Bank of Crestwood v. Gravois Bank

616 S.W.2d 505, 1981 Mo. LEXIS 312
CourtSupreme Court of Missouri
DecidedMay 11, 1981
Docket62179
StatusPublished
Cited by18 cases

This text of 616 S.W.2d 505 (Bank of Crestwood v. Gravois Bank) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Missouri primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Bank of Crestwood v. Gravois Bank, 616 S.W.2d 505, 1981 Mo. LEXIS 312 (Mo. 1981).

Opinions

[506]*506WELLIVER, Judge.

The Bank of Crestwood (Crestwood) appeals from a judgment of the circuit court affirming an order of the State Banking Board (Banking Board) which approved the granting of a certificate of authority by the Commissioner (now Director) of Finance to Gravois Bank for the operation of a banking facility in St. Louis County. This cause was originally taken to the Court of Appeals, Eastern District, which reversed the circuit court. The cause was transferred to this Court for examination of the question raised which is one we deemed to be of general interest and a matter of first impression as to the statutes involved. Rule 83.03. The case is determined here as though on original appeal. Mo.Const. Art. V, § 10; Rule 83.09. We affirm the judgment of the Circuit Court.

The facts are simple and for the most part undisputed. Gravois Bank and the site for the proposed facility are both located in an unincorporated section of South St. Louis County. The Gravois Bank’s main banking house is located at Heege and Gra-vois Roads in an area generally known as Affton. The proposed facility site is approximately four and one-half miles west of Gravois Bank’s main banking house at 11659-85 Gravois Road in an area generally known as Sappington. Crestwood is located approximately one and one-half miles north of the proposed facility site. The standing of Crestwood in this action was established in Bank of Crestwood v. State Banking Board, 554 S.W.2d 519 (Mo.App. 1977), where it was ordered that the Banking Board conduct a hearing. Following the hearing, the Banking Board issued findings of fact, conclusions of law and its order confirming the Commissioner’s issuance of a certificate of authority for Gravois Bank to operate a facility at the proposed site.

The Banking Board made the following findings of fact and conclusions of law:

4. Based on the record before the Board taken as a whole, the Board finds:
(a)Gravois Road is an historic artery of travel in South St. Louis County, Missouri, running southwest from the City of St. Louis through the City of Fenton, Missouri.
(b) In the late 1800’s and the early 1900’s, major family landholdings along Gravois Road were dissolved and the entire length of Gravois Road in St. Louis County was bordered almost exclusively by small farms and truck gardens. This agricultural community was populated primarily by persons of German ancestry who had many occupational and social connections.
(c) In the late 1800’s the area located around the intersection of Gravois and Tesson Ferry Roads became known as Aff’s town (later Affton) after a merchant who maintained a post office at that intersection. A short distance to the west on Gravois Road, the name Sapping-ton was given to the area around the intersection of Gravois and Sappington Roads. The distance between Gravois Bank in the area known as Affton and the proposed facility site in the area known as Sappington is approximately 4.6 straight-line miles.
(d) Gravois Bank was chartered in 1913. Of its none initial directors, four came from the Sappington area. From and after the time of incorporation, Gra-vois Bank was the only bank located on Gravois Road between Grand Avenue in the City of St. Louis and the City of Fenton, located south of the Meramec River. From the time of its organization, many of the farming families and merchants in the area along Gravois Road in St. Louis County patronized the bank. The evidence presented to the Board shows that substantial numbers of persons in the unincorporated areas of Aff-ton and Sappington along Gravois Road maintain deposit and loan accounts at the Gravois Bank. These accounts are substantially greater in dollar amount than accounts maintained with Gravois Bank by residents of the Lemay area which is geographically much closer to Gravois Bank and its existing facility. The banking habits of the residents of the Affton and Sappington areas suggest the exist[507]*507ence of a community for banking purposes.
(e) Statistical data presented to the Board indicates that housing values and income levels throughout the entire area along Gravois Road in St. Louis County fall in the middle to upper middle categories. More than two-thirds of the entire working population of the area is engaged in white collar occupations and most workers of all classifications leave the area daily for commercial and industrial centers of St. Louis and St. Louis County for their employment. Most of the residential housing stock in this area is less than thirty years of age.
(f) Residents in the Affton and Sap-pington areas are in close proximity geographically and obtain most municipal type services from the same source, the charter government of St. Louis County. Emergency services are obtained through the same sources and all police services are rendered through the third precinct of the St. Louis County Police Department. An Affton school district and an Affton fire protection district exist as political subdivisions in the area. No political subdivision bearing the name Sap-pington exists. An examination of the boundaries of school districts and fire protection districts as well as non-legal boundaries such as postal zip codes, Catholic parish boundaries and census designated places shows that few boundaries coincide. This evidence leads the Board to conclude that each of such boundaries was drawn for reasons related to the purpose or objective of the political or social entity encompassed therein.
(g) In addition to the evidence relating to the common banking habits of the people in the places designated as Affton and Sappington, other credible evidence was presented to the Board by disinterested parties including a veteran locally elected official, a long-time community newspaper editor and a St. Louis County Planning Department professional staff member, each of which verified that common backgrounds, traits and concerns exist among the families populating the unincorporated areas of South St. Louis County and further that no valid basis existed for distinguishing between residents in the Affton and Sappington areas along Gravois Road in South St. Louis County.
(h)The Bank of Crestwood was incorporated in 1958. For over forty years prior to the incorporation of that bank, the Gravois Bank had served the Gravois Road community of people including both the Affton and Sappington areas. The relative proximity of the two locations and the substantial number of accounts representing people who have relied upon the Gravois Bank for banking services in the Sappington area lead the Board to believe that an unnecessarily restrictive interpretation of the term ‘community’ would render a disservice to the people who have been served by the Gravois Bank. Since the only issue before the Banking Board, by stipulation, is the interpretation of the term ‘community,’ it is clear that an interpretation which allows the Gravois Bank to continue to serve its customers in the Sappington area will contribute to the convenience and needs of the community which Gravois Bank has served and will continue to serve.
CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. The judicial precedents to which the Board has been referred by counsel indicate that the legal concept of ‘community’ is a broad and flexible one and one which changes shape depending upon the purposes for which the term is applied.
2.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Schneider v. State, Division of Water Safety
748 S.W.2d 677 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1988)
In the Interest of P.A.W. v. A.M.W.
716 S.W.2d 284 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1986)
Paw v. Amw
716 S.W.2d 284 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1986)
Juvenile Officer v. Ward
707 S.W.2d 814 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1986)
In Re SPW
707 S.W.2d 814 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1986)
Bay Finance Co. v. Missouri Commission on Human Rights
701 S.W.2d 562 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1985)
State Ex Rel. Lack v. Melton
692 S.W.2d 302 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1985)
Sermchief v. Gonzales
660 S.W.2d 683 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1983)
Bartley v. Special School District of St. Louis County
649 S.W.2d 864 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1983)
Eminence R-1 School District v. Hodge
635 S.W.2d 10 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1982)
Brooks v. Pool-Leffler
636 S.W.2d 113 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1982)
Oakville Bank & Trust Co. v. Lemay Bank & Trust Co.
628 S.W.2d 350 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1981)
Eureka Fire Protection District of St. Louis County v. Hoene
623 S.W.2d 79 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1981)
Bank of Crestwood v. Gravois Bank
616 S.W.2d 505 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1981)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
616 S.W.2d 505, 1981 Mo. LEXIS 312, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/bank-of-crestwood-v-gravois-bank-mo-1981.