State v. Gray

360 P.3d 472, 51 Kan. App. 2d 1085, 2015 Kan. App. LEXIS 75
CourtCourt of Appeals of Kansas
DecidedOctober 30, 2015
DocketNo. 112,035
StatusPublished
Cited by3 cases

This text of 360 P.3d 472 (State v. Gray) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Kansas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. Gray, 360 P.3d 472, 51 Kan. App. 2d 1085, 2015 Kan. App. LEXIS 75 (kanctapp 2015).

Opinion

Malone, C.J.:

Marcus Gray appeals following his convictions of possession of cocaine, possession of marijuana, driving with a suspended license, failure to signal a turn, and two counts of felony interference with law enforcement. Gray claims: (1) the district court erred in denying his motion to suppress because the law enforcement officer who conducted the traffic stop did so in violation of Kansas statutes prohibiting racial or other biased-based policing; (2) the State failed to present sufficient evidence to support his convictions of felony interference with law enforcement; and (3) the district court lacked jurisdiction to impose a felony sentence for possession of marijuana because the State did not charge Gray with felony possession of marijuana. We agree with Gray that the State failed to present sufficient evidence to support his convictions of felony interference with law enforcement, but we otherwise affirm the district court’s judgment.

Factual and Procedural Background

On November 10, 2013, at approximately 2 a.m., Deputy Brandon Huntley of the Harvey County Sheriff s Office was on patrol when he noticed a silver Ford Focus driving north on Interstate 135 (“1-135”), south of Newton. Huntley later testified that he [1087]*1087began following the car simply because it was there. He ran a check on the license plate and discovered that the car was registered to a female living in Salina. Based on Huntley s “extensive experience with drug interdiction,” he knew that illegal drugs were often trafficked on 1-135 from Wichita to Salina.

Huntley continued to follow the car along 1-135, off at Exit 31, and through a roundabout with street lighting, at which point he realized the driver was male. Huntley later testified that in his experience, many drug cases involve someone operating a vehicle not registered in his or her name. The car pulled into a gas station but parked with the gas pumps on the passenger s side. According to Huntley, this was suspicious because he believed the gas cap was on dre driver s side—Huntiey was unaware at the time that a Ford Focus has the gas cap on the passenger s side of the car.

Huntley decided to continue watching the car, so he drove past the gas station and parked down the road where he could still see the car. The driver got out of the car and went into the gas station. It was not until the driver got out of the car that Huntíey realized he was African-American. The driver walked back to the car a few minutes later, looked all around, got into the car, and drove away.

Huntley continued to follow the car and shortly thereafter saw tire driver turn without using a turn signal. At that point, Huntley turned on his emergency equipment and conducted a traffic stop. According to Huntley s written report, which was introduced into evidence at the suppression hearing, Huntley approached the driver and explained the reason for tíre stop. Huntley asked the driver for his driver’s license. The driver stated that he had a Louisiana driver’s license but not in his possession. Huntley asked tire driver if he had any idéntification on him. The driver stated that he did not, but he said that his name was Jimmy Ray Turner. At that point, Huntley smelled a moderate odor of marijuana and a slight odor of an alcoholic beverage emitting from inside the vehicle.

Because the driver did not have any type of identification on him, Huntley asked him to provide his social security number and address as listed on his driver’s license. After rambling off several combinations of numbers, the driver finally provided a social se[1088]*1088curity number. He also stated that the address listed on his driver s license was 106 Turner Lane, in Ruston, Louisiana. Huntley told the driver to stay inside his vehicle while he checked his driver s license status.

Huntley returned to his patrol vehicle and requested dispatch to send a second officer to his location because of the circumstances with the stop. Huntley also checked for a driver s license through the State of Louisiana under the name of Jimmy Ray Turner. Huntley was informed that a Louisiana driver s license was issued to Jimmy Ray Turner, but the address and social security number did not match the information that the driver had provided. Also, the physical description of Jimmy Ray Turner provided on the Louisiana drivers license did not match the driver s physical description. At this point, Huntley was confident that the driver had provided him with a false name.

Officer Jon Adlans with the Newton Police Department arrived at the scene a short time later. Pluntley reapproached the driver and explained that the information from tire State of Louisiana did not match the information he had provided. However, the driver insisted that his name was Jimmy Ray Turner. Huntley asked the driver to exit the vehicle and he did. After conducting a quick pat-down to check for weapons, Huntley asked the driver to place his hands behind his back. At that time, the driver quickly spun to his left and attempted to run away. He ran about 20 feet before Huntley and Adlans pulled him to the ground. After being told to stop resisting numerous times, the driver complied and was placed under arrest. At that point, the driver identified himself as Marcus Gray. When Huntley contacted dispatch for information on Gray, he learned that Gray had outstanding out-of-state warrants and a suspended driver’s license. Adkins took Gray to the Harvey County Detention Center and found marijuana and cocaine on him.

On November 13, 2013, the State charged Gray with possession of cocaine with intent to distribute, possession of marijuana, possession of cocaine with no drug tax stamp, driving with a suspended license, failure to signal a turn, and two counts of felony interference with law enforcement. On December 5, 2013, Gray filed a motion to suppress the evidence. The motion generally alleged that [1089]*1089Gray had been subject to an “illegal traffic stop and detention.” The motion did not allege illegal racial policing as a ground for suppression of the evidence.

The district court held a hearing on the motion to suppress on January 6, 2014. At the hearing, Huntley and Gray testified. Huntley freely admitted that at the time he pulled Gray over, he was watching for a traffic infraction so that he could conduct a pretex-tual stop; he wanted to see if he might find drugs in the car. However, he maintained that the only reason he stopped the car was Gray s failure to signal a turn.

Gray testified that on the night in question, he was driving his girlfriend’s car to Salina, where he and his girlfriend lived. He noticed Huntley following him on 1-135 and exited at Exit 31 because he was hungry. When he pulled into the gas station, he went into the store and bought a sandwich. Gray further testified that when he came out of the gas station, he looked around to see if die officer who had been following him was still around, but he did not see anyone. According to Gray, he used his turn signal at every turn, including the turn Huntley testified that Gray had failed to use his signal.

At the end of the hearing, the district judge denied the motion to suppress, explicitly stating that he believed that Huntley observed Gray failing to use his turn signal. The district court found that the traffic stop was a permissible pretextual stop. Gray’s counsel then stated there was “one other issue [he wanted] to put on the record” before the hearing closed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State v. Gachelin
Court of Appeals of Kansas, 2024
State v. Cobb
Court of Appeals of Kansas, 2022
State v. Gray
Supreme Court of Kansas, 2017

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
360 P.3d 472, 51 Kan. App. 2d 1085, 2015 Kan. App. LEXIS 75, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-gray-kanctapp-2015.