W. VA. CONSOL. PUB. RETIRE. BD. v. Weaver

671 S.E.2d 673
CourtWest Virginia Supreme Court
DecidedOctober 10, 2008
Docket33864
StatusPublished

This text of 671 S.E.2d 673 (W. VA. CONSOL. PUB. RETIRE. BD. v. Weaver) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering West Virginia Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
W. VA. CONSOL. PUB. RETIRE. BD. v. Weaver, 671 S.E.2d 673 (W. Va. 2008).

Opinion

671 S.E.2d 673 (2008)

WEST VIRGINIA CONSOLIDATED PUBLIC RETIREMENT BOARD, Petitioner Below, Appellee,
v.
Jerry Allen WEAVER, A Retiree of the West Virginia Public Employees Retirement System, Respondent Below, Appellant.

No. 33864.

Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia.

Submitted September 24, 2008.
Decided October 10, 2008.

*675 Leah Perry Macia, Stephanie L. Ojeda, Eric E. Kinder, Randal M. Whitlatch, Spilman Thomas & Battle, PLLC, Charleston, for Appellant.

J. Jeaneen Legato, West Virginia Consolidated Public Retirement Board, Charleston, for Appellee.

DAVIS, Justice.[1]

The appellant herein and respondent below, Jerry Allen Weaver (hereinafter "Mr. Weaver"), appeals from an order entered July 23, 2007, by the Circuit Court of Kanawha County. By that order, the circuit court determined that Mr. Weaver, who is a retiree of the West Virginia Public Employees Retirement System (hereinafter "PERS"), had forfeited his right to receive benefits therefrom because he had rendered "less than honorable service" in violation of W. Va.Code § 5-10A-1 (1976) (Repl.Vol.2006) and W. Va. Code § 5-10A-2(e)(2) (2005) (Repl.Vol.2006). *676 Specifically, the circuit court determined that because Mr. Weaver, who, prior to his retirement, had served as the elected Assessor of Lincoln County from 1980 until 2006, had been convicted of the felony of conspiracy to buy votes pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 371 (1994) (Repl.Vol.2008), such crime constituted a "[c]onviction of a participant of a felony for conduct related to his ... office ... which he... committed while holding the office" in violation of W. Va.Code § 5-10A-2(e)(2). On appeal to this Court, Mr. Weaver contends that the circuit court erred by concluding that his conviction of conspiracy to buy votes was related to his office as Assessor insofar as he claims that he did not benefit directly from such conspiracy. Upon a review of the parties' arguments, the pertinent authorities, and the record designated for appellate review, we affirm the ruling of the circuit court.

I.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

The facts underlying the instant appeal are largely undisputed by the parties. Mr. Weaver served as the elected Assessor of Lincoln County from 1980 until he resigned from that office on December 30, 2005.[2] When Mr. Weaver retired on January 1, 2006, he had twenty-seven years and six months of credited service with PERS. At the time that the circuit court entered its aforementioned order, Mr. Weaver had been receiving PERS pension benefits of approximately $2,020.79 per month since the date of his retirement.

On August 2, 2005, the United States Attorney's Office charged Mr. Weaver with a single count of participating in a conspiracy to buy votes in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371 (1994) (Repl.Vol.2008).[3] The indictment alleged that Mr. Weaver had participated in the alleged vote-buying conspiracy and committed acts in furtherance thereof from 1990 until 2004; during this same period of time, Mr. Weaver was the elected Assessor of Lincoln County and was a contributing member of PERS. Thereafter, on December 27, 2005, Mr. Weaver entered a plea of guilty. On West Virginia Primary Election Day 2006, i.e. May 9, 2006, the United States District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia sentenced Mr. Weaver to twelve months' imprisonment and fined him $2,000.

During the guilty plea hearing, Mr. Weaver testified that his only role in the alleged conspiracy was as a conduit of monies from one third-party to another third-party. Mr. Weaver claims that he did not directly benefit from the alleged conspiracy insofar as none of the monies were used to buy votes to win his reelection and that he did not use his office in furtherance of the alleged conspiracy insofar as he did not reduce tax assessments or engage in other improper behavior in an attempt to buy votes or to defeat the opponents of the slated candidates. Subsequently, during the sentencing hearing, the district court found that "the defendant [Mr. Weaver] did not abuse his position as assessor of Lincoln County in that he has not shown to have abused that position to facilitate the commission of the conspiracy offense to which he has pled guilty."[4] The court *677 also described Mr. Weaver's involvement in the alleged conspiracy as "a conduit of funds destined for vote buying."

Subsequent to these criminal proceedings, the appellee herein and petitioner below, the West Virginia Consolidated Public Retirement Board (hereinafter "the Board"), by written notice dated September 18, 2006, informed Mr. Weaver that it believed his felony conviction indicated that he had rendered "less than honorable service" and that, as a result thereof, he was no longer eligible to receive pension benefits from PERS. Mr. Weaver then requested the Board to seek a judicial determination as to whether he had rendered "less than honorable service." As a result, the Board filed a petition in the Circuit Court of Kanawha County on November 6, 2006, seeking to terminate Mr. Weaver's retirement benefits. Following responsive pleadings and a hearing on the matter, the circuit court, by order entered July 23, 2007, determined that Mr. Weaver had forfeited his right to receive his PERS retirement benefits. In so ruling, the circuit court observed that "`public service, compensated at public expense, is a public trust and necessarily implies faithful service.... Simply put, public pensions, unlike private-sector pensions, are premised in part upon faithful service of the public trust; therefore, a breach of that trust leads to a forfeiture of a public pension.'" Quoting West Virginia Pub. Employees Ret. Sys. v. Dodd, 183 W.Va. 544, 549 & 553, 396 S.E.2d 725, 730 & 734 (1990) (additional citation omitted), overruled on other grounds by Booth v. Sims, 193 W.Va. 323, 456 S.E.2d 167 (1995). Thus, the circuit court concluded,

[a] fundamental breach of the public trust occurred when an elected official, Respondent [Mr. Weaver], feloniously engaged in a conspiracy to buy votes during elections in which he was a candidate[.]
Respondent's felony conviction is related to his elected position. Respondent became a member of the West Virginia Public Employees Retirement System (PERS) by virtue of holding an elected office and remained a member by repeatedly winning elections. He was convicted of corrupting many of the elections which triggered his eligibility and allowed for his continued participation in the public funded pension system (PERS)[.]
Pursuant to West Virginia Code § 5-10A-1, et seq., the Respondent, Jerry Allen Weaver, has rendered less than honorable service and as a consequence is legally ineligible to receive any benefits as a retirant of the Public Employees Retirement System[.]

(Emphasis in original). Finally, the court ordered that Mr.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Magill v. Louisiana State Police Troop G
714 So. 2d 139 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1998)
Chrystal R.M. v. Charlie A.L.
459 S.E.2d 415 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1995)
State v. Epperly
65 S.E.2d 488 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1951)
Smith v. State Workmen's Compensation Commissioner
219 S.E.2d 361 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1975)
Farley v. Buckalew
414 S.E.2d 454 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1992)
Booth v. Sims
456 S.E.2d 167 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1995)
State Ex Rel. Cohen v. Manchin
336 S.E.2d 171 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1985)
West Virginia Public Employees Retirement System v. Dodd
396 S.E.2d 725 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1990)
State v. General Daniel Morgan Post No. 548
107 S.E.2d 353 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1959)
Ohio County Commission v. Manchin
301 S.E.2d 183 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1983)
Lee-Norse Co. v. Rutledge
291 S.E.2d 477 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1982)
Appalachian Power Co. v. State Tax Department
466 S.E.2d 424 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1995)
Freer v. Weinstein (In Re Weinstein)
173 B.R. 258 (E.D. New York, 1994)
Cpf Agency Corp. v. R&S Towing Service
34 Cal. Rptr. 3d 106 (California Court of Appeal, 2005)
Miners in General Group v. Hix
17 S.E.2d 810 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1941)
State v. General Daniel Morgan Post No. 548
107 S.E.2d 353 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1959)
West Virginia Consolidated Public Retirement Board v. Weaver
671 S.E.2d 673 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 2008)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
671 S.E.2d 673, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/w-va-consol-pub-retire-bd-v-weaver-wva-2008.