Vantrige v. Lloyd's of Louisiana Ins. Co.

543 So. 2d 603, 1989 WL 40784
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedApril 27, 1989
Docket88-CA-1373 to 88-CA-1375
StatusPublished
Cited by3 cases

This text of 543 So. 2d 603 (Vantrige v. Lloyd's of Louisiana Ins. Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Vantrige v. Lloyd's of Louisiana Ins. Co., 543 So. 2d 603, 1989 WL 40784 (La. Ct. App. 1989).

Opinion

543 So.2d 603 (1989)

Clarence VANTRIGE, et al.
v.
LLOYD'S OF LOUISIANA INS. CO., et al.
Eric BRADLEY, et al.
v.
Elaine Williams DOUGLAS, et al.
Louise LEWIS, etc.
v.
Elaine Williams DOUGLAS, et al.

Nos. 88-CA-1373 to 88-CA-1375.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Fourth Circuit.

April 27, 1989.

Louis A. Gerdes, Jr., New Orleans, for plaintiffs/appellants.

Thomas L. Gaudry, Jr., Michael G. Fanning, Windhorst, Gaudry, Talley & Ranson Gretna, Brad G. Theard, Young, Richaud, Theard & Myers, Okla Jones, II, City Atty., Don J. Hernandez, Val K. Schewich, III, *604 Belhia V. Martin, New Orleans, for defendants/appellees.

Before BARRY, KLEES and BECKER, JJ.

BECKER, Judge.

In these consolidated suits arising out of a two car intersectional collision involving a missing stop sign, appeals have resulted from the trial court's judgment finding one driver's negligence the sole cause of the accident. This court concludes that both drivers, the plaintiff and the City of New Orleans, were liable. We reverse and recast the judgment.

The collision occurred at approximately 8:30 p.m. on February 18, 1984 at the intersection of North Johnson and Desire Streets. Desire Street is a two way, favored street, intersected by North Johnson, a two way cross street controlled by stop signs. Both streets appear of equal dignity.

The right quarter of the automobile driven by Robert Douglas, south bound on Desire Street, struck the driver's side of the vehicle driven by Eric Bradley, an off duty Jefferson Parish Sheriff's Deputy, east bound on North Johnson. Bradley was attempting to turn right or south bound onto Desire Street when the accident occurred. The stop sign normally controlling the intersection on the southwest corner of North Johnson was missing. After impact, the Douglas vehicle ended up in the yard of a local resident.

Clarence Vantrige, a guest passenger in the Douglas vehicle, filed suit naming Robert Douglas, his insurer Lloyds of Louisiana, The City of New Orleans, Harry Lee, Sheriff of Jefferson Parish and Eric Bradley as defendants. Harry Lee, Sheriff of Jefferson Parish and Eric Bradley answered and filed a third party demand against Robert Douglas, Lloyds of Louisiana Insurance Company and the City of New Orleans. The City also answered and filed a third party demand against Sheriff Lee and Eric Bradley. Robert Douglas and his insurer did the same. Plaintiff also added as a defendant Sheriff Lee's liability carrier Zurich American Insurance Company. After a trial on the merits the trial judge awarded plaintiff $150,000.00 for pain and suffering, $25,000.00 for past and future medical expenses and $60,000.00 for past and future loss of income. In her reasons for judgment, the trial judge concluded the sole legal cause of the accident was the negligence of Deputy Eric Bradley and that the plaintiff Robert Douglas was free from fault.

Defendants Eric Bradley, Sheriff Lee and Zurich American Insurance Company appeal the judgment from the trial court on liability and damages.

EVIDENCE

On February 18, 1984 at approximately 8:30 p.m., Clarence Vantrige, after leaving work earlier that day went out for the evening with two of his friends, Robert Douglas, who drove the three in his own vehicle, and Pervis Wright. The trio drank beer that evening and were on their way to another restaurant and bar in the city as they drove down Desire Street southbound. As Mr. Douglas drove, Clarence Ventrige, sat in the passenger side of the car and Mr. Wright in the rear of the car, all three conversing as they approached North Johnson on Desire Street.

That same evening, Mr. Eric Bradley, an off duty Jefferson Parish Sheriff's Deputy, was off work and was driving the Jefferson Parish Police car assigned to him. He was heading toward his brother's house on Pauline Street with his daughter and his niece. His brother had just moved and he was not familiar with the area. At about 11:45 p.m. Bradley decided to avoid a backed up intersection by turning one block early and taking the next available parallel street. Bradley turned east onto North Johnson for one block and was approaching its intersection with Desire Street.

Desire Street and North Johnson where they cross each other are both two way black top thoroughfares of roughly the same width. Desire Street runs northsouth; North Johnson runs eastwest. Stop signs on northeast and southwest corners normally control the traffic on North Johnson, *605 however the sign on the southwest corner was missing on the evening of February 18, 1984. According to an accident report taken thirty-three days prior to the accident the stop sign was missing from its location even at that time. Mr. Bradley testified that as he approached Desire Street on North Johnson, intending to turn right, he did not observe a stop sign but, being unfamiliar with the area he cautiously entered the intersection "rolling" through it, looking to his left, then his right and, as he was going into the intersection, left again. This time, when he looked he saw Mr. Douglas's automobile about a car length away, approaching rapidly. Mr. Bradley then testified that he accelerated, hoping to get out of the way but was struck along the left side of his vehicle.

Mr. Douglas was a long time resident of the area familiar with the intersection. He took no precautions as he approached the intersection and was driving at approximately 30 miles per hour along Desire Street when he suddenly observed the white police car, only a few feet away emerge from North Johnson. He then swerved in a vain attempt to avoid the collision but still struck Mr. Bradley's car, bounced off and ended up in the yard of a local resident. A New Orleans Police Department Officer testified that he investigated the accident and observed a number of opened and unopened beer cans in the Douglas car. He further testified that when he spoke with Mr. Douglas about the accident, he noticed a strong smell of alcohol on his breath and observed that Mr. Douglas slurred his words and walked unsteadily. He noted that the stop sign controlling North Johnson on the southwest corner, facing the direction Mr. Bradley had been traveling, was missing.

About ten days after the accident Clarence Vantrige saw Dr. Henry Evans who diagnosed a lumbar sprain and a contusion of the right leg and treated him conservatively until July 25, 1984 when he determined that Mr. Vantrige was asymptomatic and discharged him.

On October 23, 1984, three months after being discharged by Dr. Evans, Mr. Vantrige returned complaining of further, more severe back pains. Dr. Evans, believing that he accomplished all he could, referred Mr. Vantrige to Dr. R.C. Llewellyn, a neurosurgeon. Dr. Llewellyn subsequently performed a partial diskectomy on Mr. Vantrige on February 14, 1985 at New Orleans Methodist Hospital. Mr. Vantrige was examined following the operation and continued to complain of back pain. His last visit to Dr. Llewellyn was in December 1985 and his complaints were the same.

Although, further diagnostic studies are necessary to determine whether another diskectomy is necessary, Dr. Llewellyn believes that sometime in the future Mr. Vantrige will be able to work again.

Dr. Carl Culicchia also examined Mr. Vantrige on two occasions and testified that he felt that Mr. Vantrige had no neurological disability. Mr. Vantrige continues to complain of back pain so severe that he cannot work, in particular as a carpenter or carpenter's helper, his former trade, and frequently cannot sleep, remaining awake until 2:00 o'clock in the morning. Mr. Vantrige last worked as a carpenters helper.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Fox v. Housing Authority of New Orleans
605 So. 2d 643 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1992)
Alexander v. Rivers
560 So. 2d 999 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1990)
Conerly v. South Central Bell Telephone Co.
557 So. 2d 1041 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1990)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
543 So. 2d 603, 1989 WL 40784, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/vantrige-v-lloyds-of-louisiana-ins-co-lactapp-1989.