State v. Free

Wyoming Supreme Court

State v. Free

260 P. 173, 37 Wyo. 188, 1927 Wyo. LEXIS 76

CourtWyoming Supreme Court

DecidedOctober 17, 1927

Docket1404

StatusPublished

Cited by14 cases

This text of 260 P. 173 (State v. Free) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Wyoming Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

State v. Free, 260 P. 173, 37 Wyo. 188, 1927 Wyo. LEXIS 76 (Wyo. 1927).

Pincite

Opinion

Per Curiam:

Frank Free was convicted on April 12, 1926 for violating the prohibition law, and was sentenced to pay a fine of $250 and costs and to be committed to the county jail for the period of thirty days. From this judgment he appeals. While the appeal was pending and awaiting decision before this court, the defendant died, and his death has been suggested to the court with the request that it make an appropriate order in the premises. It is well established that in the absence of a statute expressing the contrary — and we have no such statute — all proceedings in the matter abate. 17 C. J. 94, sec. 3361. This is true whether the punishment consists of imprisonment or a fine, or of both. In the case *189 of State v. Furth, 82 Wash. 655, 144 Pac. 907, in which ease a fine was assessed against the defendant, the court said:

“The courts of the country, both state and federal, have, with marked unanimity, held that the death of the defendant in a criminal case pending appeal, in the absence of a statute expressing the contrary, permanently abates the action and all proceedings under the judgment. They make no distinction between a sentence of imprisonment and the imposition of a fine. The underlying principle is that the object of all criminal punishment is to punish the one who committed the crime or offense, and not to punish those under whom his estate is cast by operation of law or otherwise. ’ ’

See also Boyd v. State, 3 Okla. Cr. 684, 108 Pac. 431, and People v. St. Maurice, 166 Cal. 201, 135 Pac. 952, and cases cited.

It is accordingly adjudged that all proceedings in the above entitled cause, and the judgment therein rendered, have permanently abated, and that the trial court enter its appropriate order to that effect.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Per Curiam:

Frank Free was convicted on April 12, 1926 for violating the prohibition law, and was sentenced to pay a fine of $250 and costs and to be committed to the county jail for the period of thirty days. From this judgment he appeals. While the appeal was pending and awaiting decision before this court, the defendant died, and his death has been suggested to the court with the request that it make an appropriate order in the premises. It is well established that in the absence of a statute expressing the contrary — and we have no such statute — all proceedings in the matter abate. 17 C. J. 94, sec. 3361. This is true whether the punishment consists of imprisonment or a fine, or of both. In the case *189 of State v. Furth, 82 Wash. 655, 144 Pac. 907, in which ease a fine was assessed against the defendant, the court said:

“The courts of the country, both state and federal, have, with marked unanimity, held that the death of the defendant in a criminal case pending appeal, in the absence of a statute expressing the contrary, permanently abates the action and all proceedings under the judgment. They make no distinction between a sentence of imprisonment and the imposition of a fine. The underlying principle is that the object of all criminal punishment is to punish the one who committed the crime or offense, and not to punish those under whom his estate is cast by operation of law or otherwise. ’ ’

See also Boyd v. State, 3 Okla. Cr. 684, 108 Pac. 431, and People v. St. Maurice, 166 Cal. 201, 135 Pac. 952, and cases cited.

It is accordingly adjudged that all proceedings in the above entitled cause, and the judgment therein rendered, have permanently abated, and that the trial court enter its appropriate order to that effect.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

260 P. 173, 37 Wyo. 188, 1927 Wyo. LEXIS 76, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-free-wyo-1927.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack