Estate of Martha S. French v. Stratford House

333 S.W.3d 546, 2011 Tenn. LEXIS 9, 2011 WL 238819
CourtTennessee Supreme Court
DecidedJanuary 26, 2011
DocketE2008-00539-SC-R11-CV
StatusPublished
Cited by118 cases

This text of 333 S.W.3d 546 (Estate of Martha S. French v. Stratford House) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Tennessee Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Estate of Martha S. French v. Stratford House, 333 S.W.3d 546, 2011 Tenn. LEXIS 9, 2011 WL 238819 (Tenn. 2011).

Opinions

OPINION

GARY R. WADE, J.,

delivered the opinion of the Court, in which

CORNELIA A. CLARK, C.J., JANICE M. HOLDER, and SHARON G. LEE, JJ., joined. WILLIAM C. KOCH, JR., J., filed a separate opinion dissenting in part.

The administratrix of the estate of the deceased brought this wrongful death suit against the defendant nursing home and its controlling entities, alleging damages as the result of ordinary negligence, negligence per se, and violations of the Tennessee Adult Protection Act. The trial court granted the defendants’ motion for partial summary judgment, holding that the Tennessee Medical Malpractice Act applied to the ordinary negligence claims, thereby precluding allegations of negligence per se [550]*550or violations of the Tennessee Adult Protection Act. The trial court also dismissed a claim for punitive damages. The Court of Appeals affirmed, but vacated the portion of the order dismissing the punitive damages claim. This Court granted the administratix’s application for permission to appeal in an effort to clarify the standards governing nursing home liability and to resolve a conflict in the decisions rendered by the Court of Appeals. We hold that, because the administratrix of the estate of the deceased has alleged violations of the standard of care pertaining to both medical treatment and routine care, she has made claims based upon both medical malpractice and ordinary negligence. Further, she may offer proof of negligence per se and violations of the Tennessee Adult Protection Act as support for her ordinary negligence claims. We affirm the Court of Appeals’ reinstatement of the punitive damages claim. The judgment of the Court of Appeals is, therefore, affirmed in part and reversed in part. The cause is remanded to the trial court.

Facts and Procedural History1

In 2000, Martha French (“Ms. French”), age 54, suffered a debilitating stroke, her second, and was admitted to total care at the Highland Manor Nursing Home (“Highland Manor”) in Portland. Also afflicted with diabetes, arterial fibrillation, depression, hypertension, and anxiety, Ms. French periodically experienced pressure ulcers2 at Highland Manor. After Ms. French had been a patient at Highland Manor for approximately three years, her daughter, Kimberly S. French (the “Ad-ministratrix”), arranged for her transfer to the Stratford House, a long-term care facility in Chattanooga. At the time of her admittance on April 3, 2003, Ms. French had no pressure ulcers. Because of her immobility, however, Ms. French was at significant risk of developing ulcers. The facility’s Patient Transfer Form, Resident Assessment Protocol (“RAP”) Summary, and Care Plan all documented Ms. French’s susceptibility to pressure ulcers. A course of treatment was prescribed in order to prevent a reoccurrence of the condition. According to the plan of care established at the facility, Ms. French had to be turned by nursing home personnel and repositioned frequently, kept clean and dry after incontinence, and provided with adequate hydration and nutrition.3

Ms. French’s condition deteriorated during her time at the Stratford House. By the middle of July 2003, she had both a low-grade fever and low blood pressure and, on July 23, the Administratrix arranged for a transfer to Erlanger Medical Center (“Erlanger”), where physicians attempted to increase her blood pressure by hydrating her intravenously. When she was admitted to Erlanger, Ms. French had a urinary tract infection and a number of pressure ulcers that had become infected. She developed pulmonary swelling after her admission, and medical devices were required to assist with her breathing. A feeding tube was inserted. Later, when [551]*551the Administratrix discovered the gravity of her mother’s condition, she instructed the physicians to halt the aggressive measures, including the breathing assistance and the use of a feeding tube. Ms. French died on July 26, 2003. Her death certifí-cate lists sepsis (commonly known as blood poisoning) as the cause of her death.

On March 22, 2004, the Administratrix filed suit on behalf of Ms. French’s estate against the Stratford House, OP Chattanooga, Inc., Tandem Health Care, Inc., Tandem Health Care of Ohio, Inc., Cooke-ville Long Term Facility, Inc., f/k/a Tandem Health Care of Tennessee, Inc., HP/Stratford House, Inc., and HP/Holding, Inc. (the “Defendants”).4 The Admin-istratrix alleged (1) ordinary negligence; (2) negligence per se based upon violations of state and federal nursing home regulations; and (3) violations of the Tennessee Adult Protection Act (“TAPA”), Tenn. Code. Ann. §§ 71-6-101 to -122 (2004 & Supp.2010). The complaint sought both compensatory and punitive damages. In response, the Defendants contended that all of the Administratix’s allegations qualified as medical malpractice claims under the Tennessee Medical Malpractice Act (“TMMA”), Tenn.Code. Ann. §§ 29-26-115 to -122 (2000 & Supp.2010).

There is significant dispute between the parties regarding the cause of Ms. French’s death. During depositions, Dr. Absalom Tilley, the medical director of several nursing homes in Arkansas, testified on the Administratrix’s behalf. He asserted that it was more probable than not, and within a reasonable degree of medical certainty, that Ms. French died as a result of the infection that had caused her sepsis. It was his opinion that Ms. French suffered from Stage IV pressure ulcers when she was admitted to Erlanger, including an ulcer on her sacrum which was so severe as to expose the bones of her spinal column. According to Dr. Til-ley, these ulcers became severely infected, giving off a foul odor, and had become necrotic, meaning that the cells and tissues surrounding the ulcers had died. Dr. Til-ley and Nurse Teresa Lowery, the Admin-istratrix’s nursing expert, testified that these infections and, correspondingly, Ms. French’s death, were caused by the Defendant’s failure to provide the basic care that her condition required.

Dr. David Cifu, the Chairman of the Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation at Virginia Commonwealth University and also the medical director at several rehabilitation facilities in Virginia, offered testimony on behalf of the Defendants. Dr. Cifu acknowledged that Ms. French suffered from infections upon her admission to Erlanger. Based on a lack of definitive evidence, however, it was his opinion that Ms. French’s death was not the result of sepsis. Dr. Cifu concluded that Ms. French died of respiratory arrest or a failure of pulmonary function as a result of the aggressive methods used by Erlanger while attempting to resuscitate her. His assessment was that Ms. French had become overly hydrated from the excessive fluids she received at Erlanger. It was also Dr. Cifu’s opinion that Ms. French was neither abused nor neglected at the Stratford House and that she had received adequate care and treatment at that facility.

[552]*552The Administratrix introduced the deposition testimony of several nurses’ aides (Certified Nursing Assistants, or CNAs) who had been employed at the Stratford House, some of whom confirmed that they had treated Ms. French while she was a patient there. A summary of the allegations contained in the various depositions is as follows:

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Mark Rutland v. Jeremy Locklair
Court of Appeals of South Carolina, 2024
Deborah Russell v. HSBC, Inc.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2022
Adams v. Adient US LLC
W.D. Tennessee, 2022
Estate of Samuel Corrado v. Karen Rieck
Michigan Supreme Court, 2022
Donna Cooper v. Dr. Mason Wesley Mandy
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2020
Bauer v. Fitzhugh
M.D. Tennessee, 2020
In Re: Braelyn S.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2020
Amy Angell Tucker v. Sandra Jackson Iveson
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2020
Richard Faber v. Ciox Health, LLC
944 F.3d 593 (Sixth Circuit, 2019)
Watts v. United States
D. South Carolina, 2019
Larry Beckwith v. LBMC, P.C.
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2019
Unitta Sue Newman v. State of Tennessee
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2019
Deborah Hart v. Memphis Light, Gas, & Water Division
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2018
In Re Eleanor Chappell Revocable Living Trust
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2018
FDA Properties, LLC v. David Doyle Miller
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2018
Williams v. Quest Diagnostics, Inc.
353 F. Supp. 3d 432 (D. South Carolina, 2018)
Estate of David Lyons v. Latony Baugh
Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 2018
Faber v. Ciox Health, LLC
331 F. Supp. 3d 767 (W.D. Tennessee, 2018)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
333 S.W.3d 546, 2011 Tenn. LEXIS 9, 2011 WL 238819, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/estate-of-martha-s-french-v-stratford-house-tenn-2011.