LeBlanc v. State Farm Ins. Co.

878 So. 2d 715, 2004 WL 1166170
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedMay 26, 2004
Docket2003-1522
StatusPublished
Cited by6 cases

This text of 878 So. 2d 715 (LeBlanc v. State Farm Ins. Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
LeBlanc v. State Farm Ins. Co., 878 So. 2d 715, 2004 WL 1166170 (La. Ct. App. 2004).

Opinion

878 So.2d 715 (2004)

Julaine C. LeBLANC, Ovey LeBlanc, et al.
v.
STATE FARM INS. CO., et al.

No. 2003-1522.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

May 26, 2004.

*716 Julius Willis Grubbs Jr., Haik, Minvielle & Grubbs, Iberia, LA, for Defendant Appellee State of LA., DOTD.

Dennis Ray Stevens, Gibbens & Stevens, New Iberia, LA, for Defendants/Appellees Timothy Edler, Rebecca Edler, Standard Fire Ins. Co.

Michael G. Daiy, Toce & Daiy, Andre F. Toce, Lafayette, LA, for Intervenor/Appellee Toce & Daiy Law Firm.

Stacy Skolfield Lee, Lafayette, LA, for Defendant Appellee Allstate Ins. Co.

Barry Louis Domingue, Simon Law Offices, Lafayette, LA, for Plaintiff Appellant Julaine C. LeBlanc, Ovey LeBlanc.

Charles Martin Kreamer, Allen & Gooch, Lafayette, LA, for Secondary Defendants/Appellants Conn Appliances, Inc., U.S. Fire Ins. Co., North Rivers Insurance Co.

Shane Errol Romero, New Iberia, LA, for Defendant/Appellee Iberia Parish Government.

Court composed of JOHN D. SAUNDERS, BILLIE COLOMBARO WOODARD, and MICHAEL G. SULLIVAN, Judges.

SAUNDERS, Judge.

Plaintiffs, Julaine LeBlanc and Ovey LeBlanc, appeal the judgment of the trial court granting, in part, the defendants' Motions to Compel Enforcement of Settlement and Execution of Settlement Documents and Demand for Defense and Indemnification, filed by the Conn's defendants, and adopted by the other defendants. Plaintiffs also appeal the trial court's judgment that the Mediation Settlement Agreement executed on March 24, 2003 is an enforceable settlement which the court ordered enforced, but without the need for the plaintiffs to sign any additional documents. Additionally, the LeBlancs appeal the trial court's ruling denying their Motion for a New Trial and finding it moot in light of its ruling on the Motions to Compel. We affirm.

FACTS

On Wednesday, July 30, 1997, Julaine LeBlanc was driving in a southerly direction on Louisiana Highway 86. Paul Julien, while acting in the course and scope of his employment with Conn's Appliances, Inc., made a left turn into Louisiana Highway 86 from the private driveway of Timothy and Rebecca Edler without yielding to Ms. LeBlanc. Ms. LeBlanc's vehicle struck Mr. Julien's vehicle.

As a result of the accident, a lawsuit was filed for personal injuries on behalf of Julaine LeBlanc on July 30, 1998, and a consortium claim was made on behalf of Ms. LeBlanc's husband, Ovey LeBlanc, and on behalf of Dustin Courrege.[1] Named as defendants in the original and/or subsequent amending petitions were the driver, Paul B. Julien, his liability insurer, State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company ("State Farm"), Conn's Appliances, Inc. ("Conn's") and its liability insurers, North River Insurance Company ("North River") and U.S. Fire Insurance Company ("U.S. Fire"), Tim and Rebecca Edler and their insurer The Standard Fire Insurance Company ("Standard Fire"), as well as the State of Louisiana, Department of Transportation and Development ("DOTD") and Iberia Parish Government.

Following much litigation in this matter, the parties agreed to participate in a mediation *717 conference in the hopes of settling the lawsuit. The mediation conference was held on March 24, 2003. All parties were present or represented. Mr. LeBlanc was not present at the mediation, but at the time of the mediation he and his wife were both represented by Mr. Andre Toce, who was present at the mediation. At the mediation on March 24, 2003, all parties present signed a "Mediation Settlement Agreement." The terms of the agreement were as follows:

1) Conn's, North River, and U.S. Fire agreed to pay the plaintiffs $320,000.00;
2) DOTD agreed to pay the plaintiffs $50,000.00;
3) Iberia Parish Government agreed to pay $10,000.00; and
4) Tim and Rebecca Edler and Standard Fire agreed to pay the plaintiffs $15,000.00.

As of the date of the mediation, State Farm had already paid the plaintiffs $25,000.00, the limit of its policy, for its underlying policy on the personal vehicle of Conn's employee, Mr. Julien. Therefore, the total settlement proceeds to the LeBlancs were $420,000.00. In addition to the financial settlement, the Mediation Settlement Agreement contained defense and indemnity language stating that the settlement "includes consortium claims of Mr. LeBlanc and plaintiff to defend and to hold harmless the defendants as to same and indemnify as to consortium claims." The agreement also stated: "The parties also agree that all claims will be dismissed with prejudice, and the parties agree that a formal settlement agreement will be executed at a later date." In addition, it was a term of the agreement that DOTD's settlement with the LeBlancs would be in the form of a Consent Judgment. A Consent Judgment regarding DOTD's settlement was signed and filed with the Iberia Parish Clerk of Court on March 25, 2003. A Voluntary Motion and Order to Dismiss Claims of Ovey LeBlanc was signed by Mr. LeBlanc, ordered by Judge Keith R.J. Comeaux, and filed with the Iberia Parish Clerk of Court's office on March 25, 2003. As set forth in the agreement, all parties agreed that a formal settlement agreement would be executed at a later date.

On April 1, 2003, Charles Kreamer, Sr., attorney for Conn's, North River, and U.S. Fire, faxed a letter to all parties with draft settlement documents attached, requesting notification by the parties of any necessary revisions. On the afternoon of April 1, 2003, Mr. Kreamer received a letter from Barry L. Domingue stating that his services had been retained by the LeBlancs, that Mr. Toce had been terminated by the LeBlancs, and that there was no settlement of this matter.

On April 2, 2003, all defendants received a letter from Mr. Toce, addressed to Mr. Domingue, which contained a copy of the settlement agreement, the Voluntary Motion and Order to Dismiss signed by Ovey LeBlanc, the Consent Judgment on behalf of DOTD, and that advised that a Motion to Enforce Settlement Agreement would be filed and the settlement funds deposited in the registry of the court.

On April 7, 2003, Conn's, North River, and U.S. Fire filed a "Motion to Compel Enforcement of Settlement and Execution of Settlement Documents and Demand for Defense and Indemnification." A similar motion was filed by the Iberia Parish Government, Timothy and Rebecca Edler, and Standard Fire on April 7, 2003. On April 7, 2003 plaintiffs filed a Motion for New Trial.

A hearing on these motions took place May 2, 2003, in front of Judge Comeaux. The trial court held that the signed Mediation Settlement Agreement was a valid and *718 enforceable compromise as per La.Civ.Code. art. 3071, and denied plaintiff's Motion for New Trial. On May 27, 2003, a hearing was held formulating a final judgment with regard to the trial court's May 2, 2003 ruling. A Judgment on Rule was signed May 27, 2003.

The LeBlancs present two assignments of error for our review.

1) That the trial court committed reversible error in finding that a binding settlement agreement existed between the parties.
2) That the trial court committed reversible error in denying plaintiff's Motion for New Trial where plaintiff's prior attorney had no authority to enter the Consent Judgment or the Voluntary Motion and Order to Dismiss Claims of Ovey LeBlanc, and where the signature on the Motion purported to be that of Ovey LeBlanc, was, in fact, not the signature of Ovey LeBlanc.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Feingerts v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance
117 So. 3d 1294 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2013)
Instant Replay Sports, Inc. v. Allstate Insurance Co.
102 So. 3d 851 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2012)
Smith v. BAMBINO
62 So. 3d 255 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2011)
Norwood v. Garber
29 So. 3d 735 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010)
Eaves v. Spirit Homes, Inc.
931 So. 2d 1173 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2006)
Dewayne S. Eaves v. Spirit Homes, Inc.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2006
LeBlanc v. State Farm Ins. Co.
930 So. 2d 296 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2006)
Julaine C. Leblanc v. State Farm Ins. Co.
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2006

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
878 So. 2d 715, 2004 WL 1166170, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/leblanc-v-state-farm-ins-co-lactapp-2004.