McNevin v. McNevin

444 N.E.2d 320
Indiana Court of Appeals·Decided March 30, 1983·No. 2-1280A414·Published·Cited by 4 cases

Opinions

BUCHANAN, Chief Judge.

CASE SUMMARY

Petitioner-appellant Nancy J. McNevin (Nancy) appeals from the trial court’s judgment dismissing her personal injury claim against respondent-appellee Robert W. McNevin, Sr. (Robert), contending that the court erred in concluding her claim was extinguished by the parties’ dissolution decree which incorporated a previously negotiated settlement agreement.

We affirm.

FACTS

The record discloses that in May of 1978, after the parties had separated, Robert allegedly struck and injured Nancy. Robert filed a petition for dissolution of marriage in the Hendricks Circuit Court in November of 1978. A dissolution decree incorporating a previously negotiated settlement agreement was entered in September of 1979. The sections of the dissolution decree pertinent to this decision are set forth below:

6. Settlement Agreement. The settlement agreement of the parties, as set forth hereinafter in this decree, was duly executed by each of the parties freely and without duress and after consultation and advice from counsel, and the rights of the parties should be adjudged accordingly.

IT IS, THEREFORE, ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED by this Honorable Court as follows:

A. Dissolution. The bonds of matrimony heretofore existing between the parties are hereby absolutely dissolved effective with the issuance of this decree.

B. Property Settlement Agreement.

1. Personal Property. The petitioner [Robert] shall be the owner of all household goods, furniture and furnishings now in his possession as well as his own personal effects, clothing and jewelry. In addition, the petitioner shall be the owner of the following property:

motorcycles presently in possession of respondent
Datsun 280Z 1979 automobile;
1 Aluminum houseboat with Chrysler engine;
1 fishing boat and trailer;
household goods in El Dago, Florida real estate;
certain savings account at Peoples Bank and Trust Company; and, business account at Peoples Bank and Trust Company;
a certain Honda automobile which will be titled to the son of the parties at the time of the final Decree

except as otherwise provided in this agreement, all other tangible personal property heretofore reduced to his possession, or standing in his sole name.

Except as otherwise provided in this agreement, the respondent shall be the owner of all intangible and tangible personal property heretofore reduced to her possession or standing in her sole name, and the following property;

a certain Dodge wagon automobile;
a certain 1979 Oldsmobile;
a certain Chasta motor home;
[323] a certain speed boat;
2 small Honda motorcycles;
all household goods located at 650 Arthur Drive, Indianapolis, Indiana.

As well as her personal effects, clothing and jewelry.

2. Real Property. That the wife be [sic] is hereby adjudged the individual owner of a [sic] certain pieces of real property commonly known as follows:

650 Arthur Drive, Indianapolis, Indiana 558 Arthur Drive, Indianapolis, Indiana 1 lot on John Johns River, Crescent City, Florida; (which said real estate has heretofore been deeded from the husband to the wife)

3. Obligations. The petitioner and respondent hereto each agree as to the separate obligations assumed hereunder to save the other party harmless from any further liability thereon.

The petitioner shall assume and pay until discharged in full, according with its terms, the existing indebtedness on the following:

(A) Master Charge in the approximate sum of $673.65
(B) L. Strauss & Co. in the approximate balance of $51.12
(C) Sears in the approximate balance of $2929.70
(D) Penney’s account in the approximate sum of $705.20
(E) Ready Credit account in the approximate balance of $795.18
(F) Town & Country account in the approximate balance of $465.07
(G) VISA account in the approximate balance of $877.94
(H) Block’s account in the approximate balance of $208.48
(I) Ayres account in the approximate balance of $639.71
(J) Lazarus account in the approximate balance of $95.13
(K) Woolco account in the approximate balance of $100.00
(L) Automobile insurance on wife’s Oldsmobile for a period of one year from date of. entry of this Decree.

4. Petitioner agrees to make arrangements for and to pay the cost of repair of damage to the den floor in the residence at 650 Arthur Drive, Indianapolis, Indiana within thirty (30) days from the date of entry of this Decree.

5. Petitioner agrees to waive that certain sum of One Thousand Dollars ($1,000.00) heretofore agreed to be paid by the wife to the husband for the purchase of a certain 1979 Oldsmobile.

6. Husband agrees to pay to the wife as alimony judgment the sum of Sixteen Thousand Eight Hundred Dollars ($16,-800.00) payable in twenty-four (24) equal monthly instalments of Seven Hundred Dollars ($700.00) per month beginning on October 1, 1979 and continuing month to month thereafter until paid in full or until the death of the wife whichever occurs first. It is understood by and between the parties that said sum agreed to be paid by petitioner is an alimony judgment, the intent of the parties being to provide the husband with a deductable [sic] expense for Federal and State income tax purposes.

7. Husband agrees to assume and pay schooling expenses for the children of the parties.

8. Life Insurance. That the petitioner shall have the sole possession of the policies of life insurance on his life and the respondent shall become the owner of the existing life insurance policies on her life, and each party assumes and agrees to pay the premiums on said policies after the entry of this Decree of Dissolution.

9. Petitioner agrees to assume and pay Income Tax liabilities for the year 1979 incurred on his behalf and to save the respondent harmless from any liability thereon.

10. Accounts. That the Respondent has a checking account at the Indiana National Bank in Indianapolis, Indiana, this said account shall become the property of the wife.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

McNevin v. McNevin, 444 N.E.2d 320 (Ind. Ct. App. 1983).

444 N.E.2d 320 (McNevin v. McNevin) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Hutchcraft v. Eastern Indiana Production Credit Ass'n
486 N.E.2d 644 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1985)
Allstate Insurance v. Boles
587 F. Supp. 807 (S.D. Indiana, 1984)
McNevin v. McNevin
444 N.E.2d 320 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1983)