State v. Nelson

775 So. 2d 579, 2000 WL 1781658
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedDecember 6, 2000
Docket34,077-KA
StatusPublished
Cited by9 cases

This text of 775 So. 2d 579 (State v. Nelson) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Nelson, 775 So. 2d 579, 2000 WL 1781658 (La. Ct. App. 2000).

Opinion

775 So.2d 579 (2000)

STATE of Louisiana, Appellee,
v.
Emmie Petty NELSON, Appellant.

No. 34,077-KA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

December 6, 2000.

*581 Louisiana Appellate Project by Amy C. Ellender, Mixon Law Offices by James E. Mixon, J. Scott Sartin, Counsel for Appellant.

Richard Ieyoub, Attorney General, Iley H. Evans, District Attorney, Carl B. Duke, Jr., Assistant District Attorney, Counsel for Appellee.

Before BROWN, WILLIAMS and KOSTELKA, JJ.

KOSTELKA, J.

A unanimous jury convicted Emmie Petty Nelson ("Nelson"), as charged, of second degree murder, La. R.S. 14:30.1. The trial court sentenced Nelson to the mandatory term of life imprisonment without benefit of parole, probation or suspension of sentence. She now appeals the conviction and sentence. We affirm.

FACTS

Although they lived in Richland Parish, Louisiana, Bryan "Dale" Bonnette ("Bonnette") and his wife, Donna ("Donna"), owned a trailer camp in Caldwell Parish on Templeton Bend Road, on Woolen Lake, in an area of the parish colloquially referred to as "Hazard County." Nelson and Donna were best friends and had known each other for over twenty years. In late April 1998, Nelson leased a piece of property adjacent to the Bonnettes' camp. Nelson, along with her boyfriend, Joe Perot ("Perot"), intended to make their camp, a small frame house, their home.

The Bonnettes, Nelson and Perot maintained a campfire on the property between the Bonnettes' trailer and Nelson's home. On the evening of Saturday, May 2, 1998, the Bonnettes, Nelson and Perot sat by *582 the fire talking and drinking beer. At about 8:00 or 9:00 p.m., Perot and Bonnette told Nelson and Donna that they were going fishing; Perot and Bonnette left in Nelson's pickup truck and were gone all night. Instead of fishing, the two men sat by the lake while each drank a case of beer and, between them, smoked three rocks of crack cocaine.

After the two men left, Nelson and Donna continued to sit by the fire drinking beer. At about 2:00 a.m. on Sunday, May 3, 1998, Nelson tripped and fell in her front yard. After an aborted effort to drive themselves to the hospital, Nelson and Donna called the Caldwell Parish Sheriffs Office ("CPSO") and a deputy was dispatched who took them to the hospital to have Nelson's injuries treated. Nelson was diagnosed with a broken nose and released to go home. The women returned to Nelson's house to sleep. Donna, at the behest of the hospital, stayed with Nelson to monitor Nelson's condition.

Bonnette and Perot returned to the campsite early Sunday morning and slept for a few hours. Sometime before 10:00 a.m., Bonnette gained entrance into Nelson's home and proceeded to pull Donna out of the house by the arm. After Donna went back into the house, Nelson called CPSO and either Nelson or Donna locked the door. Bonnette then sought to forcibly enter Nelson's home through the locked door but left the scene driving the car belonging to him and Donna when he learned that Nelson had called CPSO. CPSO deputies Ed Basco ("Basco") and Orvis Watson arrived at Nelson's home at 10:23 a.m. and found that Nelson's front door appeared as if it had been locked and then forced open. Donna took Basco into the Bonnette trailer where the deputy saw that someone had thrown the contents of the refrigerator onto the floor. When Nelson expressed a desire to press charges against Bonnette, Basco informed her to come to CPSO headquarters on Monday morning to file a complaint. After a brief drive through the area in an unsuccessful search for the Bonnettes' car, the deputies left. Nelson, Perot and Donna then went back to their chairs by the campfire and drank beer. Nelson armed herself with a.38 revolver.

After leaving Nelson's camp, Bonnette met Jimmy O'Neal ("O'Neal"). O'Neal and Bonnette drove, in O'Neal's truck, to Richland Parish where they stayed for about two hours; Bonnette drank two or three beers during that time. The two men then returned to O'Neal's camp, which is near Bonnette's and Nelson's camps, between 11:00 a.m. and 12:00 noon. Bonnette fell asleep on O'Neal's couch.

At approximately 4:00 p.m., O'Neal drove Bonnette to Bonnette's father's nearby camp where Bonnette had left his car. O'Neal then drove back to his home.

Bonnette drove back to the campfire at Nelson's camp and slid to a stop between the campfire area and the Bonnettes' trailer. While in his car, Bonnette allegedly inquired as to who had signed the warrant against him. Nelson admitted that she had done so.

Nelson testified that after she told Bonnette she had sought his arrest, Bonnette got out of the car with perhaps a Busch beer can in his hand. Nelson said that she then fired up into the air as a warning shot.

Perot testified that Nelson said, "If you mess with any of us, Dale—I will kill you if you mess with any of us." The evidence is conflicting as to whether or not Bonnette then threw the beer can at Nelson, which, she testified, struck her in the face. She also stated that Bonnette threatened to kill her. Donna denied that this occurred, and Perot initially told police that Bonnette had nothing in his hand when he got out of the car but corroborated Nelson's version of the event at trial.

Nelson claimed that Bonnette then came up to her, brutally struck her on the upper body with a plastic lawn stool and stepped on her foot. Perot corroborated this portion of the events. An overturned plastic *583 lawn stool appears in the photos of the scene. Photos of Nelson taken after the event show bruises to her back and shoulder. Donna denied that Bonnette struck Nelson with the stool.

At this point, Perot tackled Bonnette. Perot claimed that as the two hit the ground, Bonnette landed on top of him. He then grabbed Bonnette by the hair, kneed him in the stomach and rolled Bonnette off of him. Perot stated that from his position on the ground he could not see Bonnette. Nelson claimed that Bonnette separated himself from Perot and reached over to the woodpile to pick up one of the sticks but admitted that Bonnette never picked up any of the sticks. Claiming that she feared Bonnette was going to kill them, Nelson fired at Bonnette from at least two and one-half feet or more away, killing him.[1]

Nelson admitted to sheriffs deputies that she shot Bonnette and would do it again.

Nelson said that she drank several beers after the shooting. A blood-alcohol test conducted on Nelson at 7:17 p.m. revealed a blood-alcohol content (BAC) of .236 grams/percent. A toxicology screen of Bonnette's body revealed a BAC of .181 grams/percent. The screen also revealed Valium and a "significant amount" of methanol in Bonnette's blood as well as cocaine in his urine.

As a result of these events, Nelson was charged with the second degree murder of Bonnette. After conviction and sentencing, Nelson filed motions for post-verdict judgment of acquittal and for a new trial. When the court denied the post-trial motions, this appeal ensued.

DISCUSSION

Sufficiency of the Evidence

In her first assigned error, Nelson argues that the evidence was insufficient to convict her of second degree murder because the state failed to prove Nelson had the specific intent to kill or inflict great bodily harm. Specifically, Nelson argues that the evidence failed to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she did not act in self-defense. Alternatively, Nelson argues that the evidence was sufficient to prove only the crime of manslaughter.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State v. Burton
274 So. 3d 122 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2019)
State of Louisiana v. Randall Paul Burton
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2019
State v. Dock
167 So. 3d 1097 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2015)
State of Louisiana v. George Jameson Gray, III
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2011
State of Louisiana v. Michael W. Hood
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010
State v. Spring
30 So. 3d 286 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010)
State v. Simms
25 So. 3d 250 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009)
State of Louisiana v. Deandre Johnson
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2007
State v. Alexander
888 So. 2d 401 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2004)
State of Louisiana v. Michael Alexander
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2004
State v. Graham
799 So. 2d 645 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2001)
State v. Johnson
796 So. 2d 201 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2001)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
775 So. 2d 579, 2000 WL 1781658, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-nelson-lactapp-2000.