Juan Enriquez v. Rick Thaler
Opinion
«l 1 FILED IN COURT OF APPEALS 12th Court of Appeals District
MAR 20 2015\yttfY TYLER TEXAS
CATHY S. LUSK, CLERK COURT OF APPEALS Court of Appeals District
M>, la-l^-Oo-olL-Cv/
JQftw tfo^pc/fe-z;
Rick TWal^^W^
Reply sgyrg fo^App^cca^t
ft) 7^ tfOtfCtf^g^l? JUJ>Ces OF 3f^O CDukJ?
3"ci*n ^nrfyucz^ p-pfetl*^ pucswivJ0 -h> &*^
^U\$ CA££ ia^«^s c<L£mU«W U^t+^«7o+^AAJ<^6x^,
ficP«'l/\jr .r-f Is -ton* im^orJ^^ ^^^^W-^ i 1 .
\SSUC) n*meh-> VeniM., be PtUrcsseif rfi'rx)- ^ec^^^ ^jA q! fc-Wf Cv*<^~ Wctyfr "+r*r&-Ie&*<t t€ver^-k0 c 4h«T Jt>l\vw€i
P^-fus£rf T"o p/<-o^«fe- f^pp*Uev«4- U/rfK 4K-. VjciniCrJp^ ^ '
T^C Virtue +r^n5^ hCRrinj» T^ <*k4inc+cItv-fc u>Ot^rf/i'4-
pW>pfc||«<wU cjV*vur\<t 4-hflf the- SfWfn^s CJ^Ktf^. cD^4^ V<nuc 4<nu*Per ^v/ut, d rcf ^ot «*t>f ty +* cas<=s 4M/
JV^ .£VwWj eUuSc of-4**c melton sf U L5
Clause tun^i^ +*v«- ^Wu+^ uAivc£i jrchtfmef ^vVc 4c ^<7W bu-f u;htc£t tTju^f H£«-tf H<y«i-
tff-ffrvls »cXl^r\d +#wrift«^ *> fc"
3 \
K)ou/ -Hiolj Ue^y^very cl«**r, TVis S^ptUX^ frpplici eWy 4v pyrk -fWf-^CCurrc/A#er- W.C
J.'rvi Simply s-Wi/i^ AcAfcf^f ^K^ J'*m Coming/, jtHhtfn proceed ArV^Wc }h ^«4r*f6 4j
fiO £>a.ST<roce_ <?r "fn*»f Acc^hc/ before IW7 TWi <^Kc/> "fn<j?**- ninety 4^cse_ people Ai^fncvi-z.^^ "f%^ to***)fes&*h& Je^cjflfc 4V}^ rAccs, to AketAm\*rfi lydMuic,
Hgy*''K <j~ ^orHor><fe<TritAsfg>f Uwm* g?4:(g [JoW '0*j n*w/r_ ^pM fcce^ *f4% LM'rf? ^Vf^ .^K7£i (?i/E7_ : A4 -*% Untf; JI'vk, been
-fhco lTvc4M/^e</ fn H**, IT believe, T^vro J7 CAW ^Vftnsf<WQf AJ ^vio . An/1 CAwvc J> «W< ** ^°°°°r^ fUco jL7 iAK*'$tf*As&tv**/A\ftin* JT Cftroe- ^«efc hcflt/4/ 2<»& f**d <Av4»— purpose. O^AtV/e/iwdM^ -every+Kir»«j f« ,rxy CTmpW *»!- rv\f^r fc<=_ except*,/ as ~frtf£, JC rv\eoo , YY\y CAU.kt o-f- Ac4ioo »,* F*UTDm**4rcAlly ACCeft/u^nrA i4 15 Ct>s\s!c&s<n/Or\c(<r 4^ C^Wt t>f- AcfJz>/v '
W^*± XJ?Ay Here i.S U^*wf ^Ov/<rrn^ 4*,^ -H^aH .S^ ?kpfc Si^p/jr, oomy pUfrferf*fr&t docs fiot Afp/y4
H*ftrtn* 0^ WfrfVp^ 4i?"T^AnsAt- N/g/i*^ /£>, 17, T^ CWf ?yAo4^ -f^ m^o. 4(7 -f>Anj?-£- v/enM(L
J Us\~ fu4oo 4+id ire<W, An/ 3" ^^ £€**._ ^ of^Y ferftfyj bn4 hej *s+pu+ on 4h^ wzcc*S4h#t-^ h^ rf
5e> W^^<-SAyj»iA +Wf 4o/- 4A«_ tiftfiij q£ ^is CD/vv^/^f 4-W he h*+specSonni kf\oJl*<£#^ cri(z,L i~Ae A&Mvqs, +h*+- have, vccusrd G^jl^ IHlt/^/^u Me has Wo 4A^ <JVn<Ar(y »<**ca4*, Artf-f^ ^idW ^J~ 1S/oepW m A'vtrrsv^ Ckm4v !
s
T^a. C^fr mA<£<- CH^frl^^^^^rm/nA44£)oS R-&J*W Vac 4^. p'eA<£>/ <fAef* . ^f* *, aVo4w $4& s4w/v*7o, 4^©4" ^"f^effAnf" l'\fW/ 4^ C$e<r4- ^ k^^ccLn C>i «4^VT (Hfe^Wi^Alf-SlflCe, K£7;4W, ?A 111*, fAen /a/2o^ <v\so, 4n. c^uof- rfW/ 4uf-4^Af- //Vf-M/ A& c&^l^f-
4tT Acl Air^^f 4t7 ^u-VC 4^2_ m«tr4r C?4 -A COufc, CL termor?
/W^X^S**'' h* 4*.far-, «*es;MfeW A* *4Upf*y, 4<^ C&LCrAcS'
rt^c^/ W^ Ateo pf«a/ -Mof he ^Acf J,^ k&c<r«y of by Tfcc.CV.fW. t&tM.G,^ Section \5T oL+Cl>) wMcHs+fffes On *vppeJ f™*» He 4v.'aI Dn He hner^ if Venue was Irhp^p^ ff^nW/ irt noeW kc Venue u/«s o^ tvas nD4-pr£7p^ 4V *ppeH4le Cocir4-<shAl( Ct>n-s'i^~^ en4<"re vcetf/tf, fflCMinj 4ki4^iA/ c?o-4V mer4i
X£4*y,£, 'o "* evio(e/>ce ~^+ ^^ ^s p«p^> f^e a^^IUt^ Ce?Ur-/- rysM&4- r^vc^e, 4-^e.4wJ aI Cc?4rf!s <errv<r\£odL3> VenMd. vufmj a^ ^m^J 4"*ie eA^e. fas *> ^^
W^brbt C-'fy v. HArf- qnSM/.*Zd 77%7^f CTcy 1*1Of
C>f 4V K-Arc 5rfuA4;on5 lA^^crc f-^e h Arm^ss-eyv<5Y^ Km/c^ T^AP i-tt+jCttyi does tsth^f^Y' X-f 4*e+riA/ec?«rf-ynAfcor #a ew<?nc0i/s Venue V"u\Uj, 4*e. Ca^c a>ws4 Jbcreve/.^v' -ex/e^ f'-f Qpp^n*n± CAnncrf- shvtAS h^rm, Wilsvsr v, 7^^
A-ppell <irt4 r^lle^es 4U<yf A^p^lU^s AAve rAAJnfA-. *W ^rsc^^)wa4ory pv*iso^ 5yi^ u/K*vcJv dIsc^tWtto*fe* (\cfiKsys1 rltSffynit* ^Y dQnytrtj He/vi e^u/yj <adutA-4»loo^/
Cr *^^ce Am^ Coft>r^ c/cny!^ -4V/vi e<*u^f mecfrc aI An^cfe/f+A/ TlrCA4nr\f0f-; An/ cfUclplWnj 4^e^ u/i4*v hivsl^p^ Wr4x Pr££±lW Brief, a4 4, X^e- ftppellees Al.St> Ifece>*r^ Zr: 4^A+//£pf«flA«4 4-w«4*e/- C(tf-\alS 4in*v4 AfpeJ/eei h Av^. Ap»|fcy In pl*£eL Vejft^W M& 5w^e^istt?rt &4-4f\<Lis CMrfs -fctA-dc\)cs ^juM l^c^fm<-n4 A*v 5e^\/iC^ 4p WiS^AnkS 4^A+ Are 'prc^v^/^^flne^ 4? A/^/f,
|trn\W4o nr\ichAel Un'.f<>W£ £nWcjue2~pufC?a~K^ ft-e-cW tWf- he 44^f *W, ve^ a4- 4^e_ rArcivAel txa'i 4" r* *^%"7j g-iefh't ycA/ts bef©r£- f-^e_ inrn/vfe- v/enue_ sfefcfe Ujf^S Cr^i^cA^J* *p^e- ^our^ \]nOr*-d -\hes^ eiah\~ y^A^
r^*X ^Ai! A* J^J^oof h&S\±, PlAJn4rfi- foformes 4a^ Cc?urf f4^4 ffi p«m.«^i « '"0 e«fty7^An4i ^e cfe^sj-^zjj- In 4-fot (^^ qp^cegy ^Ac»»(^y S^iraj&kt f>rhon± in VtOlOHvn cf4^ 5:4^ ^fcf f^edtnff Ctn*tih*ftt»~ molted
^rvw Cc?^\firln^ fe ^A£e</ 01 A-p-ohcy 4*#4- u^*v£ \^ jtyU4e<ice or 4^Af Clcc(lu<4 ^«4We Wr . Ta*v4-'.s u/^ei 4a?^-- CaJ^O ff\££e. pe^^le, ^u4Ac?^;2_</ -rh^xr \AJf\tden$ -4-Q 5^/o ft^ 4^U rcAte^) +r» of Jsc^i^ i*/«4e- ^y S+^u-Uy f*r*f £ UJh«/« ^>W Ctfxv<o/ A-4ip^ acci^u-o// |4e.ftff^ £j prvo4r0^> 4o T^Af^fU v/eV\i<a-, o4~ I t -
%
"pLe_ AppefUet /vc^n".'^ fCfrppJl<x^ Arnen^L/ h #$ Ce>mpl#,04 4* IacU^ ^,^/ I'ncf^f/rko^rflr^^.^^^ ye4 cffes «J**kr A^Wnce On A~y llrt^V^ 6*Uf A4- IJ, r4 ivAi nft-4 Aece^3ArX4V Ap^/|A^ JJl pi-trfc 4Ae Wrk 04 Ac^ ^ Ae4j^ fcerW|e ewhnJ'^ Cft^- «* Ac4,'oo; uyne^ pfe**,, properJ^ sk^fi 6e_ 4a^0
P\ $ect>r>el ^eAson a £*-p'/ Bv-i«f is Aec^-^Wy ffiAt- 4f^ 4-^Ta/ cour^did nc& hAs/e. diSCtcrfior? -h? en+5r
2) fhe. +oU( Amoc^f t>i <^?c^f cf-eci <WcWj cK*^/ fco 4^ tim<9£ i"1 '+K|-r CAi^v
T^e ^mi Couflf w>°»3 Kmriifecf -4~z> 4*»e. ^S/A rv\on4^s depos'rb 4Vo»v> H<L ^Wr^ 7, JL.6fCX; a fA'cfcwrf (jjkfch Was Ht bASisCrf fbe |A<//}c/icy deferreda?a4-i>>?^ TAe Fekv-uA/y 7; 2.0/2, a-ttMfirttf reflects A+b!*l of RT70 f^ov4Hc precsccfinj 6 monfAj. iMieri+f percent &-p-$S7C> ij> jfrmo . XV\s4eA^L by us/nj 4^e. 4—mor>4^ p?r\x>$ -£n>m 4nc d«+e of 4^ Dec*«bf, Nj 2o'3, Oroter^e Ap^lfA^f u>a<; CW<*c/ ^aW.4(7 fCK \Hi)} $ \0tH more 4-n«n 4^^ Courf Aw4nov[^-ec< 4o "imp&se. Thus, even if 4^e_ Courf tv/vs co^ef in Jtnyinj l^^cy, He eG«^ erre<fj" 4**.'^ p 4-KJ/.J1 rleAAo,-4h«4 * fWy C^'ef »SAee*&r%y Is 4^ a4-f-h e, ^«•*-e-^fa n4s Ave misf^/v/i*j ~^e Cou*f ^ *W;<^ Q S*ep 1 'j^cv'A.KC; '% f/Ntt) Afpe«U/rf \re>£us*J 4c f. 'e /i 5fcp -X aViWArtcc p>± Ail An/ H«^4i«= faiiec/ 4-d c-eotpi^ U/lff, 3f ¥. OOS-(<£>Ci}s Pj££*M*e*l &y\A,(\T »2 jhc-\ruAk \S 4M"-H^ £lee ia^.ev'A-^ce &sr\ &^is L\eJ f**J on1/ e^«-'iSSwe- fr/hvk^A/c? is Al/ew/e/.T^le Step 2 f^^AACC <ece^*rf On 4^. Cfn 5f On June ^, 2oO,
;S/Me fD b^ pves^W p^ ^»^^r<- X^
Jt>
fV- -44ic Iam/5^4-|o Aa^cct^ Cvuoiy,
The &4a,|/ ^/t^fSmWf/^t. CaSc <*A>cA
,As;sf/ 4H, Aft*lUrf ^wd an 44^_^cumer4s 4il*rf 1^ T</Vic Cottffly^n Ak, /a, r- •/ AI "R^ WH/ua^ 4nA4 tl'^ cj0\r^ fb~v u,t4h 4^ ple'AtffiW YOU, h*^e~ OnfiU K>1 < fc-0 " s,
No Vd'crn/ U/As p,^ov\do/ hy 4-k<L- 'V^rw/isCourrisy
previa/ by T^Av/is Comty, *Titav\s Co^jy c^Ci'^is refuse/ h (2w^lC^ /O^^W w4h ^ ^ecWx, Inobudhj 4Ae_4/nAA*c^<>f4*c v/^Ht t>a,*^ ^ ^ p^0v. fa { by Appellees, £W^L*.fi,* 0-fVE-h/K>/ V a, Afp^A/xt p*W 44i^ Cos\S cU^ JA 4Mj CAJfc-
X4 brpetors 4+\c4viM C/xv+ w«oW An ey4^a fz^ -fv Tr^s CoM/v-fy Or _S^e U^otfl^ h*\^ ctiSfYii'sfeS-He Cp&a- ak>c/ advi^ecf 4^^ onre- 4d^ *^<A/*»</, ~Ty)&-l
5f ja^o £e rfefeWVWx 4i? e^ricit 4^e_ C&tfes^s 0"h
1/
Wfe£EF<*£; p/lBrv\iS^s Cv^SipizfZTErb^ App«//a*/-
p^Ays 4^A~f~ 4^iis AppeA^ be^c/nA^/e/ ArW 4^c c?(f$miss& / JUckyvys^cf (^^trs^d dlAe^tv Qr^ e*rrontons \S<nae- ~f ^^/^ f&A_ fZu.liio^. A/WoAfVcly fnA4 TAo Coi*4" /2-^^i A/\/s ^"^ "^V(S oTi-Sm V*sa /j u^/wvf vmv^ns^/ du<^ 4c? Hc_ 4a\ /iuc -ar~"i^e ]rt&l Cour+ 4(7 ^iWlX_S-4^tf CAX^ An/ <!\\ow Plfi\\rArlf~+0 f>rty
Ti)ccr-m^hA<4
TcnAesi^ 0p/V>/j4X *7S$8; b £V4141' ^^4^ e> 4- J*e^x/1 c< X Tuaa ^^utri, ee,-ft4y 4n»t A c™*^ ^y o4-Ke -WW fofty Brief-Jar Give'/*"') ^ "^^ b/ f J 5Amc m 4fce- Cln,1lrif' - \ . iT Crf^ni t<AU AiSiVkof Bfkr^y^^fj fiO, tfbpc j^SY*, Ams4W, TX 7*7//
T7 'JuA.vtnnf|^a, <^ec( Ar<^ Ur^ta-penally or f^j^ry^ V-T -7?'4^rby p>/Ac;^-SAme in 4^c J>^jf4v4/^/v/ /vu;/ ry5/r^,}«fi>sj of'tosW'hrw^Pn-ril djMnsse* 4* C'c^ Ty\er jy 7S7&2-" *r*c«W *n^*^ ^j 2-°JSr
Texas Department of Criminal Justice ,111(1 7 42013
STEP 2 OFFENDER GRIEVANCE FORM
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
Juan Enriquez v. Rick Thaler (Juan Enriquez v. Rick Thaler) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.