Fors v. United States

14 Cl. Ct. 709, 1988 U.S. Claims LEXIS 69, 1988 WL 39083
United States Court of Claims·Decided April 28, 1988·No. No. 638-85C·Published·Cited by 2 cases

Opinion

OPINION

MARGOLIS, Judge.

In this military pay case, plaintiff, Jennie B. Fors, seeks interest from the defendant United States, in the amount of $203,690.09 on her son's accumulated military pay and allowances for the period from 90 days after he was declared dead until the funds were paid to the plaintiff over four years later. The parties earlier filed cross motions for summary judgment. The court denied these motions, concluding that disputed issues of material fact existed. See Fors v. United States, No. 638-85C (Cl.Ct. May 5, 1987). Trial was held on January 7, 1988, in Washington, D.C. After full consideration of the trial record and oral argument, the court finds for the defendant.*

FACTS

In 1967, Capt. Gary H. Fors was a United States Marine Corps pilot stationed in Vietnam. On December 22, 1967, Capt. Fors was on a classified strike mission piloting an F-4B aircraft across the border into Laos. After enemy fire struck Capt. Fors’ aircraft, Capt. Fors and his Radar Intercept Officer were forced to eject from the aircraft.

Search and rescue teams were promptly notified and arrived at the scene of the crash within minutes. A rescue helicopter was able to locate and rescue the Radar Intercept Officer. The search continued for Capt. Fors, but due to heavy enemy fire, the rescuers were unable to locate Capt. Fors prior to darkness. Rescue operations resumed the next day and continued until December 29, 1967 with no results. In February 1968, Capt. Fors was classified as missing in action (MIA).

Pursuant to the Missing Persons Act, 37 U.S.C. §§ 551-558, Capt. Fors continued to receive all military pay and allowances. As he had no dependants, Capt. Fors’ monthly payments were deposited into an interest-bearing account under the Uniformed Services Savings Deposit Program (USSDP), which was established for missing service-members pursuant to 10 U.S.C. § 1035. Section 1035 authorized the payment of interest on USSDP funds, terminating 90 days after the servicemember’s return to the United States, at the rate of 10% per annum, compunded quarterly.

During Capt. Fors’ classification as MIA, he received regular promotions and was eventually promoted to the rank of Lieutenant Colonel. Lt. Col. Fors’ parents maintained hope that their son was still alive and encouraged the United States government to search for MIAs in Laos. The Fors became active in the National League of Families of American Prisoners and Missing in Southeast Asia, an organization composed of the families of ser-vicemembers missing in action in Southeast Asia. The group was organized for the purpose of communicating with the federal government concerning efforts to locate servicemembers listed as missing in action.

After the formal cessation of hostilities with North Vietnam, and after the return [711] of prisoners held by North Vietnam, Henry Fors, Lt. Col. Fors’ father, believed that the United States government was no longer making any real effort to learn what had happened to the servicemembers still missing in Southeast Asia. In unsuccessful efforts to ascertain the whereabouts of his son, Mr. Fors traveled both to Moscow and to the Paris Peace Talks to meet with the North Vietnamese. Mr. Fors also helped to organize and sponsor a group that traveled through Southeast Asia in an unsuccessful search for servicemembers missing in action.

In 1978, the Fors received notice that the Marine Corps Missing and Captured Review Board was going to review their son’s MIA status to determine whether it should be changed to killed in action (KIA). On July 31, 1979, the Review Board held a hearing, at which the Fors were present, to review all evidence and to present additional evidence. Over the opposition of Lt. Col. Fors’ parents, the Board recommended that Lt. Col. Fors’ status be changed to KIA.

At the direction of the Commandant of the Marine Corps, on August 7, 1980, the designated reviewing officer, Lt. Col. J. Hammond, made a presumptive finding of death for Lt. Col. Fors. Remarks made on Form DD1300, the military equivalent of a death certificate, indicate:

The exact time and place of Lt Col Fors’ death are not known.... On the basis of the foregoing, the absence of information from all sources that he survived, and the elapse of time without indication of survival, it was determined that Lt Col Fors is dead. This finding of death was made by me as designee of the Secretary of the Navy under Title 37, U.S.Code Sections 555 and 556 on 7 August 1980. Accordingly, continuance of Marine Corps pay and allowances under Chapter 10, Title 37, U.S.Code, terminates on that date.

On August 7, 1980, then Capt. Larry A. Johnson, the Marine Corps officer charged with notifying Lt. Col. Fors’ family of the change of status, contacted Henry Fors and arranged to meet with him on August 8, 1980. At that meeting, Capt. Johnson notified Mr. Fors that a presumptive finding of death had been made on August 7, 1980 and explained what benefits were available to Lt. Col. Fors’ family. Capt. Johnson said that he would contact Mr. Fors within the next few weeks so that a meeting could be arranged to deliver a casualty assistance package. The casualty assistance package included a number of forms that the family was required to fill out in order to receive the servicemember’s accumulated back pay and benefits.

On or about August 27, 1980, Capt. Johnson telephoned Henry Fors’ office to arrange a meeting to deliver the casualty assistance package. Henry Fors was not in the office, and Capt. Johnson was informed that due to an emergency, Mr. Fors would be unavailable for approximately three weeks. On two other occasions between August 27, 1980 and September 15, 1980, Capt. Johnson unsuccessfully attempted to contact Mr. Fors.

In late August and early September of 1980, Henry Fors suffered from a number of strokes. During this period, Henry Fors was either in the hospital or at his beach house, which was about an hour and one-half drive from his office. Also in early September 1980, Mr. Fors, in his capacity as guardian of Lt. Col. Fors, filed an application for correction of the presumptive finding of death before the Board for Correction of Naval Records. At the same time, in a second effort to regain his son’s MIA status, Mr. Fors also filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington challenging the presumptive finding of death.

On September 11, 1980, Capt. Johnson learned of the lawsuit through an article in the Tacoma News Tribune. On September 15, 1980, after his third unsuccessful attempt to contact Henry Fors, Capt. Johnson wrote to his superior, Major Gary Al-lord, advising him that Mr. Fors was challenging the presumptive finding of death. Capt. Johnson’s impression was that in light of the unsuccessful attempts to contact Mr. Fors and in view of the pending litigation, all attempts to deliver the casualty assistance package should be temporari[712] ly halted. Capt. Johnson requested guidance on this matter as soon as possible.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Fors v. United States, 14 Cl. Ct. 709, 1988 U.S. Claims LEXIS 69, 1988 WL 39083 (cc 1988).

14 Cl. Ct. 709 (Fors v. United States) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Brazos Electric Power Cooperative, Inc. v. United States
52 Fed. Cl. 121 (Federal Claims, 2002)
Ulmet v. United States
19 Cl. Ct. 527 (Court of Claims, 1990)