Putt v. City of Corinth

579 So. 2d 534, 1991 WL 50626
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedMarch 27, 1991
Docket07-CA-59335
StatusPublished
Cited by23 cases

This text of 579 So. 2d 534 (Putt v. City of Corinth) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Putt v. City of Corinth, 579 So. 2d 534, 1991 WL 50626 (Mich. 1991).

Opinion

579 So.2d 534 (1991)

John PUTT
v.
CITY OF CORINTH, a Municipality, and the Board and/or Commission of the Corinth City Gas and Water Department.

No. 07-CA-59335.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

March 27, 1991.

Charles R. Wilbanks, Wilbanks Law Firm, Corinth, for appellant.

Jimmy B. Fisher, Corinth, for appellees.

Before ROY NOBLE LEE, C.J., and PRATHER and ROBERTSON, JJ.

ROBERTSON, Justice, for the court:

I.

This appeal arises from a seller's suit for breach of an oral contract for the sale of land. The Circuit Court entered judgment summarily, dismissing the suit, and en route refused to credit the municipal corporation buyer's minutes as a note or memorandum satisfying the statute of frauds.

We reverse.

II.

A.

John H. Putt is an adult resident citizen of the City of Corinth in Alcorn County, *535 Mississippi. At all relevant times Putt was the owner of certain commercial real estate in Corinth commonly known as the King Tractor Building. The property lies on Highway 45 South along the south side of Elam Creek Canal. Putt had most recently used it to operate a used car business known as P & M Motors. Putt was the Plaintiff below and is the Appellant here.

The City of Corinth is a municipal corporation and is the county seat of Alcorn County, Mississippi. The Corinth Gas and Water Department is an arm of the City of Corinth and is operated by the Corinth Public Utilities Commission, see Miss. Code Ann. § 21-27-13 (1972). These various entities were Defendants below and are Appellees here and are sometimes hereinafter collectively referred to as "the City."[1]

In the Fall of 1984, the Corinth Gas and Water Department was seeking a building suitable for housing its maintenance department and for storage of equipment and spare parts. Putt learned of this, and in December, 1984, he approached Wayne McGee, Department Manager, and Dennis Coleman, a Department employee, and told them his building was for sale. Putt's asking price was $100,000.00.

On January 14, 1985, McGee appeared at the regular monthly meeting of the Utilities Commission and reported his conversation with Putt. The Commission authorized Clifford G. Worsham, a Commission member, to inspect Putt's building and to explore purchase possibilities, including financing. Commissioner Worsham reported favorably at the February meeting, and, at that time, the Commission authorized Commissioner Leland Martin to negotiate a purchase agreement with Putt. A few days later, Martin and McGee, acting on behalf of the Commission, met with Putt. It seems that there was a metal shed or building on the property which the Commission saw no use for, and Martin and McGee suggested to Putt that he keep the shed but remove it from the premises and reduce the purchase price to $95,000.00.

On March 11, 1985, the Commission formally approved the purchase as evidenced by the following minute entry:

WAREHOUSE. Commissioner Martin reported that they had obtained the agreement of John Putt to sell the building on Old Highway 45 (Tate Street) to the City for $95,000.00 with him to retain the shed immediately north of the building. After discussion, the Commission found that the appraisal by Lou Miller was $100,000.00 and that the shed would be of little value to the Gas and Water Department and that the reasonable market value of the property was $95,000.00 and should be purchased for the use of the Water and Gas Departments. The purchase to be made with funds from the Gas Department and the Water Department to pay rent on the building.

These minutes were signed by C.R. Caviness, Chairman, and attested by Clifford G. Worsham, Secretary.[2] The Commission advised Putt of this action. There is no evidence the Commission and Putt agreed regarding any possible outstanding encumbrances or judgments or the matter of proration of taxes, omissions whose importance will presently appear.

Putt removed the shed from the land and then moved his used car business to another location. Putt had at-will renters on the premises, from whom he had been receiving $250.00 and $450.00 per month, respectively, and he terminated these tenants. Putt cleaned up the warehouse in preparation for closing. One Gas and Water Department employee said the Department had built shelves to install in the building after the sale was completed.

In time the Commission turned the matter over to its lawyer "to conclude the transaction." Brief of Appellee, filed October 17, 1988, p. 7. Upon examining title to the property and checking the courthouse *536 records, the Commission's lawyer found an outstanding deed of trust and, more importantly, two judgments enrolled against Putt and held by Ray Sewell Co., Inc., in the aggregate principal sum of $11,993.01. Putt secured the Alcorn Bank and Trust Company's release of the lien of the outstanding deed of trust. The Commission's lawyer prepared a separate release to be executed by Ray Sewell Co., Inc. regarding the judgment liens. Putt was not able to secure Sewell's release.

On May 9, 1985, Wayne McGee, manager of the Gas and Water Department, and acting on behalf of the Commission and the City, met with Putt in the office of the Commission's lawyer to close the sale. McGee had with him a Corinth Gas and Water Department check payable to Putt in the amount of $78,717.26, and advised that he was ready to conclude the transaction. The Commission's lawyer presented to Putt a closing statement as follows:

                           JOHN PUTT PROPERTY
                            CLOSING STATEMENT                     5-9-85
PURCHASE PRICE                                                 95,000.00
LESS:    Withheld by Corinth pending settlement of Sewell
         judgment                                           (- 16,000.00)
                                                           ______________
                                                               79,000.00
LESS:    Prorate taxes
         City:         451.10
         County:       302.88
                       ______
                       753.98     =Putt @ 4.5/12=               (-282.74)
                                                               __________
Corinth Check to Putt                                          78,717.26

First, Putt objected to the $16,000.00 escrow withholding. He advised McGee and the Commission's lawyer that the judgments were on appeal to the Supreme Court of Mississippi and were covered by a bond sufficient to secure payment in the event his appeal failed.[3] Putt then relented and agreed to the withholding, provided only that the money held in escrow would draw interest payable to him at a reasonable rate. The Commission and its lawyer refused these terms.

Putt also disputed the proposed proration of ad valorem taxes. Putt said he had made his deal with the Commission in January of 1985 and, accordingly, that he should not be responsible for any taxes for the year 1985. The Commission, through its lawyer, disagreed and insisted upon proration as of the date of closing. Because they were unable to agree on issues of withholding and escrow to protect against the judgment liens and the proration of taxes, the City, the Commission and Putt did not close the sale.

The City and the Commission refused thereafter to purchase Putt's property and soon located an alternative site. On July 17, 1985, the Commission purchased this other property.

B.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Gulf Coast Hospice LLC v. LHC Group Inc
273 So. 3d 721 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2019)
Hinds County Economic Development District v. W & G Properties, LLC
203 So. 3d 49 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2016)
William T. Kelly v. Corinth Public Utilities Commission
200 So. 3d 1107 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2016)
Lott v. Pritchett Construction Co.
141 So. 3d 437 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2013)
Reeves v. Midcontinent Express Pipeline, LLC
119 So. 3d 1097 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2013)
Whiting v. University of Southern Mississippi
62 So. 3d 907 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2011)
Cotton v. Corinth Gas & Water Department
406 F. Supp. 2d 713 (N.D. Mississippi, 2005)
Simmons v. Jaggers
914 So. 2d 693 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2005)
Eddie Simmons v. Marvin Jaggers
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2004
Allred v. Fairchild
785 So. 2d 1064 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2001)
Murphree v. WW TRANSP.
797 So. 2d 268 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2001)
Gatlin v. Methodist Medical Center, Inc.
772 So. 2d 1023 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2000)
Scarbrough v. Long
112 F. Supp. 2d 609 (S.D. Mississippi, 2000)
William Wallace Allred v. Wiley Fairchild
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1999
Yarbrough v. Camphor
645 So. 2d 867 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1994)
RC Const. Co. v. National Office Systems, Inc.
622 So. 2d 1253 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1993)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
579 So. 2d 534, 1991 WL 50626, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/putt-v-city-of-corinth-miss-1991.