Commonwealth v. Harding

46 Pa. D. & C.5th 292
CourtPennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Lackawanna County
DecidedApril 13, 2015
DocketNo. 13 CR 1885
StatusPublished

This text of 46 Pa. D. & C.5th 292 (Commonwealth v. Harding) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Lackawanna County primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Commonwealth v. Harding, 46 Pa. D. & C.5th 292 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2015).

Opinion

MINORA, J.,

Factual Background

On or about May 5, 2013 members of the Scranton Police Department were dispatched by the Lackawanna County Communications Center to the 700 block of Vine Street in the City of Scranton, Lackawanna County, Pennsylvania. The nature of the call was that a male had been shot in this geographic area. Upon their arrival the police found a black male, later determined to be Rashan Crowder, lying in the roadway with a gunshot wound to the chest.

Medical personnel were summoned and arrived at the scene. These personnel unsuccessfully initiated life saving measures. They subsequently transferred Mr. Crowder to Geisinger Community Medical Center. The victim, Rashan Crowder was later pronounced dead at Geisinger.

On May 6,2013 an autopsy was performed by a forensic pathologist on the decedent. The results of that autopsy as noted by Lackawanna County Coroner Tim Rowland indicated that Crowder, the decedent, had sustained two gunshot wounds, one to the chest and one to his right thigh. The cause of death was the gunshot wound to his chest. The manner of death was listed as a homicide. As a result of the initial investigation and the autopsy findings the police began a criminal investigation into this incident.

The police investigation determined that Crowder was a student at Lackawanna College and lived across Vine Street from the site of his death in the Tobin Hall dormitory of Lackawanna College. Numerous witnesses, not all in concurrence, led police to determine what occurred on or about May 5, 2013.

[295]*295Decedent Crowder was apparently accompanied on that fateful night by a friend named Shaquille Isbell. Isbell was an eye witness to the relevant events. Isbell told police that he was a friend of decedent Crowder and attended Lackawanna College with him.

Earlier that evening Isbell and Crowder attended a house party in the 400 block of Monroe Avenue in Scranton about two blocks from the area of the shooting. There may have been some words exchanged at the party but Isbell and Crowder peacefully left that party and walked to other locations in their Hill Section neighborhood and to a mini mart and returned to their dormitory. After the passage of time Isbell and Crowder left their dormitory and returned again to the mini mart.

Upon leaving the mini mart to return, for the second time, to their dormitory they happened upon a group of males and females on the comer of Monroe Avenue and Vine Street just up the street from the original party earlier that evening. The two groups began to give each other “attitude” and trash talking and insults back and forth. The unfortunate result of this exchange was that a male member of the group produced a handgun firing it at Rashan Crowder striking him in the right thigh. After the shooting, a University of Scranton security car happened to arrive at the scene thus causing the two groups to separate and walk down the 800 block of Vine Street from Monroe Avenue towards Madison Avenue, the location of the Tobin Hall dormitory. During this one block plus walk, words, trash talk and insults resumed.

The arguments continue beyond Madison Avenue on Vine Street to an area in the 700 block of Vine Street near Moir Court. At that point, a second male from the group begins to goad the male into shooting the decedent for [296]*296a second time. Repeatedly, the second male encourages and urges the first male to fire again. When the second shot occurs, it hits decedent Crowder in the chest fatally injuring him. At that point, the group of males and females all flee the area.

Subsequent interviews and investigation and review of security video revealed that the shooter was our defendant, Ryan Harding. He was determined to be the man holding the gun. The co-defendant, Marlon Clotter was also identified as the male coaxing, encouraging and goading Ryan Harding to fire two shots at decedent Rashan Crowder.

Ryan Harding was bom on May 13, 1995. At the time of this offense on May 5, 2013, Harding had just turned eighteen (18) years of age two days prior to the crime. At the time of sentencing, Harding was nineteen (19) years of age.

Ryan Harding’s Criminal Complaint

As a result of the slaying on May 9, 2014, the City of Scranton Police Department filed two police complaints, one against Ryan Harding and one against Marlon Clotter.

The criminal complaint and subsequent criminal information against Harding alleges that Harding fatally shot Crowder. It charges Harding with murder in the first degree, 18 Pa. C.S.A. §2502(a) and murder in the third degree, 18 Pa. C.S.A. §2502(c) and two criminal conspiracy counts to commit murder in the first and third degree, 18 Pa. C.S.A. §903(a)(l). Other charged criminal conduct includes two counts of aggravated assault, 18 Pa. C.S.A. §2702(a)(l) for the handgun shooting of Crowder in both the right thigh and the chest.

[297]*297Finally, Harding was charged with two weapons charges: Possession of Firearm Prohibited, 18 Pa. C.S.A. §6105(a)(l) and firearms not to be carried without license, 18 Pa. C.S.A. §6106(a)(l).

On May 21, 2013, Harding was arrested in Syracuse, New York based upon the arrest warrant prepared pursuant to the May 9, 2013 criminal complaint.

Procedural Background

On August 30,2013, Clotter’s preliminary hearing was held before magisterial district judge Sean McGraw. On September 30, 2013 by order of president judge Thomas J. Munley, the undersigned was appointed to preside over this case. On November 7, 2013, discovery deadlines and motion deadlines were set as well as a tentative trial date for August of 2014. On November 6, 2013, the district attorney for Lackawanna County issued a four count bill of information against Clotter. Defendant Clotter was formally arraigned the same day. Defendant Harding who had initially fled was later arrested in Syracuse, New York.

On January 15,2014, defense counsel filed an extensive omnibus motion on behalf of defendant Clotter. Defendant Harding joined in as well as filing his own motion. The Commonwealth responded to the omnibus on February 4, 2014. On July 3, 2014, the court decided both Harding’s and Clotter’s voluminous omnibus motion in a lengthy consolidated opinion.

On November 5, 2014, a joint sentencing hearing was held for both defendant Clotter and the shooter, our defendant Ryan Harding. After consultation with the court reporter, it was determined that this joint proceeding began on November 5, 2014 at 10:01 a.m. and concluded at 1:30 p.m. It is most unusual for a sentencing proceeding [298]*298to take three and one half hours even if a joint one. In this case, it was done to allow extensive victim/family/ friend testimony and also to allow substantial defendant allocution. The court covers its reasons for the sentencing scheme for defendant Harding starting at page 121 to page 192, N.T. Proceedings of Sentencing, 11/5/14.

Subsequent to sentencing, on November 14, 2014, counsel for defendant Harding filed a reconsideration of sentence. That motion was denied on November 17, 2014 by order of this court. Defendant Harding’s notice of appeal to the Pennsylvania Superior Court was filed on December 15,2014 and their concise statement of matters complained of on appeal was filed on February 20, 2015, thus giving rise to this opinion.

Appellate Arguments of Defendant Harding

A.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Grady v. Frito-Lay, Inc.
839 A.2d 1038 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 2003)
Commonwealth v. Walls
926 A.2d 957 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 2007)
Commonwealth v. Robinson
931 A.2d 15 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2007)
Commonwealth v. Smith
673 A.2d 893 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1996)
Commonwealth v. Greer
554 A.2d 980 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1989)
Commonwealth v. Bishop
831 A.2d 656 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2003)
Commonwealth v. Lewis
911 A.2d 558 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2006)
Commonwealth v. Jones
613 A.2d 587 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 1992)
Commonwealth v. Prisk
13 A.3d 526 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2011)
Commonwealth v. Evans
901 A.2d 528 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2006)
Commonwealth v. Austin
66 A.3d 798 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2013)
Commonwealth v. Antidormi
84 A.3d 736 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2014)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
46 Pa. D. & C.5th 292, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/commonwealth-v-harding-pactcompllackaw-2015.