Stapleton v. Great Lakes Chemical Corp.

627 So. 2d 1358, 1993 WL 490232
Supreme Court of Louisiana·Decided December 7, 1993·No. 93-C-1355, 93-C-1459·Published·Cited by 24 cases

Opinion

627 So.2d 1358 (1993)

Johnny STAPLETON, et ux
v.
GREAT LAKES CHEMICAL CORPORATION, et al.

Nos. 93-C-1355, 93-C-1459.

Supreme Court of Louisiana.

November 29, 1993.
Dissenting Opinion December 7, 1993.
Rehearing Denied January 6, 1993.

*1359 Curtis D. Street, Monroe, for applicant.

Esmond Phelps, II, Dane S. Ciolino, Stone, Pigman, Walther, Wittmann & Hutchinson, New Orleans, Fred W. Jones, Robert E. Shadoin, Smith & Shadoin, Ruston, Lisa C. Rogers, Susan N. Belsom, Crawford & Anzelmo, Phillip D. Myers, Walter C. Dunn, Jr., Theus, Grisham, Davis & Leigh, Monroe, for respondent.

WATSON, Justice.[1]

A car skidded off an icy road, a pickup truck stopped to render aid, two tractor-trailers arrived at the scene, one eighteen-wheeler jackknifed into the other and this suit ensued. Plaintiff, Johnny Stapleton, was badly injured when the trailer of a truck driven by Max Henderson crossed into Stapleton's lane of travel. Stapleton brought a tort claim, Mrs. Stapleton sued for loss of consortium and his employer's insurer intervened to recover worker's compensation benefits. A divided jury found Henderson and the pickup driver, Brown, free of fault. The jury did not reach the issue of Stapleton's fault. The trial judge, who decided the intervention, assessed Henderson and Stapleton's fault each at fifty percent. A divided court of appeal reversed the trial judge's intervention decision but affirmed the jury's verdict. Stapleton v. Great Lakes Chemical Corp., 616 So.2d 1311 (La.App.2d Cir.). A writ was granted. 620 So.2d 856 (La.1993).

FACTS

On January 9, 1988, Stapleton was driving a loaded propane tank truck for Martin Gas Company. He was travelling south from Dubach on Highway 167 near midnight. The weather was freezing, and the road was icy. Stapleton crossed a bridge, saw a woman walking and broadcast a warning on his CB radio. Coming out of a curve, Stapleton entered a straight section of highway approximately 1,600 feet long. The two-lane highway widened into two south and one north. Stapleton stayed in the middle lane. The straightaway ends at another curve to the south. Stapleton saw a pickup, driven by Christina Brown, slowed or stopped in the opposite lane of traffic (the northbound lane) and an approaching truck, driven by Henderson. Stapleton sent the truck an alert on his CB radio. The alert was too late to help Henderson, who was skidding toward the pickup.

The accident occurred toward the northern curve of the straight highway section. Stapleton's truck carried 9,500 gallons of propane and weighed 78,000 pounds. He estimated his speed at 25 to 30 miles per hour. He did not swerve to the right for fear that his trailer would jackknife on the ice, wipe out the pickup and possibly blow up the propane. As Stapleton pulled even with the pickup, the trailer of Henderson's truck swung around and hit him.

Henderson's truck was travelling north, pulling a flatbed trailer 45 feet long bearing three empty chemical tanks. He had been driving a little over nine hours and planned to stop and sleep in Dubach. Henderson came out of the southern curve in sixth gear, in the high range of his nine gear transmission. When Henderson saw the pickup stopped in his lane of travel, and Stapleton's truck, he started pumping his brakes but *1360 could not stop. From the southern curve to the point of impact, there are approximately 1,100 feet. Henderson testified that he could have stopped three times in the distance available if it had not been for the ice.

Christina Brown was driving a Toyota pickup truck north to Dubach from Ruston. She was averaging 20 to 25 miles per hour. She saw a car in the ditch and a man in the road flagging her down. She did not move off the road for fear of ending up in the ditch but slowed (and probably stopped) for the distressed vehicle. There had been no other traffic that night. Randy Rivet, the man in the road, moved to the shoulder as she slowed and then started running. She saw headlights. A truck crashed to a stop on the shoulder beside her pickup. Brown testified that the accident occurred close to the northern curve toward Dubach. Brown did not see Stapleton's tank truck until after the accident.

Catherine Weimer was a passenger in the pickup. She heard the horn of an eighteen wheeler behind them. As Brown attempted to move the pickup, the engine killed. Weimer also did not see the Stapleton truck until after the accident.

When Rivet started running, Henderson turned right to the shoulder. Stapleton's truck and the pickup were roughly even with each other when Henderson hit the right shoulder. Henderson's cab missed the pickup. Henderson's trailer jackknifed into the left lane and struck Stapleton's cab before arcing around to hit the ditched car.

Dennis Owen, a Dubach city policeman, went to the scene of the accident. There were two to three inches of ice on the road. Like Stapleton, Owen came out of the northern curve from Dubach, the curve closest to the accident. As Owen approached the accident site, he had to keep his car's right side on the shoulder to prevent sliding into the scene. The road slopes toward the opposite ditch, where Henderson's cab came to rest against Rivet's vehicle. The southern curve that Henderson negotiated is known as "trucker's curve". [Tr. 637.] Every three or four months, a truck going north fails to make that curve and ends up in a pond on the right side of the road. Because of concern that the propane would explode, Owen left the scene to assist in evacuating the area.

Ray Herd testified as an expert in the field of accident reconstruction. He placed the site of the accident at approximately 500 feet from the north curve and 1,000 feet from the south curve. In Herd's opinion, Henderson was driving 40 to 50 miles per hour and was still moving around 20 miles per hour at impact. Because of the ice, there were no skid marks on the road. Oil leaking from the broken crankcase of Stapleton's truck left some black marks. Herd identified the point of impact as the center of the southbound lane, near the end of the north curve.

Stephanie Reynolds was in the company of Sheldon Cooper, Randy Rivet and Shannon Durbin that night. Sheldon Cooper was driving Rivet's car, and she was sitting in the passenger seat. The ice was thick, and the car slid off the road into the ditch. She was angry and started walking toward Dubach. Stapleton's large tank truck passed her, and she heard the collision noise.

According to the video deposition testimony of Sheldon Cooper, there was ice on most of Henderson's route from Ruston to Dubach. The southern curve ended in a solid sheet of ice, and Henderson's truck went out of control when it hit the ice. In Cooper's opinion, Henderson's trailer did not hit him because it stopped when it landed on Rivet's car. Like the two women in the pickup, Cooper did not see Stapleton's southbound truck until after the accident.

Randy Rivet also testified in a video deposition. Because of the solid ice on the road, the centerline was invisible. Rivet also did not see Stapleton's truck until after the accident. When Rivet saw Henderson's truck moving toward him, he grabbed Shannon Durbin and they both hit the ditch. The trailer of Henderson's truck landed on top of Rivet's car. [The statement in the court of appeal opinion that the Rivet vehicle was not hit is unsupported by the evidence. Henderson admitted his trailer ended up against the Rivet car. He was "... glad there wasn't anybody in it." (Tr. 573.)]

James A.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Stapleton v. Great Lakes Chemical Corp., 627 So. 2d 1358, 1993 WL 490232 (La. 1993).

627 So. 2d 1358 (Stapleton v. Great Lakes Chemical Corp.) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Amlani v. McGee
135 So. 3d 1246 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2014)
Rozina Amlani v. Rocky James McGee
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2014
Daniels v. USAgencies Casualty Insurance
92 So. 3d 1049 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2012)
Gatlin v. KLEINHEITZ
34 So. 3d 872 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009)
Cooley v. Trinity Universal Ins. Co.
862 So. 2d 248 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2003)
Davis v. Witt
851 So. 2d 1119 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2003)
Madison v. ERNEST N. MORIAL CONVENT. CENTER
834 So. 2d 578 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2002)
Johnson v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance
741 So. 2d 159 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1999)
LeBlanc v. Steptore
723 So. 2d 1056 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1998)
Legros v. Westlake Polymers Corp.
704 So. 2d 876 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1997)
Bockman v. Caraway
691 So. 2d 815 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1997)
Porter v. Saia Motor Freight Line, Inc.
692 So. 2d 1197 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1997)
Harvey v. Traylor
688 So. 2d 1324 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1997)
Hollenbeck v. Oceaneering Intern., Inc.
685 So. 2d 163 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)
Bannerman v. Bishop
688 So. 2d 570 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)
Hurts v. Woodis
676 So. 2d 1166 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)
Busby v. St. Paul Ins. Co.
673 So. 2d 320 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)
Whiddon v. Hutchinson
668 So. 2d 1368 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)
Spiller v. State ex rel. Department of Transportation & Development
668 So. 2d 1318 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)
Marigny v. Allstate Ins. Co.
667 So. 2d 1229 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1996)