Caddo-Shreveport Sales & Use Tax Com'n v. OMV THROUGH DEPT. OF PUB. SAFETY AND CORRS.

710 So. 2d 776, 1998 WL 171788
CourtSupreme Court of Louisiana
DecidedApril 14, 1998
Docket97-CA-2233
StatusPublished
Cited by44 cases

This text of 710 So. 2d 776 (Caddo-Shreveport Sales & Use Tax Com'n v. OMV THROUGH DEPT. OF PUB. SAFETY AND CORRS.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Louisiana primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Caddo-Shreveport Sales & Use Tax Com'n v. OMV THROUGH DEPT. OF PUB. SAFETY AND CORRS., 710 So. 2d 776, 1998 WL 171788 (La. 1998).

Opinion

710 So.2d 776 (1998)

CADDO-SHREVEPORT SALES AND USE TAX COMMISSION
v.
OFFICE OF MOTOR VEHICLES Through the DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY AND CORRECTIONS OF THE STATE of Louisiana.

No. 97-CA-2233.

Supreme Court of Louisiana.

April 14, 1998.

*777 Richard P. Ieyoub, Atty. Gen., Michael C. Barron, Stephen A. Quidd, Thomas S. Halligan, Baton Rouge, for Applicant.

Richard G. Barham, Barham & Warner, Shreveport, for Respondent.

MARCUS, Justice.[*]

This case comes before us on direct appeal pursuant to La. Const. art. V, § 5 for our review of a ruling of the trial court declaring La. R.S. 47:303(B)(3)(a) and (b)(i) unconstitutional and unenforceable to the extent that the Commissioner of the Louisiana State Office of Motor Vehicles is mandated to collect local sales and use taxes levied by political subdivisions of the State of Louisiana on motor vehicles absent a voluntary contract between the political subdivisions and the state Vehicle Commissioner.

The Caddo-Shreveport Sales and Use Tax Commission (hereinafter the "Commission"), the central collector of taxes for the parish, filed suit for a declaratory judgment asserting that it was being unconstitutionally prohibited from collecting locally levied sales and use taxes on motor vehicles by the operation of La. R.S. 47:303. That statute dictates that local tax collectors must enter into an agreement to use the Vehicle Commissioner of the Office of Motor Vehicles (hereinafter "OMV") as agent to collect local motor vehicle sales and use taxes. The Commission argued that La. Const. arts. VI, § 29(A) and VII, § 3(A) & (B) confer upon local governments the power to levy and collect all local sales and use taxes. No exceptions are made in the constitution with respect to local taxes on motor vehicles. In short, the Commission argued that the legislature has no right to require that OMV collect local taxes against the Commission's wishes or to designate a collection agent for the Commission. OMV responded that it was acting only as an agent of the Commission and that the constitution does not expressly forbid the legislature from designating agents for local tax collectors.

The Commission and OMV filed cross motions for summary judgment, agreeing that there were no material issues of fact in dispute and that only an issue of law, the constitutionality of the statute, was presented for resolution. The trial judge granted the motion for summary judgment filed by the *778 Commission and denied the cross motion filed by OMV. OMV filed a suspensive appeal to this court. The sole issue presented for our review is the constitutionality of La. R.S. 47:303(B)(3)(a) and (b)(i).[1]

La. R.S. 47:303(B)(3)(a) and (b) provide:

(3)(a) It is not the intention of this Subsection to grant an exemption from the sales and use tax levied in this Title to any sale, use, items, or transaction which has heretofore been taxable, and this Subsection is not to be construed as so doing. It is the intent of this Subsection to transfer the collection of state and political subdivision sales and use taxes on vehicles from the vendor to the vehicle commissioner as agent for the secretary of the Department of Revenue and Taxation and for the collectors of such political subdivision taxes and to provide a method of collection of the tax directly from the vendee or user by the vehicle commissioner as agent of the secretary and such collectors.
(b)(i) The vehicle commissioner and the governing body of any political subdivision as defined in Article VI, Section 44(2) of the Constitution of Louisiana, in which a sales or use tax has been imposed by such political subdivision on the sale or use of motor vehicles, shall enter into an agreement by which the vehicle commissioner shall collect such tax on behalf of the political subdivision. Except as provided in Paragraph (5) of this Subsection, no certificate of title or vehicle registration license shall be issued until such local tax is paid.
(ii) The tax imposed by the political subdivisions on the sale or use of vehicles subject to the Vehicle Registration License Tax Law (R.S. 47:451 et seq.) shall be collected by the vehicle commissioner and distributed to the political subdivisions as provided for in R.S. 47:301(10)(f) and (18)(b). The vehicle commissioner shall withhold from any such taxes collected for the political subdivisions one percent of the proceeds of the tax so collected, which shall be used by the commissioner to pay the cost of collecting and remitting the tax to the political subdivisions.
(iii) The vehicle commissioner shall cause to be conducted annually, by the legislative auditor, an audit or examination of the books and accounts of sales and use taxes collected by the vehicle commissioner for each political subdivision. The scope of the audit shall be sufficient to determine whether or not sales and use taxes collected for each political subdivision have been properly and correctly distributed in accordance with law during the period under audit. The cost of such audit shall be prorated to all local political subdivisions for whom the vehicle commissioner collects sales and use taxes on the basis of total tax dollars distributed to each local political subdivision, and the vehicle commissioner shall withhold the cost of such audit from taxes collected. In the event the audit determines that adjustments to tax distributions are required, the vehicle commissioner shall adjust future tax distributions to applicable tax recipient bodies. The prescriptive period for adjustments under this Section shall be three years from the thirty-first day of December of the year in which such taxes became due.
(iv) All such agreements now existing between any political subdivisions and the *779 secretary are hereby declared valid and the functions of the secretary thereunder are hereby transferred to the director of public safety as vehicle commissioner (emphasis added).

The Commission asserts that the statute violates the constitution because the constitution grants the power to levy and collect local taxes to local governments and provides that there shall be a single tax collector of such taxes within each parish. The Commission relies on the following provisions of the Louisiana Constitution:

Art. VI, § 29. Local Governmental Subdivisions and School Boards; Sales Tax

Section 29. (A) Sales Tax Authorized. Except as otherwise authorized in a home rule charter as provided for in Section 4 of this Article, the governing authority of any local governmental subdivision or school board may levy and collect a tax upon the sale at retail, the use, the lease or rental, the consumption, and the storage for use or consumption, of tangible personal property and on sales of services as defined by law, if approved by a majority of the electors voting thereon in an election held for that purpose. The rate thereof, when combined with the rate of all other sales and use taxes, exclusive of state sales and use taxes, levied and collected within any local governmental subdivision, shall not exceed three percent (emphasis added).

Art. VII, § 3. Collection of Taxes

(B)(1) Notwithstanding any contrary provision of this constitution,

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Kishbaugh v. City of Lafayette Gov't
275 So. 3d 471 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2019)
Voice of the Ex-Offender v. State
249 So. 3d 857 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2018)
Billeaudeau v. Opelousas Gen. Hosp. Auth.
239 So. 3d 306 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2018)
Shepherd v. Schedler
209 So. 3d 752 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2016)
canal/claiborne, Limited v. Stonehedge Development, LLC
156 So. 3d 627 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2014)
Louisiana Federation of Teachers v. State
171 So. 3d 835 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2014)
Johnson v. Harrison
150 So. 3d 30 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2014)
State v. Webb
144 So. 3d 971 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2014)
Retired State Employees Ass'n v. State
119 So. 3d 568 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2013)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
710 So. 2d 776, 1998 WL 171788, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/caddo-shreveport-sales-use-tax-comn-v-omv-through-dept-of-pub-safety-la-1998.