United States v. Joseph Pace, Anthony Besase, Christ Savides, Donald Smith, John Cialoni, and Robert Wilson

898 F.2d 1218, 1990 U.S. App. LEXIS 3831
CourtCourt of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
DecidedMarch 15, 1990
Docket87-2529, 87-2547, 87-2568, 87-2587, 87-2606 and 87-2798
StatusPublished
Cited by206 cases

This text of 898 F.2d 1218 (United States v. Joseph Pace, Anthony Besase, Christ Savides, Donald Smith, John Cialoni, and Robert Wilson) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
United States v. Joseph Pace, Anthony Besase, Christ Savides, Donald Smith, John Cialoni, and Robert Wilson, 898 F.2d 1218, 1990 U.S. App. LEXIS 3831 (7th Cir. 1990).

Opinion

*1223 MANION, Circuit Judge.

Joseph Pace, Anthony Besase, Christ Sa-vides, Donald Smith, John Cialoni, and Robert Wilson appeal their convictions of various cocaine distribution offenses committed between 1981 and 1987 as part of a continuing criminal enterprise headed by Sa-vides. The defendants raise a number of issues, most of which surround searches and seizures that occurred during the investigation of the enterprise. We affirm all the defendants’ convictions, but remand Savides’ case to the district court for resen-tencing.

I.

FACTS

A. The searches and seizures

On the evening of March 8, 1986, several Chicago police officers arrived at Savides’ condominium in Park Ridge, Illinois, to execute a search warrant authorizing them to search the condominium for evidence of gambling, including gambling records and money. Savides answered the door and allowed the officers to enter. Upon entering the condominium, the police saw Be-sase come out of the kitchen and Donald Greco (a co-defendant who pleaded guilty and did not appeal) come out of the condominium’s bedroom area. The officers found Pace in the den; he was carrying a paper bag, which one of the officers took from him. The officers detained the four men in the living room, patted them down for weapons, and then searched the apartment.

The officers found nine one-kilogram packages of cocaine lying on a bed in the room that Greco had exited. The officers also found another kilogram package of cocaine in a kitchen drawer, and found $63,000 in United States currency in the room in which they had found Pace. Believing they had walked in on a major cocaine deal, the officers arrested Savides, Pace, Besase, and Greco, and searched them incident to the arrests. The officers discovered that the bag Pace had been carrying contained nearly $13,000 in cash. The officers also seized several items from Besase, including car keys and receipts from hotels in Daytona, Florida, and Lafayette, Indiana, that showed he had stayed at those hotels within the preceding few days. One of the officers found and cursorily examined Besaseis car in the parking garage beneath Savides’ condominium building that night; the search turned up no evidence.

The next day, March 9, Chicago police officers returned to Savides’ condominium complex where they found Besase’s car and a car they believed Pace had driven the day before. The officers decided to seize the two cars pursuant to state and federal forfeiture statutes because they believed that Besase and Pace had used the cars to drive to the cocaine transaction at Savides’ condominium. Before taking Pace’s car away, an officer inventoried the property in the car pursuant to departmental procedure. During the inventory, the officer found a record book and a personal address book. The officer paged through both books; he noticed that the record book appeared to contain some type of cryptic drug records, and that the address book contained a list matching the code numbers in the record book with initials. Based on his observations and on the events of the day before, the officer concluded that the books were evidence of drug transactions, and seized the books. In the following days, officers read the books in detail.

The officers transported Besase’s and Pace’s ears to a nearby police station. At the station, officers inventoried the contents of Besase’s vehicle and found and seized receipts that indicated that Besase had been in Georgia and Indiana a few days earlier. A few days later, on March 13, the police learned that Besase was a reputed member of a Toledo, Ohio organized crime syndicate, and that he had been in Florida, a known drug source state, shortly before his arrest. This information, along with the receipts suggesting that Besase had traveled from Florida to Chicago, led police to suspect that Besase had brought the cocaine found in Savides’ apartment from Florida. Suspecting that the car might still contain drugs or money *1224 in a secret compartment, the police brought Goldie, a trained narcotics-sniffing dog, to the car. Goldie alerted positively to the car’s rear seat, where the police discovered a secret compartment that turned out to contain traces of cocaine.

Shortly after Savides’ release on bail following his arrest, members of the Chicago Organized Crime Intelligence Unit (the “Intelligence Unit”) determined that Savides was a likely candidate for assassination by the Chicago Organized Crime Syndicate because he had broken a syndicate rule against mixing gambling business with narcotics distribution. Because they suspected the syndicate might assasinate Savides, the Intelligence Unit officers decided to stake out Savides’ residence.

About three weeks later, on April 3, 1986, surveillance officers saw a stranger, later identified as defendant Wilson, drive a Ford sedan regularly driven by Savides out of the parking garage beneath Savides’ condominium building. This struck the officers as suspicious because in their three weeks of surveillance they had seen nobody but Savides drive that car, except when Savides had been a passenger (and the officers had seen that but once). Because of their suspicions, the officers decided to follow Wilson.

Wilson drove to a nearby restaurant and met another unknown man, later identified as defendant Smith. Wilson and Smith walked up and down the aisles of the parking lot and appeared to be peering into car windows. Wilson and Smith then entered the Ford and rode slowly up and down the parking lot aisles while again appearing to search the parked cars. To the officers, it appeared that Wilson and Smith were checking to see if anybody was watching them. After conducting their apparent counter-surveillance, Wilson and Smith stopped behind a car with out-of-state license plates. Smith left the car, took a suitcase from the out-of-state car’s trunk, and placed it in the Ford’s trunk. Smith then got into the out-of-state car and followed Wilson out of the parking lot.

Wilson and Smith drove to the condominium complex. While turning into the complex, they apparently spotted the trailing officers, sped up, and made several turns; the officers considered Wilson’s and Smith’s driving maneuvers to be attempts to elude them. As they neared Savides’ building, Wilson and Smith split up, Wilson heading for an underground parking area and Smith heading for the parking lot. Wilson opened the electronic garage door and entered the garage; one of the officers, Michael Patton, pulled his car under the descending door to wedge it open. Patton drew his gun, approached the Ford, and announced he was a police officer. Wilson dropped the car keys to the floor, kicked them under the car, and told Patton, “This isn’t my car.” When Patton asked whose car it was, Wilson replied, “I wasn’t driving that car.”

Another officer, Nick Nesis, who had followed and apprehended Smith, entered the garage with Smith. Based on what they had been told by the Intelligence Unit and on the suspicious activities of that day, Patton and Nesis believed that Wilson and Smith were hit men and that the suitcase possibly contained guns or explosives that could pose an immediate risk to the public. Nesis therefore recovered the keys, opened the Ford’s trunk, and carefully opened the suitcase. Nesis found no explosives or weapons in the suitcase; he did, however, find ten kilograms of cocaine.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Richardson v. Johnson
N.D. Illinois, 2020
United States v. Antoine Richmond
924 F.3d 404 (Seventh Circuit, 2019)
United States v. Shontay Dessart
823 F.3d 395 (Seventh Circuit, 2016)
Kendrae Amein Montez v. State
Court of Appeals of Texas, 2014
United States v. Anderson
705 F. Supp. 2d 1 (District of Columbia, 2010)
United States v. Musick
291 F. App'x 706 (Sixth Circuit, 2008)
United States v. Smith
Sixth Circuit, 2007
Kosyla, Joyce v. City of Des Plaines
256 F. App'x 823 (Seventh Circuit, 2007)
United States v. Abdi
Sixth Circuit, 2006
United States v. Presley
Sixth Circuit, 2005
People v. Conner
832 N.E.2d 442 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2005)
Baldwin v. United States
412 F. Supp. 2d 712 (N.D. Ohio, 2005)
United States v. Baskin
370 F. Supp. 2d 813 (S.D. Indiana, 2005)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
898 F.2d 1218, 1990 U.S. App. LEXIS 3831, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/united-states-v-joseph-pace-anthony-besase-christ-savides-donald-smith-ca7-1990.