State v. France

776 N.W.2d 510, 279 Neb. 49
CourtNebraska Supreme Court
DecidedDecember 24, 2009
DocketS-09-101
StatusPublished
Cited by82 cases

This text of 776 N.W.2d 510 (State v. France) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Nebraska Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
State v. France, 776 N.W.2d 510, 279 Neb. 49 (Neb. 2009).

Opinion

776 N.W.2d 510 (2009)
279 Neb. 49

STATE of Nebraska, appellee,
v.
Stephen E. FRANCE, appellant.

No. S-09-101.

Supreme Court of Nebraska.

December 24, 2009.

*512 Corey A. Burns for appellant.

Jon Bruning, Attorney General, and George R. Love, Columbus, for appellee.

HEAVICAN, C.J., WRIGHT, CONNOLLY, GERRARD, STEPHAN, McCORMACK, and MILLER-LERMAN, JJ.

MILLER-LERMAN, J.

NATURE OF CASE

Stephen E. France appeals his convictions and sentences for first degree murder and use of a weapon to commit a felony. France asserts that the jury erred in rejecting his insanity defense and in failing to find that he acted in self-defense. He also asserts that the district court for Dawson County erred by instructing the jury that to find France acted in self-defense, the jury must find that he "reasonably" believed deadly force was necessary to defend himself. We affirm France's convictions and sentences.

STATEMENT OF FACTS

France was charged with first degree murder and use of a weapon to commit a felony in connection with the December 18, 2007, stabbing death of Dwayne R. Morrison. France and Morrison were coworkers at a haymill in Gothenburg, Nebraska. The two frequently argued with one another, particularly in the week prior to Morrison's death. On the morning of December *513 18, France and Morrison had a physical altercation in which France stabbed Morrison with a knife. Morrison died from his injuries, which included three deep stab wounds to the chest, with one stab penetrating the heart.

After charges were filed against France, the court granted France's motion for a psychological evaluation pursuant to Neb. Rev.Stat. § 29-1823 (Reissue 2008). Dr. Bruce Gutnik conducted a psychiatric evaluation and concluded that France was suffering from mental illness and was not competent to stand trial. Based on Gutnik's report, the court, on March 24, 2008, found that France was not then competent to stand trial but that there was a substantial probability he would become competent to stand trial within the foreseeable future. The court ordered France committed to the Lincoln Regional Center for appropriate treatment until his disability was removed. On August 8, the court determined, based on the opinion of Dr. Klaus Hartmann, that France was competent to stand trial.

France thereafter filed a notice of intent to rely upon a defense that he was not responsible by reason of insanity. The court granted the State's motion to require France to be examined by Hartmann to determine France's sanity at the time of Morrison's killing.

At trial, the State presented the testimony of coworkers of France and Morrison who testified regarding the animosity between the two. Jason Edgins testified that approximately 4 days before Morrison's death, he heard France say that he would like to kill Morrison. Edgins also testified that the day before his death, Morrison told Edgins he feared for his life and was going to the police to get a restraining order against France, because France had threatened to kill Morrison and his family.

Another coworker, Donald Friesenborg, testified that he heard France say "maybe half a dozen times" that he was going to kill Morrison. Two days before Morrison's death, France confronted Friesenborg at his home, because Morrison's wife had said that Friesenborg wanted France to quit his job. Friesenborg denied having made a remark regarding France's job and suggested that Morrison's wife was trying to agitate France. France told Friesenborg that Morrison abused his children and that "somebody ought to kill him." France also told Friesenborg he suspected that Morrison had sabotaged machinery at work, and France said, "I'm going to stab and kill that SOB." Morrison told Friesenborg the day before he was killed that France had threatened to kill Morrison and his family and that he planned to get a restraining order against France.

A third coworker, Tony Cañas, testified that France and Morrison argued and threatened each other on a daily basis the week prior to Morrison's death. During such arguments, Cañas heard France threaten to kill Morrison. Cañas also heard France on the telephone telling Morrison he was going to kill Morrison and his family. Two days before Morrison was killed, France told Cañas that he blamed Morrison for a fire in the mill the night before and that he was trying to borrow a gun from another coworker in order to kill Morrison.

Cañas testified that on the morning of December 18, 2007, Morrison arrived early for his daytime shift, while Cañas and France were finishing a nighttime shift. Cañas was walking toward the back door of the mill when he saw Morrison stumble out the door and fall to the ground. Cañas then saw France come through the door, straddle Morrison, and stab Morrison in the chest with a knife. France kicked Morrison and said, "I told you I was going to *514 kill you, you son of a bitch." Cañas did not see Morrison make any movement after he fell to the ground. France went back into the building, and Cañas called the 911 emergency dispatch service.

Deputy Sheriff Greg Gilg was the first law enforcement officer to arrive at the mill. Gilg saw Morrison's body and then saw France come out of the building with his hands held up and out. France was covered in "blood from head to toe." Gilg handcuffed France and secured him inside Gilg's patrol car. Gilg examined Morrison's body and determined that he was dead. After other officers arrived, Gilg placed France under arrest and took him to a hospital. A physician's assistant at the hospital determined that France had a cut on the back of his head that required stitches. Gilg heard France tell the physician's assistant that he and Morrison got into a fight and that Morrison got France down on the ground and bashed France's head into the concrete. Gilg observed other cuts and bruises on France's body, but France did not require medical attention beyond the stitches to the head. During the trip to the hospital, France told Gilg that Morrison "was basically bugging him so much that he was tired of his crap."

The pathologist who conducted the autopsy on Morrison's body testified that Morrison's death was caused by "deeply penetrating stab wounds of the trunk or torso." The wounds included three stabs to the chest caused by a knife, including one stab that went through the heart. The pathologist noted other injuries to Morrison's body, including cuts, bruises, and abrasions to the face, head, arms, hands, and legs. The pathologist opined that the injuries were contemporaneous to the stab wounds and were consistent with being defensive wounds.

France testified in his own defense. France admitted stabbing Morrison but asserted that it was in self-defense. France described various instances of conflict with Morrison over a period of years that the two had worked together. In particular, France described a machine malfunction and a fire that occurred in the mill during the week prior to December 18, 2007. France asserted that Morrison was to blame for both incidents. France did not immediately confront Morrison about the incidents but told coworkers that Morrison was to blame. France admitted that he told coworkers that Morrison "ought to be killed," but asserted he did not mean it literally and did not expect anyone to take it seriously. On December 16, France received a call from Morrison and his wife in which Morrison confronted France about France's comments that Morrison should be killed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State v. Lopez
Nebraska Supreme Court, 2026
State v. Duarte
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2025
State v. Adams
33 Neb. Ct. App. 212 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2024)
State v. Allen
314 Neb. 663 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2023)
State v. Winston
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2022
State v. Bedford
980 N.W.2d 451 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2022)
State v. John
310 Neb. 958 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2022)
State v. Perez
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2020
Fuentes v. Frakes
D. Nebraska, 2020
State v. Stack
307 Neb. 773 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2020)
State v. Malone
26 Neb. Ct. App. 121 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2018)
State v. Reed
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2018
State v. James
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2018
State v. Heng
25 Neb. Ct. App. 317 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2017)
State v. Hamed
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2017
State v. Eagle Elk
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2016
State v. Dubray
885 N.W.2d 540 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2016)
State v. Pittman
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2013
State v. Ruegge
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2013

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
776 N.W.2d 510, 279 Neb. 49, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-v-france-neb-2009.