Williams v. Mason

556 So. 2d 1045, 1990 WL 11742
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedFebruary 7, 1990
Docket07-58847
StatusPublished
Cited by26 cases

This text of 556 So. 2d 1045 (Williams v. Mason) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Williams v. Mason, 556 So. 2d 1045, 1990 WL 11742 (Mich. 1990).

Opinion

556 So.2d 1045 (1990)

Joe Ann WILLIAMS, Administratrix of Estate of Roosevelt Adams, Deceased
v.
Frances MASON.

No. 07-58847.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

February 7, 1990.

*1047 Tyree Irving, Walls & Irving, Greenwood, for appellant.

Kinney M. Swain, Greenville, for appellee.

Before HAWKINS, P.J., and ROBERTSON and PITTMAN, JJ.

ROBERTSON, Justice, for the Court:

I.

In 1962, Roosevelt Adams promised Frances Mason that, if she would live in his home and do his bidding, at his death she would take all of his property. Not a word of this was in writing. In fact, Mason moved into Adams' home and did for well over twenty years as she had agreed. Adams died intestate, and our question is whether, by reason of the agreement or otherwise, Mason holds any enforceable rights against his estate, the principal asset of which is some twenty acres of farm land in Washington County, all of which were acquired during the period of the parties cohabitation.

The Chancery Court held the agreement enforceable and ordered Adams' administratrix to deliver the property to Mason. In this the Court erred and we must reverse. Because Mason holds rights under other law, we remand for further proceedings.

II.

Roosevelt Adams was born on November 24, 1912. He married Della Adams and of that union a son, Roosevelt Adams, Jr., was born in December, 1931. Della Adams is long since deceased.

Adams married Audrey Mae Adams in 1942, but of that union no children were born. At some time thereafter, Adams and Audrey Mae separated and she has lived in Chicago since that time, although the parties have never obtained a divorce.

In 1949, Roosevelt, Jr., then eighteen years of age, left home and never saw his father again.

Frances Mason was born on September 19, 1940. In 1962, under the circumstances described above, Mason moved onto the Adams farm in Washington County, Mississippi, and into Adams' home. At the time Mason was twenty-one years old, while Adams was fifty-two. Mason continues to live on "the place".

Roosevelt Adams never promised to marry Frances Mason, a fact not explained, nor is any reason given why Adams failed to obtain a divorce from his estranged wife in Chicago.

The record is less than clear how much land Adams owned in 1962. It does appear that in 1966 Adams acquired certain interests in the west half of the southwest quarter of the northeast quarter of Section 19, Township 18, North, Range 6 West, Washington County, Mississippi, from Jasper Adams. Also, in 1966, Audrey Mae Adams transferred all of her rights in Adams' property to him.

On February 4, 1986, Roosevelt Adams died. On September 5, 1986, Joe Ann Williams[1] filed in the Chancery Court of Washington County, Mississippi, a petition for letters of administration upon the Estate of Roosevelt Adams, deceased. Williams alleged that Adams had died intestate and was survived by Roosevelt Adams, Jr. and Audrey Mae Adams as his sole heirs-at-law. Letters of administration were granted to Williams and notice to creditors was published first on September 11, 1986.

On November 20, 1986, Frances Mason answered the petition and by counter-claim set up her agreement with Adams and claimed his estate. The case went to trial as a contest between Mason and Adams' heirs-at-law. On October 7, 1987, the *1048 Court made the following express findings of fact:

That Frances Mason and Roosevelt Adams entered into an oral agreement wherein Frances Mason agreed to take care of Roosevelt Adams until his death, and in consideration for said Agreement, Roosevelt Adams would leave Frances Mason all of his property at his death, and thereafter, Frances Mason lived with him until his death and that during his lifetime, Roosevelt Adams never made a will, and no proof was shown to the contrary in this proceeding and no specific mention of the word "will" was made.
That on March 30, 1981, Roosevelt Adams conveyed the store and residence house where the parties, Roosevelt Adams and Frances Mason, lived to Roosevelt Adams and Frances Mason, as joint tenants with survivorship rights and not as tenants in common, and, prior to his death, established a bank account with the Bank of Hollandale in Greenville, Mississippi, as joint tenants with the right of survivorship corroborating that it was Roosevelt Adams' intention to place all property in Frances Mason at his death.
That a clear, definite and certain agreement existed between Roosevelt Adams and Frances Mason that at his death, Frances Mason would have all of his property. The services that Frances Mason provided Roosevelt Adams during his life, were unique, necessary services and, as a result of that agreement, Frances Mason made substantial changes in her lifestyle.
That Frances Mason rendered good and valuable services in connection with the agreement between Frances Mason and Roosevelt Adams, and that she cannot be restored to her original status, that Roosevelt Adams accepted these services and these services were rendered to Roosevelt Adams in good faith; that Frances Mason lost over 25 years of her life while providing for Roosevelt Adams and that Frances Mason was the only person present and able to take care of Roosevelt Adams, and therefore, that Frances Mason executed performance of the agreement between Frances Mason and Roosevelt Adams as to Roosevelt Adams' estate and that said contract is enforceable as to Roosevelt Adams' estate.

Following these findings, the Court ordered Joe Ann Williams, Administratrix, to deliver all property of the Estate of Roosevelt Adams to Frances Mason, less and except all properly registered and probated claims and expenses of administration, fees and costs.

From this judgment, the heirs-at-law appeal.

III.

A contract to devise or bequeath property by will is enforceable in this state. Trotter v. Trotter, 490 So.2d 827, 830 (Miss. 1986); Estate of McKellar v. Brown, 404 So.2d 550, 552 (Miss. 1981). As with other facilities our law affords persons for achieving their wishes, the contract to devise is attended by certain formalities which, if not observed, may result in the contract being legally unenforceable. One of the most important of these formalities is that the contract must be in writing, a function of our statute of frauds. Miss. Code Ann. § 15-3-1 (1972); Estate of McKellar v. Brown, 404 So.2d at 553; Collins' Estate v. Dunn, 233 Miss. 636, 644-45, 103 So.2d 425, 430 (1958); Stephens v. Duckworth, 188 Miss. 626, 634, 196 So. 219, 221 (1940). Though a party may satisfy the court of the existence of an unwritten agreement to devise, the statute precludes specific performance as a remedy our courts may decree. Liddell v. Jones, 482 So.2d 1131, 1132 (Miss. 1986); Collins' Estate v. Dunn, 233 Miss. at 644-45, 103 So.2d at 430; Ellis v. Berry, 145 Miss. 652, 110 So. 211, 213 (1926). This is so even though the promisee has done all he was expected to do under the agreement. Wells v. Brooks, 199 Miss. 327, 332, 24 So.2d 533, 534 (1946). Holmes put the point well a century ago in Bourke v. Callahan, 160 Mass. 195, 35 N.E. 460 (1893):

We are aware that by our construction of Pub.Sts. C. 141, § 1, the statute of frauds may be made an instrument of *1049 fraud. But this is always true, whenever the law prescribes a form for an obligation.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Garet Urban v. Tina Urban
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2023
Nethery v. Estate of Doris Nethery
146 So. 3d 999 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2014)
Hall v. Lewis
107 So. 3d 1057 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2013)
Cotton v. Cotton
44 So. 3d 371 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2010)
Pringle v. Shannon
794 So. 2d 261 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2001)
Edwards v. Roberts
771 So. 2d 378 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2000)
Reed v. Weathers Refrigeration and Air Conditioning, Inc.
759 So. 2d 521 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2000)
In Re Estate of Horrigan
757 So. 2d 165 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1999)
John B. Gillis v. Alexander Scott Gillies
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1999
Tucciarone v. Norwalk Zoning Board, No. Cv99 0172495 (Sep. 8, 1999)
1999 Conn. Super. Ct. 12268 (Connecticut Superior Court, 1999)
In Re Estate of Stewart
732 So. 2d 255 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1999)
Eunice Horrigan v. Christine Ladner
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1998
Logan and Bise v. R. L. Stewart
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1997
Weeks v. Weeks
654 So. 2d 33 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1995)
Alvarez v. Coleman
642 So. 2d 361 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1994)
Estate of Stamper
607 So. 2d 1141 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1992)
Bell v. Mitchell
592 So. 2d 528 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1991)
Bruce v. Bruce
587 So. 2d 898 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1991)
Newton v. Long
588 So. 2d 192 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1991)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
556 So. 2d 1045, 1990 WL 11742, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/williams-v-mason-miss-1990.