2019 IL App (3d) 160132
Opinion filed April 11, 2019 ____________________________________________________________________________
IN THE
APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS
THIRD DISTRICT
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF ) Appeal from the Circuit Court ILLINOIS, ) of the 14th Judicial Circuit, ) Henry County, Illinois Petitioner-Appellee, ) ) Appeal No. 3-16-0132 v. ) Circuit No. 14-DT-258 ) BOB WILLIAMS, ) Honorable ) Peter W. Church Defendant-Appellant. ) Judge, Presiding ______________________________________________________________________________
JUSTICE O’BRIEN delivered the judgment of the court, with opinion. Justices Carter and McDade concurred in the judgment and opinion. _____________________________________________________________________________
OPINION
¶1 Defendant Bob Williams was arrested by officers with the Kewanee Police Department
and charged with driving under the influence after he crashed his vehicle into a guardrail and left
the accident scene. Following his conviction, he appealed, alleging the Kewanee police were
without jurisdiction to arrest him. We affirm.
¶2 FACTS
¶3 On December 12, 2014, defendant Bob Williams was arrested by the Kewanee police
after he was found walking down the road one-half mile from where he had crashed his vehicle into the guardrail at Route 34 and Kentville Road. He was charged by complaint with driving
under the influence (DUI) (625 ILCS 5/11-501(a)(4) (West 2014)); failure to provide immediate
notice of an accident (625 ILCS 5/11-407 (West 2014)); leaving the scene of an accident with
vehicle damage (625 ILCS 5/11-402 (West 2014)); failure to reduce speed to avoid an accident
(625 ILCS 5/11-601(a) (West 2014)); and failure to wear a seat belt (625 ILCS 5/12-603 (West
2014)).
¶4 A jury trial took place. The parties stipulated that Williams was under the influence of
alcohol when he was found walking down the shoulder of the road by the Kewanee police
officers. Rebecca Barnett testified that she lived on Route 34 outside the Kewanee city limits. On
December 12, 2014, she was in the driveway when she heard a loud banging noise and assumed
there had been an accident. She investigated and discovered a vehicle had hit the guardrail on
Route 34 and was sideways in the road. There was no one in the vehicle. She called 911 and
talked to some passersby who had also stopped. She was unsure whether the accident site was
within the Kewanee city limits but she did not believe it was.
¶5 Ronika Long testified that she was on Route 34 on December 12, 2014, and saw a vehicle
sideways in the westbound lane crashed into the guardrail. She saw a person standing outside the
vehicle next to the driver’s door who looked like he was trying to get into the vehicle. The man
then fled. She described him as a white male with a mustache, wearing a white T-shirt and jeans,
and without a coat.
¶6 William Rivord testified. He was a lieutenant with the Kewanee Police Department who
responded to the 911 call. He observed the vehicle’s airbags were not deployed and the seat belts
were in the upright retracted position, meaning they had not been worn. He spoke to witness
Long and put out a dispatch with the driver’s description. Andrew Kingdon, a Kewanee Police
2 Department patrol officer, testified. He responded to the dispatch regarding the accident,
participated in the search of Williams’s person and found a set of car keys on Williams. He later
successfully used the keys on the crashed vehicle.
¶7 Nicholas Welgat, a sergeant with the Kewanee Police Department, testified. He was
dispatched to respond to the accident and found Williams walking on the shoulder of the road
one-half mile east of the crash site. Welgat noticed Williams smelled strongly of alcoholic
beverage, and had glassy eyes, slurred speech, and trouble talking, standing and walking. Welgat
searched Williams, discovering a pipe and pill key fob with burnt residue in them. Both items
field-tested positive for the presumptive presence of cannabis. Welgat arrested Williams for DUI.
On cross-examination, Welgat stated the accident scene was outside the city limits of Kewanee
in unincorporated Henry County.
¶8 At the close of evidence, the defense orally moved to dismiss the charges on the basis
that the Kewanee police lacked jurisdiction to arrest Williams outside of the Kewanee city limits.
The trial court granted the motion on the charge of failure to report an accident, finding the
accident occurred outside the city limits and notification was required to state or county law
enforcement but not to Kewanee. The trial court denied the motion to dismiss regarding the other
charges. The jury found Williams guilty of DUI, failure to wear a seatbelt and failure to reduce
speed to avoid an accident. Although the parties indicate the jury also found Williams guilty of
possession of cannabis and paraphernalia, the citations and jury verdicts for those charges are not
in the record.
¶9 Williams filed posttrial motions to dismiss and for a new trial. In arguing his motion to
dismiss, Williams submitted that the Kewanee police officers lacked the authority to make an
extraterritorial arrest. The State argued that the police were not outside their jurisdiction and
3 presented an annexation agreement indicating the accident site was within Kewanee’s city limits
and a letter explaining that Rivord and Welgat were deputized as Henry County Sheriff’s
Department members and had countywide jurisdiction.
¶ 10 The trial court denied Williams’s posttrial motions to dismiss and for a new trial. The
court found the Kewanee officers had jurisdiction as they were “personally aware” an offense
had been committed. The court further considered that Williams was required to remain at the
scene and the officers became immediately aware on arriving that the driver did not remain, thus
giving them authority to question and arrest Williams. The court did not reach either the
annexation or deputization issues. The court sentenced Williams to a 12-month term of
conditional discharge, 5 days in the county jail and fines. Williams appealed.
¶ 11 ANALYSIS
¶ 12 The issue on appeal is whether the trial court erred when it denied Williams’s motion to
dismiss because the Kewanee police lacked jurisdiction. He argues that the arresting Kewanee
officer lacked jurisdiction to stop and arrest him because the accident and arrest occurred outside
the city limits of Kewanee and the circumstances did not establish authority for an extraterritorial
arrest.
¶ 13 An officer may arrest a person without a warrant when he has “reasonable grounds to
believe that the person is committing or has committed an offense.” 725 ILCS 5/107-2(1)(c)
(West 2014); People v. Jackson, 2014 IL App (3d) 120239, ¶ 85. A police officer may make a
stop and arrest outside his primary jurisdiction if (1) the initial offense occurred within the
officer’s proper jurisdiction and pursuit or investigation led outside the jurisdiction or (2) the
officer becomes “personally aware” a person has immediately committed an offense.
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
2019 IL App (3d) 160132
Opinion filed April 11, 2019 ____________________________________________________________________________
IN THE
APPELLATE COURT OF ILLINOIS
THIRD DISTRICT
THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF ) Appeal from the Circuit Court ILLINOIS, ) of the 14th Judicial Circuit, ) Henry County, Illinois Petitioner-Appellee, ) ) Appeal No. 3-16-0132 v. ) Circuit No. 14-DT-258 ) BOB WILLIAMS, ) Honorable ) Peter W. Church Defendant-Appellant. ) Judge, Presiding ______________________________________________________________________________
JUSTICE O’BRIEN delivered the judgment of the court, with opinion. Justices Carter and McDade concurred in the judgment and opinion. _____________________________________________________________________________
OPINION
¶1 Defendant Bob Williams was arrested by officers with the Kewanee Police Department
and charged with driving under the influence after he crashed his vehicle into a guardrail and left
the accident scene. Following his conviction, he appealed, alleging the Kewanee police were
without jurisdiction to arrest him. We affirm.
¶2 FACTS
¶3 On December 12, 2014, defendant Bob Williams was arrested by the Kewanee police
after he was found walking down the road one-half mile from where he had crashed his vehicle into the guardrail at Route 34 and Kentville Road. He was charged by complaint with driving
under the influence (DUI) (625 ILCS 5/11-501(a)(4) (West 2014)); failure to provide immediate
notice of an accident (625 ILCS 5/11-407 (West 2014)); leaving the scene of an accident with
vehicle damage (625 ILCS 5/11-402 (West 2014)); failure to reduce speed to avoid an accident
(625 ILCS 5/11-601(a) (West 2014)); and failure to wear a seat belt (625 ILCS 5/12-603 (West
2014)).
¶4 A jury trial took place. The parties stipulated that Williams was under the influence of
alcohol when he was found walking down the shoulder of the road by the Kewanee police
officers. Rebecca Barnett testified that she lived on Route 34 outside the Kewanee city limits. On
December 12, 2014, she was in the driveway when she heard a loud banging noise and assumed
there had been an accident. She investigated and discovered a vehicle had hit the guardrail on
Route 34 and was sideways in the road. There was no one in the vehicle. She called 911 and
talked to some passersby who had also stopped. She was unsure whether the accident site was
within the Kewanee city limits but she did not believe it was.
¶5 Ronika Long testified that she was on Route 34 on December 12, 2014, and saw a vehicle
sideways in the westbound lane crashed into the guardrail. She saw a person standing outside the
vehicle next to the driver’s door who looked like he was trying to get into the vehicle. The man
then fled. She described him as a white male with a mustache, wearing a white T-shirt and jeans,
and without a coat.
¶6 William Rivord testified. He was a lieutenant with the Kewanee Police Department who
responded to the 911 call. He observed the vehicle’s airbags were not deployed and the seat belts
were in the upright retracted position, meaning they had not been worn. He spoke to witness
Long and put out a dispatch with the driver’s description. Andrew Kingdon, a Kewanee Police
2 Department patrol officer, testified. He responded to the dispatch regarding the accident,
participated in the search of Williams’s person and found a set of car keys on Williams. He later
successfully used the keys on the crashed vehicle.
¶7 Nicholas Welgat, a sergeant with the Kewanee Police Department, testified. He was
dispatched to respond to the accident and found Williams walking on the shoulder of the road
one-half mile east of the crash site. Welgat noticed Williams smelled strongly of alcoholic
beverage, and had glassy eyes, slurred speech, and trouble talking, standing and walking. Welgat
searched Williams, discovering a pipe and pill key fob with burnt residue in them. Both items
field-tested positive for the presumptive presence of cannabis. Welgat arrested Williams for DUI.
On cross-examination, Welgat stated the accident scene was outside the city limits of Kewanee
in unincorporated Henry County.
¶8 At the close of evidence, the defense orally moved to dismiss the charges on the basis
that the Kewanee police lacked jurisdiction to arrest Williams outside of the Kewanee city limits.
The trial court granted the motion on the charge of failure to report an accident, finding the
accident occurred outside the city limits and notification was required to state or county law
enforcement but not to Kewanee. The trial court denied the motion to dismiss regarding the other
charges. The jury found Williams guilty of DUI, failure to wear a seatbelt and failure to reduce
speed to avoid an accident. Although the parties indicate the jury also found Williams guilty of
possession of cannabis and paraphernalia, the citations and jury verdicts for those charges are not
in the record.
¶9 Williams filed posttrial motions to dismiss and for a new trial. In arguing his motion to
dismiss, Williams submitted that the Kewanee police officers lacked the authority to make an
extraterritorial arrest. The State argued that the police were not outside their jurisdiction and
3 presented an annexation agreement indicating the accident site was within Kewanee’s city limits
and a letter explaining that Rivord and Welgat were deputized as Henry County Sheriff’s
Department members and had countywide jurisdiction.
¶ 10 The trial court denied Williams’s posttrial motions to dismiss and for a new trial. The
court found the Kewanee officers had jurisdiction as they were “personally aware” an offense
had been committed. The court further considered that Williams was required to remain at the
scene and the officers became immediately aware on arriving that the driver did not remain, thus
giving them authority to question and arrest Williams. The court did not reach either the
annexation or deputization issues. The court sentenced Williams to a 12-month term of
conditional discharge, 5 days in the county jail and fines. Williams appealed.
¶ 11 ANALYSIS
¶ 12 The issue on appeal is whether the trial court erred when it denied Williams’s motion to
dismiss because the Kewanee police lacked jurisdiction. He argues that the arresting Kewanee
officer lacked jurisdiction to stop and arrest him because the accident and arrest occurred outside
the city limits of Kewanee and the circumstances did not establish authority for an extraterritorial
arrest.
¶ 13 An officer may arrest a person without a warrant when he has “reasonable grounds to
believe that the person is committing or has committed an offense.” 725 ILCS 5/107-2(1)(c)
(West 2014); People v. Jackson, 2014 IL App (3d) 120239, ¶ 85. A police officer may make a
stop and arrest outside his primary jurisdiction if (1) the initial offense occurred within the
officer’s proper jurisdiction and pursuit or investigation led outside the jurisdiction or (2) the
officer becomes “personally aware” a person has immediately committed an offense. 725 ILCS
5/107-4(a-3)(1), (2) (West 2014); People v. Reynolds, 2016 IL App (4th) 150572, ¶ 27.
4 “Personally aware” means having firsthand knowledge or awareness. People v. Contreras, 2011
IL App (2d) 100930, ¶ 32. Whether the police had jurisdiction is an issue of statutory
construction we review de novo. People v. Bond, 2016 IL App (1st) 152007, ¶ 16.
¶ 14 The trial court found two bases under which the Kewanee officers had jurisdiction to
detain, question and arrest Williams. The first basis on which the trial court relied was the
statutory authority to make an extraterritorial arrest granted an officer who “becomes personally
aware” that a felony or misdemeanor had been immediately committed. 725 ILCS 5/107-4(a-
3)(2) (West 2014). The second basis was the grant of authority to the officers based on
Williams’s violation of the Illinois Vehicle Code, where he failed to remain at the scene of an
accident. 625 ILCS 5/11-402(a) (West 2014).
¶ 15 The trial court’s finding that the officers’ authority arose because they were “personally
aware” of a crime immediately committed was contrary to the facts and the law. The Kewanee
officers were not personally aware that Williams immediately committed any offense. Thus, they
lacked the firsthand knowledge necessary to establish extraterritorial authority to arrest. The
officers’ awareness came via the witnesses and was not firsthand. The testimony of the
witnesses, Barnett and Long, established that a vehicle was crashed into the guardrail and
obstructing the roadway. Barnett did not see anyone in the vehicle. Long saw a white male
outside the driver’s door looking into the vehicle before he fled. Neither witness saw a man exit
the vehicle as the trial court found. The Kewanee officers did not see Williams commit any
offense nor did they witness Williams immediately commit the offense of leaving the scene. He
was one-half mile down the road when found, negating any observation of Williams immediately
committing an offense. Neither of the bases on which the trial court relied provided authority for
Williams’s arrest.
5 ¶ 16 We may affirm the trial court’s decision on any basis in the record. See People v. Lee,
2016 IL App (2d) 150359, ¶ 14 (reviewing court looks at the trial court’s judgment, not its
reasoning, and can affirm on any basis in the record). An annexation ordinance approved by the
Kewanee City Council in November 1964 incorporating the site of the car accident was included
as an exhibit to its response to Williams’s motion to dismiss. Although the trial court expressly
stated that it did not consider the State’s annexation claim, the supporting documentation is
dispositive of the jurisdictional issue. The annexation ordinance establishes the location of
Williams’s accident was within the Kewanee city limits. Accordingly, there was no
extraterritorial arrest. We find that the Kewanee police officer who arrested Williams had
jurisdiction to make the arrest. We note that the trial court previously dismissed the charge for
failing to report an accident on the basis that Williams did not have to inform Kewanee law
enforcement because the accident was outside the city limits. The State did not argue on appeal
that the charge should be reinstated, and we decline to address it. The trial court did not err when
it denied Williams’s motion to dismiss. Accordingly, we affirm Williams’s conviction.
¶ 17 CONCLUSION
¶ 18 For the foregoing reasons, the judgment of the circuit court of Henry County is affirmed.
¶ 19 Affirmed.