Dickerson v. Young

332 N.W.2d 93, 1983 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 1437
CourtSupreme Court of Iowa
DecidedMarch 16, 1983
Docket67657
StatusPublished
Cited by18 cases

This text of 332 N.W.2d 93 (Dickerson v. Young) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Iowa primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Dickerson v. Young, 332 N.W.2d 93, 1983 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 1437 (iowa 1983).

Opinions

UHLENHOPP, Justice.

This appeal involves legal questions which arose in an action based on trespass, conversion, and violation of civil rights. [96]*96Viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the plaintiffs who prevailed at trial, Andrews v. Struble, 178 N.W.2d 391, 397 (Iowa 1970), the jury could find the facts as follows. Bernard Dickerson was a garbage hauler for forty-seven years. In 1968 he and his wife, Margaret Dickerson, bought a new, three-bedroom mobile home for about $14,000. The home was twelve feet wide and seventy feet long. In 1973 they bought an acreage in the east part of Braddyville, Iowa, a very small municipality, and moved the mobile home onto that land. Thereafter they lived at that location, and Dickerson operated his garbage hauling business from there.

Defendant Leslie Kirchner was superintendent in a nearby quarry and also mayor pro tern, council member, and marshall of Braddyville. His property adjoined the Dickerson acreage; a ravine with a line fence down the middle ran between the two properties. Kirchner kept a few hogs, and the runoff from his hog lot went into the ravine. A sewer line from the Dickerson acreage also emptied into the ravine. Not far distant was the city dump, where rats were a continual problem.

In addition to the mobile home, the Dick-ersons had numerous miscellaneous items of property on their acreage from time to time. At one time Dickerson was told he had to get rid of some old cars on the property, and he had the bodies of no less than forty of them crushed and hauled off. He would remove and use or sell the useful parts from cars. At the time of the events in question the Dickersons had the following property on the acreage in addition to the mobile home: a frame building twenty feet square, their son’s eight-by-thirteen foot travel trailer (and its furniture), two “packer” garbage trucks formerly used in the business but presently inoperable, a number of old cars in various states of disrepair, tools, and numerous other items of personal property.

The mobile home contained three bedroom suites as well as living-room furniture, kitchen appliances, a microwave oven, a color television set, the Dickersons’ clothing, family keepsakes, Margaret Dickerson’s collection of over 100 salt and pepper shakers, their deceased son’s Purple Heart medal, the flag from his coffin, voice tapes from him when in Viet Nam, Bibles containing the Dickersons’ family records, and numerous other family items listed on several single-space pages in the record.

With considerable justification, neighbor Kirchner objected to the condition of the Dickerson acreage, and the subject was discussed in city council. Within about a year prior to the events in question — the exact dates are difficult to decipher from the record — Dickerson became ill and required treatment. He had diabetes, very poor eyesight, and difficulty passing his urine. The Dickersons packed two bags, gave directions for their mail, and left for a nearby city where they stayed with a son while Dickerson received treatment. Later Dickerson was in a nursing home for a time, and then in other temporary quarters in Cre-stón, Iowa, to be near the place of treatment. The Dickersons intended to return home when he got better.

The poor conditions at the acreage deteriorated greatly during the Dickersons’ absence. With all the cars and other items, the acreage presented an unsightly appearance to begin with, but unattended it grew much worse. Vermin and rodents inhabited the mobile home, food rotted in the refrigerator and freezers, and the place degenerated into a deplorable state.

On the evening of March 29, 1979, a tornado struck Braddyville. Severe damage occurred in the west part of the city; some secondary wind damage occurred in the east part where the Dickerson acreage lay. The Dickersons’ mobile home and the other structures on the acreage were left intact, although the mobile home was turned on its concrete-block foundation somewhat and the door was loosened. Other minor damage was done to property on the acreage.

The Braddyville tornado brought numerous volunteers from surrounding areas to help with the debris, and various firms furnished heavy equipment including bulldozers.

[97]*97The Dickersons, then at Crestón, heard about the tornado and called the Page County Sheriff the morning of March 30, 1979. He told them their home was flattened. Their son immediately took them and friends named Jollifies to Braddyville. After discovering that their damage was minor, they padlocked the door on the mobile home and returned to Crestón, thinking their property was secure.

Although the condition of the Dickerson property was not materially different than before the tornado, the jury could reasonably find that Kirchner resolved to seize upon the occurrence of the storm to end the Dickerson acreage problem. The problem consisted not only of the structures, items, and rodents on the acreage; it also involved the sewer draining raw sewage into the ravine between the acreage and the Kirchner property. Kirchner subsequently testified about post-tornado activities, “Well, he had sewers that run down, dumping raw sewage on me. And that was going to cease.”

After obtaining the city council’s concurrence to a plan of “cleaning up” the Dickerson property, Kirchner advised Page County Sheriff Dick Hunt of the plan on or about March 31, 1979. The sheriff fell in with the plan and said he would arrange for persons from the county health department to inspect the property and declare it a health hazard.

Accordingly on April 3, 1979, two representatives of the county health department went to Braddyville and to the Dickerson acreage, forcibly entered the mobile home, viewed the deplorable conditions, and returned to the sheriff in the business district. The sheriff composed the following written statement:

I have inspected the Bernard Dickerson property in Braddyville, Iowa on this date. I declare that it is a health hazard and that it should be taken down and cleaned up at once. 4/3/79
[Signed:]
Joyce Hickey PHN RN Theresa Borthwick, Page County Health Committee
[Signed:]
73-1 Dick Hunt

At this time defendant Stanley Young was a bulldozer operator employed by a local construction firm. He assisted in the cleanup work in Braddyville. When the signed writing was obtained, Kirchner went to the Dickerson acreage and, by radio, directed Young to come there. The sheriff was also there, and made an inventory of items he thought people might be interested in. He then took charge of allowing persons to come onto the premises, of establishing a price on items of personal property based on what those persons were willing to pay, and of selling them the items accordingly. Later the sheriff paid these proceeds to the Dickersons.

Kirchner asked the sheriff two or three times at the site if he was going “to stop them from cleaning this place up.” The sheriff testified:

Q. Each time you were asked that, your reply was no, you were not going to stop them; is that correct? A. That’s correct.
Q. And you didn’t stop them? A. No, I didn’t.

The contents of the mobile home were not removed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Davis v. City of Waterloo
551 N.W.2d 876 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1996)
Fink v. Kitzman
881 F. Supp. 1347 (N.D. Iowa, 1995)
Jaeger v. Dubuque County
880 F. Supp. 640 (N.D. Iowa, 1995)
O'BRYAN v. KTIV Television
868 F. Supp. 1146 (N.D. Iowa, 1994)
Pulla v. Amoco Oil Co.
882 F. Supp. 836 (S.D. Iowa, 1994)
Rouse v. Farmers State Bank of Jewell, Iowa
866 F. Supp. 1191 (N.D. Iowa, 1994)
Hoffman v. National Medical Enterprises, Inc.
442 N.W.2d 123 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1989)
Torner v. Reagen
437 N.W.2d 553 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1989)
City of Gladewater v. Pike
727 S.W.2d 514 (Texas Supreme Court, 1987)
Pfiffner v. Roth
379 N.W.2d 357 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1985)
Rhiner v. City of Clive
373 N.W.2d 466 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1985)
Bethards v. Shivvers, Inc.
355 N.W.2d 39 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1984)
Briner v. Hyslop
337 N.W.2d 858 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1983)
Dickerson v. Young
332 N.W.2d 93 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1983)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
332 N.W.2d 93, 1983 Iowa Sup. LEXIS 1437, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/dickerson-v-young-iowa-1983.