State v. Morrison

359 P.3d 60, 302 Kan. 804, 2015 Kan. LEXIS 809
CourtSupreme Court of Kansas
DecidedOctober 2, 2015
Docket110835
StatusPublished
Cited by4 cases

This text of 359 P.3d 60 (State v. Morrison) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Kansas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Morrison, 359 P.3d 60, 302 Kan. 804, 2015 Kan. LEXIS 809 (kan 2015).

Opinions

The opinion of the court was delivered by

ROSEN, J.:

The State of Kansas brought a quo warranto action pursuant to K.S.A. 60-1205 to remove David Scott Morrison from his position on the Prairie Village City Council. After conducting a hearing, the district court concluded that the evidence was suf[805]*805ficient to show that Morrison willfully engaged in misconduct while in office and willfully neglected to perform a duty enjoined upon him by law. Consequently, the district court entered an order removing Morrison from office pursuant to K.S.A. 60-1205(1) and (2).

Morrison appealed, and the Court of Appeals concluded that the undisputed facts did not, as a matter of law, satisfy the criteria for judicial ouster established by caselaw applying K.S.A. 60-1205. The Court of Appeals reversed the district court and remanded the case with directions that judgment be entered in Morrison’s favor, thus reinstating him to his public office. We granted review and conclude that, based on the applicable statutory language and caselaw, both the district court and the Court of Appeals misapplied the standard required for ouster under K.S.A. 60-1205(1) and (2). As a result, we reverse both the district court and the Court of Appeals and remand the case to the district court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

Facts

The parties do not dispute the facts of this case. The Court of Appeals’ recitation of the facts is quoted below.

“Morrison was elected to the Prairie Village City Council in 2008 and re-elected in 2012. Kelley Malone was Morrison’s long-time friend and a former coworker. In 2011, Malone began to have substance abuse problems. Eventually, Malone lost his job and became homeless. At this point, Malone called Morrison seeldng help, as he believed he had nowhere else to turn. Morrison arranged for Malone to stay in a hotel for a week, bought him clothes, and set up a job interview for him. With employment, Malone’s circumstances improved and he was able to purchase a home.
“Unfortunately, the following year Malone relapsed. He again lost his home and feared for his life because he came to believe that a ‘hit’ had been taken out against him. On Saturday, October 27,2012, Malone again sought Morrison’s help. Morrison called his church seeking both advice and sanctuary for Malone. A pastor informed him that the church could not accommodate Malone and, further, that putting Malone in a hotel was ill-advised. Morrison then called a Prairie Village dispatcher, Dawn Johnson, to inquire into public resources available to assist the homeless. Johnson told Morrison that the usual practice was for a police officer to take the person to the City Union Mission in Kansas City, Missouri. Morrison arranged a spot for Malone at the City Union Mission, however, Malone refused to go as he did not believe it was a safe location. Morrison did not consider his [806]*806own home a viable place for Malone to stay as Morrison lived with his elderly parents. Morrison’s mother’s immune system was so compromised that Morrison himself would check into a hotel when he contracted an illness or cold so as not to expose his mother to illness. Morrison feared a stranger in his home would endanger his mother’s fragile health.
“At a loss, Morrison made the fateful decision to house Malone in city hall for a few days. The Prairie Village City Hall and police station are located in the same complex, separated by a long corridor. Access to city hall after normal business hours requires entering the police station, walking past the dispatch window, and passing through a locked door opened using a four digit security code. Each city councilman had a unique security code, though there were no policies or restrictions as to how those security codes could be used. The security code permitted access to tire employee lounge, a weight room, and a locker room but not to any work spaces or other areas of city hall.
“That Saturday evening, Morrison brought Malone to city hall around 6 p.m. Morrison walked to tire dispatch window where Johnson was working and told her that he and Malone were there for a neighborhood meeting. Morrison also told Johnson not to be alarmed if she saw Malone on the surveillance cameras as he was with Morrison. Johnson was suspicious of Morrison’s explanation and sent the following message to a Prairie Village police officer:
‘Ok, you know the homeless guy I told you David Morrison was calling about? Well he just took him over to city hall. Telling me “they” were having a meeting with the rest of the neighborhood .... Surely he wouldn’t let that guy stay the night over there would he? I don’t know of any meeting . . . not that that matters.’
“At some point, Morrison and Malone left city hall to get dinner, returning at about 9 p.m. Pamela Huskey was working at the dispatch window when they returned and Morrison told her that he and Malone would be working in city hall that night. Twenty minutes later, Morrison left while Malone stayed to spend the night. Before leaving, Morrison gave Malone his security code after realizing that without it, Malone would not have restroom access.
“The following morning, the janitor saw Malone in the city hall employee lounge. Just after noon, Morrison picked Malone up and the two attended a football game that evening. They returned to city hall just after midnight on Monday morning, October 29, 2012. Morrison told the dispatcher on duty, Cory Parker, that he and Malone were going to do paperwork in city hall. Morrison left a few minutes later. Malone again spent the night in city hall, leaving mid-morning on Monday and not returning for the rest of that day. He spent Monday night sleeping in the back of another friend’s car.
“That same day, Morrison called Police Chief Wes Jordan to discuss Malone’s situation. Morrison described Malone’s current drug addiction and told Chief Jordan that Malone had information about drug transactions and human trafficking operations. Chief Jordan instructed Morrison to have Malone contact him so [807]*807lie could meet with the Special Investigations Unit, a police unit primarily focusing on drug crimes. Neither Malone nor Morrison contacted Chief Jordan to arrange a meeting time.
“The following evening, Tuesday, October 30, 2012, Malone again called Morrison and asked to stay the night at city hall. Morrison told Malone that he did not think it would be a good idea, however, Malone ignored Morrison’s plea. Malone arrived at city hall just after midnight on Wednesday, October 31, 2012. Malone told Huskey, who was again working the dispatch window, that he and Morrison were going to be working again in city hall and that Morrison would be arriving soon. Malone then entered city hall. Morrison never arrived.
“That morning, multiple city hah employees encountered Malone. Bettinajam-erson, tire court administrator, encountered Malone at 7:30 a.m. as he was sitting in the employee bréale room.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

City of Prairie Village v. PV United
Court of Appeals of Kansas, 2025
State v. Sasser
Supreme Court of Kansas, 2017
State v. Walker
372 P.3d 1147 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 2016)
State v. Page
363 P.3d 391 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 2015)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
359 P.3d 60, 302 Kan. 804, 2015 Kan. LEXIS 809, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-morrison-kan-2015.