Johnson v. Western Union Telegraph Co.

79 Miss. 58
Mississippi Supreme Court·Decided March 15, 1901·Published·Cited by 8 cases

Opinion

Terral, J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

E. M. Quigley & Co., of St. Louis, on July 27, 1898, sent to appellant the following telegram: “ E. A. Johnson, More-head, Miss.: We have million yards, pay both ways; work [61] Georgiana, Ala. Do you want any ? Hancock will be Georgi-ana after Thursday. Speak quick. R. M. Quigley & Co.” The declaration for damages by Johnson alleges that he wanted work, had worked before with Quigley & Co., and would, if he had received the telegram, have gone to Georgiana, where Quigley & Co. had a large contract for the construction of a railroad,’and that he would have entered into a contract for the doing of a part of said work, and would have made a large sum of money upon said contract.

We think the damages here sued for are too remote to be recovered. If the telegram had been received, it only gave appellant an opportunity for making a contract for railroad work, which he might have made or might not have made; and, if he had made a contract for work, what he should have made thereon would have been subject to several contingencies. In other words, the damages here claimed are not the direct result of the breach of duty complained of. They do not naturally, or necessarily or probably, arise from the wrong done; and, because the damages claimed are remote and uncertain, the appellant may not recover. Railroad Co. v. Ragsdale, 46 Miss., 458; 1 Suth. on Damages, sec. 15; Telegraph Co. v. Hall, 124 U. S., 444 (s.c. 8 Sup. Ct., 577; 31 L. Ed., 479).

Affirmed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Johnson v. Western Union Telegraph Co., 79 Miss. 58 (Mich. 1901).

79 Miss. 58 (Johnson v. Western Union Telegraph Co.) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Dowling v. Western Union Tel. Co.
92 F.2d 864 (First Circuit, 1937)
Davenport v. Western Union Tel. Co.
9 P.2d 172 (Montana Supreme Court, 1932)
Munson S. S. Line v. Horace Turner & Co.
81 So. 76 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1919)
McQuilkin v. Postal Telegraph Cable Co.
151 P. 21 (California Court of Appeal, 1915)
Postal Telegraph Co. v. Criscoe
64 So. 933 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1914)
Postal Telegraph & Cable Co. v. Crook
63 So. 350 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1913)
Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Adams Machine Co.
47 So. 412 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1908)
Mills v. Western Union Telegraph Co.
51 S.E. 290 (Supreme Court of Georgia, 1905)