~~~ E~t ~0tR50A ~ J:-\\l T"HE:
FILED IN
15th COURT Of APPEALS
AUSTIN. TEXAS
,4p~ElI""t, ____ _ j_ 1s-y~ _t{X/2\it Qr ~ov to 2025 CHRISTOPHER A PRINE
Cl.£AK
' \
~•tft1E Of Tt'l~/ & . Al, ·- ~ l 5 - _) 5-OO\ ~~_:- ~ V__ _ _
~_ __ _ _P _r _ ~l)E€5 __ ----'-
~- - - - - - ---
\
Pea""" T'ne 9&~'-' D,stR{ii- touR+ ·-r@'tY,"l ~ v , : ~ 1- __
- ------
·T~'J<As 1 - CAvsE
~
ND. '.b ·-\ - ~N - d-5 - DD \C\ffi_ _ ---
_j
/fohV\ _Ei<lt -~ ~~ 1c_!.~__t~~ S.-:6==---- - - - - ______ ~CPC\ 5 f (Y\. '35l4
-~. __8c;flu.v_-nfh'\·\- , .T£'1<f'I-S "\~1tDS"
- ------
l
' '
\ . IDEN.I.ltl.f~ Df:.'tl'I_R'!Jt';;) __ ...... - . . • · .. ····· .~ tov"' ⇒s1,.., ....
.. riohl' tRlt. AAdfl<Slx1 ?ilt>l:\~ fen 3 fi\Ll .... ~Ef:\0.~.o".':t, .Ii;,'l'~'$.. 'l~ 1 D'S
. ~~~_fu:1but±, .T~~~Gu>2~Y.\P~1.f"\f1·~- ~ . si;:-'€\?g\ ...
- - · - - - __ _y'.i'A:J1(.-S. Qffitit,L .OEf.\Ci;:.! :I~1~ ~~C\C,I(~ . Qffi c:«=. _ _ _ _ _....,re.,.,.D"'-'-,~Q.1~L~1:{}:o.. 8v~±in1.I~~ '11'~J\ :.::l:~}9;
ec:h\)<r kumpian, f.:tctv-1iue- 't,geelo~/ I".\~ Be- ~ieval ... V.1.A.. hi-:i. Dft3r:,\~\ Otf\c(: ~Ttit-5 . . tEp~f'<'.'e:J Df _ __,l."~;'mu\1rlrf"'s+;c;.e-~,C, 6Q1 °{\ 'r\0~':S\.J"i.J\e: '\1:ct:A-s ti~'3ll~i
5 BDt .. "-lD,. J Lt l l!L!IY2tL ._ -·········~·· ............ .
-~···-- ······~········· lliSiSfr'M'--t ftttD(!Y'l:y ~t.N~e~........ .
Bo,Brn; \ ';}SL-IB, CQ,\>\\er\ 5-\-'ff\-Joy,, ----·~ tlu~b ·,E1<AS 18.'l \\ - _;}5 ':\ 12;,.__ ···········
. UIL/-;\,\:5 Df- p ~ tMcA ~O~(~\Si;\ ''
.. \ I .
. '[fl10\ic' PF- tpi,-trfh ·;t:~f( o\:=- f\v.~~;+:e>
. S•tfr'lEM«?vJ D F-Ths ~/\~E Stwtr""ei4- .Re~,~ 01'<A\ A!?.,Q1.-1mEJ-
. :t:-ss.ues - "' -.-- ... ,.",," t>i2E~t<l-r-J .. .. ,,, ..
.-- -,, . . ., , - ' _ ' ' - . '•() ,•·
~W'El\-t" Qr R,c;:5 .
'SlA'M l"\l\f. y Op A {4:tu ME~t --- - - ·- .... ·-. -- -- - jj~IJ_fXl~Y.. t . p~~C:R
t
- - ____ JV -····-·-······--·-··-····
_ :J]\~Oa. a~ flvI\\adttE:$ .
~-Af£~;
:rv-. 11ue~r('.\Jn'MS- svt,; \-.P13SI?> S,w.~ 455 lTEJ,.~on) .... l~
'bl/\M ;t:NI)~{), 'Sc\,,., vs. '1l1AG, 34 s~~ S41:7 (Tt:11, J9co) ... \l) ChE~/\E TV\chistR,ES, I\\tl'. V.1. M~11.\lftrtt$, 'lt,,3 '::>1-'l ad 11.IPS
bEVH\i1;:1c_ v~. Te~AS, loO\ .IJ-,S, 'J.t"pS- ()b~l\J, , . , &.. ,,3 ttu V\t V';), \7:>ft"i>S LJ>1£;tl '),w,')J ~-;).?:, /;rOl \ct £1,lu . . . l 'h l..
f)\/1-gst-1 U\'\iM ~"~s, T~. ~i Ced(.,, '3'51.\ "')w.qd '1Le.L\
(lc.ll-' JDlij ' . . ' . . ' . '· l l I ' l \ \ I , ., • ' ' • I \ t.\ RH, \}':), ")0, ~¼ 3 ~9 S.L,LJ, ~J . "\ Sic, . (TE"t., A-rfl· DA\ \f\-S )O\'J , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , d--D ':) Lftv8\ttEie - 1-\w~c- C-A':£5, f;'3 L\,S, '3!R [\'21J-.) .. ,, lb,lll SL,\b~u b\:- AM, Vs. ~-J ~ bJ ~,,~s/\"'11:i\l., 9l\ SµJ, "3d .;)1)- T"ci, )OD)..'. l , • l •• I., 15.
. f6J\£RN\. tcde 4} U':)t ~ \Clf33 t,v\\ ~cto,,t .FPR de~R;~fihbi\ or
.V
~ l1 Tm<~ ft(( pJol1c L-lSE ~ ~rtccY-r\ p~hA\~c:S . M"-J f r\'.\y\'\Lll'l.11:1::Sj ('t;,d«v\ br': pi{; ,J,\~e:-s ~l F!'l-/lW'½I'>~. , . , .
':)TfTTU"tES ·-rn. tcde oc Ct-'.; rn; "M 9J20tavu/2c:. ~. \ ID~ r?olfl;\c,,1/£ ~ ~u\8"1!M wi-\\A I?~+ b~ ~€:1\M\'. l t \ t I t_t ,t ___ r t I l f, fl _I\ I_\ l' l I l ~ l 1 '- ,I l Ir•,; 11.. TE~ .. l:om, ~ \~S, Cc6E ),')o{o. , .. , ,.. , , , , , , , to
---- -- -- ___ Tt:·i;. t:iv1 I r~Att,rr lt 1Q(YlEc\l[~
·A'l2.t, \4,D04 Aff,~Ni'f t?cl~_-b {2Rfi-;1C1.AU.il11$S' • '1~~.
I IL'--_\_
_______M , (:)L2'l__c~~\dis_"J_)~,f,.,\,:~ f'"-°' ~£(('.~Ai'~-i~i:!,,trr\___ ----··--
Vi,
"fE:'1-, C:roo, Cc:dc. ~ 5\\,'l))\ ecrnmo(\ .AN! 'TfciAn1'cM L,\~e OF ~ s
~ ·31 \ , D::,\ Sr-,u; '',C4S 'PRoui<_, ~ottS " , , , , , ~:)... ~ 5D~. \43 Lf:Afll l'u~~q, , , , . , , 15, lll . 3 s-~. 149 ·rl'rN'l'ti:S :r:v-1:\\j~;b\c .~. rv».J8-~)' sv<,.'f?~-Yrs_i_~)'.\.. -• , , l , , , , , __ , l_ , .. , , , _, ··-"- .. _ , . , , __ , ~;;;...
~ 'SD<t,, )~3 ':>f'\rCTll)l'\S, , , , , , , , , , , ii, d-d-
TE11\'S c.Jc:-s Df t_ 1<;ii\ P<?Ceedut2c=: . Rule d9/c, Y<e~ts+ f,::,1< t,\,',ts Or fnc:l-$ f\"-d, to,xJ-tS'4'\'-S .. ., of, 1-.~ _, , _, . , _, _{ , , -~ ,_ -~ , , _ ,._ ,_. ,._ ,_. -~- ,. , . . d-_p__ .
(<u\E dql) 'T~=c To .l_e"'d r\\l\'\f\S o'f- f~1'c\'i"$4S p~ f:t\ct f\V'o eor-c,)l)..s~s p~ 1--·*W- •... , ' ' , ' ' ;}o
Vii
_ _ _ .. ·- .:Ibt_.Cnn1fru£f:'.5.~ _;:0_'ibLs ce:~ i'.':LtJi;gy 1t1?f\\f<\J-
fqCZ1A.Y~ 1 ~pI\~~ j,:flS ~J ~E -$T<'TTE O'f-
_ _ _ _ _77_,_,E=-'f.;,_,,_fl'--'-S fQ« e ~,~_c_Vl@...c~-\_\~\,A,""' ~--· On :CNJ)i:::te.$f- tQr,t ()f:'(l'\NNfio~_f\,S_ ~l)R~~rJ 'pt?
_____·_._±re-'-=-·I.E'l!i!.~.to'"'~t M. l ~ l'l!.J2~ ('\d<fY?,~Stov\S, %E ....... . _ _ _ _ _'S=w-'-'-'---'tF"'--_,t>e:::.·f Te'f(A-S ·t-co\l -\.1\.t E¼oE\)f\"t'\tz, ~<?opf~~/-a~L -····-· ..... .
_ _ ___1..iT.,_..1.cJJ,A:!1.!\WlSI /r 15 e~w.:Ji j'Q__QQ_j~¼7.. h~'..:~lr..\..f1S
______ houxt,)cg_~r1~'Qg.L::\l:l.J)IEe.t .~.Q0ft::n-s@q'.,\. fc£.·:\nt:'
·:rA\<; I"~- · - -·--· . .
....... ~ CV\p-\117!\ \::,~ :½:-f Jrf~o"~~ 'Tt>IIIS 1 ~ C\ $-\-h -·- .... . .. ...OL-:;,¼,4 C!XJR! hfts VS?Pni\)i~(:d -\-\1 ~ plAi~Fr fRCXt\ r~Qt@ ,-1'~ on f'I \ fl}'i· Y',9.":> C\ r\ i' rv\ \>LAI<$~~+ +n •_ _ _ _ _ l a ,__ f_nr-._~t .fus±-.L~ 1~ 1 b1 . lJfRDfr\\y_ . .CQ'.'1Ji:,'3! • "~-. ~f C,\ir\® ·to (-\- ·I~f/\:, ·To~:t C\ " \)V~SU,tl'.
..... -fl.1.M .,J-..........
.\u .
,--------fhE_ +Rll1L~ru¥Z1 &/\~Ed. ·+he plA\JiFr h,"$. ~°"st.t'u.1-lQf(._~ . _ _ _ _ _f?.=l, ,.p\J-=, \-:o \211.o~ud_.wJ-lli_\c'i5_l'on2b:k~. i~1:1~ ct~Lm,....L"'-_ Dppo~;+; Dt-l OF "J.he:- \J.b, '.S1-<tp ~~I;: t@V<-~$ J<fCeflt dlE~ 1si D¥'\ . \(\ be Vi\ He-iz Vs, ·rei<t:\'S L:Q, ~·- Jf:t5, _ J9 3 (do·dt.t), fu,~f 4-hE twff J1s1ni•:{2l·d a~---- c\AlM.'J I.AJ'v~'\. ?i?S \lAd; t£, The 0ppt:\)A-1-,.T lvt-, t.o6}~1\l).~½'---
----~05Se{i~~ '-t~ hE AA:, not' 1+-\-re«ip~~~k_L;\E.J:L. ~-----_,_~=e-"''ff\.,_,,,____,T-""-'oQ\ t.\ A-i W\, ()~ e , A~1-~-:-.~s__C1"'1tM_~tA~su.M-'t ~---+~o 'Ti;:Y, ~i:;vl:&± fhdtL~_IJ __
Arfi:-~\fm.1'.'> t\~Y'l\ Ms beer\ pro~E~\y fi~SEictec\ ~flt1'-ck ___ __ _ _ 'Le'!:1'~, y_;ft__f,rtvtlDl"-/-:sERvi lE DI'\. ~E: &0ve-~-00~ . ~ ____ ..
+ne- Ett;:CLA+~vr: b1fc('+l:)a_ or. 'tf.lt:1'. ~ ~~'t-lDl'-,1
_ _ _ _ _O=o=ith~O£F~ ~~g.$_hFtu e 'hcc.-i __()f?Qv1dt:ci 00\-iet:;__ Q£__·i½E __ _
... ___________ --~fIA\\ I,(- e',( c l'LA·\y._J . __ j u.d$~t£-11-t_J"}J,.1.1t~\2-\.~_. ~½!"'-_e-<::> 1 _Eh\J ____ . __ oy29-c;gi::t,.i.niTI?_ :n> . D.A€,1;c,__f\r12\J~~-~, :0~-\-.tvfft:\'\1-~~ twF, nEd ~().l?'S!A®+ .'k. . 0- \~_IAJ\)~ _. ~'i(~Ctlr~l'.'$4..~vdi_c,i~ ___ _ . l)Ro0a.Jq\CE<"'enl1 ~.\- _ rn \AncictJ.,\fr'\t"'Y e1etuf1 vE f,e,'t\oV\,Tk \2Etr;,fil ~mfi>Rrv-s Of ~bTk:E o~ B \)_f~l')y\
.FEE,
/"-------~---<;~u_~fdT of- ·The ~Tf1TC~ (('Efc~')fil b c.ornp~y <.>-)1-th ..... ~----- . 't~ trer""<:> . Dt= }t"', Q<.AJn -~t>J~~enT,
. .. (tppe)l1JYct- wA; \Jtc":> oeRl f\<?'('4iAfY)e:: l'l,:t l,A(\\c:,s. ~@~ ·to ...\k A()pc llff'.'.:> •
. . . _. _. J:SSl) E?~ _ '\J~ t: ) Ente:l GfQJl'\O ONE : t cu.et V, o\Amd ton:sh 1l-11'\Dr\k\ g~kl- +o f\<S5ER+ _ _ _ _ ____,_A-_,____17_,__,-~_,._,.ill,Ql5_f_lALl'.".\1Jn . oppQ::i'i.'bDV\ +o..... . ~---~L\u.....-,::>..___s_u9Rf:cnE t_ru_,g:_r __~~-C~DccT:.
bROtA~ T u)O~ f<cG-t '.lttl ·+b f;~e f~v-di'l';lS OF Rie!l-S A~ tcx-du~w)\s DF. hfuµ .1s ~rW0\fµ.\ j\-S /+.. m,Jrh:R . Df= L,i\w
. GJ'.ou 1"-ol ·111f:££
Cwft VlplMr:·-d to(\-skh\+,~"A\ R1?t,it- ~\l REfu~,"'~ t-o hef\1( Mv+.'D1, ~oR S,\ mm A Rt{ ;:.fvJ~ync:<t,-\-
NO w:dc::f\LE.
- ~ _·-----·-·· -__ --- .S:JJj_j Effil;:,[1,,! 0 F FAtT-S .
A. E~tc0te o~ l?L£A-l>, ~s . - .. ' ·•· .·. ' . . . ., ,, .. ' .JL)!QII
l I P\tn1'hrf wf\5 tDl"\Jk"rc.\ or C5) feJon1n I I'\ c<AVst: Nvmbe.'26 f ~-A\ '3 5'1-1~} f 2?4-<\3'5q9-ci ~/ F8'9-'i~5lll?· Git:./ ric1-°t~59'1/ex(.2, / r-'91- ~lo~!..\? -S\< ; " fhE )-4> 'S ..-It ~,;hi; e-1- ~ O(,A<2·\ ~v\)/l-s 'leiAS , -,_ \)foc«1'1::e.. DP 19 ~L ~I 1hl\tl F-F wAs 5tr'1'e:V'tt:d ¼ "3 5 ~cfl~.,, l'oot.(\i:W\ei.+ 1'1-\. +he ·rt)dJ\<, btpA-RtWtei~ Of l'ti(Y\1,,JI.(
Av\Stlt'E (tDc::r)lt)CP. ~,'1);
5
). ?lttJ,-:\-:ff _S1:,Rt-<:d ~v¼ t1:RY".' "r cCV\fu=c:.d-- fRl:Y<\ ___ httt::f'll-Y-1£~ D.F _\Cl.ffi, tJ? Ptttmvii;:12, a'}: de@. \\-.1{~1t/\l\.~1r __
5. _()\/\~'fF, '.Sr&J- tL\ yefl.«-S ~- r!pp~olJl'>A!'-ttl'{ .
:ii (Y'c,,,,t\,-,-;; t:>V'- .. r0-~/Xtcey 5t,<()E~u1~L(),1. fel)(V\.
__ ~i~C:.V"""'\:Je'R. J.oOLt -\-p A~Lt.~:;t QF ~P\B 012 U>t9 1.:>\'\
l'Y1fudfl--~l?y 5upcgv\3o"' , ftL, fl- \'Y\l"--'1'\-ER of hfu.v, P1 ~l\'.t\Ff- ~ rc,vt eo,l, {T(\_J. ElJi:f?.y'dA-t,i 00 i:nAY\C-l~~v, '
_ :SupceOl.~'\:J,~ 1vt "thE C.t-~:;,k~c;, u? "¾"'°'e ~TATE,
- - -- - __ (TDc-:1__c1t:>/(3Pp)(~IEJ,,t,Du,l'~-~5D?>,\Ll'3
Lf-G-f\\.- tuSfo'D¼7) (t:il~R ~~·~>
_Ll, ... ~l~J-;n=, \,/,c,\kl ~IS ~/\R!!_ti=,_)\- B\uE \,\,){\~ v-.J.A:;' iSSLtcd \.,_ dDlt, CR ',}olct. "Yhe ritL-1E w~~ °tEIUY\.1{lJal
+l,f Dcp/\li~e.1ils Supi?~uk,;-vYt. 1 1w-J t\-tc:Rt:Ftl1.!; f\5 t-l,\~k~-
l)til»J-ltF WM J cil= 'TE'll\:') el,l.-,hly \1-Dte App~i; mAltr lY) bry'.:) Q)t\2 r?'\· ,D);
5, Plf\~~ff 1 :SEi?txj -l\-ie C<.EvYlA\l'ctcR of ""'"'-5 -sm1tl\e~
bn ~E TDU R\Lhl'tl?d U--\slfu\t Lly\.\+ {h1.d Dfu~
VAf?-~DL.t::> Ff\c'it~t~f:?S of ,Dc.:r, r\A~ffs ~entf'l"-<!.E u.>11s
f u.\..ly E"l4ECLl11:-J ~~ \)e::t2M\)E-R )l\ -~ tF JDJ-t.t, lfe\
0
~\A-i.J\TT- ~)'Y\A iKS IK- tuNy 0~ 1\)t.:r, ~e R p~1D)
lP. ~\m\J.'f\=-1 \MY-o~ME2) ·,\Jt:r Dv ~ f..J\'11 E1x.~ -Str¾E"'-~E ·\n r-c f1V"'1 L GR~Ar-. tc\\'it"R . ~ S~lii\-i\Je \\ i ~&uf<_ tAJflS p(<01.)\J.a\ (lei'\. Orf-E.R ~ \I\ Com~RDr:i SE
W,.,.,,;J~Ct )-'Jo/.p/ TE'!S., torn, ~(v~ todc ).)ct:,) to m':,ufe ,S-n=r-r1= 1-.fli..v 1, eo~\1!:'A \,U~Ji.\.,.\ ,~t.:s-, fr I'\
1
!'\D eo5-t ophoo k RctEft$ 1 o«- -\o tanpms~ ·\¼E ~\t\\1vt\t'F .
:\t~DW pet< i':ifrlf f?om bElfM\,£1~ ;J'5,·6oJ'-l +v
. tu (<)~EY\.,+ 4A'~c, [t> t \< ~9-.· '.\- \3)~
~. (bl' Qefl-A")°ir',S:{ b ~~~ JyYIE 1.~sue:: 1 OR EC\'rd'cE ~ . \ f\i.,0-, ·Te_ ''f.-ftS -~oLAp,'K- ,'ts f\ $4.en-\-s \'\rr~ . Ll.n\&vfuLl..y ..1f\\2'E\'\ ~ \)~Teow\ --~. r\A;'nt\ff::>
rl<qc(I.~ +¼?oL~ ·r\-lVtfSE tof\~mNAfl Dr\, ........ (1) c_ R f9\· \ 5)•1- ..... _ . . .
B. , e. 1.-1\ s hA--'5 rue t ,~\.._t? r\- fl~~ 9, A1 ,Mrf1s 'f(260,00'\, ftD'i \\+L? tD E.f'rl<'<l A \ \ tii'l"fa 1 0nd rn Pri:i£ hi rn f\ vM&
oF ·~c ~-\-f\"'tc fDR ·..l..Jne ru_epo':£::" oF mR'1n~1'f\lO,.G
,ocr ~ ray.>u.\#;vl'\ tou-.nT. ,~tr) +w: ~,~E bt° ~E'/,t\~ 1 f\l'+~ Vf\\J ¾Jo'K 1 ~ -¼~E~ P\~\ cd\'rf~
rfo\-'c~\7 fb« (-)u~\\c LA<f, (bt(< ~(,?\, \5) N,ow ¼E ,Si-f"ic rnu '5\- C'Df\'\()~IT':)t\7E p\tA,'h'.t~ \"-:::f . ftiJ. n,s pQ~ty;
L 'j!>di\ (';f)\_ ~lltlces F'i\\w I ;:fJ1' \ ;\- ;;)D;) 'SI A~d
rfw\tr JC\, ';}D}5 (~t\< p~, \l,F\ 1\°l·d-, J_\L\, )')OJ;
'}, \)d\-R\ct ~ruio1 IZEtto\ tlnc1 ·-red< No+~ec.
(R~ pp,1 \',n.E: \D·-~'3 \·,.-e:\b,)
1nr: ·tR10A Coi>~ ER{<ortEDL{ ~ly Re6\~rFte-J 't)\E p\A~l'Lt1ff:S r·Ro?Ei)y f1\Ed tc'J<'., tu!\#: f.t-J. \ ~ \~ 'rA \( lr\G\.S Q\A1VV\ \j;A ·r~V2£1£- ~DNtEN\~A'flb"l, £\5 {\ TE'i&~ ·,o<2T plA«StA.An7 ·.-\o "\£i, t~v,\ ·<?e.j\t, [
~c:rn1c\'ie::> [\-Rt \0 i, 5 'l. · r ( \ rn_t~SUR.l~ -t'0E \)EtE'l'OAvct-\ p\cfl -6 ¼E ,_lu(Q; S'd,c:.\t\Dl'\ 1 ¼e tDu~t
ERf>Dt'\£Dl,\~Y RLA\a! \ l'l 4-YtE ~UE~1t1~:S ffk>oR. 1,01\+-cu-.\- \ ttwfiJ StA~r~( pRou ~ch13 +YlE dif8\clA-ivt . An unde:~Et<ua::l w:·i\, And dE0~~f\,',\ ¼E ~\A~ittlrF t>f h'i-s R;~\J to ~t11t\ol'\ 'fol2. ~1:decss oF tsR~EVftv\.~e Crc-t, toV\.Sl: ~ ' \ ~ d1).
,tD f="~\e ft ~,«A\~ OF fftc\s; flvJ tov\.c,-\i,1.~~ 6F
kA-t-v- Je::sp l ·k pRoc;:>cR eEqf-,\E,s-+, 0-0c\ JE~?i--\-E ·-Yne ft)0: ¼A~ %F dEtEi\clft1<t ~eE<;cntcc\ ~ ~\ffirV\S f6~ A d\smis<::,M, ; vt ~~(2. ~\er1 -to ·-\ne AlA.«;J;;Jio,,.
tt()p\ I (',~vi -/½,Sl)X)'\t.S t\\Wt ~I:: 01'\.h; REflSO\"I -th£ ·¼ ,tr\ tol)et A~A\'\tcc\ ~e f:>\Eft ·+o +nc c\Lt'l(~c\i1A~ol'\ W fT"S -+\.E t DU Rt3 t..R RO~EO.>'S ~cl lJ S1 D (\ S Rt:.8f\{<(1\np f\ 'TE-'fo-f\") 1DRT bc-~n~ Re\'1ed U~O(\
H>R Au.R~ sd1c+~til'\,
10
'ihE ett} +o pttlt\cw, ~Df? iQii:\f'E-;:,5 0~ [4f<.LE.\lf\-1'.C.E hAs btt~ h1=lc\ ·\-D be A- ~~o~~ (< ,?\\J-. ~\)DR h11-s \o"B . ~Ef;r\. Co1'l":>1cicRtd p~ope¢_ty>, S\~r'h-lr-E~- \-\olASE Cf)SE:5, <33 U,S.3&, ·3e (\'d'l)). ·,\.E beTT:rdA,.1-:,
~f)oi \ 01Dl\ D'\=- ~\ /\'i,JYft:J:, R\~\J-s docs 00-\- de!'YJ\ 0·i ~t\ th.e \ff\'\µ~ oF .\'\is Q«cQcl<frq.
{I)
8RG-LA"1En+
A-. Gfouy\~ ONE:: C.ou.e+- VI b\kd 0orYst'; \-1,\ttD}'\.t\-\ ((1?'1¼,+ -~ (\S:£0 A TA K' 11",Q s C\ />11 M 1 , '1\ D?? vs ·i·t\ D1"- ·¾:, \).,~, SlA)~~)'Vle 0ou..'Rir ~2:t.t:d1=rtt:
-r...+ ,s lt--,<1&MMic ·-\-\\J ·1\-;xt.ld.,Qtc (Y'\~E dec~510·/\S _ tx}~t:d __ (?.f\_r1E-Kh .~ r£fbi(E --\k_tOI_Ae:t 'I_n -~t:: CASE 0 f ..P. p\EB ·-\o '-\11£ c\lAR~~1<.:\-'i 6\1\. 1 \-\-- 1-S t:..ut: f\ 'fY\ DRE
1('{l(y(.~f\,J-- +o n:,~\iu...-='f?E ¾ ·+he p\erJ;,~ dL>-e ·to -+he. ~l)f1-za.\ \ lM1-\-ed -S tD~E: D~ ~c v\ eL-V, ·Tne f1-dl W£1?wt of= Ev~dey\CE \ ":, not hefo~c ·~ \,_e Cot.Aet. 8\ftncti ·tNci1::p, ~e-'lA. ti; st, v~, Glu-E; ...... ·34 <SJv, '3d 5L\'1, 5·54 ( Te'1, _JDoo), '"'fhtk chc' I\D+ ~pcY\ 1.... ·+\.,s e·A'SE,
~~c, ·--\111:: ciE:ft::f\~t§ ~\ \i:d f\ 61 \M-0'2 ½1 p\et,- -\-o ·-\-\-\E c\uRi'6ci)c+-10"' eorn'y\A{ n,~ o~·+\,E ~')x{\lE ~c\Nh:-c\ ·\-o ·,i:::-'l6, to(\":Jt ftRT. \ ~ \"°\, ot=- c\1.,1,R,sct, et,~\'\. 4 } us t ~ , q '2i <3 ; TE-')(., liov. ccdcs>s D~ .:;/2/3 , ·-rt:)(, Cede- L'f!.lrn., PRol, M, \ \ ,D't I r\Y\c1' 000 -
tomr-,\1flnCE w\\\A ·,s"i., C\V\ \ f?f\t. fi' \<cm,
th, \4,0D4:, The plf\~rJ~Ff~ pR1mfh2.y tlMwt t.u f) ~ h ,0,:1 or R ·,A~''>4 \) I..? :r:Nvt-rZse ~ ComlE1Y\ t'-..k'~ t"oK, w~tx:l 2£d tiq '\e~, ton,_/,.
Ad I ~ lt .
l)(t~ l"I\:~\~/ +n, s ~f\<;E L-vt\S c-\1 $me '$~Ed btr ~\\-\E CDLAIZT t\f\v1r';4 f°DiA«l ~D AlAt<~~ch\L'\~D1'\. fD(2.. q\-
1l
12
1Dll:S 'IPRI Ctfn\V\ ·rtPR fu± \_DI.S~. Now\\Ei'<.~ .\\'\ . . ·m ~lA1'JiFF:S ~c:1-\'t)ul'l 1s ·-rhBeA ty\CJ1DY\ of /'r . T'fit\-S 'TO R:T l: \1\ ,'w\ tJ ¥\GAE~ TC. PR f\~t. \0 \ , 5 h, /· D(<, .
\C>\,58, \¥\E tDu~"t t(\EJ ~\\.t f)t~0~E oF
c-\L-\f:1-SChd-1~ v:Jc:\«\c:d. 1o ·T'tfl\2. ~t \Dl .. ':i 1 fi-s . . \<Ef\1>(.,)n Vo\l< cl1srn1sl::,tY\( ~f, ~' 9-le,. \~ nc ~ \ \ 4\tk, JD), ·,1ne-. couRl- de:1:,1Ec~ p\f),J,ff= l"\1<;, g~-h:, ~~@l w\·-\h M Aw~\ 2.eol to\'\sbhAh\x\~ C~A\i=:1\!;le:, 'Th£. 'TEY.A-s ~)0f.'c<nE tourt, 'hfl-5 pREv1ov~\t? ,de-,J-,t;i:c~. +'nfi\-- A ~1xhdt\l\ J1::r1~1br- ,-s f'I ~eo~ R1~\-:t, . 5tAff,c1t::vd- io mfi\ntftll" 5,~v0~(\.~ , r\v )'(+ V:), 6f½>S I Lo t.i, 4 'S ).A), JJ '3')'31 ''3 d L\ (,c'f- \C\BL\) .
.P\ f\ \' ~ \:"f ,; pct tFi c- M\¼1 l'<t:: fu+Ed ·~ C\ 'c\ Ra.A 'i\d s - ~ - - - ~ ~ ~1;11__ J~½1 ~Efer<l·~~ e,l;{J 'tp_j~ c\lARi'::Ok1ffivl. .. -~···-····· . .. l:b CR ~,\ c>5 - ,3·d-), ~\:l\,J\'Ft c\trd rnl-\\\-\ p\e --·-··-· ... .:C:t'-\V~_--CONQ(:/{/j\\7\'1:'l_t,1\J_ ~IA-1.1\1.\S Mh'ib.\,LW_ ,11),. ~.E:. •··•· deFtvJ~ #Lt eR ~$\• \)ii?, l )C\, , Yo), . .
_____ :::r\'\ il:ckti1QJ/\-,-~\A,'&tiff y::\i;:J A- lV\ot;'v"'. 4_o T!\:Kt:=: •• --- - --
.... '.J<i-d.,·<!~t .N.o±i"rr (t.eR . Pf4,1'13,IlLl,J'15,J1.lcd_'l'3,\£>.3 1•
(qDJ, Th,":>. ()10\-~01" {=-o'/2. 3~c\M Not~e:- WI'<"'> Of-ff~Fct,
t:b,J __ !\tfe1)td by 1:\1\1: +12,t)\ .ewi& (~R r~,<?i k", ·1-:J),J, _
MtA.\ -\i ()\E Asse-ie,+io"'s ~tM-)iA'2,sJtc}i'pt') (ZfsT 1,1.,pcn _ . . . 1€¥.. Cc,\'\>'t.i M~ J . ~ JJ.,. t::NVEfS:t::-:fonbENit-l.A1:_Pn.L-.. ------•----------•
- - - - :JbE_~__of_Ic.t.r\5 eE:tE<L+\~ .tooCFc\ft:Ji_ ,_'{\ _ -\-\-\F_____________ .__ U, :), Su\ol~mE . . tQ.Ag,t-1 ¼A AR.;+, t_~\'l pR(lv1dE_s _ __ (\y\ .1Ackv£11-J~t .Clsv-.se __ cf .trc-:bJJ:i:1 i~. St"'~--~g.t _____ ~----
------ ___ w¼E\'\. M 1-\\\~#l'Or\ pF J:\\vl=J-'$1:- C'Ql'()e"4.j\{A'~pl'\. ~ s
______,M~a1_,_(b_~_\Ll}.\kf:_ y_">,_STfi.T~ !:,f 'f~l<t\$1. . --- - ----
LoOt .U! ':), -~9.S, d_ci3 (--:; 0ef'-t), .')(.Ach AUE~-M-i'cv-_ ts '{)ieEseJ- f\T{t,t.'/2,, ()~--\.e,\k)_,______ __
·'f~y:11:5 __\--i\w__ hltS \p}\14 f!Etop.n,-z~ -\wV\- ~u.,\ll,
-/\{ ¼wp.l. i\\+&!\$'!~\le _1s pfof fRty , AV\d ,s 1m _ __________ J~l'fRJ~--pfWitcz'f--\-1'f:' b<,\.';,~\\.IS":>S,~5,,t~'? .. l15 ~\\~5\CJ_ ~ - - - - ' - ' ·~-d::,__ ME._J!t\fsh__., _Uv1jifJ . SJt\'h-s, I~t.. '1 ~. tcoK, __ 3 54 ~.w. 3d 1.\.Qll, "l \1 (,1::.-,: ~ l \),
~ l 'The 1<~k,+- io lAbo<s.1~~ g~~ht :to . Ort~'s_ ~E\f ~bt/Siclv 1~ 1
,-------~----~--~ ~-l'"tE\\e~+lAt\\1'{/t1"'-d:k+hf p~vd l ) f l)I\ES C,u.)I'\.
__ ______ __fa~1Jt1E~, i~_pMf_dwht f.>~pc;e-ty I Awl ~~fC~"Y o\= A :51ttre:l. !(,)\J, Ye+- '-\-G\"'> ?12<{ftly b de~cd by +\-\E _ _ _ 6~+; de-s¥oqed N& \:y. due pRo tES~ of \-r11.01 'o<A,t- bq l~-AtrlER.; ·ft- 0e~ or: pR., "' \1:~e o'f: '((\tMcpo\y j l.A-l\-cic1'
A·\,\t>l-0.'.'> $(.At,k R,,¼~ '"- 'th1:S '(Vl,'ittE~ +t> l\o .D'I\~ ~uJ· +o ft ~t\uoRi:J ,~ '5,€L>EY\.~Et=r-'.~ '$ LA-LA&H-TER- r\DU 5£, B3 Ll.~. 31'> /38 08'1 ).) .
~, L ::t:F -& 91k?A-w1 b\= )uiEYsdi'ct~Ot'\ o~ 12e\11::f fuA~~iz.J it' +\-t1c s--t¥i1Lttc ~1-ceed~ ·-\-'-'t \,-M'i·ts__ J?f fr
[J-e_t, to~s±, &t v] / E-'fl bv,/, t~~ ~ S:08. )1lf}-r\t£t\ .. ··-·-- ~~~E 'Si ""p\1,{ t:c.Y.ff..Rt,sc=. f\-":J l'.l"0cJ,Juie.i·"?d1c\--,011, oQc'«
i'hE tf'rsc fr5 +-he . toY'$+.+1A-\-16\'\ tr\ \ows, tl-5 w E d Id
II
lO.Vf:, .::r:~ 'Bf__ /\-~\t-ftt.C..\tn½) =>Vl., .J.,f', _ ;X'_--_ _
. .. 3SLP s,w!3d_Ll.551L\kia-(IE'f-, )p\\)'
"A V(<yk--d v:18\,t i's fl {)~~:\-y_Ri~~i, whi'cl,._ '-\1he: .
- ~ - -----'~ov\stlivdJDn penAc:~+s._Au~t 11 ¼: th'~\?.-®U.t?,1p\,~t. __ _ M1cld\Etol'\ Vs.1e1'1\S .9Qw~K f 1,,\~C.P,,lQ«o.1.e'h, I/
. 9te, \f35_:,~, 55"-' 1 56l)(TE)(, ~R-;\ J[p, \.9\\e) .
__ _ Sc\bf\~ of {\r-1\, VS, ~v·,c\ fV\L \)w;J. ~\-SSA1' 1
~N.t.,) BY $.LA), '3d ;)\),)v1tTEi. Jco~), ..
'ht. pttR1i'2s I r--~\.-c S\fiu.rwt-ER.- \\Du-<:£ tou.\6. £As,\t,? tie 'Sl-\~s-\-;-\-"'tc-d f0l2. T.t>.c:::r., ~ ~-\-s LA.Y\~ i\OW'i\. LA~AttQU vJ-A~\e- or~\ CI t\'\? v.)\..1.J Qo1lttcY\o\ -6 +M<E ·-H'\E ~i)\1(M<-\-~ ~ROfcl'<,-\v wi¥v-, ow+ . t.oM~l'\":,Pi"tlDY\c, EvEY\ A tOY\lJicJeJ Qc:1<$0,,\ ht\-s If¼\ 1::10ed-AtfoV\ ¼A+ ~ E °SE!{\t-Er-tc hE 1<Et£.1ud 1-s ~ "SE:nfEV\cE he u..>;\\ SEA.:£,~1: tou.«!.t:"
---~~~- ... ~\::L r10-\c 'i-Yli\-+- -\:\1e. \Sffi tof\vi·cbei,v; ~ cL·sro-scd oF V1f't r\Eft-°\~)f)~\'<;lv\..
'1\,E 1\Wl1~ }\~ ~~ Vc::;:,ihl l<'&,\~t~, rn<my bf w'°',c~ f\-Re- dcA~lj' MNJLA~~& in.'ik 'Tr;:t. ~~':,,+. M.. I G, \\ DF r,8\d-s,
''f\1f 'fA\<\(\~'S CLA11V\, Dl,\E 9f(otESS1 Q,8'1\\,t +o petl·t1Dl'\. fo(< G-R ;1.::VtmtE, A-\D~ w ~\"'- n-\1'-\'\.\f cnoRE, ·fvt'.€ pt:ort\iv--e\'\,t R~0v-\-s <11:F~V\a::l -\:\.-E~, "'·
'11.t tau Rt wi-1/\, ()wrnt\\~ 1 t v--dE ~EY\J6}1t\ Ye AV'ci E«RON:CI..J-S\'? dec,JJ ~ -Ac '1E:i1I:") Tot, u..)h':, p\€d c\Es~;-\c rAu.ht\~\c ·t\S~ffi;!,.v-.s <b~ to~«fl1Zq (R.R. (:>91, \)\.-I'\,\,-)., P'A·J-0 "'"'· d5). ~L)Ct\. "TY\E: clefEY10\M-.t AJM\ \\-cd -¼vA- V\1: Y\1tJ not- ~\e<l flr- 'Tt=:.'{,f-S ·Tci2T t\A,M. detEv-.<oE («..~. \?(;\,\'5 \...v--.,:)~-)'S) 1 ~~ w¼:I"\ Y\e ,Sfu-v f\ (b<:h1\\E Wl'l\.1 \,E C..\Lo£ +o \<._ee~ -:5',,e~+-, The p\f\,~f:F teRJ'A~(\\v. w'l'IS Not- lnV\hA~:
~ fYlR F\vdEKSD<\.~ r d\:)j ~\ \c= 1t , cR!- t\A1.N\.
..... . . . . lo. ~OJ YEE? 'tl>t\\:111",A fltuJ.,1 f\ ,oRT l'\:A 1M .
~. \\°\f tc;ul?T~ ~i)/\°'2, 0\CA1\':,~u':,t 'I6tA.'f2<,1, 8, ~ A fu"cy \e~v"l UJDt2J ~DR ~"'-J'IA<t~ 9, We CA\\ ·Toets i0,-\Uf<Lj).
17
\0, 0'\i<, t\-\'\o\e~SC\11. ~ ·:r=·-n,u:x')A~ ft ,oeT t \,/¼l\J\. ~Ad-\-o l \. do L,V\-¼-- ft- I\U-'t"D Mcb~ \E f\Ct}dEJ. ld, ·,hE L'.ocu~t~ T\-vvt \ s 'the w~\E dtt1\, At F\ 12-s+ \ '3, yDv c.Cl).\d (lo+ ~ E --th~ ~oi.£K'.f::.l9>\'\. , ·TuE \<'~ ~ lJ...IA-S SOtJE~Ets;4~. ( 1?,R, pp.. d1)
\+ct'.t: wE At2E1 No t,osE~ \o (2c::olu\1'-~ ~ T~~(\µs t,\./1 ,M..
'1k --fR~ftl tw«:+ Wef\-1 vt=d (W\~ ~l:V\~E 1/\lt ·TtrR. 1l\,OOLt L «~. ~· \q \...V\, 3-9), dcdJ"'B ~Mp'\-EJ e~vf,fu'\CE. T\\e Mevx:!tm:\-, R-~,esta:l +a ')(J.rr\e('{le~ ·t¼c ~L\,CO-\ ";;>'tfi-\.c:Mr:0.-L (2() (:)~, \°t ~y\, \\-1)\,
Dete\/\Jf\j- A~h:-ste-J ~tk +hE: tw'Ct nt>J rlu.~1-sc\,c:hDrt 'fo-12 A\"\ :r:Y\v~'Sl':- tDJ\l'>6v'\l\t"\-1JM. t \tr~ M. (~R. ()~. Jo i-~. to-\::,),~-\- e,~M\EYl?\ed ¼E {)~~\7 C' \A, M , Fi\6-ttA~ Qe-v'iew 6--trc f\&uA~ C,\MM vUA-5 beycw,d ~ L:,torc oF- ~ ~\tfl- ·flo ,i\AfZ-~sJ,c.t~o""
1V'IE tcu~+ EY-ltcJe-c~ ~s \1Ml+E-& ~1A~i,;J,J1Drt '1" ·+\.E cA~E oF ft plEA- -.\-o --YW= ~ u.l'Zi~\~ DY\, '""'E CW!Zl c~~ frY\. 1Y\o\Ef-lcrd&d- Cf\LASE c,\= /c\e,:Bo\\. (\c'\-
0cli"ho)'.cc\ b,:, --\ 'nE p\"'1J4 FF, dEt\t?\ r-r4 \,\, M \-1'3 ~0\'\)1i~'tl 15)\/(\ Rl'?l'kt-s -\c, ~«E'SE:i\t /\- ~-A-~l\\~S t \v-\ (IV\ v; A Te:,<, toj\s1, A-Pf, \ § \~ , \ht ~LAd.9-1Es clEt1S1DI'\ \ S t \EA~\,' ERt2-01"i:cuS t f\-0d not bf\qd DD --\-\-.E rlrnd ~~s. 'T\-\E \.)\ ")fr\\ S~f\\_, -s ~()T -".::0- 0) {)f(T eD ~ Lr , Y1 e- ?~tf\'D\ (\ e:,s ,
A Awct~rn"t- Kcl}fle'::>T -tY\E t.cucl a~ Appc:c,\S I
f~!'d ~D~ -\-\-,E r\t,~~1rFI (2c~.C, ·+¼:- det\<,\C,V\_ --r\.c --\ R1 f\ \ tou R-t ~\c.\ htti:- n--v="'c\e I f't<\c\ RE fl\fu'c\ :i, +"'i::- Cf\-SE bAclC ""tb +~t ~;t\\ ~tu~t ro~ ~\ty\ DY\ ''t)~f'lp_ES, ~. QEfust.\ -h, '8\e f;"o\ft\,'(S Df f"is And ~Oi\du~l~s or= ~Aw l":> t\f\fMrul--- .f\~ tt ('(\A1iER O+= \..1lw
\._\
Whel'\ ()~D()mly ~led *~ +~;~\ ~cl- Dt\-S A- rnnfdpn,R-q dL1.'¼ ·\-o ·~\ \£ f, l"d\~s o"° ~C'\C\s ~ QO<'C,\lA$1'onS_Qt= h R - w . r~ .A~~~\ C-u,l<lr Jocs no+ F't\E' rl'('o\l ~-s oF ff\ct.s ftY'dl /:C)(\dU.~lll\S 0 f- \ - A w f\fteiZ Fl 1 2 9 ) U o + h f l ~ neEn ()'26()2'2-\,1
'()lf'dt/ ; +'is pReSu med h~m rw\ l,l~\ess ¼E" ~EN::\Zd /\ff~fMJt,t\vE\tj ~~ ·tnAt ¼e ~O{(\p\-Alvd~ r~ -SlA~fEt2.Eo\ \\\o \('_J.\}.~ I ---rhE ~EY\UZA\
fi,1.\ c , s -\- "r0- A- t[)(YI r\ fl'i "'~r- nf)-:') \'£fu \\AR{'{)fJ 1t=-\-rt FA\\u~E tb f~\E ~·iV\d'tr\,91 DI=- ~t\ttL,, t\\f'd ~01\c,\u.':,11M~ bf \....t'n-v- l'.f\VSES h,EQ, ·-\o 'N,ue 1\--o
fjUE~S m- * ~SDI'\ '\YlE -\-(<_\-A\ twvZ.r- ?-t;.\Ed. ~f\-il\~ hEi?. t?R. p~ve.k \'\ER ffsi'oM ~~ol)ER\t? ~f'c<:E~l ~ ~ER C'ft5E 1o -\ \'le A?PE\\ME tw\Q·t. Wll\En CAfY A ~,¥\£ ~k'ov1v\d o~ k1t(\)LJeey, ~ f\ -Slf'f\'E dt:TT:i\SE IS ~l<f<J:ntc~ "to'-\ It '1(<~t\\ tw~t1 '\-ht: l'C<Y\ rt fl i ri1' fl )'\"\- ~ L\.ffc)'<. '> I{\ o 't\'M<M , . , f\5 ThE tomp\;fli\,\ttnJ- 1s Y\OT fo~cr1.~ -\-o jl-lf'::6 ¼E ~ __ ____ fu_ ·--tn~ ±ttitr~ crud~ detisto"' ," R.-\-\-. V:S• ~ CQ\~, '3 39, '5µ.J, 3d 7 Slo/1l.Dlo( Tei-, t\W· ~\\i\,s d0\\) lil°tl~Yl:/t\ l'1~;_ws oM\11c.o\
.1-1\ -{"-.;.;. <]_""'>E ~c:lli\'4 ~de: Mui-\~ !)le 1tileM.p'ts +o \,vwE
+k- tfJ..,A( ~OL).~t- i 5SLAE i'°fs fi't'\Ji~_t, t>f ~ ft~ Co~u~1ZM-s o F 1--..tu..,.., fke 'h\AI lo1.-<1(-i ~ cl!-cd b&ti:1'-SE ~l'-<..E( -+o Flle F,~i'~s ti f -Fr1-lk, ~t i+- 1Bll f!.EfiAscJ
tc Aul O\l)t- Sl-'l.ck fil"cti "'$l(S,
thi<l~o\~ 'Tl(t P Rl,l,1£ J9LP Rciuc:51- (tc.R r'A• J.le0<~1,'3~j Ot2c!Eett1 -+wt ·~erc"J,xJ- +v f;\E R-?oposcd f~t-.A•~S (~~t p<;1, )'1C1; - - - D~ ~eY'-~; r1-_91 F,'rol,~s Df- F~s (t>t i f~· 'J-<3~ j ·--r{!. t? Rl-Llt dq"l N.otl(£ OF- lAT£ flrct";Qs rit<lsi;,\=
(De ie. rfA· "3 o ~ - 3d\)j
~ . ..&_tfl,A':)!;__f¼E_3R~l l:w-£ls _Jul~- -\u t1icYivcl;"foS. .. oE ---•-- _tAfil_~d_tol"ClY.s}o~~ ~t . ~ .. is -~1,.1w: ft:i\(,\~£ --
·+1> et:.,;r~ wk-R AR r2Eftiw;it ~~ '1?c:I'\, pl~pi;:~ )q (}'\itdE
--·------ ___ _i .~ .. _pJ_E&\.~ ... hl'r(lii\'.\tul ;~JJ~E:$.S ~ - e,.,;Ji.¥<1 .»tf111i;-. i'hE .
___J\:Wcillffi;_ Cou¥1ct _.&ff'.; .e.-~~fr.vx1'f'..'.S~~HJ'l ~ _'lg J;1,"."lpJl)mJv1.8 . .. . . _.. ... _
.... -· .~~J\12 SJAfn;ttt:J_ND i"-iutt~~/ vJhFd'\/;~ ~S. ..~\<;\.u, \L(Jie~,
. --·--·----- _331.,.3~13, l'lS '.),t,_<,.)'._µ.1.Ll..i:J)Q_(l(>i':llf) ...... .
C' kl~~~\(:: rv<dus+~,E~, 11\~I V5, (Y\,:\~~loV\e:s, 1lo 3 ~1,0,J4 .
--. _··--· . -~1o6,113.ff~JC~L9fil)L .--· -·. ---- .... · · · · · -· ... _-· .. ···-. __
... 1be Jru.~~ Ei'_K:/\\_QR.cleK t5. fu:½,'1'i,(4VcOOS. i ~~A:t3t ·-•- _. . . . _ - .
-~-.-~:sJ1,~~tit ,· tAsb~_¾.-9P.>21.\1',\~~ o.f."__'Tc::l(,. ti' 11{\ ... --···- ·-·-··· - ..
_____ .. - ..P~t<A-1 cE _~-2.tlY\Ec\,E:S .£\t~ \4._.j'. b\Ji'I\ o"--+ ./'tYJ:,.. o:thER.--•·- ______ __ ......... - -- ~1Ef\cll"',9.S ' Tb§. ~f~~Qit ~+s . 8\t:f4\r'?1.S . c,tr '1. ~(>,?£) 1<,.S
1h.~t ~lC r~ ~4 ½e:.. ~<?~, \»t?,l ~ ~ ~;"'8 ... ·-H~ c4V::Clflc t' SSEis1trt h.e u.x:v.kL not_dl_srn,~s fu\~J.1\Q. ...... _ _ UV\<kt_ t~f\\)~ \l{_~~<e:J-~ \l\µ\-\1plf 0\-.. \L\ f:\\~s c::,«.uieg:l._ ... •..... .
See=_:,~tJ<;_p~51~.5l-C'1- _Ile: .;}D;}'.:>).,-Q-~ .\l:\)::S~\ £~--·------··-·-•- -- ..
. - .... ·····-·(L> __ -_.\L:,_--::¢Q)'5)J ___________ ······· ·------··----- -- ·•·· -···----··· .
_-------P ~' J lO-:l\l ('\ • \L,,-Jo;i 5). Thc _f~ilj ___flld_\l\\~~--~'f____ ~~---~------- _
_pt<::<i.e)\ct i\::t~ (bt -'2. 0A· ;J->-tL?:J_ra~C~ :1 s:· :}0~s}:) _ _ __ __
7£~.'311 ,o3l. 5f\uiro pro\J\5,ol'\S , r::V\. M \ Ct\-SE'S, oiQc:t, "-A-ie_q ?'WtLtoRg Col'.'s--\~tl D"'-
V::'~LL-\c;\. «c:av~ -"t~ N:-1·-\'¼E:R~ 5oS. I~<?\, o~ 5oB.1;}'2i3 wq,\\d A(?0\Z io :\::\:u;: -+bEn e-,;ecµ+t(l~ \C\Si __ _ SEni\c-1\.l'~ - It'\- \(EE:f? !1')9. IA..) ;+h :-\111; e~Eti,d--,"7"
SE½"tEY\~E" ff-\- l!?t:~n~1Emc.J', Tc1, b:Qv,, tcJe ~ 31 L, 03 \1 AYICA ~ 3\\,D\\ fr?olH \(\~$ l't\Sf.
As c,W ;"- folfOA-rd, ll"E, ¼E A()()c\\/'IJ-- Y\A-5 I\EvER pu1<SuEcl B _·U:1(Jt5 'TD~T t_ \A1m u\'\(}.ER, ~ t\vl\ {>~!
rtro\ t<cf<\. l'\\Ap-Wi!.. \P\. ·Toe ecu12~ ofZclc=~ i'~ _____ _
Amb~~t.Aw~ l:t>tR r9,, :}-"st,,)S~- _ licRE -t111':v0t f\[-\W:meriit' ·-fuN\-- '\C l<'P t \,\. \ D\. 5 r'\ w A-S
<t\-1.E" 01\\1' i(EflSDt\ +\1c to,,1~~ ~\lhM'S _~+ h.!'rJ No ,4u.{l.,~~1c1i'Dr\. 1 t.o<l.FL-\S10t\. E-1~s+ DY\ ¼c Qf\i<.-t oY
~ A-ppd I An,-\-.
_ . C1 lC1.J.«J- llto\M CQn,s-tt·\u.'1~~ ~~\,j- _\-)L? @fusi'-0,A +o }'\Ef\J5 mo'\-.'D'\'\ tllfs ~IY){(\FtRt,i .:t 1.).6,Arnen+- \\lo
EL>i' \',)E(\C E ,
___ t\f(:J:' '"rV\E tR~r<\ ro.Aie.t dE(iJEJ 1_": \M::V-\J on,\\' \tEflR
Pr ,.-1ue1'sd,t.f;l:,\'\,.J ~\1c'f\~c{fi )B \..".C\-}OJ. ,\,e
Coue+ i'f'<lnoQcd +he pftim½fF1 fRopc:f2-\~ t=}\d 'Mo't-101'\ fDK' ~cnml't1<'-7 ;\-u-JF<rncl\t- ~o l::0l~rv::£ t\w: ®f\(20~ ,0-1v- 20~s)(DC.f<'. ~ 51\-1)), P\('111\htt's mdt1 b'- LV .,,,.., ~, \Ed tol\-½?m {b~Ml;l:u-:'i\'f Wt~ ¾t oie_~91, "J {> di"t~C\'\ 1 L,vE.\ \ t>Ef~c\-½E dE~(ldA--1\.~ ? IEft -h:, +~c ;ruei :5c\\J-, 00- ~rt" d .';)o} 5) (b C. Q fP.· \ Ob- l)o) Rr0. u..tis tv \1E 1t£MJ D,,_ <¼\E srtl'Y\€ d"';i, M pte\l\Ou?\l{ St'kdviltd (bt\<. ~~-~o'J.)
z. 3
1be: C£::L£t ~ M\£chsaf::P\ 1¼ \'LD-t\Cf\ 8-)R . "::x.ArnmN2~ ,ALAdFtfY\e<V't No tµ,dtcxe- I inf defurJttJ bes_d~t?--tic!f\lldi~d__ i\. toffl.f\'\J ¾J ¾ ·1~1 ~ (}?t£()R\\L\-\\lo), Bro\ hM ~A;\EJ. W o~Ei<u.Jt<5e _ ---·· -~espo<x(_.w'tlh . . ~t_e_tXdct.ff_iQ E5lr~\L5h . __ .
ft rnf't{ER11'\\ 'Ff\& ; K 00,)DS ,\:; DI'\ '\t:, ~E . pl11mVifFs t~AJMS ..
Xc(l'\E o~
Appel\Arf 'f<ct'.bucs+ ½.e tO-J<{!:\- o~ P9pE8'1s <f=,'~ ... foR '-t\'\€: plA-h\+1ff, ~Eroe-125 ~ o\2c.1S16'\ A~E --\-~1f\\ lw~i\- ~\ttou\d ~t>-0t <DPd,E: 1 000 \2crnA<'d$ +Y\f C~'?£: Pfll.'\< +o ~ ·-\-(2;M ~cut29-. ~DR ii<~M en ·ofrn'\~~.
fo~ pge-r,,~B tops'ic)i::fcJ, flw\,cfu'\'.,t- ~c-st . -tw+ -the ~Q_u2l- Of ltppr~s f<&AD,t ~es+al RE\t1;:F, f\l'\d. RE\/ER~e:, ~ e ' 'i v-.sW tME. FoR . fµ-(!_+\'1:1<- r gatac\~ -s.
··•·-·-··-:J;,~ot:\tlE€k~~)\. Tfl('.;S:ff: ,':>~Ilk, do \.1ER1:~
~LAJEAI<... •,-',J~~.~ {) '°/\ir\¼. of. {)U/2.JtJJ?,Lfil\ :¼E=: fil~ f<\E"~eol ~¼""c~S f\.2c ~ t ~of21?E~ C'ln.d .+ hfttJE mt.': L\eJ ~ ·\xw£ ~ o~ ~'<-\'-4'.- -tbh B ei'e,f: . . TD ·m 'Te~ Mh:f21\91 &t:rcQJ\ / ~,)- #6~ ~r'E~ . K't? le 'i?ae,~\\"s . t:rt . . r.p. '1P~ ,~5~.B l'flf>~ <$4-A~o.... ~)-. ;T1.:~ '-\St-i\) ~ ~Sl\<?:,
_ &J A--~~ to tbe _l5·tk loµat of {\,pco\s, ...
. . . .. .. . tJ/6 /b-----.
.\.-i:-0\-"Wx' U ~ .'3 Q,\c~ Cr 10 '3. 3teC\S- f\vt 3':?\Z:f . &-~w>~ 'TelC. 'l7'1P5
. . . A~rEi,di t
. . \, '16* _t1,J)21J tov~* <urcke.
'I
07/31/2025 04:48:32 PM
Velva L. Price District Clerk Travis County
D-1-GN-25-001988
CAUSE NO. D-J-GN-25-001988
JOHN ERIC ANDERSON, § IN THE DISTRICT COURT P/aiutiff, § §
v. § 98m DISTRICT § §
STATE OF TEXAS, ET AL., § TRAVIS COUNTY, TEXAS Defemlrmt(.\'). §
ORDER
On this clay the Court considered defendants the State of Texas, the Texas Department of
Criminal Justice ("TDCJ"), and TDCJ Executive Director Bryan Collier' s (collectively,
"Defendants") Plea to the Jurisdiction and Motion to Dismiss Pursuant to Chapter 14 of the Texas
Civil Practice and Remedies Code. Having considered Defendants' motion along with the other
pleadings filed herein, the Court orders the following:
It is hereby ORDERED that Defendants' motion is GRANTED.
It is further ORDERED that plaintiff John Eric Anderson's suit is dismissed with
~ -ej: Y
Signed this 3 / ~ ay of J t./ \ 1 , 2025
E:-2>~
JUDGE P~ IDING~
·1·..J 1 ' '
\..()
w
.<-
.J~ ~
"' =
\.(")
z
i'i' a. t
·---•--·-_-_ • -o. @:::~ < "' cc cc
0
I j::O -
11} tr~ = !l!~ I
irl§3 > ~u .()
I ---lE "' <
C) ~ :z: i'i'
iS c...
C,. <I. u...
0
..J-
---
r
<;)). /4 OJ :s
0
\fl .c
<..) cP I'
(0 ..,..
<C. ·:;t-
...£. ill
t y
0
I---~
U..J
1.U ce +,C (~
-r 0 '.P u.- w= c... ct
\(!
0
r
.r'
- )--r
ct \
- r
-ct \v
_J ,.-
\(!
E\ \
\
t0 J;::;
--r-
en /lJ Cl j--
t J..-
Lu(