to put his hands outside the window of the car. At this time New Orleans police officers arrived at the scene. They retrieved $27.00 from the area around the car and additional money from defendant's pocket. Defendant was wearing a dark T-shirt and blue pants.

Officer Herman Cade advised defendant of his Miranda rights.

Defendant told Cade he was not armed during the robbery and was only carrying a toy airplane. Cade searched the car and found a green toy airplane and a pack of Kool cigarettes. Defendant was taken back to the Time Saver store and was positively identified by Johnson and Armoure.

At trial, Officer Cade testified that defendant told him he was a crack addict and had robbed the store to support his habit.

Defendant testified he ordered Johnson to give him the money. He stated he did not have a gun but was carrying a green toy airplane. He testified he was under the influence of crack cocaine when he committed the robbery. He denied robbing the other stores. He stated that Cade did not read him his rights on the rights of arrestee form and that he had forced him to sign the form.

*267 Defendant appeals his conviction and sentence asserting the following assignments of error:

1) The trial court erred in denying the defendant's Motions to Suppress the identification, evidence and confession due to the State's failure to carry its burden in establishing a valid waiver of rights;
2) The trial court erred in failing to suppress the physical line ups and subsequent identifications based on the exclusionary rule;
3) The trial court erred in failing to grant the defendant a post-judgment verdict of acquittal based on the fact that the state presented only uncorroborated eyewitness testimony so that the jury could not have excluded every reasonable hypothesis of innocence;

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

State v. Green, 613 So. 2d 263, 1992 WL 385520 (La. Ct. App. 1992).

613 So. 2d 263 (State v. Green) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Castell
991 So. 2d 579 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2008)
State v. BJB
983 So. 2d 1032 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2008)
State of Louisiana v. B. J. B.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2008
State v. Barthe
806 So. 2d 53 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2001)
State v. Craft
796 So. 2d 907 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2001)
State v. Trepagnier
744 So. 2d 181 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1999)
State v. Harge
730 So. 2d 983 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1999)
State v. Scott
709 So. 2d 339 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1998)
State v. Guillory
715 So. 2d 400 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1998)
State v. Gaines
688 So. 2d 679 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1997)
State v. Cushenberry
650 So. 2d 783 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1995)
State v. Deville
644 So. 2d 1117 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1994)
State v. Acevedo
633 So. 2d 828 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1994)