Trustees of German Township v. Farmers & Citizens Sav. Bank Co.

113 N.E.2d 409, 66 Ohio Law. Abs. 332, 51 Ohio Op. 346, 1953 Ohio Misc. LEXIS 372
CourtMontgomery County Court of Common Pleas
DecidedMay 14, 1953
DocketNo. 103750
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 113 N.E.2d 409 (Trustees of German Township v. Farmers & Citizens Sav. Bank Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Montgomery County Court of Common Pleas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Trustees of German Township v. Farmers & Citizens Sav. Bank Co., 113 N.E.2d 409, 66 Ohio Law. Abs. 332, 51 Ohio Op. 346, 1953 Ohio Misc. LEXIS 372 (Ohio Super. Ct. 1953).

Opinion

OPINION

By MILLS, J.

This is an action by the trustees of German Township, Montgomery County, Ohio, against The Farmers & Citizens Savings Bank Company, an Ohio corporation, with its principal office in Germantown, Montgomery County, Ohio.

Plaintiff prays, in the amended petition, that:

(a) A lease, dated March 25, 1873, between the trustees of German Township, Montgomery County, Ohio, and the late [334]*334David Rohrer, also of said county and state, whereby the said trustees leased to the said David Rohrer the premises described in said lease for the term of ninety-nine years, renewable forever, from April 27, 1872, be declared null and void;

(b) A deed, dated May 6, 1910, from the trustees in bankruptcy of the said David Rohrer and conveying the leasehold interest to the defendant, be declared null and void;

(c) The defendant be directed to quitclaim to the plaintiff its interest in the leased premises, and in default of so doing, that the decree of court operate and be considered as such;

(d) The title of plaintiff in such real estate be quieted against all claims of defendant;

(e) The defendant be enjoined from interfering or depriving plaintiff of the peaceful use, possession and occupancy of the leased premises; and

(f) For such other and further relief as may be just and proper in law and in equity.

The facts in the case for the most part have been stipulated and agreed to and are not in dispute. In addition to the written stipulation of facts, the court at the hearing of April 15, 1953, received additional stipulation of facts and evidence.

The court finds from the written stipulation of facts, (1) That on March 26, 1872 the General Assembly of the State of Ohio passed an act.

“To authorize the Trustees of German Township, Montgomery County, Ohio, to lease the premises on which they have commenced the, erection of a town hall.” Reported in 69 Ohio Laws 230,

which act contains the following provisions:

“Whereas, a majority of the qualified electors of German Township, Montgomery County, voted at a general election held in said township on the first Monday in April, 1871, voted in favor of levying a tax for the purpose of erecting a town hall, for the use of said township, in accordance with an act passed April 2, 1866 (Ohio Laws, Vol. 84; S. & S. 783), and
“Whereas, a large portion of said tax has been collected, the site for said building purchased, and the foundation and cellar constructed; and
“Whereas, it appears' desirable to erect business rooms in connection with said town hall; therefore
“Section 1. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Ohio, that the trustees of German township, Montgomery County, are hereby authorized to lease the premises on which they have commenced the erection of a town hall, to be one or more individuals for a period of ninety one years, [335]*335renewable forever; provided, said individual or individuals shall erect on said premises, the first story of a substantial building, in accordance with a plan to be furnished by said trustees, and shall permit said trustees to erect on said first story, a town hall for the use of said township; and provided further, that before leasing said premises as above specified, the trustees shall give fifteen days’ notice by advertisement in some newspaper of general circulation in said township, or by posting written or printed notices in at least three conspicuous places in said township of the time and place of said letting; and at the time and place specified, they shall let the same at public vendue to the highest and best bidder. The rent for said premises shall be payable semi annually for the use of the township, and the trustees shall have a lien on said premises and the appurtenances therefor.
“Section 2. Said trustees shall let said premises as above provided, on or before May 10, 1872, and the individual or individuals leasing the same shall, within ten days after said letting, enter into a bond with surety, and payable to said German township, in such sum as may be required by said trustees, conditioned for the erection of said business rooms, in accordance with the plan and specifications furnished by said trustees, on or before the 15th day of September, 1872, and the said trustees shall also be bound for and on behalf of said German township, to erect said town hall over said business rooms, or at least inclose and roof the same on or before the 15th day of December, 1872.
“Section 3. This act to take effect on its passage.”

(2) That David Rohrer, the lessee, did erect the first story of a building on the premises described in said Act of March 25, 1872, and as mentioned in the lease attached to the petition of the plaintiff, which lease is dated March 26, 1873.

(3) That the trustees of German Township erected a town hall for the use of the Township on the first story of the building erected by David Rohrer, as provided in the Act of March 26, 1872.

(4) That David Rohrer entered into possession and control of the leased premises under and in accordance with the terms and conditions of the lease, which was introduced into evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit A, and remained in possession and control until his interest was sold, for valuable consideration, to the defendant on May 6, 1910, which conveyance was introduced in evidence and marked “Mutual Exhibit C.” Defendant has since May 6, 1910, been in possession and control of said premises.

(5) That at the time the lease was executed the trustees [336]*336acknowledged and the lease recites that David Rohrer had

“fulfilled the conditions imposed by the said Act of Legislature.”

(6) That the rentals payable for said premises to the trustees by David Rohrer and the defendant have been paid for all yearly periods beginning with the date of leasing and have been accepted by the trustees.

(7) That all taxes levied and assessed on the leasehold and the building have been paid for all years, including all taxes levied and assessed by or for the benefit of German Township.

(8) That all other terms and conditions of the lease have been performed by the lessee.

(9) That the premises leased to David Rohrer and the first story of the building erected by him on the leased premises (except so much of the first story reserved to and by the trustees) since the date said premises were leased, have been continuously and exclusively in the possession and use of David Rohrer and the defendant, and

(10) That during the period from the date of the leasing of said premises to the date of the filing of the petition herein, no action has been filed by the trustees of German Township, or any other body, to recover possession of said leased premises, to the best of plaintiff’s knowledge and belief.

The court finds from the evidence adduced at the hearing of this case on April 15, 1953, that none of the present trustees, all of whom testified, ever read any of the minutes of the trustees of German Township for the years 1872 and 1873, and that such minute books were missing, although search had been made for the book or books.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
113 N.E.2d 409, 66 Ohio Law. Abs. 332, 51 Ohio Op. 346, 1953 Ohio Misc. LEXIS 372, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/trustees-of-german-township-v-farmers-citizens-sav-bank-co-ohctcomplmontgo-1953.