Aiken v. United States

4 Cl. Ct. 685, 1984 U.S. Claims LEXIS 1472
CourtUnited States Court of Claims
DecidedMarch 6, 1984
DocketNo. 626-82C
StatusPublished
Cited by10 cases

This text of 4 Cl. Ct. 685 (Aiken v. United States) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Court of Claims primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Aiken v. United States, 4 Cl. Ct. 685, 1984 U.S. Claims LEXIS 1472 (cc 1984).

Opinion

OPINION

LYDON, Judge:

This is an action against the United States for damages based on an alleged breach of a scholarship agreement between plaintiff and the Public Health Service, Department Of Health, Education and Welfare (HEW) (now Department of Health And Human Services). Plaintiff seeks to recover $36,042 plus legal interest.1 Defendant denies that it breached the scholarship agreement, but insists, instead, that plaintiff did, and that as a result thereof defendant is entitled to recover on its counterclaim.2

Both plaintiff and defendant have moved for summary judgment based on the following facts which were taken from the pleadings, affidavits and documentation appended to the briefs of the parties. There is no dispute about the material facts. Upon consideration of the submissions of the parties, and after oral argument, it is concluded that plaintiff is not entitled to recover but that defendant is entitled to judgment on its counterclaim.

I.

On October 27, 1972, the Emergency Health Personnel Act Amendments of 1972 was approved. Pub.L. No. 92-585, 86 Stat. 1290. This Act amended the Public Health Service Act. See 42 U.S.C. § 201, et seq. (1976). Under Pub.L. No. 92-585, the Secretary of HEW was authorized to establish the Public Health and National Health Ser[687]*687vice Corps Scholarship Training Program.3 The purpose of this program was to obtain trained physicians, dentists, and other health-related specialists for the National Health Service Corps and other units of the Public Health Service (PHS). The Secretary was, in furtherance of this purpose, authorized to award scholarships to applicants covering basic tuition, books, supplies, equipment, student medical expenses and other necessary educational expenses which were not otherwise paid as a part of the basic tuition payment. Such a scholarship was related to pursuit of an approved course of study in an accredited educational institution leading to a degree in medicine, dentistry, or other health-related speciality. Each scholarship was for approved academic training for a period not to exceed 4 years, and involved amounts prescribed by the Secretary and payable in monthly installments.

Section 225 of Pub.L. No. 92-585 provided in pertinent part as follows:

(e) A person participating in the Program shall be obligated to serve on active duty as a commissioned officer in the Service or as a civilian member of the National Health Service Corps following completion of academic training, for a period of time prescribed by the Secretary which will not be less than one year of service on active duty for each academic year of training received under the Program. At least one-half of the period of service required by the preceding sentence must be spent providing health care and services (1) in an area designated under section 329(b), (2) as a member of the Indian Health Service or the Federal Health Programs Service and in an area (determined under section 329 or otherwise) to have a health manpower shortage, or (3) in connection with any program, designated by the Secretary, for the provision of health care and services in such an area. For persons receiving a degree from a school of medicine, osteopathy, or dentistry, the commencement of a period of obligated service can be deferred for the period of time required to complete internship and residency training. For persons receiving degrees in other health professions the obligated service period will commence upon completion of their academic training. Periods of internship or residency shall not be creditable in satisfying an active duty service obligation under this subsection unless the internship or residency is served in a facility of the Service or other facility of the National Health Service Corps.4
(f)(1) If, for any reason, a person fails to complete an active duty service obligation under this section, he shall be liable for the payment of an amount equal to the cost of tuition and other education expenses, and scholarship payments, paid under this section, plus interest at the maximum legal prevailing rate. Any amount which the United States is entitled to recover under this paragraph shall, within the three-year period beginning on the date the United States becomes entitled to recover such amount, be paid to the United States.
(2) When a person undergoing training in the Program is academically dismissed or voluntarily terminates academic training, he shall be liable for repayment to the Government for an amount equal to [688]*688the cost of tuition and other educational expenses paid to or for him from Federal funds plus any scholarship payments which he received under the program.

On September 30, 1974, plaintiff filed an application for enrollment in the PHS’s Health Professions Scholarship Program. In his application, in response to a question as to his future plans, plaintiff wrote: “Possibly General Practice, or Family Medicine.” At this time, plaintiff was a first year medical student at Tulane University School of Medicine.

On or about May 6, 1975,5 plaintiff received a Notice of Scholarship Award covering the period July 1, 1974 — June 30, 1975, under which plaintiff was to be paid a stipend of $6,700, with monthly payments of $750, and his tuition and fees of $2,616 were to be paid for him. In his Notice Of Scholarship Award, plaintiff was advised: “Total Period of Support Recommended 7/1/74 — 6/30/78.”

The Notice Of Scholarship Award set forth certain “Conditions Of Award.” These “Conditions Of Award” provided in pertinent part:

1. This award is made upon the condition that the awardee agrees to fulfill the service obligation as specified by Section 225 of the Public Health Service Act and implemented in the governing regulations (42 CFR, Part 62) as follows:
(a) A scholarship recipient is obligated to serve on active duty for one year as a Commissioned Officer in the Public Health Service or as a civilian member of the National Health Service Corps following completion of academic training for each academic year of support or fraction thereof received under this program:
* * * * * *
(c) For recipients receiving a degree from a school of medicine or osteopathy, the commencement of a period of obligated service may be deferred for a period of time not to exceed one year for internship (or equivalent training) and for good cause shown, at the option of the Secretary for an additional period of time for residency training. Such period of internship and residency shall not be creditable in satisfying an active duty service obligation, unless such internship and residency is served in a facility of the Public Health Service, or other facility of the National Health Service Corps.
2. In accordance with Section 225(f) and the implementing regulations:
(a) If, for any reason a participant fails to complete an active duty service obligation, such participant shall be liable for the payment of an amount equal to the scholarship payments, tuition and other educational fees paid, plus interest at the maximum legal prevailing rate running from the date such payments were made.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Mangual v. United States
27 Fed. Cl. 480 (Federal Claims, 1993)
Haberman v. United States
38 Cont. Cas. Fed. 76,420 (Court of Claims, 1992)
Rendleman v. Bowen
860 F.2d 1537 (Ninth Circuit, 1988)
United States v. Turner
660 F. Supp. 1323 (E.D. New York, 1987)
Fisher v. Bowen
659 F. Supp. 784 (D. Oregon, 1987)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
4 Cl. Ct. 685, 1984 U.S. Claims LEXIS 1472, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/aiken-v-united-states-cc-1984.