Jones v. State

23 A.3d 880, 420 Md. 437, 2011 Md. LEXIS 432
Court of Appeals of Maryland·Decided July 6, 2011·No. No. 87·Published·Cited by 9 cases

Opinion

BATTAGLIA, J.

In the aftermath of Evans v. State, 420 Md. 391, 23 A.3d 223 (2011), we now address whether the statutory provision criminalizing the unlawful possession of a regulated firearm by a convicted felon has a related penalty provision.

Petitioner, Troy A. Jones, Jr., seeks to overturn his conviction on Count Five of a criminal information filed against him which charged him with the unlawful possession of a regulated firearm after having been convicted of a felony, pursuant to Section 5-133(b) of the Public Safety Article, Maryland Code (2003),1 asserting that Section 5-133(b) does not contain a [440] penalty provision and that the penalty provisions in Sections 5-133(c) and 5-143 of the Public Safety Article do not apply.2 [441] He also asserts, alternatively, that an out-of-state conviction cannot serve as a predicate conviction for a violation of Section 5—133(b) and that the trial judge erred in imposing a mandatory minimum five-year sentence for the violation. The Court of Special Appeals affirmed Jones’s conviction and sentence for Count Five,3 45and we granted certiorari, Jones v. State, 416 Md. 272, 6 A.3d 904 (2010), to answer the following questions:

1. Is there a penalty provision applicable to a violation of Public Safety Article § 5—133(b), and if not, is a violation of that subsection a crime and does a court have jurisdiction over the charge?
2. Can a prior out-of-state conviction serve as the predicate conviction where the State has charged a defendant with possessing a regulated firearm after having been convicted of “a violation classified as a felony in the State” in violation of Public Safety Article § 5—133(b)?
3. Having found that the trial court erred in imposing the mandatory-minimum, five-year, no-parole penalty applicable to violations of § 5-133(c) for a violation of § 5—133(b), did the Court of Special Appeals err by only striking the no-parole condition and failing to vacate the sentence and remand the case for a new sentencing so that the judge could consider imposing a sentence of less than five years?

We shall hold that Section 5-143 of the Public Safety Article serves as the penalty provision for a violation of Section 5-[442]*442133(b) of that Article. We shall further hold that an out-of-state conviction can serve as a predicate conviction for the purposes of Section 5-133(b). Finally, although we affirm the conviction, we shall hold that the trial judge erred in imposing a mandatory five-year sentence for a violation of Section 5-133(b) and shall remand for a new sentencing.

Jones was charged in a criminal information in Case # 207270027 with two drug crimes.4 He also was accused in another criminal information in Case #207270028 with five firearm-related crimes, one of which was Count Five, involving his possession, as a felon, of a handgun.5 Jones and the State agreed to proceed on an Agreed Statement of Facts as to [443] Count Two, in which he was charged with illegal possession of marijuana in Case # 207270027; Count Four, in which he was charged with illegal possession of a regulated firearm having been convicted of a crime of violence in Case #207270028; and Count Five, the charge with which we are concerned, from Case #207270028, in which the information alleged that: “[Troy A. Jones, Jr.] unlawfully did possess a regulated firearm, to wit: A .25 caliber Lorcin handgun-serial # LT043282 after having been convicted of a disqualifying crime, to wit: 2003-Fairfax County, VA-case # 102485 a violation classified as a felony in this State, in violation of Public Safety Article, Section 5-133(b) of the Annotated Code of Maryland.”

The Agreed Statement of Facts reflected that Jones admitted he had purchased a handgun after having been convicted of manufacturing cocaine in the Commonwealth of Virginia:

[ASSISTANT STATE’S ATTORNEY]: Your Honor, on July 30, 2007, at approximately 0630 hours in the morning, the Warrant Apprehension Task Force responded to 4200 Eldone Road in Baltimore City, State of Maryland, looking for a wanted person. On arrival, Detective D. Koenigberg, from the Baltimore County Police Department, and other members of the Warrant Apprehension Task—Task Force, knocked on the door and was met by a black female. Detective Koenigberg said that the police were looking for a wanted person and was invited in by the female.
In the back bedroom of the residence, Detective Koenigberg made contact with a black male, later identified as Defendant, Troy A. Smith, Jr. [Troy A. Jones, Jr.][6] Detective Koenigberg looked under the bed (indiscernible) a wanted subject and there was a magazine for a firearm. Mr. Smith [Jones] was in the bed—was in the bed—Mr. Smith [Jones] was in the bed of the room with no clothes. Mr. Smith [Jones] attempted to put his shorts on when Detective [444] Koenigberg observed a bulge in the right front pocket of his shorts.
Detective Koenigberg grabbed the bulge with his hand and immediately knew it was a gun. Mr. Smith [Jones] stated to Detective Koenigberg that, somebody must have put the gun in my shorts while I slept. Also in the right front pocket of his shorts was a Maryland identification card with a picture of the Defendant and the information of Troy A. Smith [Jones], with a date of birth of 9-13-1982. In the left front pocket of those same shorts, was a plastic sandwich baggie, with 10 smaller zip-loc—zip-loc (indiscernible) red devil baggies, containing a greenish, brown vegetable matter, suspect marijuana.
Mr. Smith [Jones] was placed under arrest and transported to the Warrant Apprehension Task Force Office. The gun was described as a .25 caliber, Lucerne handgun, with a serial number of LT043202. The handgun is considered a regulated firearm in the State of Maryland.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Jones v. State, 23 A.3d 880, 420 Md. 437, 2011 Md. LEXIS 432 (Md. 2011).

23 A.3d 880 (Jones v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Howling v. State Abongnelah v. State
274 A.3d 1124 (Court of Appeals of Maryland, 2022)
Hamilton v. Pallozzi
165 F. Supp. 3d 315 (D. Maryland, 2016)
State of Tennessee v. Anthony R. Smith, Jr.
495 S.W.3d 271 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Tennessee, 2016)
State v. Stewart Le Richardson
Court of Appeals of Texas, 2014
State v. Richardson
439 S.W.3d 403 (Court of Appeals of Texas, 2014)
McCloud v. Department of State Police
44 A.3d 993 (Court of Appeals of Maryland, 2012)
McCloud v. Department of State Police
28 A.3d 214 (Court of Special Appeals of Maryland, 2011)
Jefferson v. State
26 A.3d 352 (Court of Appeals of Maryland, 2011)
Davis v. State
24 A.3d 113 (Court of Appeals of Maryland, 2011)