State v. Drieman

457 N.W.2d 703, 1990 Minn. LEXIS 189, 1990 WL 87407
CourtSupreme Court of Minnesota
DecidedJune 29, 1990
DocketC5-89-1625
StatusPublished
Cited by24 cases

This text of 457 N.W.2d 703 (State v. Drieman) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Minnesota primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Drieman, 457 N.W.2d 703, 1990 Minn. LEXIS 189, 1990 WL 87407 (Mich. 1990).

Opinion

YETKA, Justice.

William Drieman, defendant, appeals from a conviction of murder in the first degree for causing the death of 3-year-old Corey McDougall while committing criminal sexual conduct and a conviction of murder in the second degree for causing the death of Corey McDougall while committing an assault. Defendant was convicted *705 after a jury trial in St. Louis County District Court. We affirm the conviction.

Laura McDougall, Corey McDougall’s mother, has been twice married and divorced and has two daughters, Tina and Tanya, who were age 10 and 7 respectively at the time of trial. Corey McDougall’s father is Jeffrey Spartz, but her relationship with him broke up when the latter moved to Texas. Laura McDougall started to see defendant in March of 1988. They spent five or six nights a week together.

Shortly after Laura McDougall started going with defendant, a number of people, including Laura McDougall, her mother and her two sisters, noticed that Corey McDougall had an unusual amount of bruises. When asked about the bruises, Laura McDougall said that she thought maybe Corey McDougall was hurting himself on his metal bed or falling down. Laura McDougall’s sister who babysat the children four mornings a week noticed new bruises every Monday morning after Corey McDougall had spent the weekend at defendant’s house in Chisholm. Two other acquaintances also noticed bruises appearing after Laura McDougall started dating defendant. One called social services.

Corey McDougall fractured his collarbone on Saturday, June 18, 1988, at the home of defendant’s parents. Defendant’s father testified that he saw Corey McDou-gall accidentally fall down the stairs. Defendant was upstairs when Corey McDou-gall fell. Laura McDougall noticed that Corey McDougall began bruising easily, stumbling and losing his appetite after he fractured his collarbone. She noticed two marks on Corey McDougall’s penis 1½ to 2 weeks before he died. She became cautious and concerned about her children, her babysitter and even the dog, but not anyone else. At trial, she admitted that she testified to the grand jury that she initially suspected that defendant had caused the bruises.

About 1½ weeks after the broken collarbone, on a Sunday, Laura McDougall noticed that Corey McDougall had a sprained left wrist. Defendant had spent that weekend at Laura McDougall’s apartment. Laura McDougall brought Corey McDou-gall to Dr. Gene Kishel later that evening. She told the doctor that Corey McDougall seemed to be bruising very easily. She asked him to perform a blood exam. According to Laura McDougall, Dr. Kishel said, “Boys will be boys.” The doctor later denied saying this. The doctor put a splint on Corey McDougall’s wrist.

Dr. Kishel then noticed over 20 small, fading bruises on Corey McDougall’s face, upper body and neck. One appeared to be the shape of a hand. He had never noticed bruises on two other visits. He confronted Laura McDougall and notified St. Louis County Social Services. She said that Corey McDougall’s sisters were mean to him and wedged him in the door. She testified at trial that she also saw Tina put a jump rope around Corey McDougall’s throat and that both girls hit and pinched him. The doctor did not think this explained the bruises. Laura McDougall did not mention to the doctor that she was dating defendant. Because the handprint on Corey McDougall’s cheek appeared small, the doctor mentioned the older sister in his report to social services.

In November 1988, school records indicated that Tina was 48 inches tall and weighed 50 pounds; Tanya, 42Vi inches and 42 pounds. People who babysat the children stated that, generally, the girls treated Corey McDougall nicely although they fought like normal siblings. In fact, one of Laura McDougall’s sisters testified that the girls felt protective towards Corey McDougall.

Laura McDougall’s mother and others stated that Corey McDougall banged his head on the floor when he had temper tantrums, causing bumps. No one ever saw defendant mistreat Corey McDougall.

Laura McDougall’s sister testified that, on Tuesday, July 12, the day before his death, Corey McDougall looked ill. He pointed to his eye, which was bloodshot, and said “Hit.” She asked who hit him. Corey McDougall answered “Bill,” but he did not talk well. When he said “Bill” and “Bear,” the defendant’s dog’s name, the words sounded the same.

*706 Later on July 12, Laura McDougall and her children went over to defendant’s house around 2:30 p.m. About 4:30 or 5:00 p.m., Laura McDougall and the girls went to the store to pick up some ingredients for spaghetti. They were gone for 30 to 45 minutes. Corey McDougall stayed with defendant in the house. He was the only person alone with Corey McDougall that afternoon. When Laura McDougall returned, she saw Corey McDougall waving at her from the door of the upstairs loft to the garage.

Laura McDougall then fixed dinner. When Corey McDougall started to eat, he turned pale and vomited on his plate. Laura McDougall said that, at this time, she noticed an abrasion on Corey McDougall’s stomach. She also noticed that Corey McDougall had four or five bruises on his face as well as a popped blood vessel in one of his eyes.

Defendant removed the plate, dumped the contents, rinsed it off, put some more spaghetti on it and set it on the table by Corey McDougall. Corey McDougall just looked at the food and, when asked, indicated that he wanted to go to bed. Corey McDougall and the girls slept in the upstairs bedroom. Defendant brought him upstairs while Laura McDougall finished eating. Around 7:00 p.m., Corey McDou-gall vomited in bed. Laura McDougall and defendant thought that Corey McDougall had the flu so they remade the bed for the girls and laid Corey McDougall on the floor with a bucket beside him.

Before they went to bed at 11:00 p.m., according to Laura McDougall’s trial testimony, she heard some thumping noises from upstairs. Defendant went upstairs to investigate. According to defendant, she testified, Corey was holding his stomach and pointing up to Tina, who was sitting on the edge of the bed and complaining that Corey was bothering her. Laura McDou-gall did not mention this incident in lengthy statements to the Hibbing Police Department, the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension or the grand jury.

In his first statement, defendant said that he and Laura McDougall checked on Corey McDougall and went to bed about 10:30 p.m. 1 He said that Corey McDougall was sleeping, but restless. He did not know if Corey McDougall woke up later in the night. In the second statement, defendant added that he and Laura McDougall heard some bumping around so he checked on Corey McDougall, who was tossing and, semi-asleep, complaining that his stomach hurt. Defendant said that the girls were asleep. He did not mention Corey McDou-gall holding his stomach and pointing at an alert Tina sitting on the edge of her bed as Laura McDougall testified.

Defendant explained Corey McDougall’s injuries as follows: While Laura McDou-gall and the girls were at the store on July 12, defendant and Corey McDougall went to the upstairs of the garage and defendant fixed a window. Defendant claimed that, after he went down the stairs, Corey McDougall slid down the steps. A barbecue grill and a spare tire were at the bottom of the stairs.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State of Minnesota v. Jacob Michael McKinley
891 N.W.2d 64 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2017)
State of Minnesota v. Heather Leann Horst
880 N.W.2d 24 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 2016)
State of Minnesota v. Larry Leo Geleneau, Jr.
873 N.W.2d 373 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015)
State of Minnesota v. Calvin James Jennings
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015
State v. Munt
831 N.W.2d 569 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 2013)
State v. Matthews
779 N.W.2d 543 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 2010)
State v. Dorsey
701 N.W.2d 238 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 2005)
State v. Courtney
682 N.W.2d 185 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2004)
State v. Asfeld
662 N.W.2d 534 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 2003)
State v. Burns
632 N.W.2d 794 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2001)
State v. Anderson
603 N.W.2d 354 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 1999)
State v. Warren
592 N.W.2d 440 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1999)
State v. Whittaker
568 N.W.2d 440 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1997)
State v. Steinbuch
514 N.W.2d 793 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1994)
State v. Orfi
511 N.W.2d 464 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 1994)
State v. Scharmer
501 N.W.2d 620 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1993)
State v. Moore
481 N.W.2d 355 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1992)
State v. Elvin
481 N.W.2d 571 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 1992)
State v. Frisinger
478 N.W.2d 538 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 1991)
State v. Everett
472 N.W.2d 864 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1991)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
457 N.W.2d 703, 1990 Minn. LEXIS 189, 1990 WL 87407, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-drieman-minn-1990.