Treadwell Ford, Inc. v. Campbell

485 So. 2d 312
CourtSupreme Court of Alabama
DecidedMarch 7, 1986
Docket83-574, 83-583
StatusPublished
Cited by18 cases

This text of 485 So. 2d 312 (Treadwell Ford, Inc. v. Campbell) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Alabama primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Treadwell Ford, Inc. v. Campbell, 485 So. 2d 312 (Ala. 1986).

Opinion

485 So.2d 312 (1986)

TREADWELL FORD, INC.
v.
Clarence W. CAMPBELL; Dairyland Ins. Co.; Katherine Chapman Hamilton and Frederick B. Hamilton, as Co-Executors of the Estate of Sallie Chapman Hamilton, Deceased; and Jacqueline Evans.
DAIRYLAND INSURANCE COMPANY
v.
Katherine Chapman HAMILTON and Frederick B. Hamilton, as Co-Executors of the Estate of Sallie Chapman Hamilton, Deceased; Jacqueline Evans; and Treadwell Ford, Inc.

83-574, 83-583.

Supreme Court of Alabama.

January 10, 1986.
As Corrected on Denial of Rehearing March 7, 1986.

*313 James H. Crosby, Philip H. Partridge, E.J. Saad, and Vincent A. Noletto, Jr., of Brown, Hudgens, Richardson, P.C., Mobile, Bibb Allen, of London, Yancey, Clark & Allen, Birmingham, for appellant/cross-appellee Treadwell Ford, Inc.

Bert S. Nettles and Forest S. Latta, of Nettles, Barker & Janecky, Timothy P. McMahon of Reams, Vollmer, Philips, Killion, Brooks & Schell, Mobile, for appellant Dairyland Ins. Co.

Neil L. Hanley, Mobile, for appellee Clarence W. Campbell.

Richard Bounds and James A. Yance, of Cunningham, Bounds, Yance, Crowder & Brown, Mobile, for appellees Katherine Chapman Hamilton, Frederick Chapman Hamilton, and Jacqueline Evans.

ALMON, Justice.

These appeals are from consolidated cases in which judgments were entered on verdicts for the plaintiffs totalling $1,410,000. Sallie C. Hamilton and Jacqueline Evans were struck by a pickup truck driven by Clarence Campbell. Hamilton died as a result of her injuries. Her executors filed a wrongful death action, Code 1975, § 6-5-410, and Evans and Campbell each filed separate suits for damages against Treadwell Ford, Inc., which had sold Campbell the truck. Hamilton's executors and Evans later added as a defendant Dairyland Insurance Company, which had, prior to the truck's coming into Treadwell's possession, paid a total loss claim on the truck and sold it to a salvage company.

The truck, a 1979 Ford F-100 pickup truck, was extensively damaged while insured by Dairyland. It was rebuilt after Dairyland sold it and before Treadwell purchased it. The alleged cause of the plaintiffs' accident was that the accelerator linkage stuck against the firewall, causing the truck to surge forward uncontrollably. The plaintiffs recovered from Treadwell on various theories relating to the alleged defect in the firewall. The primary basis of recovery from Dairyland was Dairyland's failure to remove the vehicle identification number (V.I.N.) plate and the license plate from the truck, as required by Code 1975, § 32-8-87, before reselling it. Dairyland was also sued under the Alabama Extended Manufacturer's Liability Doctrine (AEMLD). Treadwell filed cross-claims against Dairyland in the death action and *314 in Evans's action, and a third-party claim in Campbell's action. The jury returned verdicts for Treadwell on the cross-claims and for Dairyland on the third-party claim.

The history of the truck from its original purchase will explain Dairyland's and Treadwell's involvement. Gary Nicholson bought the truck new from a dealer in Mississippi in late 1979. In January 1980 he wrecked the truck by running into the rear end of a flatbed trailer truck. The front end of the truck suffered at least the following damages. The hood, fenders, and grill were crumpled, and the engine was driven back into the firewall. The bumper was attached to "bumper horns," metal brackets extending forward on the frame. The impact bent these bumper horns. The frame was bent somewhat and the post holding the hinges for the driver's door was knocked out of alignment.

Nicholson had collision insurance with Dairyland. After that first accident, the truck was towed to a salvage dealer, Late Model Auto Parts. Dairyland's appraiser determined that the truck was a total loss and Dairyland paid Nicholson accordingly. Code 1975, § 32-8-87(b), at the time Dairyland processed the claim, required that

"An insurance company which pays money as compensation for total loss of a motor vehicle shall obtain such vehicle's certificate of title, manufacturer's identification number plates and license plates and, within 72 hours after receiving them, shall forward them to the department for processing."

The evidence was undisputed that Dairyland did not obtain the identification and license plates from Late Model. Instead, the certificate of title found its way to Late Model. John Ewing, Dairyland's senior claims examiner, testified by deposition that the file showed Dairyland sent the title certificate and a bill of sale to Late Model on June 11, 1980.

Late Model Auto Parts then sold the truck to L.R. Boyette. Boyette hired Jim Harris, of Harris's Body Shop, to repair the truck by replacing the fenders, grill, radiator, and hood. Harris cut the original bumper horns off the frame and welded new ones in their place. He took the truck to a dealership and had the frame straightened. He realigned the driver's doorpost so the door closed properly. Harris testified that he did not replace the engine onto its mounts or do any work on the firewall. When he finished his body work, he completely repainted the truck in its original colors.

Boyette testified that, as he used the truck after it was rebuilt, he occasionally had trouble with the accelerator sticking, but that he could free it by tapping the gas pedal. Boyette sold the truck after a few months to Rudolph Phillips. Phillips traded the truck to Treadwell Ford for a smaller pickup truck in December 1980.

Treadwell performed a complete inspection of the truck. Treadwell's mechanic, William Brooks, made the inspection. He testified that he put the truck on the lift so he could inspect it for oil leaks or frame damage and removed the wheels so he could inspect the brakes. He also inspected the transmission, the engine, the body, and the interior and test-drove the truck. He testified that one of the objects of the inspection was to see if the truck had been wrecked. Brooks testified that he noticed that the truck had been repainted, but that he did not see the welds on the new bumper horns, the damage to the firewall, or any other evidence of the reconstruction. The truck passed the inspection for Ford's Extended Service Policy on used vehicles.

Campbell bought the truck from Treadwell on December 30, 1980. He testified that when he test-drove the truck, he experienced a problem with the truck jumping forward when he put it in gear, so that when he returned to the Treadwell lot, he asked the salesman, Charles Stevens, to inspect the truck. Campbell left to withdraw the money for the truck from his bank account. He testified that when he returned, the salesman told him the truck had been inspected and was "OK," so he bought the truck. Five days later, the accident in question occurred.

*315 The accident causing the plaintiffs' injuries occurred shortly after 11 p.m. on January 4, 1981, in the parking lot of the Mobile Infirmary in Mobile, Alabama. Campbell was sitting in the truck, which he had bought five days earlier at Treadwell's used car lot, waiting to give a ride to a friend. When she got in the truck, he put it in gear and it accelerated forward, jumped the curb, and struck three nurses who were walking to their cars. One of them, Nancy Morris, was not injured. Evans's injuries were relatively minor. Hamilton died almost immediately. Campbell became ill and vomited after the accident.

Campbell testified that the truck "took off in a flash" and that the brakes would not stop it.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Wyeth, Inc. v. Danny Weeks and Vicki Weeks
159 So. 3d 649 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 2014)
Hand v. State
873 So. 2d 255 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 2003)
Jones v. Mitchell
816 So. 2d 68 (Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama, 2001)
Pfizer, Inc. v. Farsian
682 So. 2d 405 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1996)
Rhodes v. Tractor & Equipment Co.
677 So. 2d 194 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1995)
Patton v. McHone
822 S.W.2d 608 (Court of Appeals of Tennessee, 1991)
Fincher v. Robinson Bros. Lincoln-Mercury
583 So. 2d 256 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1991)
Johnny Spradlin Auto Parts, Inc. v. Cochran
568 So. 2d 738 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1990)
Schump v. Firestone Tire & Rubber Co.
541 N.E.2d 1040 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1989)
State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. Robbins
541 So. 2d 477 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1989)
Lumpkin v. Cofield
536 So. 2d 62 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1988)
King Mines Resort, Inc. v. MALACHI M. & MINERALS, INC.
518 So. 2d 714 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1987)
Hart v. Jackson
510 So. 2d 202 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1987)
Mobile Dodge, Inc. v. Alford
487 So. 2d 866 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1986)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
485 So. 2d 312, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/treadwell-ford-inc-v-campbell-ala-1986.