State v. Ture

632 N.W.2d 621, 2001 Minn. LEXIS 542, 2001 WL 923487
CourtSupreme Court of Minnesota
DecidedAugust 16, 2001
DocketC8-00-798
StatusPublished
Cited by57 cases

This text of 632 N.W.2d 621 (State v. Ture) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Minnesota primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Ture, 632 N.W.2d 621, 2001 Minn. LEXIS 542, 2001 WL 923487 (Mich. 2001).

Opinion

OPINION

PAGE, Justice.

Appellant Joseph Ture was convicted in January 2000 of four counts of first-degree murder in violation of Minn.Stat. § 609.185, subd. 1 (1978), for the December 15, 1978, murders of Alice Huling and three of her four children. Ture was sentenced to four consecutive life sentences. In this direct appeal, Ture argues that the district court erred when it denied his motion at trial to suppress three items seized from his car four days after the murders: a metal bar wrapped in what appeared to be a steering wheel cover, a two-inch Corgi Juniors Batmobile toy car, and a ski mask. Ture also claims that the court erred in finding that the police properly retained those items until his trial in this case. In addition, Ture argues that he was denied a fair trial by evidentiary rulings that (1) permitted the state to introduce evidence that the seized toy car was similar to a toy that may have been present at the murder scene and (2) allowed the state to present expert testimony that a bruise on Alice Huling was caused by the metal bar seized from Ture’s car. Ture also raises various pro se issues. We affirm.

During the early morning hours of December 15, 1978, Alice Huling and three of her four children were murdered in their house located in rural Stearns County. The surviving child, William Huling, was 11 years old at the time and was the only witness to the murders. At trial, William testified that he was asleep in the upstairs bedroom he shared with his 13-year-old brother, Wayne, when at approximately 4:00 a.m. he was awakened by loud noises coming from the kitchen below. He heard muffled noises and wrestling, and then a gunshot. A short while later, he heard footsteps coming up the stairs and saw a person standing in the doorway to the bedroom. The person appeared to be of medium build, less than six feet tall, and wearing a stocking cap. William could see a silhouette of the person’s face, but not well enough to make a positive identification. From his bed, Wayne asked, ‘Who are you?” The person fired a shotgun at Wayne, lolling him instantly. The person then left the boys’ room and went to 16-year-old Susie’s bedroom where he shot *625 her in the head, and proceeded to 12-year-old Patti’s bedroom where he shot her in the head. Both girls died instantly. After shooting both girls, the gunman returned to the boys’ room and fired twice at William, missing both times, and then left. After 10 or 15 minutes, William got out of bed and fled to a neighbor’s house.

On the morning of December 19, four days after the murders, Wright County Deputy Sheriff Gary Miller was dispatched to the restaurant at the Clearwater Travel Plaza in response to a complaint about a customer later identified as Ture. After learning that the car Ture was driving had been reported stolen, Miller arrested Ture for unauthorized use of a motor vehicle and placed Ture, handcuffed, in the back of his squad car. Upon entering Ture’s car to look for its keys and a newspaper Ture indicated he wanted, Miller discovered a metal bar, approximately 32 inches in length, on the front passenger seat. Miller seized the metal bar, transported Ture to the Wright County Sheriffs Department, and arranged for Ture’s car to be towed. Miller and another officer conducted an inventory search of Ture’s car, during which the toy car 1 and ski mask were discovered. No weapons or ammunition were found.

Several of the items found during the search, including the toy car, the ski mask, and the metal bar discovered earlier, were turned over to Deputy James Kostreba and Detective Ross Baker of the Stearns County Sheriffs Department, who were investigating the Huling murders. Kos-treba and Baker interviewed Ture on December 20, 1978. An audiotape of the interview was played to the jury at Ture’s trial. During the interview, Ture said that he had been fired from his job a few days before and that he had been living out of his car. Ture stated that the toy car belonged to him and that he had grandchildren. Ture then indicated that the toy car was for his sister’s children. Ture was charged with unauthorized use of a motor vehicle and released on January 4, 1979. Although Ture was not charged with the Huling murders at that time, he remained a suspect.

In 1981, Ture was incarcerated with Toby Krominga at the Sherburne County Jail. According to Krominga, Ture confessed to murdering the Hulings and signed a written confession that Krominga had drafted according to Ture’s instructions. Although the police obtained a copy of the written confession and questioned Ture on several occasions about the confession and the murders, no charges were brought against Ture. In the summer of 1998, Ture and Randall Ferguson were inmates at Minnesota Correctional Facility-Oak Park Heights. According to Ferguson, Ture confessed to the Huling murders. Ferguson informed the authorities of Ture’s statements in August 1998, and in May 1999 Ture was indicted on four counts of first-degree murder in violation of Minn. Stat. § 609.185, subd. 1.

Before trial, Ture moved to suppress, among other things, the metal bar, the toy car, and the ski mask, claiming that the warrantless seizure of those items was not justified by any exception to the warrant requirement. He also claimed that the three items were improperly retained by the police from the time of their seizure until the trial in this case. During the suppression hearing, Ture testified that he found the metal bar and the toy car while working at a junkyard and that he had the ski mask because he worked outdoors at a car lot. The state argued that the metal *626 bar was properly taken during a search incident to arrest, and that the toy car and ski mask were properly taken during an inventory search or, in the alternative, during a search under the automobile exception to the warrant requirement. The district court found that the metal bar was properly seized during the search incident to Ture’s arrest and, noting that there was no evidence that the inventory of Ture’s car was conducted in bad faith, that the toy car and ski mask were properly seized during the inventory search. The district court also found that the three items were properly retained by the police and admissible at trial. Ture subsequently filed a motion in limine to prevent the state from introducing evidence related to the toy car. This motion was also denied.

At trial, the state offered evidence concerning Ture’s confessions to Toby Kro-minga and Randall Ferguson. Krominga testified that, while he and Ture were incarcerated at the Sherburne County Jail in 1981, Ture admitted to committing the Huling murders. According to Krominga, Ture asked him whether someone would be considered crazy for killing a bunch of people. Ture repeated the question a few weeks later and at some point admitted to killing a family of four. Krominga stated thafi' over time, Ture gave him additional information, and that Ture wanted to dictate a letter for Krominga to write and send to a judge. Krominga testified that he wrote a number of drafts of the letter, to which Ture made corrections until they had a final draft. Krominga testified that he saw Ture sign the letter and that he signed it as a witness.

The four-page letter indicates that it was written by Krominga because Ture’s spelling is not very good.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State of Minnesota v. Raenard Romalle Douglas
Supreme Court of Minnesota, 2025
State of Minnesota v. Cody Logan Fohrenkam
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2024
State of Minnesota v. Shane Ryan Oneil
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2024
State v. Hallmark
927 N.W.2d 281 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 2019)
State v. Bradley
908 N.W.2d 366 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2018)
Otis Sams, Jr. v. State of Indiana
71 N.E.3d 372 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2017)
Tyler Lee Johnson v. Commissioner of Public Safety
887 N.W.2d 281 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2016)
State of Minnesota v. Joshua Brandon Cochran
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2016
State of Minnesota v. Faith Annette Jenson
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2016
State of Minnesota v. Ryan Mark Thompson
873 N.W.2d 873 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015)
Kristin Marie Poeschel v. Commissioner of Public Safety
871 N.W.2d 39 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015)
State of Minnesota v. Todd Eugene Trahan
870 N.W.2d 396 (Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015)
State of Minnesota v. Derek Lawrence Stavish
868 N.W.2d 670 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 2015)
Peter Alan Krech v. Commissioner of Public Safety
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015
State of Minnesota v. William Marvin Boyenga
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015
State of Minnesota v. Jason David Fredrickson
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015
State of Minnesota v. Adam Alvarado
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015
State of Minnesota v. Troy Kenneth Scheffler
Court of Appeals of Minnesota, 2015

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
632 N.W.2d 621, 2001 Minn. LEXIS 542, 2001 WL 923487, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-ture-minn-2001.