Pacific Fast Mail, Inc. v. United States

63 Cust. Ct. 468, 1969 Cust. Ct. LEXIS 3725
CourtUnited States Customs Court
DecidedDecember 4, 1969
DocketC.D. 3938
StatusPublished
Cited by3 cases

This text of 63 Cust. Ct. 468 (Pacific Fast Mail, Inc. v. United States) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Customs Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Pacific Fast Mail, Inc. v. United States, 63 Cust. Ct. 468, 1969 Cust. Ct. LEXIS 3725 (cusc 1969).

Opinion

RoseNSteiN, Judge:

The involved merchandise, invoiced as “20,000 ft. Code 70 Nickel Silver Rail Section”, which was imported from [469]*469the United Kingdom in 1966, was assessed with duty at the rate of 35 per centum ad valorem as parts of toys, not specially provided for, under TSUS (Tariff Schedules of the United States) item 737.90. Plaintiffs contend that the article is not a toy, as that term has been defined, and is properly dutiable at 1.275 cents per pound and 22.5 per centum ad valorem as articles of nickel silver under TSUS item 657.30, which is under the superior heading of “Articles of copper, not coated or plated with precious metal”. It is claimed, alternatively, that the merchandise is scale model railroad track and, as such, dutiable at 16 per centum ad valorem as “track, including switching track” in TSUS item 737.07 which comes under the superior heading of “Other model articles and construction kits or sets”.1

The relevant provisions of the tariff schedules read as follows:

Classified:
Schedule 7, Part 5, Subpart E. Models; Dolls, Toys, Tricks, Party Favors
Subpart E headnotes:
1. The articles described in the provisions of this subpart (except parts) shall be classified in such provisions, whether or not such articles are more specifically provided for elsewhere in the tariff schedules, * * *—
*!» «í» «í» *í» * *
2. For the purposes of the tariff schedules, a “toy” is any article chiefly used for the amusement of children or adults.
‡ ‡ ‡ * *
Toys, and parts of toys, not specially provided for:
ífí ^
737.90 Other_ 35% ad val.
Claimed:
Schedule 6, Part 3, Subpart G. Metal Products Not Specially Provided For
Subpart G headnotes:
1. This subpart covers only articles of metal which are not more specifically provided for elsewhere in the tariff schedules.
‡ :J: ifc # % ^
[470]*470Articles of copper, not coated or plated with precious metal:
657.30 Of copper, other than alloys of copper; of nickel silver or of cupro-nickel- 1.2750 per lb. +22.5% ad val.
Alternatively Claimed:
Model trains, model airplanes, model boats, and other model articles, all the foregoing whether or not toys; and construction kits or sets for making or assembling such model articles:
* * ❖ >Ji %
Other models, and construction kits or sets:
787.07 [Amended by Pub. L. 89-241, §§ 2(a), 70, Oct. 7,1965, 79 Stat. 933, 947.] Nail locomotives and rail vehicles; railway rolling-stock ; track, including switching track; rail depots, round houses, signal towers, water towers, and other trackside structures; trolley buses and trolley-bus systems; cable-car systems; highway vehicles; ships and harbor structures; and airplanes and spacecraft; all the foregoing-made to scale of the actual article at the ratio of 1 to 85 or smaller_ 16% ad val.

The record2 establishes that the Code 70 rail at bar, which is imported in three foot lengths, is manufactured to exact specifications and represents a reduction in absolute scale from its prototype, the rail used in standard railroad equipment. Exhibit 1, a representative sample of the article, is thin (approximately one-eighth inch at its widest cross-section), very pliable and ridged along its length.

It was conceded by defendant that the rail is suitable only for use in the construction of scale model railroad track, such as illustrative exhibit 6, which consists of a section of multiple HO gauge track made from Code 70 rail laid down to scale on a board (to represent a section of standard railroad track).

[471]*471The construction of model track, which consists essentially of two parallel rails laid on a roadbed and connected with crossties, requires care, time, and great accuracy. The time taken to build track varies according to one’s skill: the rails must be cut, filed, fitted, gauged and soldered. One witness testified that it takes him approximately two hours to construct one foot of straight track. Another witness, a model railroader for 17 years, who had constructed exhibit 6, stated that it was “very difficult” to build a railroad track, and described the process thusly:

A. Well, Exhibit 6 was constructed from lengths of rail such as Exhibit 1. The entire exhibit, including all of the switch or turnout sections, were constructed, or what we call built from items such as Exhibit 1. There were three foot lengths of rail, various parts were cut, filed, fitted, soldered, in order to create what we call the track section that you see here as Exhibit 6.
Q,. What do you first do ? — A. First we define where we want the track to go. We lay out the course of the track; in effect, we survey it if you like to use that expression; then we determine where we are going to put our switches; we lay down a diagram, build in effect a template over which the rails have been laid and gauged, and then we begin cutting, filing, soldering, fitting, and gauging the track.
Q. Do you do anything to the board itself? — A. Many, many different things can be done with the board. In this one we have done some cutting out of the board to simulate drainage ditches, simulate the roadbed on which the ballast on which the ties, and then on which the rail is laid.
Q. Then what do you do ? — A. Then we spike down the rails.
Q,. Do you make the ties ? — A. Yes, I do make the ties. These are made from scratch, from small pieces of wood referred to as strip wood, which is usually a soft pine material. These are cut to various lengths; * * *.

Ties and spikes of the type used in building model track, and a gage, an implement used to measure the distance between rails, were received in evidence. Other tools used in building model track are jewelers’ pliers and files, and a pin vise for pre-drilling spike holes.

Pacific Fast Mail, Inc. (Pacific) belongs to the National Model Eailroad Association, Inc. (NMEA), which establishes standards and recommended practices in the manufacture and construction of model railroads. An NMEA manual of “Official NMEA Standards” and “NMEA Eecommended Practices” was received in evidence as an illustration of these standards. Additional exhibits are a pamphlet entitled “Plow to Wire Your Model Eailroad” and an article on “Building Code 70 Turnouts in Nickel Silver” in the April, 1961 issue of Model Railroader, a publication read-by model railroad hobbyists. Model railroading is a diversion which is, in turn, pleasant, frustrating, re-[472]*472lasing, time-consuming and satisfying. It is taken seriously by many hobbyists who often get together at national conventions or regional meetings held by NMBA to discuss problems and exchange information.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Doherty-Barrow of Texas, Inc. v. United States
3 Ct. Int'l Trade 228 (Court of International Trade, 1982)
Terumo-America, Inc. v. United States
2 Ct. Int'l Trade 121 (Court of International Trade, 1981)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
63 Cust. Ct. 468, 1969 Cust. Ct. LEXIS 3725, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/pacific-fast-mail-inc-v-united-states-cusc-1969.