Demery v. Dupree

511 So. 2d 1268
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedAugust 19, 1987
Docket18852-CA
StatusPublished
Cited by12 cases

This text of 511 So. 2d 1268 (Demery v. Dupree) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Demery v. Dupree, 511 So. 2d 1268 (La. Ct. App. 1987).

Opinion

511 So.2d 1268 (1987)

James E. DEMERY, Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
D.R. DUPREE, d/b/a Dupree Trucking, et al., Defendants-Appellants.

No. 18852-CA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

August 19, 1987.
Writ Denied November 13, 1987.

*1269 Kelly & Salim by Robert L. Salim, Natchitoches, for plaintiff-appellee.

Culpepper, Teat, Caldwell & Avery by James D. Caldwell, Jonesboro, for defendants-appellants.

Before HALL, C.J., and JASPER E. JONES and FRED W. JONES, JR., JJ.

HALL, Chief Judge.

From a judgment in favor of plaintiff awarding worker's compensation benefits, penalties and attorney's fees, the defendant statutory employer, Paul Shaw, Inc., and its insurer, Protective Casualty Insurance Company, appealed, raising issues of peremption and prematurity, statutory employer relationship, entitlement to penalties and attorney's fees, entitlement to travel expenses, and duration of disability. For reasons set forth in this opinion, we amend to delete the award of penalties and attorney's fees against the employer, and otherwise affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Donald R. Dupree operated D.R. Dupree Trucking Company as a sole proprietorship to perform contract hauling and logging jobs. Plaintiff was employed by Dupree as a truck driver on a logging crew. Paul Shaw, Inc. operated as a timber dealer with Billy Shaw as its president and sole stockholder. Paul Shaw, Inc., who had a contract to furnish wood to International Paper Company, had purchased merchantable timber from Mike Weaver and entered into an agreement with Dupree to cut and haul timber from the Weaver tract to the International Paper mill in Coushatta. At the time of the accident giving rise to this litigation, Dupree was not doing logging work for anyone other than Paul Shaw, Inc.

On Thursday, January 17,1985, Dupree's logging crew, including plaintiff as a truck driver, began work on the Weaver tract. On that day, plaintiff transported skidders to the Weaver tract on a lowboy hooked to one of Dupree's trucks. After unloading the skidders, plaintiff returned the truck with the lowboy still attached to Dupree's yard in Coushatta. On Friday, plaintiff drove another Dupree truck with a pole trailer to the Weaver tract where he loaded it with logs before taking it to the International *1270 Paper mill later that same day. This same trailer was again loaded with logs on Friday but was not taken to the mill. On Saturday, plaintiff and others went to Dupree's yard to prepare to go to work on the Weaver tract. Plaintiff unhooked the lowboy from the truck that he had driven on Thursday and was in the process of hooking up a log trailer to the same truck when the landing gear on the trailer fell and struck his leg, resulting in a displaced fracture of plaintiff's left distal tibia or shin bone.

The accident was reported to Billy Shaw of Paul Shaw, Inc. who notified Protective Casualty of the claim. After investigation, the insurer refused to pay compensation benefits.

On April 2, 1985, plaintiff filed a claim for compensation with the Office of Worker's Compensation Administration (OWCA) listing Billy Shaw, International Paper Company and Donald Dupree as his employers and Protective Casualty as the insurer. On July 9, 1985 a certificate was issued by OWCA stating that a recommendation had been issued, that the parties listed had received the recommendation of the office and none had rejected it, and therefore they were conclusively presumed to have accepted the recommendation as provided in LSA-R.S. 23:1310.1. Only the plaintiff, his attorney and Dupree were listed on the certificate as parties. The record does not disclose the content of the OWCA's recommendation.

On August 26, 1985 plaintiff filed this suit for worker's compensation benefits against Donald R. Dupree, d/b/a D.R. Dupree Trucking Company, Billy Shaw and International Paper Co., attaching to his petition copies of the claim filed with OWCA and the OWCA certificate. Plaintiff later amended his petition to add Paul Shaw, Inc. and its insurer Protective Casualty Insurance Company as defendants and dismissed his claim against Billy Shaw. Dupree asserted third party demands against Paul Shaw, Inc., Protective Casualty, International Paper Company, and Dobson Pulpwood, Inc. Dupree dismissed his claim against Dobson Pulpwood prior to trial. Exceptions of prematurity filed by Billy Shaw, International Paper Company, Paul Shaw, Inc. and Protective Casualty were overruled and the case went to trial. After plaintiff rested his case, the trial court granted International Paper Company's motion for a directed verdict. After trial, the district court granted judgment in favor of plaintiff against Paul Shaw, Inc. and Protective Casualty for worker's compensation benefits in the amount of $248.00 per week for 42 weeks for a total of $10,416.00, plus medical expenses incurred together with travel expenses in the amount of 23 ¢ per mile, statutory penalties and attorney's fees in the amount of $4,500.00, together with legal interest thereon from date of judicial demand until paid. All claims against Dupree were denied. Paul Shaw, Inc. and Protective Casualty appealed, and filed an exception of peremption in this court.

ISSUES

Appellants, Paul Shaw, Inc. and Protective Casualty, raise the following issues on appeal:

1. Whether the exception of prematurity filed by appellants should have been sustained;
2. Whether plaintiff's failure to reject the OWCA's recommendation perempts his cause of action against appellants for compensation benefits;
3. Whether Paul Shaw, Inc. was plaintiff's statutory employer;
4. Whether Paul Shaw, Inc. was erroneously cast for penalties and attorney's fees along with its insurer;
5. Whether plaintiff failed to prove his travel expenses for medical treatment; and
6. Whether plaintiff was erroneously awarded benefits for a period of time following his release from treatment.

PREMATURITY

Appellants filed an exception of prematurity based on their lack of notice of the OWCA proceedings and plaintiff's noncompliance with LSA-R.S. 23:1310.1. The trial court denied the exceptions.

*1271 Plaintiff submitted a claim to OWCA listing Billy Shaw, International Paper and Donald Dupree as his employers and Protective Casualty as the insurer. OWCA issued a recommendation listing only Dupree as employer/party and then issued a certificate of no rejection. Plaintiff subsequently filed this suit.

It appears that plaintiff did all he was required to do in filing his claim with OWCA. Although Paul Shaw, Inc. was not listed in the claim, the corporation's president and sole stockholder was listed along with its insurer. If those parties did not receive notice of the claim, it was the fault of OWCA and not plaintiff. The recommendation of OWCA apparently did not deal with plaintiff's claim against Shaw and Protective Casualty and to this extent did not comply with OWCA's statutory duty to issue a recommendation on plaintiff's entire claim against all parties.

Plaintiff complied with LSA-R.S. 23:1310 in filing his claim with OWCA. Since the administrative agency issued no recommendation as to the claim against Paul Shaw, Inc. and Protective Casualty, there was nothing for plaintiff to accept or reject insofar as his claim against those parties is concerned.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Moss v. Tommasi Construction, Inc.
37 So. 3d 492 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010)
Ryan v. Blount Bros. Const., Inc.
927 So. 2d 1242 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2006)
Moran v. G & G CONST.
897 So. 2d 75 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2004)
Spence v. INDUSTRIAL NDT
731 So. 2d 473 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1999)
Salmon v. Exxon Corp.
824 F. Supp. 81 (M.D. Louisiana, 1993)
Bowens v. General Motors Corp.
608 So. 2d 999 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1992)
Howard v. Georgia Pacific Corp.
583 So. 2d 55 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1991)
Frazier v. Conagra, Inc.
552 So. 2d 536 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Banes v. American Mut. Liability Ins. Co.
544 So. 2d 700 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Westley v. Land & Offshore
533 So. 2d 995 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1988)
Grigg v. Fidelity & Casualty Insurance Co.
528 So. 2d 621 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1988)
Demery v. Dupree
514 So. 2d 456 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1987)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
511 So. 2d 1268, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/demery-v-dupree-lactapp-1987.