Fastening Devices, Inc. v. United States

40 Cust. Ct. 345
CourtUnited States Customs Court
DecidedJune 10, 1958
DocketC. D. 2004
StatusPublished
Cited by6 cases

This text of 40 Cust. Ct. 345 (Fastening Devices, Inc. v. United States) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Customs Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Fastening Devices, Inc. v. United States, 40 Cust. Ct. 345 (cusc 1958).

Opinion

Foed, Judge:

The suits listed in schedule “A,” hereto attached and made a part hereof, challenge the action of the collector of customs in classifying certain imported merchandise as manufactures of metal, not specially provided for, with the consequent levy of duty thereon at the rate of 22% per centum ad valorem under paragraph 397 of the Tariff Act of 1930, as modified by the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, 82 Treas. Dec. 305, T. D. 51802.

Plaintiffs claim that said merchandise should be classified as nuts, nails, and studs, respectively, and assessed with duty at the appropriate rate under paragraph 330, 331, or 332 of said act, as modified, supra, or under paragraph 331 of the Tariff Act of 1930.

The paragraphs of the Tariff Act of 1930, as modified, supra, are as follows:

[397] Articles or wares not specially provided for, whether partly or wholly manufactured:
* * * * * *
Composed wholly or in chief value of iron, steel, lead, copper, brass, nickel, pewter, zinc, aluminum, or other metal (not including platinum, gold, or silver), but not plated with platinum, gold, or silver, or colored with gold lacquer:
% ifi ‡ *
Other (except slide fasteners and parts
thereof)_■_ 22)4% ad val.
[330]Nuts, nut blanks, and washers, of wrought iron or steel- jKojí per lb.
[331] Nails, spikes, tacks, brads, and staples, made of iron or
steel wire:
Not less than one inch in length nor smaller than sixty-five one-thousandths of one inch in diameter_ Via$ Per lb.
[332] Rivets, studs, and steel points, lathed, machined, or bright-
ened, and rivets or studs for nonskidding automobile
tires..._............._I.....__ 15% ad'val.

[347]*347Paragraph. 331 of the Tariff Act of 1930, supra, is as follows:

* * *; horseshoe nails, and other iron or steel nails, not specially provided for, 1% cents per pound; * * *.
At the trial of this case, counsel for the plaintiffs offered the testimony of one witness and the following exhibits:
Collective exhibit 1, representative of item 625, invoiced as an eye coupling in protest 246664-K.
Collective exhibit 2, representative of item 626, invoiced as a coupling in protest 246664^K.
Collective exhibit 3, representative of item 627, invoiced as a coupling in protest 246664^K.
Collective exhibit 4, representative of item 628, invoiced as a coupling in protest 246664-K.
Collective exhibit 5, representative of item DP 300, invoiced as a drive pin in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 6, representative of item DP 301, invoiced as a drive pin in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 7, representative of item DP 302, invoiced as a drive pin in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 8, representative of item DP 303, invoiced as a drive pin in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 9, representative of item DP 305, invoiced as a drive pin in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 10, representative of item DP 310, invoiced as a drive pin in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 11, representative of item TS 101, invoiced as a threaded stud in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 12, representative of item TS 102, invoiced as a threaded stud ih protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 13, representative of item TS 103, invoiced as a threaded stud in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 14, representative of item TS 203, invoiced as a threaded stud in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 15, representative of item TS 204, invoiced as a threaded stud in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 16, representative of item TS 205, invoiced as a threaded stud in protest 248791-K.
Collective exhibit 17, representative of item 2229, invoiced as a machined stud in protest 252612-K.
Collective exhibit 18, répresentative of item DP 304, invoiced as a drive pin in protest 258323-K.
Collective exhibit 19, representative of item 2204, invoiced as a machined stud in protest 260139-K.

Counsel for the defendant offered and there was received in evidence as exhibit A a card with certain drive pins and threaded studs appearing thereon. There was also received in evidence, as exhibit B, one [348]*348sheet of paper which the witness described as “a piece of our literature/' relating to the merchandise in question described as drive pins and as threaded studs. A 4-page booklet was admitted in evidence as exhibit 0, which the witness described as “A piece of Remington literature,” the front page of which is titled “The Model 450 Remington Stud Driver.”

Counsel for the plain tiffs,, in his brief filed herein, sets out the facts established by this record as follows:

* * * The imported merchandise was manufactured according to the plaintiff’s specifications and, with the exception of the couplings, is made of steel wire and is cadmium plated to prevent deterioration. All of the fasteners, with the exception of the couplings, are designed to be driven into concrete or steel or any of the types of masonry that are used for buildings, such as red brick and mortar blocks. The items which are invoiced as studs are driven into this material only to the end of their shank so as to permit an attachment to the threaded portion of the stud which.protrudes from the surface. The studs will hold over 1,200 pounds of direct pull down and can be used in any position.
Exhibits 5 through 9 and Exhibit 18 are used by the building trades for fastening materials together and function like a nail. It can be used in wood but is generally used to fasten a 2 x 4 studding to a steelfbeam or a^piecejff steel to a concrete wall. It is used to fasten wood either to metal or to concrete. The imported pins and studs have a shear strength, i. e., a resistance to drawing, of 1,280 pounds. The pins- are used exclusively to fasten two or more pieces of material together. They can be driven into the material with a powder actuated gun which is accomplished by placing the pin in the barrel of the tool and placing a cartridge behind the pin. When the cartridge is exploded the expending gases drive the pin or stud down the barrel into the material which is to be fastened. The purpose of the plastic tip on the studs or drive pins is merely to hold them in place in the barrel. The plastic tip serves no other purpose and disintegrates when the drive pin or stud is driven into the material to be fastened.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

S.I. Stud, Inc. v. United States
17 Ct. Int'l Trade 661 (Court of International Trade, 1993)
Waters Shipping Co. v. United States
60 Cust. Ct. 506 (U.S. Customs Court, 1968)
Fastening Devices, Inc. v. United States
43 Cust. Ct. 448 (U.S. Customs Court, 1959)
Reilly v. United States
43 Cust. Ct. 426 (U.S. Customs Court, 1959)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
40 Cust. Ct. 345, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/fastening-devices-inc-v-united-states-cusc-1958.