Soni v. Wespiser

239 F. Supp. 3d 373, 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 31274, 2017 WL 1234113
CourtDistrict Court, D. Massachusetts
DecidedMarch 3, 2017
DocketCIVIL ACTION NO. 4:16-CV-10630-TSH
StatusPublished
Cited by12 cases

This text of 239 F. Supp. 3d 373 (Soni v. Wespiser) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court, D. Massachusetts primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Soni v. Wespiser, 239 F. Supp. 3d 373, 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 31274, 2017 WL 1234113 (D. Mass. 2017).

Opinion

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER ON DEFENDANT’S MOTION TO DISMISS (Docket No. 25)

HILLMAN, D.J.

Plaintiff Deepa Soni, M.D., a board-certified, female neurosurgeon of Indian de[378]*378scent, filed this thirty-five count complaint alleging defendants Robert Wespiser, M.D., Timothy Counihan, M.D., Berkshire Medical Center, Inc., Berkshire Faculty Services, Inc., and Berkshire Health Systems, Inc. discriminated against her on the basis of her gender and ethnicity, retaliated against her, made defamatory statements against her which negatively impacted her career, and negligently and intentionally caused her emotional distress. Defendants move to dismiss all counts in the complaint pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) on numerous grounds, including that the claims fail as a matter of law, are time barred, and/or lack sufficient factual support. Plaintiff voluntarily dismissed Counts 1, 2, 11 and 12, leaving counts 3-10, and 13-35 currently pending. For the reasons detailed below, defendants’ motion to dismiss (Docket No. 5) is granted in part and denied in part.

Background

The facts, as summarized from the complaint, are as follows. Plaintiff Deepa Soni is a board certified, Harvard-trained neurosurgeon of Indian descent. She is the second woman to complete Harvard’s neurosurgery training program in its 80-year history, and the first Indian woman to do so. She began working at defendant Berkshire Medical Center, Inc. (“BMC”) in November 2008, pursuant to her employment contract with defendant Berkshire Faculty Services, Inc., both of which fall under the control of defendant Berkshire Health Systems, Inc. Defendant Dr. Timothy Couni-han, Chairperson of Surgery at BMC, was her direct supervisor, and she was further supervised by defendant Dr. Robert Wes-piser, the Chief of Staff at BMC.

Dr. Soni alleges that Dr. Counihan displayed discriminatory and retaliatory behavior toward her throughout her employment with BMC because she was a female minority who had achieved greater stature than he, she had complained to him about unsafe practices at BMC, and had previously sued other male doctors for gender discrimination. She complained about his failures as Chief of Surgery to BMC administration, though she does not allege that she ever reported his retaliatory or discriminatory behavior toward her during her employment at BMC. The complaint alleges that Dr. Wespiser was “passive and deferred to Dr. Counihan’s wishes, including participating in discrimination and retaliation against Dr. Soni.” Compl. ¶28.

In September 2009, Dr. Soni gave notice of her resignation to BMC, and worked there until May 2010, in accordance with the terms of her employment agreement. She alleges that, after tendering her resignation, Dr. Counihan, with the consent of Dr. Wespiser, undertook a “sham” peer review of her work outside of the BMC’s defined peer review procedures, which did not conclude until May 2010, just before her final day at BMC. She asserts that this unorthodox peer review instilled fear and inhibited her from voicing any further complaints while at BMC. While Dr. Soni pled generally that Drs. Counihan and Wespiser discriminated and retaliated against her, this “sham” peer review is the only example of such conduct during her employment with the defendants that is specifically alleged in the complaint.

In 2012, Dr. Soni’s successor in the neurosurgery department at BMC, Dr. Al-Atassi, reached out to her to discuss disparate treatment that he had experienced, which he believed to be discriminatory and retaliatory, including a similar “sham” peer review. Dr. Soni assisted him in retaining counsel to pursue an employment discrimination action.

Dr. Soni accepted a position at New Hampshire NeuroSpine in the spring of 2013, and as required by her new post, she sought privileges at three area hospitals in [379]*379April 2013, including Catholic Medical Center (“CMC”). While she was granted privileges at the other two hospitals, in July 2013, the Director of Medical Staff Support Services at CMC, Christine Sen-ko, advised Dr. Soni that her application for privileges at CMC was denied. This was the first time in her career that any hospital had refused to grant her privileges. Dr. Soni was informed that the decision was based on a letter sent by Dr. Counihan to the credentialing committee, and a telephone conversation between Dr. Counihan and Dr. Mahon, its chairperson. Dr. Soni spoke with Dr. Mahon, who “said, in essence, that Dr. Counihan’s remarks were the reason that Catholic Medical Center decided to ‘not move forward with credentialing [her].’ ” Compl. ¶ 49. Dr. Soni did not list Dr. Counihan as a reference, and asserts that he would not have been the appropriate person at BMC to have provided credentialing information.

Dr. Counihan admitted to Dr. Soni that he had sent a letter to CMC claiming “she had certain unspecified ‘difficulties’ while working at [Berkshire Medical Center].” Compl. ¶ 51. Dr. Soni asserts that any such statements are false. Dr. Soni then informed Dr. Wespiser of her concerns that both he and/or Dr. Counihan had relayed false and defamatory statements about her to CMC. Dr. Wespiser denied communicating directly with CMC, but also refused to correct the alleged misinformation provided by Dr. Counihan, despite Dr. Soni’s request for his assistance, and despite that, as Chief of Staff, such information “should have been provided by him.” Compl. ¶ 53.

An unnamed member of the CMC credentialing committee advised Dr. Soni in August 2013 that he was “ ‘aware of [her] situation,’ and that she had been wronged.” Compl. ¶ 56. Dr. Soni alleges that in a meeting with this unnamed individual, he disclosed to her that “Dr. Coun-ihan made vicious and defamatory statements about her in a letter, and that the letter was followed by a telephone conversation which was even worse.” Compl. ¶ 57. He did not provide specific details of the statements made by Dr. Counihan, but he confirmed that “Dr. Counihan said, in essence, that Dr. Soni would be trouble for the hospital because she had filed multiple lawsuits against other hospitals,” and the committee “made its decision in part based on the fact that she had previously sued other doctors and hospitals for discrimination.” Compl. ¶ 57 & 59. This same individual also shared that the credentialing committee had “essentially ignored her reference letters from several Board Certified neurosurgeons, which were ‘glowing,’ as well as her own credentials, i.e., Board Certification, no malpractice history, fellowship training, etc.” Compl. ¶ 58.

Because she was not granted privileges at CMC, Dr. Soni was unable to keep her position at New Hampshire NeuroSpine. She alleges that she suffered lost wages and emotional distress as a result.

In November 2013, Dr. Soni began practicing part time at Baystate Medical Center (“Baystate”), and in December 2013, she accepted a patient transferred from a physician at BMC. Dr. Soni alleges that this alerted Dr. Counihan to her new employment at Baystate. One month later, Dr. Soni “learned from her boss that Dr. Counihan was defaming her to senior leadership at Baystate, and that negative comments had made it to the Chair of Surgery at Baystate.” Compl. ¶63. Her boss also “indicated to her that her hiring had to be defended and justified to the Department Chair after this episode.” Id.

Despite this setback, from March to September 2014, multiple physicians at Baystate “expressed repeated and strong

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
239 F. Supp. 3d 373, 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 31274, 2017 WL 1234113, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/soni-v-wespiser-mad-2017.