STATE EX REL. WEST VIRGINIA CITIZEN ACTION GROUP v. Tomblin

715 S.E.2d 36
CourtWest Virginia Supreme Court
DecidedJanuary 18, 2011
Docket101494, 10-4004
StatusPublished

This text of 715 S.E.2d 36 (STATE EX REL. WEST VIRGINIA CITIZEN ACTION GROUP v. Tomblin) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering West Virginia Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
STATE EX REL. WEST VIRGINIA CITIZEN ACTION GROUP v. Tomblin, 715 S.E.2d 36 (W. Va. 2011).

Opinion

715 S.E.2d 36 (2011)

STATE of West Virginia ex rel. WEST VIRGINIA CITIZEN ACTION GROUP, Petitioner,
v.
Earl Ray TOMBLIN, President of the West Virginia Senate, Richard Thompson, Speaker of the West Virginia House of Delegates, and Natalie Tennant, Secretary of State of West Virginia, Respondents.
Kenny Perdue, President of the West Virginia AFL-CIO, Intervener, and
State of West Virginia ex rel. Thornton Cooper, Petitioner,
v.
Earl Ray Tomblin, Acting Governor of the State of West Virginia, And President of the West Virginia Senate, Richard Thompson, Speaker of the West Virginia House of Delegates, and Natalie Tennant, Secretary of State of West Virginia, Respondents.
Kenny Perdue, President of the West Virginia AFL-CIO, Intervener.

Nos. 101494, 10-4004.

Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia.

Submitted January 11, 2011.
Decided January 18, 2011.

*39 Kathryn Reed Bayless, Esq., Bayless Law Firm, Princeton, WV, for West Virginia Citizen Action Group.

Thornton Cooper, Esq., South Charleston, WV, Pro Se.

Thomas P. Maroney, Esq., Maroney, Williams, Weaver & Pancake, Charleston, WV, for Kenny Perdue, As President of the West Virginia AFL-CIO.

Lisa A. Hopkins, Esq., General Counsel West Virginia State Auditor's Office, Charleston, WV, for Amicus Curiae Glen B. Gainer, III, Auditor of the State of West Virginia.

Charles McElwee, Esq., Charleston, WV, Amicus Curiae Pro Se.

James M. Haviland, Esq., Charleston, WV, for Amicus Curiae West Virginia Education Association.

Thomas V. Flaherty, Esq., Tammy R. Harvey, Esq., Caleb P. Knight, Esq., Flaherty Sensabaugh Bonasso.

*40 Ray Ratliff, Esq., Charleston, WV, for Earl Ray Tomblin, Acting Governor of the State of West Virginia, and President of the West Virginia Senate.

Anthony J. Majestro, Esq., Powell & Majestro, Charleston, WV, for Richard Thompson, Speaker of the West Virginia House of Delegates.

Darrell V. McGraw, Jr., Esq., Attorney General, Silas B. Taylor, Esq., Senior Deputy Attorney General, Charleston, WV, for Natalie E. Tennant, Secretary of State of West Virginia.

BENJAMIN, Justice:

In this original jurisdiction action, the petitioners seek a writ of mandamus compelling the respondents to call a special election as soon as practicable in 2011 to fill the vacancy in the office of governor created on November 15, 2010, when former Governor Joe Manchin, III, resigned from that office to assume the office of United States Senator. Petitioners herein are the West Virginia Citizen Action Group,[1] Thornton Cooper,[2] and Kenny Perdue,[3] as President of the West Virginia AFL-CIO. Respondents are Earl Ray Tomblin as Senate President and in his capacity in fulfilling the constitutional role to act as governor during the current vacancy, Richard Thompson as Speaker of the House of Delegates, and Natalie E. Tennant as Secretary of State.[4]

After careful consideration of the parties' pleadings and oral arguments, as well as the briefs of amici curiae, and the applicable law, and for the reasons that follow, this Court denies the writ of mandamus requested by the petitioners with regard to Respondent Thompson and Respondent Tennant. We grant the petition with regard to Respondent Tomblin, and we direct Respondent Tomblin, in fulfilling his role to act as governor during the current vacancy, to forthwith issue a proclamation fixing a time for a new statewide election for governor consistent with W. Va. Const., art. VII, § 16 and W. Va.Code § 3-10-2 (1967).

I.

FACTS

The facts of this case as represented by the parties are brief and undisputed. Former Governor Joe Manchin, III, was elected to a second four-year term of office at the general election on November 4, 2008. That term began on January 19, 2009, and is scheduled to end on January 14, 2013.

On June 28, 2010, United States Senator Robert C. Byrd passed away. A special election to fill the Senate vacancy created as a result of Senator Byrd's death was held on November 2, 2010, and former Governor Manchin was elected to fill the Senate vacancy.

On November 15, 2010, former Governor Manchin resigned as governor and was sworn in as United States Senator. His resignation created a vacancy in the office of governor. On the same day that former Governor Manchin resigned, State Senate President and Respondent herein, Earl Ray Tomblin, began to act as governor pursuant to W. Va. Const., art. VII, § 16 and W. Va.Code § 3-10-2.

A question thereafter arose with regard to when a new statewide election must be held under our law to fill the vacancy in the office of governor. The next general election will be held in November 2012. The petitioners seek a writ of mandamus to compel the holding of a new election as soon as practicable in 2011. This Court subsequently issued a rule *41 to show cause returnable before this Court for oral argument to be heard on January 11, 2011.

The sole issue before this Court is narrow and straightforward-when, under our law, shall a statewide public election take place to fill the current vacancy in the office of governor?

II.

STANDARD OF REVIEW

The petitioners in this case seek a writ of mandamus. This Court has explained that the purpose of mandamus is to enforce "an established right" and a "corresponding imperative duty created or imposed by law." State ex rel. Ball v. Cummings, 208 W.Va. 393, 398, 540 S.E.2d 917, 922 (1999) (citation omitted). In determining the appropriateness of mandamus in a given case, our law is clear that

A writ of mandamus will not issue unless three elements coexist—(1) a clear legal right in the petitioner to the relief sought; (2) a legal duty on the part of respondent to do the thing which the petitioner seeks to compel; and (3) the absence of another adequate remedy.

Syllabus Point 2, State ex rel. Kucera v. Wheeling, 153 W.Va. 538, 170 S.E.2d 367 (1969). This Court will consider the question before us in light of these principles.

III.

DISCUSSION

This case rests upon the interpretation of a provision of our state constitution and a statute. The applicable constitutional provision is W. Va. Const., art. VII, § 16, which provides:

In case of the death, conviction on impeachment, failure to qualify, resignation, or other disability of the governor, the president of the senate shall act as governor until the vacancy is filled, or the disability removed; and if the president of the senate, for any of the above named causes, shall become incapable of performing the duties of governor, the same shall devolve upon the speaker of the house of delegates; and in all other cases where there is no one to act as governor, one shall be chosen by joint vote of the legislature. Whenever a vacancy shall occur in the office of governor before the first three years of the term shall have expired, a new election for governor shall take place to fill the vacancy.

(Emphasis added.) The applicable statute is W. Va.Code § 3-10-2, the relevant portion of which provides:

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Randolph County Board of Education v. Adams
467 S.E.2d 150 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1995)
State Ex Rel. Skinner v. Dostert
278 S.E.2d 624 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1981)
Robinson v. Charleston Area Medical Center, Inc.
414 S.E.2d 877 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1991)
State Ex Rel. Moore v. Blankenship
217 S.E.2d 232 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1975)
State Ex Rel. Ball v. Cummings
540 S.E.2d 917 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 2000)
State Ex Rel. Casey v. Pauley
210 S.E.2d 649 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1974)
State Ex Rel. Kucera v. City of Wheeling
170 S.E.2d 367 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1969)
State v. Huber
40 S.E.2d 11 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1946)
Harbert v. County Court of Harrison County
39 S.E.2d 177 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1946)
Simms v. Sawyers
85 W. Va. 245 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1919)
State ex rel. Trent v. Sims
77 S.E.2d 122 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1953)
State ex rel. Smith v. Gore
143 S.E.2d 791 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1965)
State ex rel. West Virginia Citizen Action Group v. Tomblin
715 S.E.2d 36 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 2011)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
715 S.E.2d 36, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/state-ex-rel-west-virginia-citizen-action-group-v-tomblin-wva-2011.